Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Graham Spencer on May 27, 2012, 06:14:35 PM
-
Now don't get me wrong - I love my old Saltarelle. It's the box I generally play in public for all sorts of reasons - it's reliable, easy to play, and with a 4th button start, low notes and the extra half-row makes all kinds of tunes accessible; it's been with me from new, been my gigging box for over 20 years, has been all over the UK and Europe with me, and played hundreds of gigs. So why, when I sit down to play for my own amusement at home, do I always reach for a cheap old Hohner? There's something about them that just makes me want to play them. My current favourite is a black 2915 in C/F and I can't walk past it without picking it up and playing it. It's even been out on a few gigs recently.........I must be suffering from Hohner's Syndrome....... ::) :||:
-
Nope.
I have worked my way through some of Castagnari's catalogue, most of Saltarelle's, I still have a L'Elfique which I rarely play. Day to day play my Penguin of Death Pokerwork (fairly highly modified but still sounds like a Pokerwork) and, as I arises from the pile of bits, I now know I am really going to love my Banderica as it just got to the playable state today (:)
-
Never had a Costalotti Melodeon but had a Costalotti PA for a very long while, to cut to the chase I denied preferring the wide musette and less refined sound of the Hohner Atlantics (Musette versions) to my big LMMH Excelsior for years, I didn`t find the Musette in the LMMM Excels and other hi-end Itals the same even . So I recently got an Atlantic Musette 4N (Lighter too : ), best thing I did ! .
So even though its a PA it still has that "Hohnerness" to it (it`s one of those with Morino reeds which may help) but I`ve seen this in all the Hohner PAs I`ve played to at least some degree, even in the little 60 or 72 bass 2 voice Ariettas and students, I really love the OTT raucous scream of the Pokerwork, 1040 1 Row and Student-1 REV1 and the smoother, thicker more refined sound of the Club-IIIBS (which is even smoother than the Morino powered Atlantic PA) . they all seem to have that Hohnerness in different ways .
I`d call it that they have "Life" . The Italian stuff (wardrobe sized Excelsiors included) have Life too, (a Lily can really scream and not just Lily Allen) but yeah its different and we all tune into different things, I`ve never had anything as unputdownable as a Hohner from tiny to massive and as a recent Hohner convert I`m knocked out :)
SO after all that waffle Bob, Yeah, I agree
-
Yes, I totally agree, there is something unique and compellingly attractive about the Hohner sounds - from my current Liliput, through my Erica, to my "monster" 123-bass Morino CBA.
Only problem I have is that, apart from the Morino which has a superb smooth/light action, in more recent years I have found the slightly stiffer action of the Hohner melodeons aggravates the latent RSI in my forearms, so I can only play them for short periods. My solution to this was to get Hohner reeds/blocks put in a Castagnari Tommy (which I find to be the most playable melodeon ever), which has resulted in yet another unique, but unmistakeably Hohner sound in a box I can play for as long as I wish at a time.
-
My solution to this was to get Hohner reeds/blocks put in a Castagnari Tommy (which I find to be the most playable melodeon ever), which has resulted in yet another unique, but unmistakeably Hohner sound in a box I can play for as long as I wish at a time.
Does that have a significant effect on the weight? I've played a friend's Tommy, and apart from it feeling a bit on the small side for me I found it surprisingly heavy for its size. To be honest, I didn't find it as playable as my Pastourelle, though I can see the appeal of a 3-voice box. Still like the 2915 better, though - it's light, more responsive than you'd think, and - well, it sounds wonderful! I can't see myself being parted from the Pastourelle as it's such a versatile box and has a lovely action, even if it is a tad on the heavy side for a full day's morris playing. I'd take the 2915 out morrising, but I don't think I'd be too popular playing most tunes in F and the rest in C.
Now the 4-voice 1-rows are another matter...........and it's nice to know I'm not alone in my preference!
Graham
-
My solution to this was to get Hohner reeds/blocks put in a Castagnari Tommy (which I find to be the most playable melodeon ever), which has resulted in yet another unique, but unmistakeably Hohner sound in a box I can play for as long as I wish at a time.
Does that have a significant effect on the weight?
No discernable difference in the weight, but yes having 3-voices crammed into such a small case does make it seem heavy for its size - but I actually find it adds a bit more inertia to counter lots of push/pull bellows action.
-
at the affordable end of the BCC# boxes (i'e'other than Shand Morino's) I much prefer the sound of a Hohner Gaelic to mmml to the paulo soprani 80 bass. My casali 48 bass is somewhere between the two haviang been retuned in Scotlaand before it came my way.
As to the DG's I enjoy digging out the pokerwork that was my only box way back but I really like the sond of my serenellini salterello ( which is why I bought it and have worked it hard for at least 15 years). But I also very much like my 4th button start Lilly as completely avoids the wet/dry argument and does everything well even to being able to roughly impersonate a fiddle, concertina or northumbrian pipes. Perhaps more importantly it is the box I hope to still be playing in another 20 years when I'm ninety - God willing!
george
-
There's something about them that just makes me want to play them.
In French it's called a: "je ne sais quoi"...
-
One thing's been puzzling me in this discussion - who's Bob? ??? ;D
Graham
-
One thing's been puzzling me in this discussion - who's Bob? ??? ;D
Graham
;D
-
Although I enjoy the sound of many different boxes, my favourite sound is that of a dryish tuned vintage Hohner. However, part of the appeal comes from the sheer quantity of old Hohner's floating around in a fascinating variety of configurations, tunings & finishes, & that these boxes can be picked up cheap & then tinkered with. Unlike PA's there are very few non-Hohner DBAs out there, so if you're looking at an old DBA, the chances are - it's a Hohner.
