Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Down

Author Topic: reed nails  (Read 16407 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

C age ing

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 434
  • New fangled melodeon?
Re: reed nails
« Reply #40 on: December 12, 2008, 06:23:52 AM »

Surely the problem is with measuring accuracy, that is, there aint any. Do you remember those small, battery powered transistor radios with the tiny speakers? If they were playing in the next room, they sound almost as good as a proper HiFi. Science tells us that this is impossible but pyscho-acoustics, id est, yer lugoles, tell you it is. The ability of homo sapien to convince themselves they are right and others are wrong, is legendary, vide wars. As the accordion is a symbiotic system, change any item and the output will change. All you have to do is improve the measuring systems. Unfortunately you'll have to wait until the defence industry can detect a healthy profit for doing so.
Even older, grumpier and more cynical Bill.
Logged
My Erika is as old as me. Luckily, it is not as decrepit.

waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
Re: reed nails
« Reply #41 on: December 12, 2008, 01:38:40 PM »

Quote from: Andy in Vermont link=topic=1136.
[/quote




  If I recall correctly, he said that the higher quality reeds did not greatly improve the sound of the cheaper box, but also that the lower quality reeds did not greatly reduce the sound quality of the high-end box.

 
I think high quality reeds have much more to do with responsiveness and ability to hold a tuning than they do with the quality of the sound. 


Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: reed nails
« Reply #42 on: December 13, 2008, 12:36:13 PM »

I could guess (figures are debatable) that the influence on the sound is something like:
construction/internal cavities/resonators/grille (including internal varnishing etc)  -- 50%
reeds/reedplates  --  40%
method of attaching reeds (wax, leather, nails)  -- 5%
materials  (body, reedblocks, "soundboard") -- 5%          <== maybe 50% for a stringed instrument


Do I understand this correctly, that what you are saying is that if I build a melodeon out of plastic in which the internal cavities are the same dimensions as those of a Castagnari Hascy, and the reedwork (tuning and "dressing" of reed and method of attaching to the block are identical, that there would only be a 5% difference from the sound of the Castagnari?  I'm not trying to criticize your argument; I'm just trying to see if you intended your estimation to mean this.

Years ago, I recall Rich Morse of the Button Box posting to the usenet accordion forum in response to a thread where someone asked about the possible outcome of putting high quality reeds in a cheap accordion.  Rich responded that the Button Box had some experience with this, and his estimates of influence on sound even included the effect of putting lower quality reeds in a high quality box.  If I recall correctly, he said that the higher quality reeds did not greatly improve the sound of the cheaper box, but also that the lower quality reeds did not greatly reduce the sound quality of the high-end box.

 To me, these (anecdotal yet experienced-based) data suggest that your estimate values the influence of the reeds too highly.  Nevertheless, I'm fairly certain that I'm with you in putting the reeds at 40%, but I can never tell with these things, since I'm general extremely sensitive to minor changes, so what really stands out to me might not be so important to the ears of others.  I'm not saying that my hearing is better, just that it is sensitive to the point of rendering me incapable of distinguishing which differences might be important for the majority of listeners.
-Andy




Making everything out of plastic instead of wood -- yes, that's exactly what I meant. There's far too much "this wood sounds better" bandied around (in regard to accordeons), most of it based on incorrect extrapolation form stringed instruments -- where of course it makes a *huge* difference -- and (almost?) none of it backed up by impartial evidence, either measurement-based or listening-based. I believe somebody years ago did make an accordeon entirely out of perspex instead of wood (because it looked fabulous!) but dimensionally identical, and it was said to sound just the same as the wooden ones.

It's very like the "cable sound" debate where so-called respected reviewers blather on about how this expensive gold-plated cable sounds so much better, wilfully ignoring the fact that on the few occasions where double-blind testing has been done nobody has *ever* reliably been able to tell the difference.

When I attributed 40% to reeds and reedplates I didn't mean just the difference between more and less expensive reeds of similar material, size and shape mounted in similar reedplates, I was including the influence of the shape/size/thickness/material of the reeds and reedplates. If you compare a small brass reed not very well fitted into a thick zinc reedplate with a larger steel reed well-fitted into a thinner aluminium reedplate the difference will be considerable (but still smaller than all the constuction size/shape/cavity effects).

I agree that the difference between "machine made" and "hand made" (yes I know they're not really, but it's what people call them) from the same manufacturer in the same box is considerably smaller but nevertheless noticeable. When Castagnari made my first box over 20 years ago (a Nik) I got them to put handmade reeds in it instead of the standard ones, and it was always noticeably brighter sounding then any of the others I heard, and was more responsive to play with better dynamics just like Waltzman said.

