Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?  (Read 11402 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Montana Melodeon

  • Guest
What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« on: November 13, 2008, 03:33:11 AM »

Hi everyone!

This is usually presented the opposite way.  Many very good players use the semitone system.  I have been listening to you-tube and my space pages from many melodeon players from this forum and I hear a high standard of playing from those players using the DG system too. So what are the advantages for those who carry a DG and a CF over the BC or C#D? There are thousands of tunes that would fit easily on the diatonic system so it seems a person could play for years before needing the semitone system (if they would ever need it)  Any thoughts?

Thank you!  Eric in Montana
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #1 on: November 13, 2008, 09:58:37 AM »

Hi everyone!

This is usually presented the opposite way.  Many very good players use the semitone system.  I have been listening to you-tube and my space pages from many melodeon players from this forum and I hear a high standard of playing from those players using the DG system too. So what are the advantages for those who carry a DG and a CF over the BC or C#D? There are thousands of tunes that would fit easily on the diatonic system so it seems a person could play for years before needing the semitone system (if they would ever need it)  Any thoughts?

Thank you!  Eric in Montana


Personal preference aside each system has advantages & disadvantages over the other & choice depends to a large degree on what is most popular in your neck of the woods i.e. if most people play Dg it is much more likely that a newcomer to the box will take up the Dg * vice versa with the BC.  Some people (including me in my teens) just bought a melodeon not having a clue about different systems or tunings. It happened I bought a BC double ray as did a mate of mine. - we both played for several years in B or C! until accidentally discovering that other keys could be got out of it.   In other words we played them like DG boxes , mostly in C because the bottom 4 bases fit in the same way as on a Dg.

As a plaayer of both systems  I prefer the Dg  for most  'English (ish) session playing and certainly for playing for a veriety of dance as their is more of a natural bounce & the bass ,whilst not offering huge harmonic possibilities are very good for driving a rhythm.  It is also capaable of giving as full a sound as a 120 bass accordion  but with a fraaction of the weight.

The BC in standard form has fairly useless bass  (there are various  possibilitie of having these altered & some examples aare on this forum) but is in theory chromatic. In practice the keys of BCGDAEF are fairly easy after which it gets progressively more difficult. Same benefits of light weight & portability as Dg  but with a better chance of having the right key for eg a singer or if playing with others  who like to use a wider range of keys.  Fingering & bellows reversals arguably faster than on a Dg making it perhaps more suitable for 200 mph stuff! if that turns you on.  I once had a 3 voice hohner double ray de lux with 12 stadella bass which ws a revelation compared with the standard 8 suck & blow basses.( hohner built them that way but they are pretty rare)

To some up , in my view neither has a clear overall advantage  & both have their good points, at the end of the day its down to personal choice , influenced by who/what you play with and your long term musical 'ambitions'.  Either system  is fine if you are happy with  a very limited range of keys - if not the BC is perhaps the better choice. If its dance music in D or G (& a bit of A)  then the DG  has an aadvantage in the bass department.- but as I have mentioned the bass on a BC can be improved. 

It will be interesting to hear more views on this

george
« Last Edit: November 13, 2008, 10:11:00 AM by Theo »
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #2 on: November 13, 2008, 01:46:41 PM »

There are thousands of tunes that would fit easily on the diatonic system so it seems a person could play for years before needing the semitone system (if they would ever need it).

Well that really depends on the music your person wants to play. The reason I chose C#/D over D/G was that I couldn't stomach the thought of being stuck in the same limited range of keys as I was on a D tin whistle - one sharp or two, basically.

On a D/G, within the keys available, you have more possibilities for cross-rowing, ergo more choice for legato phrasing and getting the basses to fit.

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #3 on: November 13, 2008, 02:50:11 PM »

 .

On a D/G, within the keys available, you have more possibilities for cross-rowing, ergo more choice for legato phrasing and getting the basses to fit.


[/quote]

lagato phrasing can be done perfectly well on the row - its all down to delicate  bellows control, the bellows being to the box player what the bow is to the fidler (so to speek)  Agreed cross rowing can increase the 'fit' of the bass  but I tend only to do so in slow tunes such as waltzes where the required bass note is going to be around for long enough to make a real difference. My personal feeling is that in fast tunes its not worth the bother as the bass note cross rowed  for is only going to be around for a fraction of a second so makes little if any difference to what the punters hear. ;)

george

gorge
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #4 on: November 13, 2008, 03:14:56 PM »

If you want to play chords on the right hand there is a wider range available on a D/G

On a D/G, within the keys available, you have more possibilities for cross-rowing, ergo more choice for legato phrasing and getting the basses to fit.