-
So why, when I sit down to play for my own amusement at home, do I always reach for a cheap old Hohner?
Some things were created "right" from the beginning, and even after 60+ years the 2815/2915 design still lives... Sometimes, the simplest things are the best.
Do not try to understand, just play it!
-
Is the Hohner the first box you played? It was for me, and I played it for so many years that it fits like a pair of comfy underpants ;D i.e it sort of moulds into me when I play it, and feels 'just right'
-
My first three boxes were all Hohners, yes; the first Erica was stolen, and the second one sold on after I got the Saltarelle. The third one is a 4-stop one-row which I still have. So I've always had at least one Hohner; but it's only recently that I've come actually to prefer them to more "sophisticated" boxes.
Graham
-
I spent years hankering after a Costalotti, but have since moved back to having a Hohner has my main box. They feel... natural, if that makes any sense.
-
To be brutally honest, I have never found a hohner I've got along with...I like the sound (apart from the clacking!!) but infinitely prefer the playability of the castagnari. And I can't stand the way hohner buttons are both air and the other sort.
I'd set the challenge of someone finding me a hohner I will like and can play for more than a minute before I'm aching all over.
So I'm afraid I'm stuck with the costalotti even though I'd love a (relatively) cheap, compact box that I didn't fret about taking my eyes off of for two seconds.
-
Lilliput. :P
-
I like Hohners, I think they've got loads of personality and are great fun....but....
I fail to understand the rampant Hohner nuthugging, (my new favourite word), that seems so firmly entrenched in England. If someone put a new box on the market with noisy actions, buttons that disappear down the keyboard holes, reeds that are prone to breakage or poorly designed springs that also break easily they'd be crucified. On Hohners such things are overlooked or, particularly in the case of the disappearing buttons, excuses are made that even go as far as to question the ability of people complaining about them instead of acknowledging them for what they are, quality issues and major design flaws.
If players in England had had access to higher quality boxes in the 60s and 70s then I doubt they'd be looked upon anywhere near as fondly as they are...
-
Lilliput. :P
The Lady said CHEAP . Fettled re-tuned Liliputs are far from cheap :P (Heck, battered wrecks running on original wax, valves and rust aren`t either ............. Try a Delicia ! ? .
-
Lilliput. :P
The Lady said CHEAP . Fettled re-tuned Liliputs are far from cheap :P (Heck, battered wrecks running on original wax, valves and rust aren`t either ............. Try a Delicia ! ? .
LdT actually said "(relatively) cheap" which a fettled Liliput is up against a Castagnari Tommy for example and a Tommy is only two row (:)
-
Lilliput. :P
The Lady said CHEAP . Fettled re-tuned Liliputs are far from cheap :P (Heck, battered wrecks running on original wax, valves and rust aren`t either ............. Try a Delicia ! ? .
LdT actually said "(relatively) cheap" which a fettled Liliput is up against a Castagnari Tommy for example and a Tommy is only two row (:)
But can I pick one up new off a shelf? I don't do buying boxes on ebay....
-
Lilliput. :P
But can I pick one up new off a shelf? I don't do buying boxes on ebay....
Well you could around 1940 (according to Hohners Chronology list), the only liliput sized boxes I know of now are are best kinda 2 Row-ish with 1 rather soprano voice ..
Have a look at the music room`s list, they have used Sandpipers from time to time (a wannabecostalotti with a good Rep but I`m sure you know that already :) , there`s a Scarlatti Costalottialike there for around £400 (Hobgoblin have one too) which they seem to rate, ask Jon Looms for his opinion ?? .
Theo has a nice used Nik (DG too if I remember rightly) in his for-sale section too for £900 - not quite pin money but I'm sure a better bet than a riced up Liliput playability wise
-
Lilliput. :P
But can I pick one up new off a shelf? I don't do buying boxes on ebay....
Well you could around 1940 (according to Hohners Chronology list), the only liliput sized boxes I know of now are are best kinda 2 Row-ish with 1 rather soprano voice ..
Have a look at the music room`s list, they have used Sandpipers from time to time (a wannabecostalotti with a good Rep but I`m sure you know that already :) , there`s a Scarlatti Costalottialike there for around £400 (Hobgoblin have one too) which they seem to rate, ask Jon Looms for his opinion ?? .
Theo has a nice used NIK in his for-sale section too for £900 - not quite pin money but I'm sure a better bet than a riced up Liliput playability wise
I was having a look its about £400 more than I'd want to pay but the excelsior mini jumped out at me.
-
I`ve not seen a used Excelsior Mini, new they`re about £1100 and if its anything like the PAs, it`ll be beautifully made and sound excellent.. from what I can gather, a similar box to the Castagnari Lily and Saltarelle Epsilon (1 voice 2 Row) which used seem to go for similar money to the Nik on Theo`s site . the Lily is one Costalotti I`d really like (as well as a Mignon for fun)
-
But can I pick one up new off a shelf? I don't do buying boxes on ebay....
I think some of the usual suspects, in particular Mike Rowbotham, may be able to sell you a fettled one from stock, or to order, still cheap against a costalotti but a lot more than a Pokerwork... *
(*PS probably depending on chosen tuning)
I find going from the Liliput to a full sized box, and vice versa, not a problem. But
... that I didn't fret about taking my eyes off of for two seconds.
not so sure about that bit...
-
nearest thing that matches my crieteria is a toy melodeon (http://www.amazon.co.uk/Tobar-5038728018699-Accordion/dp/B000H6QTO8/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1338467411&sr=8-1)
-
nearest thing that matches my crieteria is a toy melodeon (http://www.amazon.co.uk/Tobar-5038728018699-Accordion/dp/B000H6QTO8/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1338467411&sr=8-1)
the same box is £9.95 from Home Bargains :) loadsa fun for a tenner (in fettling as well as playing), the damn thing still makes my left shoulder ache worse than a 13Kg PA though - LOL
http://www.homebargains.co.uk/products/2072-junior-accordion.aspx
What gets me is these are 2 voice and have proper separate plate reeds on removable reedblock (treble) and Pan (Bass) ! .
EDIT addition - even this £10 wonder has advantages over a Pokerwork - the buttons don`t dissappear into the fingerboard, it has proper press-stud bellows straps, the Thumb strap is Screwed on so easily removed (not riveted), the Grille is properly screwed on not held on with two picture wire loops and there`s a removable panel under the fingerboard for access - LOL :D . OK I`ll keep the Pokerwork but it`s a point ..
-
nearest thing that matches my crieteria is a toy melodeon (http://www.amazon.co.uk/Tobar-5038728018699-Accordion/dp/B000H6QTO8/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1338467411&sr=8-1)
the same box is £9.95 from Home Bargains :) loadsa fun for a tenner (in fettling as well as playing), the damn thing still makes my left shoulder ache worse than a 13Kg Excelsior PA though - LOL
Doh! I paid £22 for it from a high street shop. I actually sat on a bench outside to play it I'd bought it to try it out and got a few compliments and several people asked where my hat was to collect change. lol!
I have no idea how to 'fettle' one and wouldn't attempt it. I can't even take a clicky pen apart and put it back in the same working order. :p
-
If players in England had had access to higher quality boxes in the 60s and 70s then I doubt they'd be looked upon anywhere near as fondly as they are...
Probably true; I've often said that my ideal box would have the action, playability & reliability of my Saltarelle with the sound of a classic Hohner. Maybe we need the melodeon equivalent of the Mazda MX5 - everything the MGB should have been but never quite was. But then, I'd rather drive either of the MGBs I've owned than either of the MX5s I've driven, enjoyable though they were; they just didn't have that "personality" in just the same way as modern sophisticated boxes don't.
Graham
-
Surely the key point about the Pokerwork/Erica line is that it's cheap! Would anybody here honestly choose a Pokerwork/Erica over a Castagnari if they were the same price? Even at the price it is, a modern Pokerwork seems over-priced. With the Morgane line, Hohner itself has brought out a line of boxes that fix all the basic issues with the Pokerworks & at a price only 30% higher.
On the other hand, the charm of vintage Hohners has a strong appeal to me. They have a variety of different configurations & finishes, a wonderful, unique sound & can be bought very cheaply, so that even after investing in restoring them they represent excellent value. Playability is another matter however - there's no way they can really compete with a modern high quality Italian box.
-
Vintage Hohners have The Sound. The sort of sound with personality, with depth. The sort of sound that makes even the most mundane music seem interesting. I love it. Hohner also made some exceptionally pretty boxes (late model Liliputs and Erikas especially) and some very innovative boxes (Preciosa). However, everything else about Hohners is pretty crap. I think that someone who could build a box with the sound of an old Hohner but the playability of a Costalotti would make a fortune, but there would be lots who preferred the clackety buttons.
-
Playability is another matter however - there's no way they can really compete with a modern high quality Italian box.
I really think the main playability issues with Hohners have to do with the way they are set up. A well set up Hohner with the buttons stopped is easy to play. There is no way it should 'make your arms ache' as Ltd laments. I have a Casta with A mano reeds in it to compare and, yes, the italian reeds are more responsive but the difference is not huge and I prefer the timbre of the Hohner reeds (tuned a little drier than standard). As someone mentioned earlier the vintage Hohners that have been fettled are a great value.
-
If players in England had had access to higher quality boxes in the 60s and 70s then I doubt they'd be looked upon anywhere near as fondly as they are...
Probably true; I've often said that my ideal box would have the action, playability & reliability of my Saltarelle with the sound of a classic Hohner. Maybe we need the melodeon equivalent of the Mazda MX5 - everything the MGB should have been but never quite was. But then, I'd rather drive either of the MGBs I've owned than either of the MX5s I've driven, enjoyable though they were; they just didn't have that "personality" in just the same way as modern sophisticated boxes don't.
Graham
Very true, Hohners have bags of personality. I've owned quite a few, loved all of them and played them exclusively for the last couple of years.
What really gets me is the inverse snobbery a lot of people display, making excuses for the shortcomings of Hohners and referring to Italian boxes in rather disparaging terms. I haven't noticed it anywhere else and that attitude seems to be uniquely English as far as I'm aware.
I also don't buy JK's mantra that they're the only boxes that sound right for English music. Hohners do have a lovely sound but it's only a sound, not THE sound...
-
I'd rather drive either of the MGBs I've owned than either of the MX5s I've driven, enjoyable though they were; they just didn't have that "personality"
Yeah, if you were pootling down to the local pub & then standing around admiring it with the "boys". But which car would you choose to make a long distance tour around Europe? 8)
My favourite box is my vintage 12 bass Hohner - it's what I play most of the time. I love the sound (tuned pretty dry) which is also distinct from the sound of a Pokerwork. It is certainly not as responsive to play as my Merlin however, which makes it ill-suited to certain tunes. And the clacking ... ! I'm afraid I'm about to get rid of (or at least reduce) the clacking. It may be appropriate to some tunes, but overall it's an awful distraction IMO.
-
Vintage Hohners have The Sound. The sort of sound with personality, with depth. The sort of sound that makes even the most mundane music seem interesting. I love it. ........ I think that someone who could build a box with the sound of an old Hohner but the playability of a Costalotti would make a fortune, but there would be lots who preferred the clackety buttons.
My best shot to achieve this was getting Mike Rowbotham to fit Hohner treble reeds and blocks into a Castagnari Tommy. This is reported on my Hohner-Tommy thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7456.msg92584.html#msg92584) which also contains links to sound samples so you can judge for yourselves how it turned out. I, personally, am delighted with the MM sound and think the MMM is uniquely wonderful.
-
I admit my favourite box to pick up and play is the 12 bass preciosa skillfully assembled by Mike and Theo; sure, it's a little clackity, and sure, the preciosa sized reeds' pitch is so variable depending on how hard you push it that it's virtually useless as an ensemble instrument, but as a solo instrument it just sings. It's incredibly light and responsive, and plays like a dream.
I've done a bit of recording (second Vivant CD!) on the Mory in the past couple of weeks - and with foldback, headphones, etc it's a lot more rewarding to play than if I play it acoustically. I think the big case is actually fairly poor at reflecting sound back to the player, especially at the higher end of the keyboard - sounds great to the listener, not so much to the player. That may be a reason why the smaller boxes like the preciosa seem more 'fun' to play to me.
-
I'd rather drive either of the MGBs I've owned than either of the MX5s I've driven, enjoyable though they were; they just didn't have that "personality"
Yeah, if you were pootling down to the local pub & then standing around admiring it with the "boys". But which car would you choose to make a long distance tour around Europe? 8)
An E-Type!! ;)
-
I'd rather drive either of the MGBs I've owned than either of the MX5s I've driven, enjoyable though they were; they just didn't have that "personality"
Yeah, if you were pootling down to the local pub & then standing around admiring it with the "boys". But which car would you choose to make a long distance tour around Europe? 8)
An E-Type!! ;)
I wouldn't care what it was (I don't drive) although if I did it would be a pink car. :P
-
An E-Type!!
HA! Somewhat off topic, I know but ... my father-in-law owned an E-type back in the late '60's. It spent so much time in the shop being "fixed" that he came to the conclusion that in order to drive an E-type it was required to have a second one as a back-up!
I admit my favourite box to pick up and play is the 12 bass preciosa skillfully assembled by Mike and Theo; sure, it's a little clackity, and sure, the preciosa sized reeds' pitch is so variable depending on how hard you push it that it's virtually useless as an ensemble instrument, but as a solo instrument it just sings. It's incredibly light and responsive, and plays like a dream.
Love the sound of your Preciosa. The pitch of my old 12 bass Hohner also "bends" depending on how much pressure you apply - it makes it sound very much like a harmonica at times. It definitely gives it "character"!
-
Love the sound of your Preciosa. The pitch of my old 12 bass Hohner also "bends" depending on how much pressure you apply - it makes it sound very much like a harmonica at times. It definitely gives it "character"!
Cheers - yes, I think that's right. The pitch bending is what makes it sound so great as a solo instrument; I think if I ever "fixed" that it would be far less fun to play solo.
-
If someone put a new box on the market with noisy actions, buttons that disappear down the keyboard holes, reeds that are prone to breakage or poorly designed springs that also break easily they'd be crucified.
That's exactly the point, Hohners have been around forever, they are not a new design!
As for the statements about reeds and springs, I have never had these issues with old or new Hohners.
-
The fact that they're not a new design and have been around forever doesn't change the fact that they have major flaws that people wouldn't stand for in a new box. DDR abortions of days gone by don't get a free pass on criticism, what makes Hohners exempt?...."Hohner Goggles" perhaps?. ;D
...and you might have not had issues with the reeds and springs on Hohners but a lot of people have...
-
The fact that they're not a new design and have been around forever doesn't change the fact that they have major flaws that people wouldn't stand for in a new box. DDR abortions of days gone by don't get a free pass on criticism, what makes Hohners exempt?...."Hohner Goggles" perhaps?. ;D
...and you might have not had issues with the reeds and springs on Hohners but a lot of people have...
Tell you what Andy, the Hohner Liberation Front will allow you to like what ever melodeons float your boat and but you must let us HLF members like and promote Hohners (:)
-
Well, look at it from the other end.
They have been probably THE dominant player in the melodeon field for over eighty years. The 2915 series, warts and all, first produced in 1930s (?) is still selling, still in demand, still supported.
The vast majority of Hohner box owners - who most likely are not on here - had a free choice about that they bought, I expect some even had friends to ask, they could have bought cheaper, they could have bought dearer, Hohner are still going strong.
So it takes very simple logic to say they must be doing something right.
Just because nous ne savons pas quite what the particular je ne sais quoi is, it is clearly there.
-
Well, look at it from the other end.
They have been probably THE dominant player in the melodeon field for over eighty years. The 2915 series, warts and all, first produced in 1930s (?) is still selling, still in demand, still supported.
Has ANYONE else used the same parts (or the same size parts) for ANY one box for such a length of time? , the fact that you can buy a 2x15 which is 80 years old and get almost evey part for it (and a load of parts for other less common boxes which shared parts) has to be pretty unique - also you can buy every part of a Pokerwork off the shelf in the UK including the casings and build one as a KIT !! (though it`d cost a Fortune) - I don`t know how willing other makers are about selling parts even let alone to such a degree as Hohner...
I agree with the Naysayers to a degree, they are relatively built like crap, I had a shock when I got my Pokerwork and saw how cheaply made and cost-cutting it was compared to the Delicia Popular..... I then thought , must be the Chinese ones - Nope, got a 1950s German 1040 1 Row and its made Just the same from the same bits, worse in fact in one way that it`s not got felted pallets like the Chinese PW has... but the SOUND , Oh the sound..
The Club 3B/S is far better made (30s/40s) as is the Atlantic (70s) but these were hi-end instruments of their days and even then the build of even cheaper Italian stuff is more refined and the fittings better quality
-
To clarify again, I like Hohners. If I didn't then I wouldn't have bought, (IIRC), 9 of them.
My issue is with the double standards and reverse snobbery...
-
The business success of a company is not always a consequence of the quality of their products. Microsoft anyone?
Hohner has been, & continues to be, completely dominant in the area of DBAs. I'm not sure that this is because their product is so great, but rather because, years ago, they somehow managed to completely dominate & control the market. With that domination came economies of scale that may have prevented any other company from effectively competing. The Pokerwork/Erica line is a flawed design that has barely been updated or improved in 50 years. Not updating the design over the years presumably has allowed Hohner to further reduce their production costs & increase their profitability. The only likely competition now would have to come from a Chinese manufactured product, but maybe demand isn't great enough to spur anyone to try to go head-to-head with a company as established as Hohner.
All that having been said, the Hohner sound is a distinctive & appealing sound which is enough to persuade some people to spend a lot of time & trouble doing the things to their Hohner boxes that Hohner could/should have done to them in the initial manufacturing process. Of course, Hohner actually HAS improved their basic Pokerwork design - with the fairly recent introduction of the Morgane/Merlin/Galaad line. These boxes ARE a reasonable, cheaply-produced alternative to the more hand-built Italian boxes.
-
Over the last couple of years I've seen two long time knowledgeable and entertaining members cease contributing after a lengthy series of acerbic comments were made about instruments they owned, and enjoyed. The spirit of this forum normally is positive and friendly, which must be one reason why it is successful.
-
You can't generalize too much, can you.
The good Hohners of the 40s and 50s have a unique and lovely sound and are good reliable boxes.
Same for the good Pokerworks.
Key noise can be reduced by suitable surgery and I believe this is worth doing. They are "part of the sound" but you can have too much of a good (?) thing...
And there's nothing like a pokerwork for paint jobs, lowered action, performance and comfort tweaks and all the rest of that "boy racer" customization. Like certain cars, it's the classic chassis for modding.
-
And there's nothing like a pokerwork for paint jobs, lowered action, performance and comfort tweaks and all the rest of that "boy racer" customization. Like certain cars, it's the classic chassis for modding.
Absolutely! And as Adam-T mentioned, we can literally build a Pokerwork from new spares. How about that for product support!
Yes, one can be shocked when looking inside a box, finding out how some parts were roughly made or assembled, but the whole thing works and sounds great! And is very easy to repair, customize or improve.
We Hohner-o-philes do not deny the fact that there are lots of very nice boxes out there, but nothing plays or sounds like a 2x15-series Hohner!
-
Love the sound of your Preciosa. The pitch of my old 12 bass Hohner also "bends" depending on how much pressure you apply - it makes it sound very much like a harmonica at times. It definitely gives it "character"!
Cheers - yes, I think that's right. The pitch bending is what makes it sound so great as a solo instrument; I think if I ever "fixed" that it would be far less fun to play solo.
Agreed. I find this with mine and it is probably the single thing that I love most about the instrument. My only criticism is that it doesn't work very well in a dry room, really needs a spot of reverb to sound its best.
-
If someone put a new box on the market with noisy actions, buttons that disappear down the keyboard holes, reeds that are prone to breakage or poorly designed springs that also break easily
I wonder, is the disappearing button syndrome a relatively recent (in terms of Hohner history) phenomenon? My two Ericas, both bought new in the 70s, with plastic keyboards did it - the slightly earlier red one in particular to such an extent that it became quite uncomfortable to play for any length of time and led to the first modification I ever did to a box (a chunk of foam under the levers - crude but reasonably effective!). But I don't seem to have the problem on the old wooden-fingerboard "Unpokerwork". Are the holes a closer fit on the wooden fingerboards so that the ends of your fingers automatically limit the button travel, or is it just that you don't notice it because the wooden fingerboard lacks the sharp edges of the plastic ones? Or were the older actions more carefully assembled? Or is there some other factor at work?
Incidentally, in 30-odd years and about a dozen Hohners I have had one spring go and never had a broken reed. I know I'm probably lucky and that others have had a number of problems in these areas, but there you are.
Graham
-
My 1950s 1040 1 row does it.... the Club-3BS doesn`t but then it`s at the other end of the scale price wise and about 15-20 years older ....
the daft part is that Hohner never did anything about it in at least 60 years, made no effort to reduce it even - and I thought camera makers were bad for repeating stupid mistakes ! ..whatever, I`m glad the boxes are still made and still pretty much exactly the same (unlike the Atlantic IV "Re-Issue" which is only an Atlantic in name and similar-ish appearance and is a totally different box construction wise) ..
I for one don`t mind the plastic fingerboard, it`s durable and won`t crack between the holes, I`ll have to get around to doing the mod though, I didn`t know it came in as early as the 70s (you learn something every day), I`d have guessed it was a 90s introduction but then the Hohner Button boxes I`ve experienced so far have either been up to the late 60s or nearly new. Did the Corsos move from the wood'n'bogseat to plastic at the same time?
-
Are the holes a closer fit on the wooden fingerboards so that the ends of your fingers automatically limit the button travel, or is it just that you don't notice it because the wooden fingerboard lacks the sharp edges of the plastic ones? Or were the older actions more carefully assembled? Or is there some other factor at work?
Graham
Quick check -
- 1940s (?) Erika. Buttons don't go quite as far below the keyboard (fingerboard not so deep internally or maybe thicker due to wooden construction?). Edges of holes less noticeable.
- Plastic kbd Erica - keys depress further, haven't measured but noticeable to the touch, also edges of holes feel sharper.
- Chinese toy - buttons don't go very deep because they bottom out in the much thinner fingerboard. Design feature or just how it happened?
-
the Club-3BS doesn`t but then it`s at the other end of the scale price wise and about 15-20 years older
If it's like my old Club II with a three-piece fingerboard, it will have a felt-topped bar under the levers to limit movement. So they were aware of the problem donkey's years ago, but chose to address it only on the upper-end button boxes. (At least, I assume the bar is original - it certainly looks contemporary with the rest of the box).
Graham
-
Over the last couple of years I've seen two long time knowledgeable and entertaining members cease contributing after a lengthy series of acerbic comments were made about instruments they owned, and enjoyed. The spirit of this forum normally is positive and friendly, which must be one reason why it is successful.
I'm with you. Each to their own, that's why we have such a rich and varied tradition.
I love all of my Hohners (7 of 'em) for different reasons (they all sound and play differently!). I love my Dino Black pearl II which is different again. My Dino Oakwood Special is my pride and joy, and different from all the others. I'm not keen on Castagnaris, Salterelles etc, and prefer my Hohners and Dinos, that's my own preference, can understand why others love them.
So let's stop dissing each others boxes!
-
[[[ With my admin hat on, I don't think there's anything particularly contentious in this thread is there? Certainly nothing I've come remotely close to vetoing, and I'm not shy about doing that sort of thing. Just a bit of interesting discussions about older Hohners, their pluses and minuses. If there's anything people find offensive, simply use the report link so I can take a look; might do something about it, might not, but I'd always prefer to know what's going on -- Clive ]]]
-
If it's like my old Club II with a three-piece fingerboard, it will have a felt-topped bar under the levers to limit movement. So they were aware of the problem donkey's years ago, but chose to address it only on the upper-end button boxes. (At least, I assume the bar is original - it certainly looks contemporary with the rest of the box).
there`s certainly felt topped somethings under the levers , some celluloid too (weird), the stop-levers are under the fingerboard on this model so the underside doesn`t come off . yoiu can also see how it could have been a 3 row with a few more buttons and pallets. the inner row are muffled compared to the rest due to the 3 tier design compared the later densely packed 2 tier design of the Corona-IIIs
-
I normally use my Hohner pressed wood for morris but take the Saltarelle Nuage if the weather is cold and wet.
That is how I value my instruments.
Cheers,
Sandy
Hooray for Hohners (:)
-
So let's stop dissing each others boxes!
I agree with Clive - I don't see anything particularly contentious about this discussion. And I don't think it's a question of dissing others boxes, as practically everyone here owns or has owned Hohners.
Hohner seems to have a somewhat unique position if the DBA market: somehow or other (perhaps because their designs were actually superior in the first decades on the 20th century) Hohner came to completely dominate the market for DBAs - if you look at Ebay it would appear that at least 90% of the vintage boxes out there are Hohners of one type or another. Having successfully secured a quasi-monopoly, like some other big corporations in the same position, Hohner just sat back & coasted. They chose, over a period of 60 + years not to fix what most people see as a "flaw" in the design of their biggest-selling boxes - disappearing buttons & inadequately cushioned palettes - a fix that would have cost practically nothing to address. Most inexcusable of all is their decision to start putting the most pathetic bellows tape imaginable on their low-end boxes.
However, none of this criticism means I don't enjoy the sound of a well-tuned vintage Hohner box ... (:)
-
I just think it is wonderful that we have such a huge variety of old and new boxes from numerous makers. So much choice that everyone can find an instrument that suits them. The internet has also done us a great service in getting access to this cornucopia of choice, especially the great 1930s instruments that many of us have rediscovered, and which otherwise might have been left mouldering in attics and cellars.
-
I have owned around 50 boxes, nearly half have been Hohners.. from 1040's to Club Overtures. I always felt I needed to upgrade to "better" boxes and as a consequence owned 9 Castagnaris a couple Serenellinis and some other fine accordeons.
With few exceptions , they were all great. But, I kept coming back to Hohners.
I had a conversation many years ago about this with Paul Groff. I recall exactly what he said: "Lots of great music has been made on Hohners".
We agreed they are cheap and cheerful, light, fast, fun, with gobs of character and some niggling flaws that can be overlooked or corrected with ease.
I still have a 50's HA112 in A that is undergoing some mods and restoration. I suspect before ( or while ) I lay out serious money and wait for a custom made box...I'll own another Hohner.
-
I find it interesting that of all the boxes I have tuned (quite a few now) the two The Sainted Mrs Bailey said she liked the sound of most were two Chinese Pokerworks
-
So let's stop dissing each others boxes!
I'm not aware of anyone disrespecting (sorry, I'm a former English teacher!) anyone else's choice of instrument - as far as I can see most, if not all, of the contributors own several boxes by different makers and use them all in the situation that suits each best. I don't recall anyone suggesting brand A is always better than brand B, or that brand X is rubbish, or that anyone ought to be playing box Y or Z rather than his/her current favourite. If anything, rather the reverse - it's a case of "horses for courses".
Graham
(Sorry for starting all this off!)
-
Agreed, I have a place in my heart for anything which is reliable and can bash out a decent tune however dull or unwanted it may seem (even klingenthals if they actually work like the Weltmeister/Worldmasters). I like squeezing tunes from the cheapest of stuff and nearly everyone has a soft spot for the £10 plastic toy 1 Row in C (especially Hector who raided an Erica for reeds to pep one up) .
I only tend to bash the nameless chinese boxes and only then because of the reed contamination from sawdust and unreliable mechanisms, not the sound which is often pretty good and then really because w eall know they could be a lot better with a little more care.
-
round and round in circles, ....try another box, 3 voice then 4, then single row,..then 'outside-in' for a while... maybe not , try inside out, works better...12 basses, back to 8, give B/C another whirl, lower action, raise action, long strap, short strap...maybe just thumbstrap, big, big, even wider circles...where am i now?...back at the very beginning - two voice clacky hohner double ray in C sharp/D, standard soprani type basses, medium strap and inevitably confronting my personal demons (which dwell somewhere in my neuromucular system, between my brain and fingertips!)
hohners for me, folk instrument for a peasant, that's where it started.
-
;D the 36 year old, battered, clacky, repaired with self tapping screws and carpet tape d/G pokerwork had an outing on Saturday, playing for Ebor Morris - what a sound, what a box! Unbeatable by any account. My oldest, and most favourite, box. !!!
-
Am I the only squeezer who has never had a D/g Pokerwork?
-
Am I the only squeezer who has never had a D/g Pokerwork?
Nope, neither have I! ;D
-
Nor me!
-
A sympathetic morris musician let me use his new (therefore Chinese build) DG Pokerwork. He'd ditched it after a month because of the many repairs needed to keep it going; he went on to get a Beltuna Sara III and the PW is gathering dust. I took it on holiday last August, to see if melodeon playing was for me; I returned it and got the Sandpiper for few quid more than a new PW.
I like the old German ones, properly setup, great Morris box: that said, I'll probably never buy one.
-
I was at a workshop with Ed Rennie over the weekend - his everyday box is a Chinese Erica and he said that he's very pleased with it.
And the Devon Squeezebox Pokerworks (all D/G of course) did have a certain something about them...
I rented a D/G Pokerwork for a few weeks - does that count?
-
Might have something to do with the acoustics of your house as opposed to wherever else you play.
That said, I bought a Hohner because I just loved the deep, rumbling basses. Just heard someone playing it on YouTube and loved the sound. It's sort of like the distorted electric guitar of the melodeon world. Yes, you can buy a beautiful, hand-made classical guitar, but when you're rocking with your mates in the garage, it's the Les Paul copy you want.
-
when you're rocking with your mates in the garage, it's the Les Paul copy you want.
Naah - you want a 335-alike ;D. Sorry - thread drift alert - won't do it again!
Graham
-
At the risk of extending the thread drift too far, one of the things about being an Esperantist is that you learn things about other planned languages, and because of this, I know two words of Klingon; one of these is "leSpol", which means guitar, which is an intentional homage.
I do not know the Klingon word for melodeon, however, they do appear to have played some kind of concertina, called a may'ron:
http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Klingon_concertina
http://www.klingonmusic.net/klingon-musical-instruments/susdeq/mayron/
/edit I do love the way it is noted that it "could also be used as a weapon".
More a Star Wars girl myself.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LC803TA3MY0
-
Nah - you don't want a LeSpol or a 335alike - you need a Stratalike (or even a genu-ine Leo F version)!
Anyway...back to the original point - I agree, GPS, when I'm at home and just fancy a quick melnoodle, I tend to pick up my Hohner PW rather than either of my Saltarelles. Not coz it's better - it just seems to sit there wanting to be played.
-
Nah - you don't want a LeSpol or a 335alike - you need a Stratalike (or even a genu-ine Leo F version)!
Anyway...back to the original point - I agree, GPS, when I'm at home and just fancy a quick melnoodle, I tend to pick up my Hohner PW rather than either of my Saltarelles. Not coz it's better - it just seems to sit there wanting to be played.
Now I DO like the concept of a "melnoodle"!
Graham
-
I just looked over my shoulder and guess what? There's an Epi LP on the stand in the corner and two clubs and a Preciosa by my armchair...
The Castagnari is in its case by the front door, just waiting to go out and play.
Rob.
-
I just looked over my shoulder and guess what? There's an Epi LP on the stand in the corner and two clubs and a Preciosa by my armchair...
The Castagnari is in its case by the front door, just waiting to go out and play.
Rob.
Ah - another Epi fan! My 335-alike is a Sheraton........
Graham
-
(...) I tend to pick up my Hohner PW rather than either of my Saltarelles. Not coz it's better - it just seems to sit there wanting to be played.
Looks to me like it's the Pokerwork playing with you...
-
I sneaked my old 1040 pokerwork one row in G into the office today after everyone else had gone home and played it loud for the first time. Now that I've heard it properly I can definitely say, no it's not just you.
;D
-
I just looked over my shoulder and guess what? There's an Epi LP on the stand in the corner and two clubs and a Preciosa by my armchair...
The Castagnari is in its case by the front door, just waiting to go out and play.
Rob.
Very Italian - looks extremely chic and classy, sits there being very tempting - but won't make a move until you ask if it's time to play...... >:E
-
Met a chap (don't know his name - he may be on this list) in Sidmouth last year with a Castagnari Mori. It had been tuned to sound like a Hohner pokerwork(!) - says it all I suppose. I've never owned one, but I've played a few. The 'feel' takes some getting used to, but I do like the sound, especially the couple I've played tuned in Eflat -Bflat. I can't help thinking a whole new range of tune would spring to mind if I had one.
Quote from a Sidmouth melodeon competition:- John Kirkpatrick, presenting a Hohner to Lawrence Wright, the winner. "This is a Hohner Pokerwork, ladies and gentlemen, in case you've forgotten. Why does no-one ever play one these days?"
Lawrence, "They dissolve in beer".
-
Why does no-one ever play one these days?"
Judging by the numbers of Pokerworks I get for repair there are still hordes of them being played. (:)
-
Why does no-one ever play one these days?"
Judging by the numbers of Pokerworks I get for repair there are still hordes of them being played. (:)
That was several years ago, I see them everywhere now!
-
Quote from a Sidmouth melodeon competition:- John Kirkpatrick, presenting a Hohner to Lawrence Wright, the winner. "This is a Hohner Pokerwork, ladies and gentlemen, in case you've forgotten. Why does no-one ever play one these days?"
Lawrence, "They dissolve in beer".
I remember that competition well - John Spiers and I were both contestants. As evidenced by the above, neither of us won.
1997? Before Spiers and Boden were playing together, anyway.
-
Quote from a Sidmouth melodeon competition:- John Kirkpatrick, presenting a Hohner to Lawrence Wright, the winner. "This is a Hohner Pokerwork, ladies and gentlemen, in case you've forgotten. Why does no-one ever play one these days?"
Lawrence, "They dissolve in beer".
I remember that competition well - John Spiers and I were both contestants. As evidenced by the above, neither of us won.
1997? Before Spiers and Boden were playing together, anyway.
I used to work in a fairground, and well remember the 'Wall of Death', (which needed daily checking of nuts and bolts). At Sidmouth, feeling mighty relieved I'd decided not to enter the competition, I thought how much I'd prefer to ride a motorbike around the walls of that vertical drum!
-
I had the pleasure of playing Simon Ritchie's Corona III today. One of the nicest, richest sounding boxes I've ever had the pleasure to play. Reminded me why I love Hohners. The tuning is just perfect - a gorgeous rounded sound that made the right hand chords just sing.
Trouble is, I now have a real craving for an MMM Hohner - anyone got a spare Corona or Corso lying around?! :P
-
I learnt to play melodeon for morris on a borrowed Trichord II, then bought an older Double Ray. What I liked about them was that they cut through, making me feel like I contributed something to the band. I haven't picked up my Double Ray for about a year.
I think my expensive Italian box sounds better, works better, is easier to play, is far better quality, is far more versatile, cuts through better and is just far more fun than any Hohner I've played. I don't miss playing my Double Ray and only pick up my 1 row 4 stop every once in a while. I wonder if that'll change when I'm older.
I will concede though that I had a lot of fun arsing around with a Pokerwork at Chippenham, and it'll always be the box I'd recommend to a beginner. I also find it difficult to resist falling in love with any Liliput or Preciosa I pick up and play.
-
I had the pleasure of playing Simon Ritchie's Corona III today. One of the nicest, richest sounding boxes I've ever had the pleasure to play.
I noticed yesterday what a BIG sound that box has, when he played it outside for Thaxted morris. He had the good sense to switch to a smaller box when we were playing tunes inside afterwards, or he'd have drowned us all out.
The first melodeon I ever heard (at close quarters, anyway) was Colin Cater's, which at the time was a Corona III just like that one. I was so convinced that a three voice musette was essential for being heard properly when playing dance music that I purchased a Hohner Gaelic IV when I could afford it.
-
I have to admit that as much as I like the LMM smooth warm power of the old square Club-3BS , I prefer the brighter Raw wide musette of the MMM Corso - I just wish the Corso (and coronas etc) had the 3B-S`s almost subsonic bass end and low notes instead of accidentals (aptly named as I accidently hit them producing "popeye whistles" when a low note was expected)
-
Acid Nettles, you say?
-
I also find it difficult to resist falling in love with any Liliput or Preciosa I pick up and play.
The more I play my two, the more I conclude that they are different instruments to the run of the mill. Utterly sublime constructions.
-
And I'd dearly love to be able to justify and afford one. It was particularly heart wrenching when that converted D/G passed through the buy and sell section recently.
-
I also find it difficult to resist falling in love with any Liliput or Preciosa I pick up and play.
The more I play my two, the more I conclude that they are different instruments to the run of the mill. Utterly sublime constructions.
I've just bought one! Love at first play.?it is so light, responsive, and sweet sounding (i got a d/g lilliput). I just can't put it down! and best of all, it fits into my gig bag with the morris kit and tankard in the same bag - a real bonus!
-
Congratulations! It was size that originally got me interested, I can get a Liliput and a concertina in my holdall on top of a week's clothing and still zip it up.
But the Erica has been rather lonely since it arrived.
So where did you get it?
-
from Myrrh Music, a fellow melnetter - Mary advertised it on our Buy and Sell forum :-)
-
Quote from a Sidmouth melodeon competition:- John Kirkpatrick, presenting a Hohner to Lawrence Wright, the winner. "This is a Hohner Pokerwork, ladies and gentlemen, in case you've forgotten. Why does no-one ever play one these days?"
Lawrence, "They dissolve in beer".
I remember that competition well - John Spiers and I were both contestants. As evidenced by the above, neither of us won.
1997? Before Spiers and Boden were playing together, anyway.
I used to work in a fairground, and well remember the 'Wall of Death', (which needed daily checking of nuts and bolts). At Sidmouth, feeling mighty relieved I'd decided not to enter the competition, I thought how much I'd prefer to ride a motorbike around the walls of that vertical drum!
No, not 1997. It was 1999. I know for certain, because I have the trophy in front of me.
1999 - Lawrence Wright
2000 - John Carroll
2001 - Ian Roberts
2002 - Neil Browning
2003 - James Tween
2004 - John Golightly
The competition fell by the wayside thereafter - there were far too many other things for the new organisers of the Festival to worry about. I know that for certain too. Watch this space.....