Regarding C age ing's comment about measuring accuracy -- well, I'll have to disagree here. Things that affect the sound of instruments can be quite easily measured and explained with science without having to call in any mumbo-jumbo about " the ear can hear things that we can't measure" -- for example, it's well known what sound and playing characteristics make a Strad such a great violin, and indeed why there are good and not-so-good Strads and what sound features make the difference. Exactly what elements of the material and construction lead to this sound has also been thoroughly investigated, with the results I quoted in the "new-vs-old" double blind trial.

It's equally simple to measure different accordions and see which features of the sound explain what people like or don't like about them -- richness, brightness, mellowness, responsivity, they're all measurable. In the end though what the ear thinks of the result is the key, because of course you *might* not be measuring the right thing -- which is why I stand by the position that if you can't hear a difference *without* knowing which version of the instrument you're listening to, there *isn't* one -- irrespective of whether it's made from cheap plastic or expensive exotic wood.

Expensive and rare materials are only better if they're right for the job; the wheels on the chariots of the gods in Greek mythology were supposedly made of silver and gold, and it's difficult to think of two more unsuitable materials for the purpose :-)

Using light materials to build a box which conduct more vibration to the players hands than heavy ones might make a difference to the "feel", but they're unlikely to make a significant difference to the sound because the sound radiation from the case is negligible compared to that coming out of the air through the grille. You can easily prove this by getting someone to move a small tieclip microphone around the box while it's being played; by putting the mic right next to it, you'll find the sound level being radiated by the case is so far down that it can be ignored.

Again, this is completely the opposite to stringed instruments where the vibration in the body is almost entirely responsible for producing the sound; in this case a light resonant body (and the materials it's made from) make a huge difference, so instruments that feel "live" are also likely to sound good. But just because this is true for stringed instruments doesn't make it true for free-reed ones, whatever people might believe :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Mike Higgins

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 338
    • Strolling to Italy
Re: reed nails
« Reply #43 on: December 13, 2008, 05:17:23 PM »

Quote
Making everything out of plastic instead of wood -- yes, that's exactly what I meant. There's far too much "this wood sounds better" bandied around (in regard to accordeons), most of it based on incorrect extrapolation form stringed instruments -- where of course it makes a *huge* difference -- and (almost?) none of it backed up by impartial evidence, either measurement-based or listening-based. I believe somebody years ago did make an accordeon entirely out of perspex instead of wood (because it looked fabulous!) but dimensionally identical, and it was said to sound just the same as the wooden ones.

Ian, I have been reading your, and others, posts about reeds, construction, materials etc with great interest and, as a non engineer myself, wonder if it is your view that a "perfect" instrument could be made out of synthetic materials by a machine?
Logged
Mike from Ponte Caffaro

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: reed nails
« Reply #44 on: December 13, 2008, 08:05:59 PM »

Quote
Making everything out of plastic instead of wood -- yes, that's exactly what I meant. There's far too much "this wood sounds better" bandied around (in regard to accordeons), most of it based on incorrect extrapolation form stringed instruments -- where of course it makes a *huge* difference -- and (almost?) none of it backed up by impartial evidence, either measurement-based or listening-based. I believe somebody years ago did make an accordeon entirely out of perspex instead of wood (because it looked fabulous!) but dimensionally identical, and it was said to sound just the same as the wooden ones.

Ian, I have been reading your, and others, posts about reeds, construction, materials etc with great interest and, as a non engineer myself, wonder if it is your view that a "perfect" instrument could be made out of synthetic materials by a machine?

Perhaps, but only if you could tell the machine *exactly* what you wanted it to do and what results you wanted, which is *much* harder than it sounds when there are many conflicting design issues and no clear "best" solution.

I design analogue circuits to go on integrated circuits (as my day job), and though it's been said for many years that this will be automated "real soon now" the problem has always been describing precisely *what* tradeoffs should be made -- improving one thing often makes another worse, there's no single "best" black-and-white solution. Automated design tools are still nowhere as good as an experienced designer at doing this, and I would say that the same applies to musical instrument design and manufacture -- a good instrument maker will strike the right balance (or at least, one he likes) among the many attributes which make a "good" instrument.

For example, reeds set close to the frames speak very quickly -- great for someone playing fast tunes quietly -- but choke when played hard -- not so great for a musician playing for dancing outdoors. A loud bright box is exactly what such a musician wants, but would be hopeless for somebody accompanying a singer indoors. A musician playing punchy push-pull tunes may want a small light two-reed box, one playing legato across the rows may wany a bigger heavier 3-reed box with more bellows volume, rows and basses.

Machines -- and computers -- are very good at doing something with incredible precision and repeatability (much better than a human being, no variability or randomness) so long as you can tell them *exactly* what that thing is. So if you could define "the perfect instrument" -- one which couldn't possibly be improved -- then I expect machines could turn out multiple perfect identical copies far better than people could.