Quote
lagato phrasing can be done perfectly well on the row - its all down to delicate  bellows control, the bellows being to the box player what the bow is to the fidler (so to speek)  Agreed cross rowing can increase the 'fit' of the bass  but I tend only to do so in slow tunes such as waltzes where the required bass note is going to be around for long enough to make a real difference. My personal feeling is that in fast tunes its not worth the bother as the bass note cross rowed  for is only going to be around for a fraction of a second so makes little if any difference to what the punters hear. ;)

george

George I think you are talking about your personal preferences, which is not what the original question was about.

I have to agree with Steve, that there are more choices for cross row playing on a D/G.  Choosing to play across or on the row is up to the player.  On a semitone apart box, you have very much less choice.
« Last Edit: November 13, 2008, 03:19:48 PM by Theo »
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Quebecois

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1206
  • Accordez-vous donc, c'est si beau, l'accordéon!
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #5 on: November 13, 2008, 03:27:24 PM »

There are probably as many views on the subject as there are melodeon players, but (especially for a beginner) I guess it's all about simplicity!

If most of what you play or want to play (as noted by Steve and others) is in the keys of (put the names here) then get an instrument in those keys.  
Logged
Hohner Morgane D/G, pre-Erica Hohner in C/F and G/C,
Hohner Erica A/D, Roland FR-18

Montana Melodeon

  • Guest
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #6 on: November 13, 2008, 04:13:23 PM »

"Fingering & bellows reversals arguably faster than on a Dg making it perhaps more suitable for 200 mph stuff!"

Hi George,

This thread already has great information.  Thank you.  I have a question on the statement I copied from your first response. How is it that the fingering and reversals are faster on the BC? I would think that 2 boxes by one company would have the same components and if so shouldn't the mechanical fingering be the same?

I'm not trying to start anything, I'm just trying to sort out a future direction for playing.

With respect, Eric in Montana
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #7 on: November 13, 2008, 06:31:18 PM »

hi Eric

note that I said that fingering on Bc is arguably faster than Dg  & many BC players feel that way. However there are also many who play fast Irish music  very competantly on teh DG.  As Theo said I am talking to some degree about  my personal preferences  and at the end of the day ones personal preferences are entirely to blame for ones choice of box.  I suppose bringing the difference between DG & Bc down to basics you could argue that the Dg  has limited choice of keys but reasonable bass whereas the BC  offers more keys but less useful bass. Anything else is down to personal preference and prefered style of playing.

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #8 on: November 13, 2008, 08:21:57 PM »

legato phrasing can be done perfectly well on the row - its all down to delicate  bellows control, the bellows being to the box player what the bow is to the fidler (so to speek)

I don't know if you play fiddle George but playing several notes in the same bow stroke (slurring) can produce a legato effect that cannot be got with separate bow strokes (and vice versa), even if a very skilled player can get close.

Back to boxes: when I play a run of several notes in the same bellows direction (say EF#G on my C#/D box, or ABc#d on my B/C) at speed, I can make them totally legato - no separation between them, no attack to speak off on the 2nd and following notes. If you or anyone can make those runs sound like that changing bellows direction between every note, I take my hat off to you, him or her.

Steve

Hasse

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 323
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #9 on: November 13, 2008, 08:44:02 PM »

Among other boxes I got a C/C# and a D/G box. The C/C# box works OK for music like klezmer music and Swedish fiddle tunes in strange minor modes, keys that are not possible to play on a two-row diatonic box. And that's might just be the point about semitone boxes - you can play in more keys than on a two row diatonic. When playing a two-row diatonic box you have to change box if the key of a tune get to fare out of reach, you don't have to do that on a semitone box.

