Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: chappie86 on April 21, 2012, 12:21:23 PM
-
Hi All,
I have just purchased my first Hohner to restore and learn from. I believe it is a pre-pokerwork that was aimed at the American market circa 1930's from the research I have done.
I have purchased the box as a challenge and also to teach me alot about melodeons, I am going to try and do as much as I can however, I feel a trip to one of the talented repairers from this forum will be required at certain points in the process.
Can anybody shed any light on the history of this model and anything I should do to improve it?
All the best,
Chappie
(http://)
-
The standard things to do would be:
- Re-face the pallets with thicker felt/leather
- Judging by the age a re-wax and new valves
- Restrict the treble action
- dependant on the state of the bellows (they look OK) retaping may be worthwhile
- retune
That will teach you a whole bunch of things about melodeons
-
Without dredging up the question of model numbers - it is probably later than you guess, not a "pre" pokerwork but the same body "customised" with what was construed by some as a superior finish.
Might even have an extra voice shoe-horned into it, a few did, but it is difficult to tell from a photo.
-
I did it. There's nothing like playing aninstrument you've fettled youself! :||:
-
At the risk of sounding like a troll (which isn't my intention), I strongly suggest learning how to tune on another accordion's reeds. Perhaps invest in a beater PA. I've purchased them on Ebay sometimes for just barely above the price of shipping (all in <$20). Learning to tune on your Hohner might completely destroy its lovely old set of alu H-plate reeds, a feat you could regret later. In the meantime you could learn the other aspects of a refurbishment like the things Lester mentioned which are less invasive and far more difficult to bungle. Felt padding, interior sanding and cleanup, bellows tape, gaskets, restricted action, bushes, etc. If you 'd like it to be playable, albeit out of its ideal tuning, you could even remove the reed plates (don't touch the tongues), remove all the old wax, and then replace them on the reed blocks with new wax and valves. Then reseat the reed blocks if needed. That way you'd get the hang of the whole process but will not destroy the reeds, which are sought after for their softer flutey quality -- remember if you do start tuning and you damage some of the reeds are beyond use (it can happen in a split second), you'll have to buy another accordion for its reeds when you could already have the one you just bought. It's only a suggestion, and of course if you feel up for the task you can try to undertake it. But I thought I'd lay that out first. Good luck with whichever path! (:) :||:
I'll edit this by saying that in my experience, errors made while learning to tune are a lot like errors made while boating. In the clamor to correct yourself, a cascade of other errors can follow in quick succession turning a small mistake into a small catastrophe. True story: I once dropped a keeper mackerel and another fisherman and myself both ducked down to pick it up at the same time. My cargo shorts caught on a folding bait table protruding from the transom, snapped it off, and in a rush to apologize, dropped said mackerel, thus engaging the assistance of a third fisherman who caused the second to slip and become injured. Whole thing took about nine seconds, when a lost mackerel wouldn't have mattered a tit considering how many were schooling and coming into the boat. Fortunately the injury wasn't something a few post-trip Red Stripes couldn't handle but you get the idea. :D
-
Wise words Christopher - I did exactly that, got a wrecked 1940s Ubaldi PA for £20 and practiced on that, made a mess of a few things too , I`ve yet to practice bellows taping on it and need to as my £50 beat up 1 Row could do with a few replacing.
-
Thanks for the advice Christopher K. I certainley won't touch the reeds until I really know what I am doing, which may take me years yet! For reed tuning I will take the box to one of the specialists from this forum. :||:
Out of interest does anybody know roughly how much a professional repairer charges to re-tune a box?
I am looking forward to having a go at cosmetically cleaning the box up and trying some of the easier tasks mentioned. The first thing that needs doing is removing the broken bass strap and fitting a new one? is this an easy task? are there any threads to help me on this?
Great boating story and I am glad everything was OK after a few Red Stripes! (:)
Chappie
-
Thanks for the advice Christopher K. I certainley won't touch the reeds until I really know what I am doing, which may take me years yet! For reed tuning I will take the box to one of the specialists from this forum. :||:
Out of interest does anybody know roughly how much a professional repairer charges to re-tune a box?
I am looking forward to having a go at cosmetically cleaning the box up and trying some of the easier tasks mentioned. The first thing that needs doing is removing the broken bass strap and fitting a new one? is this an easy task? are there any threads to help me on this?
Great boating story and I am glad everything was OK after a few Red Stripes! (:)
Chappie
Replacing the bass strap is dead easy just unscrew the old one and screw on a new one, the only slightly tricky bit is getting the length right but even that is not rocket surgery.
Replacement Strap (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hohner_Parts.html#16)
-
Replacing the bass strap is dead easy just unscrew the old one and screw on a new one, the only slightly tricky bit is getting the length right but even that is not rocket surgery.
Thanks Lester, much appreciated! (:)
-
I've got a C/F Hohner in exactly the same casework but in gloss black lacquer - it was my first attempt at repair/restoration and I'm very satisfied with the results; go slowly and methodically, and remember a complicated job is only a lot of simple jobs strung together. And DO get hold of some old reeds to practise tuning on; I picked up an old small PA from eBay for next to nothing, which provided me with the basis for a tuning bellows, a selection of odd small spare bits and some reeds to learn about tuning. Best of luck.
-
Replacing the bass strap is dead easy just unscrew the old one and screw on a new one, the only slightly tricky bit is getting the length right but even that is not rocket surgery.
Thanks Lester, much appreciated! (:)
Of course you could go for an upgrade:
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Bass_Straps.html#14 (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Bass_Straps.html#14)
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hardware_Misc..html#8 (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hardware_Misc..html#8)
You will also need longer bass end feet
-
Funny, a few weeks ago I acquired one of those "faux walnut" boxes for less than $100, and rebuilt it using parts of another box of the same era, and it's now my BC box! Easy to find new parts for them.
-
Funny, a few weeks ago I acquired one of those "faux walnut" boxes for less than $100, and rebuilt it using parts of another box of the same era, and it's now my BC box! Easy to find new parts for them.
That looks pretty sweet! I like the stained (not black, painted) keyboard cover. Did you sand it down and stain it yourself or find it like that?
-
That Faux walnut looks far better than the mother of bogseat versions, could have been the forerunner to the boutique italian boxes of today if it had caught on .. if it takes the same parts as the pokerwork, there`s no shortage, every part of a pokerwork can be bought from Charlie Marshall - in fact you could make up a kit box from stock and have the finish, key or reeds of your choice ! . it`d cost probably 3X the price of an assembled one though ;-)
-
That looks pretty sweet! I like the stained (not black, painted) keyboard cover. Did you sand it down and stain it yourself or find it like that?
The keyboard came like that on another donor box, the previous owner sanded and re-finished it. I decided to leave it like that, it looks better than black paint.
-
That looks pretty sweet! I like the stained (not black, painted) keyboard cover. Did you sand it down and stain it yourself or find it like that?
The keyboard came like that on another donor box, the previous owner sanded and re-finished it. I decided to leave it like that, it looks better than black paint.
I really like the stained keyboard cover, I may keep this in mind for doing mine up. Mine was not quite as much of a bargain, but at just over £100 I am very happy and hopefully the work I have to undertake will teach me lots about this great instrument!
-
I have found a video of Tony Hall playing a very similar looking box :||:
http://youtu.be/b6BxXRyylhk
-
It's basically a Pokerwork with a different finish! There was also another finish available with painted flowers. Parts are 100% exchangeable, from what I found, and current 2815/2915 parts will also fit.
-
current 2815/2915 parts will also fit.
With one two small caveats, yes they will; among the parts I replaced on mine were the grille and the cabinet corners. The modern grille fits perfectly, but the metal is lighter gauge and the fret is of a different pattern from the original, if that matters to you - I'm quite happy with the new one myself. The cabinet corners are just a shade longer than the old ones; modern 2915 cabinets are apparently fractionally wider than the old ones, so you get a tiny overhang. It did bother me a little at first, but I couldn't see an easy and satisfactory way of shortening them without damaging the plating, so I decided to live with it. I don't suppose anyone else notices, and I don't think about it myself now. All the other bits I replaced went straight in with no bother.
-
The cabinet corners are just a shade longer than the old ones; modern 2915 cabinets are apparently fractionally wider than the old ones, so you get a tiny overhang. It did bother me a little at first, but I couldn't see an easy and satisfactory way of shortening them without damaging the plating,
New cabinet corners are now made of stainless steel so no plating to worry about. I push the new corners fully into place (they sometimes need gentle persuasion with a block of wood and a hammer) and then file off the overhang, being careful not to file away any wood.
There are also some differences in reed blocks, at least three different methods have been used to hold the blocks in place, and the gasket material below the block may be on the block itself, or on the base board, so in swapping blocks you may need to add or remove gasket.
-
New cabinet corners are now made of stainless steel so no plating to worry about. I push the new corners fully into place (they sometimes need gentle persuasion with a block of wood and a hammer) and then file off the overhang, being careful not to file away any wood.
Thanks Theo - I hadn't twigged that. That's another little job to do, then!
Graham
-
Today my ebay purchase arrived in very good condition and the key of GC which I am also happy with.
A couple of questions if anybody can help:-
1) One of the bass buttons is stuck in the elevated position (as seen in the photos) and looks like the button needs pressing further onto the steel rod? Can anybody recommend a good method for doing this? I have checked the rod position inside the box and it looks the same as the others.
2) Is there any way I can stop this old box squeaking on button pressing? Would you recommend using WD40 or similar.
I am really happy and can't wait to get playing some tunes :||:!
-
1) Grip the rod from behind with a pair of long nose pliers then push the button home by leaning the whole thing against a solid surface.
2) Avoid using any lubricant which leaves an oily or sticky residue like WD40 does. Powdered graphite in alcohol is good. The alcohol carries the graphite inside joints and then evaporates leaving a dry lube.
-
Great thanks for the advice Theo!
(:)
-
Odd squeaks can be maddeningly difficult to cure. First you have to find the source! Buttons rubbing on wood is the usual culprit.
-
Odd squeaks can be maddeningly difficult to cure. First you have to find the source! Buttons rubbing on wood is the usual culprit.
Sound advice, took me a long time to learn that the mechanical squeaky noises were not in the metal parts (which is what i sounded like) but usually the buttons rubbing on the finger board, careful alignment cures it most of the time.
-
Cheers guys. I think it is Deffinatly the wood on buttons making the noise.
Can anybody recomend any really good tunes to learn on a G/C? I am currently learning a French song called Zelda. Good fun to play but lots of practice required :||:!
Chappie
-
... but even that is not rocket surgery.
Unlikely to be brain science, either, then? >:E
-
Does anybody have any tips on removing the bellows pins? I have just tried and my long nosed pliers are damaging the pins? are the pins easy to replace now that I have damaged a few of them?
Once I have removed the pins, should the bellows just pull off as there seems to be some resistance on the treble side?
Thanks again,
Chappie
-
I use a pair of end cutters to pull bellows pins eg:
End Cutters (http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B000LFX9TI/ref=asc_df_B000LFX9TI7764605?smid=A3P5ROKL5A1OLE&tag=hydra0b-21&linkCode=asn&creative=22206&creativeASIN=B000LFX9TI&hvpos=1o4&hvexid=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=73992906937864883&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=)
If he bellows pins ar stuck rust is usually j problem, I find application of a soldering iron to warm he pin will generally release it.
If you have damaged the pins Charlie Marshall has them in stock.
As to the bellows sticking, you may need to insert a screwdriver or some such between the frame and the end and gently ease the bellows off.
-
Side cutters, which are similar, can be used as well. I have old flat pallet knife that I use to rest the cutters on so I can use some leverage while protecting the finish.
I find this gives me more control. But I'm quite sure Lester has pulled more than I have >:E
-
I use Side cutters too, rest them on one of those backplanes removed from a PC case when you put cards in
-
Side cutters, which are similar, can be used as well. I have old flat pallet knife that I use to rest the cutters on so I can use some leverage while protecting the finish.
I find this gives me more control. But I'm quite sure Lester has pulled more than I have >:E
I would advise against using anything, like side cutters, which you pivot against the casework because, however hard you try, you will eventually damage it. End cutters allow you to pull directly on the head of the pin and to apply the force along the direction of travel
-
Thanks Lester! I will order some of those straight away.
Do you have any recommendations for returning the pins into the box?
Thanks :D
-
Thanks Lester! I will order some of those straight away.
Do you have any recommendations for returning the pins into the box?
Thanks :D
I use a hammer, albeit a small one. Mostly the pins just push back in but need a bit of a tap to bed them down.
More on removing pins, if its a psh box I usually cover the pin in a bit of scrap cloth and nip the pin through it to further ensure the finish is protected.
-
Great thanks for the advice.
Chappie
-
A piece of scrap wood allows you to push the pins home properly without applying any shock or risking making an unwanted dent if you're not careful...
-
I use end cutters too - get some really cheap ones from your local market or pound shop as they won't be very sharp and are unlikely to damage your pins. If you have good quality ones it's worthwhile (as long as you don't ever need them to actually cut with!) taking the sharp edges off with a needle file or similar. The ones I use were in a set of umpteen small pliers of various patterns (all useful to have to hand) for next to nothing from Aldi.
-
I use end cutters too - get some really cheap ones from your local market or pound shop as they won't be very sharp and are unlikely to damage your pins. If you have good quality ones it's worthwhile (as long as you don't ever need them to actually cut with!) taking the sharp edges off with a needle file or similar. The ones I use were in a set of umpteen small pliers of various patterns (all useful to have to hand) for next to nothing from Aldi.
Mine were in a set of 6 different sets of pliers by Draper, can't remember where I bought hm but it may have been Hobbycraft. And as you say the other ones have heir uses as well.
-
There is a lot of good advice here and some not so good:
Replacing bellows pins should never need a hammer, the danger of this method is that if the bellows are not positioned quite correctly the force applied by hammering can damaged the bellows frame. Just something firm to push with us sufficient, and of you fell excessive resistance you can stop before doing damage.
Separating tight fitting bellows with a screwdriver!! Argh! Sounds likely to damage the wood. First try firm pressure with thumbs against the bellows frames, working all round, sometimes it is easier to get the movement started at a corner. Running a thin blunt blade all round where the surfaces should separate can help. Failing that a broad thin piece of flat metal can be used to lever the sides apart. Occasionally if poor gasket material has become stuck to both surfaces it is best to slit the gasket with a sharp knife.
-
Instead of cutters to remove bellows pins I simply use a small nail puller; lever action gives a lot more control and force than a cutter, especially when the pins are stuck. I put a thin piece of hardwood on the case as a pivot and lift the pin; I can increase the thickness of the pivot piece if I need to.
-
I have gained access to the guts of the box now.
The reed plates are stamped H and M. All of the reed valves are thick blue leather, most are still in place but there were three that are loose in the box so I am guessing some of the internal valves are missing. Should I replace these with newer plastic valves? If so, which ones shall I go for? and are there any good threads detailing the process of re-valving?
-
I have gained access to the guts of the box now.
The reed plates are stamped H and M. All of the reed valves are thick blue leather, most are still in place but there were three that are loose in the box so I am guessing some of the internal valves are missing. Should I replace these with newer plastic valves? If so, which ones shall I go for? and are there any good threads detailing the process of re-valving?
Others may disagree but judging from the age of this box I would recommend relaxing the reeds as the wax is almost certainly dried out. If it is dried out the reeds will not be held solidly to the block and be impossible to tune. This will also give you he chance to inspect the valves on the inside of the reeds.
I would replace all the valves and my personal preference s to use vinyl valves from Charlie Marshall.
As to how to, remove the old valves and scrape any adhesive remaining on the reed plate, I use the back of a scapel blade, then I use EvoStik to stick the new valves in place. Use the glue sparingly on the rivet end of the valve.
The valves I use come in 3 varieties depending on the required length, also the longer reeds have either 3 or 2 leaves to increase the springiness. The valves will need trimming to length after they are fitted and I alway trim the leaves back proportionally to the overall shortening of the valve.