That's where Bruno Le Tron has his F bass/chord.
Andy - Hypothetically speaking, is there a pull bass/chord that you wouldn't miss so much? My read is that you like the Hohner layout as is. My inexperience here leads me to have a much less nuanced veiw of things and I'm assuming there was/is a good reason for the layout.
Actually, while it seems like Bruno Le Tron has "subbed out" the Dm/Amaj buttons, he actually has a standard G/C bass layout and has added four lower bass/chord buttons, and an inside row of accidentals. I think that it is more useful to think of Le Tron's box as a heavily enhanced G/C than as a modified G/C/F.
If you are going to convert the F row to a row of #s ("accidentals") then it makes sense to reconfigure the bass. The Amaj/Dminor bass/chord makes a lot of sense on a GCF and is perhaps less central on a G/C/acc box. If you change some aspects of the G/C/F without changing others, you will not really be maximizing the advantages.
FYI the Amaj/D minor basses are used when playing in D minor on the C row, crossing into the F row. If you tape off the third of the A major chord's reeds, then you can use the chord as a pressed A minor. Today I was learning Fredric Paris tunes on the C and F rows and I used the Amaj/Dminor buttons quite a bit. If you get rid of those bass/chord possibilities, then you might as well change most of the notes on the F row because you'll be giving up so many of the reasons for G/C/F to begin with.
There is a lot to be said for getting a G/C/acc box instead of a G/C/F. Changing a Gabbanelli to G/C/acc doesn't make a lot of sense because it is unlikely that you will ever recoup the expense of the conversion if you resell it. For the direction you are going, it would make more sense (in my opinion) to get a used G/C box, or treat the C/F rows on your box as a (perfectly functional) C/F box, and learn it from a book (Milleret/Pignol for example) as if it is a G/C. By the way, it is easy to use software on your computer to shift the pitch of the pedagogical recordings. I recommend Seventh String Software's "Transcribe" for pitch shifting (and "slow downing"), but Audacity has features that allow this as well.
Logged