The repertoire that sounds good on a semitone box is pretty much the same that sounds good on a diatonic. (But that's of course a personal opinion!) I've come to the very PERSONAL conclusion that it doesn't sound especially good with klezmer music or Swedish fiddle tunes (in strange minor modes) on a semitone box, there are more appropriate instruments for that kind of tunes…

/Hasse


« Last Edit: November 13, 2008, 08:47:31 PM by Hasse »
Logged
Sweden, Skåne

Montana Melodeon

  • Guest
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #10 on: November 13, 2008, 08:54:10 PM »

Hi George,

Thank you for the reply. I will slowly get all this sorted out.  Beginning with a slight but related drift.  If I took a classic reel in d minor, Julia Delaney for example, I would not be able to play it on my DG unless I hurt myself transposing it.
So as a DG player I would pick up a CF and forgo the transposing.  However, if I was sight reading I would find that my C notes and D notes are in opposite directions between the DG and CF melodeon.  This could lead to a slow down until the tune moves from the page to memory.  
On a semitone box I guess that once you know where the notes are located on the keyboard you do not deviate and can concentrate on just learning the tunes in the correct key.--since all the notes are there.--unless you want to transpose during a session from d minor to b minor--very difficult?  I think I am trying to conceive of the BC or C#D as being like a piano keyboard.
On the other hand if a musician already plays various systems it only takes a moment to adjust to whatever box is in your hands in which case its back to how much bass does he or she want.
Once again we come up against the limitations of each system and the melodeon players battle with round pegs and square holes.
Thank you again!  Eric



Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #11 on: November 13, 2008, 10:55:57 PM »

Hi George,

Thank you for the reply. I will slowly get all this sorted out.  Beginning with a slight but related drift.  If I took a classic reel in d minor, Julia Delaney for example, I would not be able to play it on my DG unless I hurt myself transposing it.
So as a DG player I would pick up a CF and forgo the transposing.  However, if I was sight reading I would find that my C notes and D notes are in opposite directions between the DG and CF melodeon.  This could lead to a slow down until the tune moves from the page to memory.  
On a semitone box I guess that once you know where the notes are located on the keyboard you do not deviate and can concentrate on just learning the tunes in the correct key.--since all the notes are there.--unless you want to transpose during a session from d minor to b minor--very difficult?  I think I am trying to conceive of the BC or C#D as being like a piano keyboard.
On the other hand if a musician already plays various systems it only takes a moment to adjust to whatever box is in your hands in which case its back to how much bass does he or she want.
Once again we come up against the limitations of each system and the melodeon players battle with round pegs and square holes.
Thank you again!  Eric





I find the BC much athan the Dg to site read  as, ignoring the spare B & E , the C row represents the 'white' notes and the black notes are picked up from the B row. Therefore G  for example is in exactly the same place & bellow direction whatever key you are in .   The C#D is a bit of a hybrid as many players tend to use the D row in much the same way as on a DG playing on the row but  using accidentals from the C# row for other keys.  eg BC 'G'  fingring produces A on a C# D box.  There may well be other ways of viewing the semitone keyboard such as   fingring different shapes or patterns but  I find the blaack & white notes concept+ knowing exactly what is where works very well.

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #12 on: November 13, 2008, 11:07:19 PM »

legato phrasing can be done perfectly well on the row - its all down to delicate  bellows control, the bellows being to the box player what the bow is to the fidler (so to speek)

I don't know if you play fiddle George but playing several notes in the same bow stroke (slurring) can produce a legato effect that cannot be got with separate bow strokes (and vice versa), even if a very skilled player can get close.

Back to boxes: when I play a run of several notes in the same bellows direction (say EF#G on my C#/D box, or ABc#d on my B/C) at speed, I can make them totally legato - no separation between them, no attack to speak off on the 2nd and following notes. If you or anyone can make those runs sound like that changing bellows direction between every note, I take my hat off to you, him or her.

Steve


In many types of folk music such legato playing -- sometimes referred to as "that slushy piano accordion sound" -- is precisely the reason the many people prefer a D/G or similar box, where gaps between the notes are pretty much compulsory :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

smiley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1021
  • Folk music: it's not as bad as it sounds
    • a few sound clips
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #13 on: November 13, 2008, 11:47:05 PM »

When comparing the DG with the C#D system it seems to me that the DG has an advantage for playing some notes above the 'main' D octave. For example, to play the G above D on the D row of a C#D box requires a stretch of the fingers and/or change of right hand position, while a DG player can just hit the same note on the G row without much effort.

I'm also finding some 'BC-style' triplets on irish tunes are possible when playing from the G row on a DG box. And there's a nice <F#B> chord on the push which can add a bit of grunt when playing Bm/Bdor tunes on the DG. And I could go on ...

You just have to forget about playing a lot of great irish tunes which rely on Fnat and G# notes over two octaves.

In the end its just a personal preference.
Logged

EeeJay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 642
  • Old Grey Paolo
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #14 on: November 14, 2008, 12:33:43 AM »

..."that slushy piano accordion sound" -- is precisely the reason the many people prefer a D/G or similar box...

Somewhat unfair on the Piano Accordion, but oh so true of some of its players... ::)

Folks teaching themselves Piano Accordion from scratch can be easily daunted by the initial undue awkwardness of the keyboard (large stretches, potential for hitting the cracks, etc.), and tend to adopt a generally restricted technique. Plus the fact that many of those who adopt PA from prior experience with a Piano (or touch sensitive keyboard) just don't seem to have any idea that the bellows control the phrasing and dynamics. Organists I assume would know better...

Whilst the piano keyboard naturally stemmed from a linear array such as organ pipes, hammers and strings, it ain't exactly the smartest interface imaginable. Particularly for reeds and bellows. Diatonic accordion of whatever subgenus forces you to think so much more about phrasing, breathing, dynamics...

Ed J
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #15 on: November 14, 2008, 03:24:47 AM »

In many types of folk music such legato playing -- sometimes referred to as "that slushy piano accordion sound" -- is precisely the reason the many people prefer a D/G or similar box, where gaps between the notes are pretty much compulsory :-)
Ian

Oddly enough, I was arguing that the D/G with the reversals between the two rows allows you to play _more_ legato than, say, C#/D. I don't like slush either but there are places in certain lyrical tunes that cry out for legato treatment, in contrast to all the punchy stuff. At least, to my fiddler's  & whistler's ear. When I first started playing C#/D the instrument's refusal to allow me to choose how to phrase such passages used to frustrate me no end. (Now I've knuckled under like the rest of you  ;) )

Quebecois

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1206
  • Accordez-vous donc, c'est si beau, l'accordéon!
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #16 on: November 14, 2008, 05:44:20 PM »

I have always perceived a B/C box as being a C box with a huge accidentals row!
« Last Edit: November 14, 2008, 05:50:10 PM by québécois »
Logged
Hohner Morgane D/G, pre-Erica Hohner in C/F and G/C,
Hohner Erica A/D, Roland FR-18

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #17 on: November 14, 2008, 08:16:24 PM »

..."that slushy piano accordion sound" -- is precisely the reason the many people prefer a D/G or similar box...

Somewhat unfair on the Piano Accordion, but oh so true of some of its players... ::)

Folks teaching themselves Piano Accordion from scratch can be easily daunted by the initial undue awkwardness of the keyboard (large stretches, potential for hitting the cracks, etc.), and tend to adopt a generally restricted technique. Plus the fact that many of those who adopt PA from prior experience with a Piano (or touch sensitive keyboard) just don't seem to have any idea that the bellows control the phrasing and dynamics. Organists I assume would know better...

Whilst the piano keyboard naturally stemmed from a linear array such as organ pipes, hammers and strings, it ain't exactly the smartest interface imaginable. Particularly for reeds and bellows. Diatonic accordion of whatever subgenus forces you to think so much more about phrasing, breathing, dynamics...

Ed J

I agree completely, I've heard (a few) excellent piano box players who've realised that the gaps between the notes are often as important as the notes, or even more so in some cases (playing for dancing) -- but unfortunately they're massively outnumbered by those who haven't...

A push-pull box pretty much forces you to play with such gaps, it takes considerable skill to overcome the limitations of the instrument and play smoothly. With a piano box the opposite is true :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

rees

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5055
  • Windjammer
    • Wesson Accordions
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #18 on: November 16, 2008, 09:55:22 PM »

I have always perceived a B/C box as being a C box with a huge accidentals row!

Me too!  :o
Logged
Rees Wesson (accordion builder and mechanic)
Gungrog, Welshpool, Wales, UK
www.melodeons.com

an bosca ceoil

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 347
Re: What are the advantages of the DG over the BC or C#D systems?
« Reply #19 on: November 16, 2008, 11:42:53 PM »

Reinforces describing B/C as a Button Accordion as opposed to Melodeon? Good many pub players made them sound more like PA than the real thing!
Logged
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal