Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Spikey on May 26, 2012, 11:36:11 PM
-
Apologies if this has been asked before (have searched and searched and could not find...), but when we took apart my old Hohner Pressed Wood (I think from around the 1940s) to replace the pallet facings the valves started falling out like confetti :o - will it be possible to replace the valves (I think best to replace with vinyl ones as recommended by Lester?) without taking the reed blocks out and having to re-wax them?
I also wondered whether the loose/missing valves could have been causing some of the air leakage? Is it possible for air to be leaking out through the valves without sounding the reed - still trying to get my head around how the reeds work so this could be a daft question - we have replaced the bellows gaskets as thought this might be where the leak was coming from, but it still seems to leak massively and we can't see where there might be any holes in the bellows - have tried shining a torch through in a darkened room, and holding them close to my face while playing...
Any advice gratefully received (:).
-
The valves on the back of the reed plate (inside the block) can't be replaced without taking the reed plate off so you are looking at rewaxing to do those.
As for leakage: missing valves won't make the box leak more while you are not pressing any buttons, but as soon as you play a note where the opposite reed is missing its valve, you will be leaking air through that reed, so it is a form of leakage.
-
Oh dear...I thought that might be the case - another thing to add to my next Charlie order ::).
If the missing valves could be a source of the leaking then I think we will wait until (if!) it is back together again, and if it still seems too leaky we can try and tackle the bellows then.
Thanks Anahata
-
There are a few places where a box can leak air - bellows-pin holes, pallets not quite seated (though you'd notice a reed trying to sound if that were the case), iffy air-valve, poor joints, small holes or splits in the baseboard (or pallet board, or whatever we're calling it now!), reed blocks not seating properly.......
Does it leak only when you're playing, or does excess air escape if you open & close the bellows without depressing a button?
-
There are a few places where a box can leak air - bellows-pin holes, pallets not quite seated (though you'd notice a reed trying to sound if that were the case), iffy air-valve, poor joints, small holes or splits in the baseboard (or pallet board, or whatever we're calling it now!), reed blocks not seating properly.......
Thanks GPS - it sounds like a case of 'How do I leak...let me count the ways...', and I think it might be many of these... Have discovered a small split in the pallet/base board - well it's either that or a woodworm going in a very straight line ;D - it has those too.
Thinking back now to when it was all in one piece it did seem to leak a lot when playing, but not hugely when trying to close the bellows without pressing a button - but I might be remembering this incorrectly.
-
Thanks GPS - it sounds like a case of 'How do I leak...let me count the ways...', and I think it might be many of these... Have discovered a small split in the pallet/base board - well it's either that or a woodworm going in a very straight line ;D - it has those too.
Run super glue along it to seal it.
Another leakage I have just spent hours finding was on an old box, it sounded to be coming from where the bellows frame met the end but I had replaced the gasket and I knew it was sealing OK. In the end it turned out that where the fondo (other words are available ;) ) met the casework the varnish or whatever Hohner used to seal this joint had failed and the air was leaking around the joint. Again super glue was my friend.
-
Thanks GPS - it sounds like a case of 'How do I leak...let me count the ways...'
Unfortunately this is often the case with old boxes: lots of small leaks. To get a real improvement you have to fix them all.
-
Two more potential leaks:
1- via the holes for the screws that hold the keyboard
2- partial failure of the glue jount that holds the bellows frames onto the bellows.
And a third, With very old and much played bellows the valley folds of the bellows can become porous. This happened to my old 1930s club box, new bellows made an immediate cure, but only after I had spend hours dealing with all the small leaks outlined above.
-
1- via the holes for the screws that hold the keyboard
When ever I have a keyboard off I install leather washers to prevent this problem. Make them myself with some punches and scrap leather bits. I notice that the Chinese manufacture Pokerworks seem to have glue all over these screws making their removal difficult.
-
Thanks for all of this everyone - has given me a lot more to think about and check - I just hope it's not porous bellows :o...will pass all this on to my chief technical expert (I am just the beautiful assistant - well, the second part anyway).
Another question about valves - on CGM you can get a full set of vinyl valves for a 21 treble / 8 bass two reed melodeon, but there are also Hohner double and triple layer valves - will the set be OK to use, or should I be putting in the double or triple type? I'm not sure what the difference is and when you would use the different types?
-
met the casework the varnish or whatever Hohner used to seal this joint had failed and the air was leaking around the joint. Again super glue was my friend.
Reed wax is another good (and flexible) sealer, in fact my Club-III had it already inside to finish off the seal after the hide glueing . I`m not sure I`d be happy about squirting water-thin superglue into the edges of a palletboard - but then you`ve fixed far more boxes than I ever wil so who am I to argue :P
-
I would avoid using wax or superglue here. Wax because once the joint is "contaminated" with wax it will be difficult to ever re-make the joint propery with glue. Superglue I avoid superglue (unless there is no alternative) because I react badly to the fumes.
Why not do a proper job and use hide glue? It is cheap, and does agreat job. A simple gluepot can be made with a baby bottle warmer and a jam jar.
-
Or you can get Titebond Liquid Hide Glue; I'm not entirely sure what it's actually made from, but it's intended for musical instrument & cabinet work without the bother (& smell) of mixing & heating rabbit-skin or pearl glue, but is supposed to have similar properties. I have a bottle, but I've not yet used it.......
Graham
-
I've tried the liquid hide glue, and have gotten inconsistent results. I'm pretty sure it is regular hide glue with urea added to retard drying. I wouldn't put much faith in it, I don't think it nearly as strong as regular hide glue, and has a very short shelf life. Go to some luthier forums and do some searches on it, you'll find that the overwhelming opinion. There is one called Old Brown liquid hide glue that is supposed to be better. I have some but don't trust it enough to use it. I use regular hide glue for many applications, especially where I don't want to mess with clamps (rubbed joints), but am using fish glue more and more. It has the glass hard drying of hide glue, pulls joints together like hide glue, but has much longer working time. It has more working time that regular woodworking glue, but a better tack so parts don't slide around when clamping like regular yellow glue. It is clear under a finish like hide glue. It can be refrigerated to last longer, and can even be frozen. In fact, the more it goes, the more my yellow glue sits on the shelf.
Jeff Hildreth first told me about fish glue, and after doing a lot of research on it and using it for the last couple years, I'm a staunch supporter of it and don't understand why it's not used more. Some think that fish glue will dissolve in humid weather. I tried to remove some veneer glued with fish glue the day before with a steam iron and finally gave up. It can be done, but not nearly easily as regular hide glue, and removed my fear of humidity. A good joint will not be affected by humidity anyway.
For a crack, I actually may use the super glue types(CA), but more likely would use epoxy on the pallet board. If you're only filling a crack, epoxy (or CA) has better gap filling than yellows glues or animal glues. I really like thin CA for a crack that is just starting, it soaks in deep and stabilizes the wood.
-
I just bought four more gallons of fish glue; been using it for about 15 years. I have found nothing better. It beats hide glue.
Four gallons costs about $130 including shipping. That's $32.50 US per gallon. Luthier supply shops sell smaller quantities for a great deal more money. It stores nicely , shelf life quite long, never had any go bad. Even if it freezes, it is still as good as new when brought back to room temperature. Does not smell as bad as hide glue and needs no glue pot to keep it warm for use.
Comes apart in the usual heat or steam methods. I have yet to find a downside.
As for TITEBOND "Hide Glue"... forget it.. it's useless. My opinion is that it has no redeeming attributes. Waste of money.
-
That's $32.50 US per gallon.
Just over 20 quid for 4/5ths of a gallon, then....... :D >:E
-
Thanks for all the replies everyone, but could I steer this briefly back to valves? (I need to put in my order!):
Another question about valves - on CGM you can get a full set of vinyl valves for a 21 treble / 8 bass two reed melodeon, but there are also Hohner double and triple layer valves - will the set be OK to use, or should I be putting in the double or triple type? I'm not sure what the difference is and when you would use the different types?
Does anyone have any wisdom they could share on which valves to use for an old Hohner pressed wood C/F - single, double or triple Hohners (does this depend on what size the reed is?), or will the standard melodeon set do? The old ones that are falling off are all leather but I want to replace them with vinyl, as this seems the recommended way to go.
Then we can get back to glue ;D.
-
The larger valves (for the larger reeds) have more layers , just pick the valve closest to the size of the reed and trim if necessary (trim all the layers by the same amount)
-
The larger valves (for the larger reeds) have more layers , just pick the valve closest to the size of the reed and trim if necessary (trim all the layers by the same amount)
Wise words ;)
-
Thanks everyone (:) - have just heard from Charlie and the CGM 038C valve set contains a selection of 6 different Hohner 3 layer and 2 layer valves so it all sounds good (and hopefully we will be able to install them correctly and the melodeon will too ::)).
-
The larger valves (for the larger reeds) have more layers , just pick the valve closest to the size of the reed and trim if necessary (trim all the layers by the same amount)
Wise words ;)
I also punch a hole at the base of the valves using a leather punch. It makes them easier to install with their base around the reed rivets, especially the leather valves.
-
I also do this with Vinyl ones like Hohner do at the factory
-
Please do NOT punch holes in non-Hohner valves!
-
I hear you - but why not?
Malcolm
-
Because, if told, Mr. Reichelt, owner of the Klingenthal based Moritz Grimm accordion valve factory and now well into his eighties, would certainly suffer a heart attack.
-
Well, that wasn't the answer I was expecting ???
I wouldn't, but only because I think it would affect the characteristics and longevity of the valve (although I do like the punched Hohner valves).
I can't see it being a problem with leather valves, but I haven't had the urge to do it with leather valves.
-
Some leather valves in old German accordions are pretty sweet. I wouldn't put holes in them. The nicest ones I've encountered are white/off-white in color and these are appreciably soft and floppy. If you can get them to lay flat and restore some of the nap on the underside, they're worth the time. On the other hand, some of the old leather valves were tanned poorly and are just the opposite, not worth restoring.
-
Holes in the valves for the rivets are unnecessary. You just butt the end of the valve up against the rivet. Plenty of gluing surface.
-
Well, I inspected the Vinyl valves from Charlie marshall and compared them to the Hohner ones which had fallen off (1 Row 1040) and they were no less together after punching rivet sized holes in than the Originals , they stuck down easily and lay nice and flat... I`ve never seen a hole punched in a leather one though.
-
The nicest ones I've encountered are white/off-white in color and these are appreciably soft and floppy. If you can get them to lay flat and restore some of the nap on the underside, they're worth the time. On the other hand, some of the old leather valves were tanned poorly and are just the opposite, not worth restoring.
Finding good leather valves is a bit of a gamble and I understand the urge to save the nicer leathers, but what technique works? The restoration video with Jehan Paul shows him using a "silicone free preparation" to restore leather valves. What is that? Is this worthwhile?
-
The nicest ones I've encountered are white/off-white in color and these are appreciably soft and floppy. If you can get them to lay flat and restore some of the nap on the underside, they're worth the time. On the other hand, some of the old leather valves were tanned poorly and are just the opposite, not worth restoring.
Finding good leather valves is a bit of a gamble and I understand the urge to save the nicer leathers, but what technique works? The restoration video with Jehan Paul shows him using a "silicone free preparation" to restore leather valves. What is that? Is this worthwhile?
Is this an online video and if so, do you have a link? My experience to restoring leather valves involves pulling a square corner of a straight edge over the smooth side, and using a toothbrush to restore the nap on the other side. It's been moderately successful, I'd be interested to know about a chemical solution that is a "real" fix. Admittedly I don't know much about leather restoration, which is a whole subject in and of itself.
-
I really think the only "real" fix for leathers, other than short term hold over fixes, is replacement.
-
Is this an online video and if so, do you have a link?
No, it's a Lark in the Morning video on concertina and box repair made in the 80's by the looks of the outfits and set. A pretty hilarious couple of guys in a very relaxed setting (drinking schnapps throughout the video) showing basic repairs. He doesn't give any details other than "a preparation", so I wasn't sure.
-
have a look at this page, it covers the art of "Valve Stroking" to revitalize old leather .. the whole site has interesting info regarding box repair in general
http://talkingreeds.com/reed-valves/
-
I really think the only "real" fix for leathers, other than short term hold over fixes, is replacement.
I agree.
Valves have a limited useful life and are quick and easy to replace. We've long since moved on from the information scarce pre-internet age and replacements are easily obtainable so I can't think of a good reason why anyone would even bother trying to restore old leather valves.
-
have a look at this page, it covers the art of "Valve Stroking" to revitalize old leather .. the whole site has interesting info regarding box repair in general
http://talkingreeds.com/reed-valves/
But I get the feeling that some of it is untried eg
"It is understood leather can be restored to some extent by application of neat’s foot oil though this has not been tried."
Neatsfoot oil is pretty coarse stuff and is designed for making leather water resistant for outdoor use, eg for boots and horse tack. It remains tacky in the long term and has the potential to be a dust magnet. It can also cause some glues to fail, as some amateur concertina repairers have found out the hard way. To even suggest it for use on the fine leather used for reed valves seems to me to be irresponsible.
As Blafleur and Andy Simpsone has said, if valves are old, stiff and not lying flat replace them with new. Anything else is only a temporary measure.
-
Someone on Ebay is selling synthetic leather valves. (Item 290718957543). Seems pricey, but could be a half-way house in an older instrument to maintain a degree of originality whilst using newer materials.
Any comments on how these compare?
Malcolm
-
Someone on Ebay is selling synthetic leather valves. (Item 290718957543). Seems pricey, but could be a half-way house in an older instrument to maintain a degree of originality whilst using newer materials.
Any comments on how these compare?
Malcolm
Looks like they are the same as Charlie Marshall's Synthetic/Vinyl valves which he sells at £9.50 per 100 so the eBay ones at £5.20 for 5 seem to be a tad expensive :o
-
I've seen the Talking Reeds page. I've never used springs on old melodeon leathers, seems like I'd just as soon buy new leathers or vinyl valves if I were going to shell out for springs. What I've done in the past to 'restore' leathers amounts to corner cutting, basically, which is what I was after. I've done this exactly twice, experimented at no cost to me and was surprised by the results. The leathers weren't badly curled and seemed of higher than usual quality, and these were the reasons I was inclined to save them. If I want an overhaul, the whole job, obviously new valves are in order. But it's worth a few minutes of your time if you're inclined to tinker for fun.
-
As Blafleur and Andy Simpsone has said, if valves are old, stiff and not lying flat replace them with new. Anything else is only a temporary measure.
I should have added this part of Theo's post in mine. If the leathers are old, stiff and not flat then they're obviously destined for the bin. But the leathers I was talking about seemed to be in much better condition, or better quality to begin with, so that's why I tried to salvage them.
-
Yeah, personally, I`d just put vinyl ones on, it doesn`t take long and they`re hardly expensive as Lester said
-
The only issue with vinyl is to make sure the valves are absolutely flat and without a crease and that the reedplate is absolutely clean! Unlike leather which as a "fuzzy" surface, the sleek surface of the vinyl valve seems more prone to wheezing when not in perfect contact with the reedplate.
-
It seems to me the ideal valve would be a thin layer of each: leather in contact with the slot for a soft surface and perfect seal, and vinyl behind it providing reliable lifelong springiness.
-
It seems to me the ideal valve would be a thin layer of each: leather in contact with the slot for a soft surface and perfect seal, and vinyl behind it providing reliable lifelong springiness.
Such valves are available in the larger sizes and work very well, and are quicker to fit than the traditional plain leather with a helper spring.
-
It seems to me the ideal valve would be a thin layer of each: leather in contact with the slot for a soft surface and perfect seal, and vinyl behind it providing reliable lifelong springiness.
Such valves are available in the larger sizes and work very well, and are quicker to fit than the traditional plain leather with a helper spring.
Yep, Even back in the 50s - as seen in the bass end of the old 1040 1 Row Hohner