If you don't know exactly what you want or what "the best" is, then a human will turn out instruments which vary -- they won't be as consistent, some will be worse than the machine ones, but the variation means that some will be better. So long as you can work out what makes the better ones better and use this as a basis for future designs, this leads to improvements in the instrument.

Of course somebody still has to decide what "better" is, and opinions may vary on this :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

C age ing

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 434
  • New fangled melodeon?
Re: reed nails
« Reply #45 on: December 14, 2008, 06:09:23 AM »

Must tell Ovation that they have got it wrong. Despite having a very satisfied clientele, they should make their acoustic guitars out of all wood.
A totally defeated Old Bill.
Logged
My Erika is as old as me. Luckily, it is not as decrepit.

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: reed nails
« Reply #46 on: December 14, 2008, 08:33:41 AM »

Comparing the construction methods and materials of stringed instruments with free reed is clouding the issue. Anyone with a passing knowledge of guitar construction theory understands why the Ovation design works, and works well. All of that theory matters not one whit when considering the melodeon and why it works or not ...

Pete.
Tama Dreadnought
Ovation Balladeer Standard
Washburn Parlour Guitar
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: reed nails
« Reply #47 on: December 14, 2008, 11:02:33 AM »

Must tell Ovation that they have got it wrong. Despite having a very satisfied clientele, they should make their acoustic guitars out of all wood.
A totally defeated Old Bill.

Horses for courses again -- many musicians who like a warm resonant characterful guitar sound think Ovations sound horrible, all thin and weedy and bland and cold-sounding.

Others who play them (for example) amplified on stage think they're great, with a clean clinical sound that cuts through and doesn't ring or feedback as much as more conventional guitars.

Of course they're both right :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: reed nails
« Reply #48 on: December 14, 2008, 08:23:04 PM »

Horses for courses again -- many musicians who like a warm resonant characterful guitar sound think Ovations sound horrible, all thin and weedy and bland and cold-sounding.
I have to say I haven't found this to be the case with my Ovation, it's deep, rich and very smooth in tone and is my weapon of choice for acoustic vocal accompaniment in folk clubs etc. Were the above observations to do with those horrid shallow bowled efforts?

My Tama on the other hand is loud, proud and strident, with the less than perfect overtones that all dreadnoughts have, but if you want a high volume acoustic it's all there.

Anyway shouldn't we be talking nonsense about reeds instead of nonsense about guitars?
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

C age ing

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 434
  • New fangled melodeon?
Re: reed nails
« Reply #49 on: December 15, 2008, 05:31:08 AM »

Horses for courses again -- many musicians who like a warm resonant characterful guitar sound think Ovations sound horrible, all thin and weedy and bland and cold-sounding.
I have to say I haven't found this to be the case with my Ovation, it's deep, rich and very smooth in tone and is my weapon of choice for acoustic vocal accompaniment in folk clubs etc. Were the above observations to do with those horrid shallow bowled efforts?

My Tama on the other hand is loud, proud and strident, with the less than perfect overtones that all dreadnoughts have, but if you want a high volume acoustic it's all there.

Anyway shouldn't we be talking nonsense about reeds instead of nonsense about guitars?
Of course, but how do you test a reed? Is every reed mounted exactly the same? If not, only the reed tongue must be tested but how do you do that?
Seems we will have to wait for light speed space travel and mount it in a black hole, although I do recollect a few sixties folk clubs that I performed in that could make a suitable substitute.
A rheumy eyed Old Bill.
Logged
My Erika is as old as me. Luckily, it is not as decrepit.

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: reed nails
« Reply #50 on: December 15, 2008, 11:56:44 AM »

Horses for courses again -- many musicians who like a warm resonant characterful guitar sound think Ovations sound horrible, all thin and weedy and bland and cold-sounding.
I have to say I haven't found this to be the case with my Ovation, it's deep, rich and very smooth in tone and is my weapon of choice for acoustic vocal accompaniment in folk clubs etc. Were the above observations to do with those horrid shallow bowled efforts?

My Tama on the other hand is loud, proud and strident, with the less than perfect overtones that all dreadnoughts have, but if you want a high volume acoustic it's all there.

Anyway shouldn't we be talking nonsense about reeds instead of nonsense about guitars?
Of course, but how do you test a reed? Is every reed mounted exactly the same? If not, only the reed tongue must be tested but how do you do that?
Seems we will have to wait for light speed space travel and mount it in a black hole, although I do recollect a few sixties folk clubs that I performed in that could make a suitable substitute.
A rheumy eyed Old Bill.

I'm sure that if it's possible to make two Strad-quality violins sufficiently similar that they can't be told apart by experienced listeners -- bearing in mind that a violin is more sensitive to exact material and construction detail than probably any other instrument -- then it shouldn't be beyond the wit of man to make two sets of reeds similar enough that we could then use them to tell the differences between two squeezeboxes made of different materials.

And unless you're comparing reed block materials, you could of course then swap the reed blocks over and repeat the test to remove any doubt.

Doing any blind ABX test like this is however not a trivial matter; it needs multiple randomised swaps back and forth between the instruments, and a large enough audience to give statistically reliable results, and knowledge about how to set up the trial to avoid any bias and analyse the results. Which is why it's been done on prestigious expensive instruments that people write theses about (violins) but never AFAIK on melodeons.

Without tests like this any opinions are just that; it's very well known (and has been proved many times) that people's beliefs are strongly coloured by their expectations, in other word they often hear what they expect to hear (this expensive cable sure sounds better). This applies just as much to instrument makers as musicians or listeners, after all we're all human :-)

Ian

P.S. The Ovation comments may well have been referring to the shallow ones; however, a curved fibreglass body is much less resonant and "lively" than a braced wooden one, and will by definition contribute less to the sound -- which means more of what you hear is defined by the top plate characteristics, so you're likely to get a smoother but possibly less characterful sound because of the lack of body resonances. This is either a good thing or a bad thing depending on whether you like the result or not -- as I said, horses for course.

P.P.S. Yes I've played Ovations, and I have a Takamine dreadnought, and I agree with tallship's comments :-)
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: reed nails
« Reply #51 on: December 15, 2008, 12:15:36 PM »


... and I have a Takamine dreadnought, and I agree with tallship's comments :-)

 But maybe only because that what you expect.... ;D
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: reed nails
« Reply #52 on: December 15, 2008, 12:17:16 PM »


... and I have a Takamine dreadnought, and I agree with tallship's comments :-)

 But maybe only because that what you expect.... ;D

Hoist with my own petard :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: reed nails
« Reply #53 on: December 15, 2008, 12:40:58 PM »


... and I have a Takamine dreadnought, and I agree with tallship's comments :-)

 But maybe only because that what you expect.... ;D

"I really like the sound of (old melodeons, old guitars)..." -- personal opinion, perfectly acceptable :-)

"...because they sound better due to the wood having aged with playing" -- incorrect/misleading factual conjecture, not acceptable :-(

There's too much rubbish written on the Internet by people who can't distinguish fact from opinion -- and before anyone shoots me down, I try *very* carefully to distinguish the two :-)

Ian

P.S. And the WWW has far too many so-called "facts" that are just wrong...

P.P.S. Just because multiple websites reprint such a "fact" doesn't make it any more correct either.
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: reed nails
« Reply #54 on: December 15, 2008, 01:06:41 PM »


"I really like the sound of (old melodeons, old guitars)..." -- personal opinion, perfectly acceptable :-)

"...because they sound better due to the wood having aged with playing" -- incorrect/misleading factual conjecture, not acceptable :-(


Agree almost completely,  but in some circumstance I might give the first type of statement the status of "observation" rather than opinion
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: reed nails
« Reply #55 on: December 15, 2008, 01:12:49 PM »


"I really like the sound of (old melodeons, old guitars)..." -- personal opinion, perfectly acceptable :-)

"...because they sound better due to the wood having aged with playing" -- incorrect/misleading factual conjecture, not acceptable :-(


Agree almost completely,  but in some circumstance I might give the first type of statement the status of "observation" rather than opinion

I agree, there's nothing wrong with observing things so long as you don't jump to the wrong conclusion -- remember the Bernard Wrigley song "Our Bill" about the bloke who came home early one night to find a sports car parked outsider his house (where his wife was at home), so he filled it to the top with concrete -- only to see the car owner come out from next door's house?

10/10 for observation, 0/10 for arriving at the correct conclusion :-)

Ian

P.S. Actually maybe 5/10 in this case -- after Bill drove off in a panic her lover emerged and rode off on a pushbike...
« Last Edit: December 15, 2008, 01:14:46 PM by IanD »
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

an bosca ceoil

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 347
Re: reed nails
« Reply #56 on: December 15, 2008, 11:18:47 PM »

So what is the verdict - should we bother replacing the nails or not?
Logged

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: reed nails
« Reply #57 on: December 15, 2008, 11:42:04 PM »

My vote is no.

I'm going to scarper quick before IanD starts singing the Ballad of Knocking Nellie!  ;D

*wanders off singing quietly to self*

Our Bill has a concrete mixer, he were coming home last night
When he come down t'street and he saw his house, there's a sports car parked outside...

Gas man, coal man, water board or the bloke what mends the tele
They're all the same to Harry's wife the famous knockin' Nellie...
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)
Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal