Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Lester on February 22, 2012, 11:22:28 AM
-
I took a Dremel grinder to some reeds today :o
I am making a 4th button start C/F Pokerwork in the equivalent layout of my Penguin of Death Pokerwork (it has the G scale layout) so needed the lowest reed on the F row to be A/Bb rather than A/C. So I Dremeled the C reeds down a tone and a half :|bl , be interesting to see how long they last. They do seem to be surprisingly stable.
-
Um... C to B flat is only a tone, not a tone and a half.
Hope it goes well, anyway - should be a nice sounding box.
-
You should be scratched out of the Guild of Reed Fettlers this instance.
-
On larger reeds (not the small, high-pitched ones) instead of grinding the reed's base, I apply a tiny drop of molten soldering on the tip, then file out to tune! Totally reversible process.
-
On larger reeds (not the small, high-pitched ones) instead of grinding the reed's base, I apply a tiny drop of molten soldering on the tip, then file out to tune! Totally reversible process.
Me too. The low reeds can be quite thin already so filing to lower the pitch can result in less stable pitch - the reed has a greater tendency to flatten if played hard.
-
Yes, I think solder is better to lower pitch but I have used a dremel conical grindstone a lot to raise the pitch of larger reeds. Very precise and efficient IMO.
-
Much prefer a nice sharp swiss file. No noise, no wires, no abrasive dust, no need to switch it on, and it leaves a nice smooth finish...
-
In a french accent a la Pariselle "Good luck!"
Seriously, Lester, let us know how it stands the rigours of your manly style.
-
I once made a similarly large adjustment to a concertina reed and it gave it a thinner tone and went out of tune fairly quickly. Not a fair comparison as it was a brass reed...
Talking of tuning, I was wondering why all the tuning scratches I've seen go right across the reed? Surely this acts as a stress raiser for the reed to crack? For raising the pitch, would a dimple in the centre of the reed work as well? It would, after all change the centre of gravity just the same. I can see the reson why a scratch near the root of the reed for lowering the pitch would be more effective if it went right across though. Do different tuners use different techniques?
Rob.
-
I once made a similarly large adjustment to a concertina reed and it gave it a thinner tone and went out of tune fairly quickly. Not a fair comparison as it was a brass reed...
Talking of tuning, I was wondering why all the tuning scratches I've seen go right across the reed? Surely this acts as a stress raiser for the reed to crack? For raising the pitch, would a dimple in the centre of the reed work as well? It would, after all change the centre of gravity just the same. I can see the reson why a scratch near the root of the reed for lowering the pitch would be more effective if it went right across though. Do different tuners use different techniques?
Rob.
Don't think I have ever seen a scratch across a reed, plenty of grind marks but all scratches have been along the reed. I would say hat if you scratch across a reed you more than likely nick the plate and cause all sorts f pain.
-
For raising the pitch, would a dimple in the centre of the reed work as well? It would, after all change the centre of gravity just the same.
Rob.
This is exactly what I do with the Dremel tool to raise pitch substantially. This is the advantage of using the Dremel instead of filing across the entire tip. Both methods work but the dimple has the advantage of not affecting the profile or thickness of the reed tip. It is also very easy to reverse and fill in with solder.
-
I took a Dremel grinder to some reeds today :o
Dremel tool can be very useful for all sorts of chores. I have found it handy to devise a speed control for the tool. Perhaps these are standard on new Dremels, but mine is rather ancient. I have merely connected mine in series with a standard 600 watt incandescent lighting dimmer, which allows almost infinite speed control, which in turn offers the operator less risk of major instant damage. I don't care for using it on reeds, though, I prefer the file.
The dimmer/control setup also works well for the electric soldering iron I use for waxing. I can regulate it to a fine degree so that the wax is hot but not scorching.
-
I took a Dremel grinder to some reeds today :o
Dremel tool can be very useful for all sorts of chores. I have found it handy to devise a speed control for the tool. Perhaps these are standard on new Dremels, but mine is rather ancient. I have merely connected mine in series with a standard 600 watt incandescent lighting dimmer, which allows almost infinite speed control, which in turn offers the operator less risk of major instant damage. I don't care for using it on reeds, though, I prefer the file.
The dimmer/control setup also works well for the electric soldering iron I use for waxing. I can regulate it to a fine degree so that the wax is hot but not scorching.
Mine is the battery type with infinite speed control, well at least it did until it got over worked at the Melodeon Building Course last year, now it just has about four speeds which you have to search out with the controller :(
-
I took a Dremel grinder to some reeds today :o
Dremel tool can be very useful for all sorts of chores. I have found it handy to devise a speed control for the tool. Perhaps these are standard on new Dremels, but mine is rather ancient. I have merely connected mine in series with a standard 600 watt incandescent lighting dimmer, which allows almost infinite speed control, which in turn offers the operator less risk of major instant damage. I don't care for using it on reeds, though, I prefer the file.
The dimmer/control setup also works well for the electric soldering iron I use for waxing. I can regulate it to a fine degree so that the wax is hot but not scorching.
Mine is the battery type with infinite speed control, well at least it did until it got over worked at the Melodeon Building Course last year, now it just has about four speeds which you have to search out with the controller :(
Does infinite speed control mean it can go infinitely fast?
If so does this mean you can finish the grinding before you've started?
Ian
-
Does infinite speed control mean it can go infinitely fast?
If so does this mean you can finish the grinding before you've started?
Ian
Yes to both questions :o
-
I have seen many reeds with scratches on them, and even pictures and videos of "technicians" scratching the reeds to "tune" them.
-
I have seen many reeds with scratches on them, and even pictures and videos of "technicians" scratching the reeds to "tune" them.
Don't think anyone was debating whether reeds are tuned by scratching, it s my normal method of attack, just the axis of the scratching.
-
I've used white enamel paint before to lower a reed pitch - the stuff you can get to patch up scratches on enamelled kitchen appliances. Just put a drop onto the reed tip. It's much easier than solder to finely tune, just scratch some paint off with a scraper! Plus I've never known it fall off a reed.
-
I started off with a Dremel. Tried some cheap hardware store needle files and always went back to the dremel. Then invested in some good Swiss files, and my dremel has collected dust ever since. For me the files can be faster than a dremel, can be a lot slower, a lot better control, and not sure if makes much difference or not, but I like to keep the tongue filed evenly and smoothly. Can't do that with a dremel.
Going up a half step, even a full step doesn't bother me, but going down a half step by filing all the reeds would make me uneasy. Lester, how has the tuning turned out?
-
Lester, how has the tuning turned out?
They sound alright but I have not finished the box so have not applied the "rigours of your manly style" (c) Rees to them yet. Too much customer work and domestic stuff getting in the way.
-
I've used white enamel paint before to lower a reed pitch (...) Plus I've never known it fall off a reed.
As long as the reed is clean before applying the enamel! A drop of Epoxy also works. But I feel "better" using solder, as it's metal to metal.
-
Going up a half step, even a full step doesn't bother me, but going down a half step by filing all the reeds would make me uneasy.
Well, don't file the reeds to lower the pitch! Use one of the non-destructive methods discussed above, like solder or enamel. ;D
-
Going up a half step, even a full step doesn't bother me, but going down a half step by filing all the reeds would make me uneasy.
Well, don't file the reeds to lower the pitch! Use one of the non-destructive methods discussed above, like solder or enamel. ;D
I have with the odd reed. Armed only with gut feeling and not true experience, I would not expect the sound of a whole set of reeds done that way to sound or respond great. But I've learned that human speculation and accordion reality often don't mesh. Anyone ever done a whole set this way?
-
Going up a half step, even a full step doesn't bother me, but going down a half step by filing all the reeds would make me uneasy.
Well, don't file the reeds to lower the pitch! Use one of the non-destructive methods discussed above, like solder or enamel. ;D
I have with the odd reed. Armed only with gut feeling and not true experience, I would not expect the sound of a whole set of reeds done that way to sound or respond great.
Why is that? When the reeds were originally set to their current pitch, they likely had bits taken off; this is visible on most reeds. Putting some weight at the tip seems to me like a better way of tuning them down than weakening their base! I have re-pitched many reeds, bass and treble, adding weight to their tips and everything always came out fine. Not expensive reeds though, the standard Hohner T and H, and Cagnoni Macchina.
-
I'm still a rookie compared to many on this forum, but I'll launch into some speculation and opinion here. Someone please correct me if I'm off base, and I'd really like hear opinions on this issue.
The profile of the reed seems a design issue. If we take too much metal off anywhere, we've tinkered with the design. I'm guessing sometimes it doesn't make much difference in performance, and sometimes it does. I also speculate that when the reed maker adds metal to the tip, it is a trade off in contrast to making the reed longer. Putting metal on a tip, changes pitch but also seems to slow response slightly. Not very noticeable on a reed or two, but I wonder on a whole set. I also wonder if it would affect tone quality.
I don't know the science of reed design, so when I have to change a reed much, I try to stay as close to original profile as possible, one reason I've started using good files, because it's easier for me to do that with a flat file. They allow me to take metal off while still (with care) staying close the original profile.
In my inexperienced mind, if I was changing pitch of a set of reeds to a lower key, I would take each one on an individual basis. Some reeds are fairly thick in the middle, some aren't. Would it be better to remove some metal on the thicker ones, and if more lowering is needed, add a little metal at the tip? If removing metal to lower pitch, I'd also spread it out as uniformly as possible to avoid weak spots. In other words, I guess I'm saying we don't have to pick one method or the other, we can use both, depending on the needs and conditions of each individual reed.
Thoughts?
-
Agree with that blafleur.
If you look at the profile of some very high pitch reeds they are very thick at the base, so in effect only part of the reed is vibrating. I find that these may sometimes be lowered by two or sometimes even three semitones without compromising the reed in response or pitch stability. This is something I have discovered in the course of converting old Hohners from other timings into DG.
A more focussed way to learn about reed profiles is to take some unimportant reeds with a wide range of pitches and successively tune them up by a semitone and then down again.
-
Not to take away from the current line of conversation, but here is a great example of why to avoid using rotary grinders on your reeds. The reeds shown had been tuned up from old German pitch to modern by someone who was impatient or not educated enough to use a slower,(http://) more controllable method. All of the treble reeds were treated this way, even the tiny reeds at the top of the block. Needless to say, some of the reeds suffered. In one photo, you can see that the shape of the tip has been dogeared to where it may not play well. Many others had been 'overtuned', and become too sharp by the rapid and uncontrolled metal removal by the grinder, and then suffered more grinding at the center in an attempt to make things right. Also, note the diagonal slash shaped marks on the mid reed, these were typical throughout, and I believe these were done at the factory. I don't think that the diagonal scraping is such a good idea, as I noted many of those reeds seemed to contact the frame, and were difficult to correct. :-\
-
I think there is a balancing point in the length of the reed that its important to be aware of where there is a neutral affect in removing material. Before all this easy access to reeds I used to use accordion reeds for repairs that would need to be a tone different to their original. Ideally I would pick one in the middle and take it a semi tone each way for the pair, but occasionally I found myself having to go the whole tone in which case I would generally pick one that I could go down a tone removing metal from the larger thicker area was less intrusive I felt than taking it from an already thin narrow area at the tip (unless of course they were weighted in which case I would do the opposite) I think there is quite a mix of even profile reeds and some where the blade grinding just drops away dramatically at either end. I have to my knowledge never had one of my repair reeds break and I have never broken a reed I think most breakages are probably cold related or stress fractures from coarse grinding. When I worked on fuel lines at airports after 4 lengths of pipe had been welded they would be bombed (xray) then lifted into place they would then be bombed again in situ when all the welding was completed the only fractures we would see (very seldom) would be related to grinding that had been done during the welding and then the lifting process I guess (they were always skimping on cranes). AtB mory
-
I have with the odd reed. Armed only with gut feeling and not true experience, I would not expect the sound of a whole set of reeds done that way to sound or respond great. But I've learned that human speculation and accordion reality often don't mesh. Anyone ever done a whole set this way?
I just finished retuning 42 PA reeds to make them into a D/G set. The donor reeds came from an old LMM Paolo Soprani that I got off Fleabay for $15. I did most of the retuning work with solder to lower the pitch rather than filing the middle to lower the pitch. It's all an experiment to see if it's possible.
The reeds are now installed in an old Presswood Pokerwork and sound rather nice. They need a complete fine tune, yes, and I'll get to that in the next week or two. I also reworked the bass and chord reeds and find that the only problem there is the low fundamentals. They just don't have the volume that I want. I may put the original Hohner low fundamentals back in.
-
I took a Dremel grinder to some reeds today :o
Dremel tool can be very useful for all sorts of chores. I have found it handy to devise a speed control for the tool. Perhaps these are standard on new Dremels, but mine is rather ancient. I have merely connected mine in series with a standard 600 watt incandescent lighting dimmer, which allows almost infinite speed control, which in turn offers the operator less risk of major instant damage. I don't care for using it on reeds, though, I prefer the file.
The dimmer/control setup also works well for the electric soldering iron I use for waxing. I can regulate it to a fine degree so that the wax is hot but not scorching.
Mine is the battery type with infinite speed control, well at least it did until it got over worked at the Melodeon Building Course last year, now it just has about four speeds which you have to search out with the controller :(
Does infinite speed control mean it can go infinitely fast?
If so does this mean you can finish the grinding before you've started?
Ian
Infinitely slow too?
:P
-
I use a combination of scratching and a battery dremel. I find regarding reeds that is so much what tool is used, but how.
I use the face of a small flying saucer stone in my dremel so I can almost "sand" off the surface. On at lest one occasion I have made a "hand finished" reed for a customer who could not wait for one to be shipped to me (I told the customer what I was going to do) the tone was as good as I hoped.
I have a lot of tex-mex customers ,these guys break a lot of reeds! I often have to make a reed by choosing a tone that is half way in between the two tones needed and grinding one note up (the results are mixed if you go up more than one tone) and leading and grinding the other reed down. I found these reeds will last for years under hard playing if done right.
It is important to take metal off over a large area to avoid heating and thin spots.
-
I took a Dremel grinder to some reeds today :o
Dremel tool can be very useful for all sorts of chores. I have found it handy to devise a speed control for the tool. Perhaps these are standard on new Dremels, but mine is rather ancient. I have merely connected mine in series with a standard 600 watt incandescent lighting dimmer, which allows almost infinite speed control, which in turn offers the operator less risk of major instant damage. I don't care for using it on reeds, though, I prefer the file.
The dimmer/control setup also works well for the electric soldering iron I use for waxing. I can regulate it to a fine degree so that the wax is hot but not scorching.
Mine is the battery type with infinite speed control, well at least it did until it got over worked at the Melodeon Building Course last year, now it just has about four speeds which you have to search out with the controller :(
Have you tried switch cleaner on the pot Lester AtB mory