Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Down

Author Topic: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?  (Read 16883 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

stillicidia

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 26
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #20 on: December 15, 2008, 05:52:10 PM »

Hmm ...
Vital bit of information was left out of your posting  - you said -

The same instrument maker who did the "new-vs-old" Strad blind test also compared two of his "new Strads", one fresh-out-of-the-box and one which had been heavily played for some time.

which seems to indicate one was newly built and one was an older instrument - an instrument of the same age which is kept tuned even if it is not played will settle in as the tensions are there to move the wood to its working position - if left untuned the same will not happen. The same goes for the strings left untuned they will not stretch and become stable they take time to reach their ultimate length.

So why should a box be any different - ok there will be minimal effect on the sound from the change of the box/bellows but there will be some and there will be minimal change in the reeds but there will be some - I could go on but the point is that something that is made from materials that undergo stresses and flexion will change over time until they reach their optimum settled state - so some change will happen - if it is dicernable by the human ear I don't know but that the change will happen I am certain of - so the fact that some people say they can tell the difference doesn't surprise me.

if asked if I would fund the testing of this as a theory the answer is a definite no - but I'm sure the instrument makers will have some research on the effects of time and playing on reeds - the material and their life expectancy - isn't that why there is the difference between brass reeded instruments and steel reeded - didn't someone somewhere try to improve what was already being made because they noted differences somewhere?
Logged
Dyslexic fingers and deaf as a post!
member of accordions anonymous - I admit it I am an accordion addict!
it all started with just one! just a little one! then another, and another...

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #21 on: December 15, 2008, 08:39:40 PM »

I'm playing devil's advocate here -- just pointing out that no matter how many people (me included!) think it's true, it's never been *proved* in a statistically valid blind test. Or has it?

Hi Ian,
I don't disagree with you about the comments above (related to "settling in") but I do question whether every aspect of life needs to be "proved in a statistically valid blind test."  It's hard to imagine anyone really enjoying music if this is there approach to everything.  So this is an internet journal in which individuals express their opinions, as well as some knowledge based on experience rather than experiments.  Should we all stop talking until we do "statistically valid blind tests" about everything.  Science can be slow on the uptake sometimes.  I'm thinking of examples from agriculture where farmers and other "non-scientific" types had drawn conclusions in the 1920s and 30s about the detrimental aspects (nutritionally) of using synthetic fertilizer in the long run.  Now the science is finally starting to back them up, about 80 years too late.  I'm glad that not all farmers waited for this advent of knowledge to begin the practices of biodynamic and organic agriculture.  Don't get me started on microwave ovens.
Positivist science does a nice job of solving engineering problems but is not the be-all and end-all of all discourse.   
-Andy

Quebecois

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1206
  • Accordez-vous donc, c'est si beau, l'accordéon!
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #22 on: December 15, 2008, 08:50:38 PM »

I'm more enclined to think that the aging of the player makes a difference in the sound!!!
Logged
Hohner Morgane D/G, pre-Erica Hohner in C/F and G/C,
Hohner Erica A/D, Roland FR-18

Falseknight

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 449
    • False Knight
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #23 on: December 15, 2008, 10:13:22 PM »

Casting a glance over at the good old days of keyboards and subtractive synthesis, to make "attractive sounds", we used to take a "harmonically rich" waveform and filtered out the harsher bits.

This is not a lot different to what you do when you change the acoustic absorbency of materials between the reeds and the outside world.
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #24 on: December 15, 2008, 11:08:23 PM »

I'm playing devil's advocate here -- just pointing out that no matter how many people (me included!) think it's true, it's never been *proved* in a statistically valid blind test. Or has it?

Hi Ian,
I don't disagree with you about the comments above (related to "settling in") but I do question whether every aspect of life needs to be "proved in a statistically valid blind test."  It's hard to imagine anyone really enjoying music if this is there approach to everything.  So this is an internet journal in which individuals express their opinions, as well as some knowledge based on experience rather than experiments.  Should we all stop talking until we do "statistically valid blind tests" about everything.  Science can be slow on the uptake sometimes.  I'm thinking of examples from agriculture where farmers and other "non-scientific" types had drawn conclusions in the 1920s and 30s about the detrimental aspects (nutritionally) of using synthetic fertilizer in the long run.  Now the science is finally starting to back them up, about 80 years too late.  I'm glad that not all farmers waited for this advent of knowledge to begin the practices of biodynamic and organic agriculture.  Don't get me started on microwave ovens.
Positivist science does a nice job of solving engineering problems but is not the be-all and end-all of all discourse.   
-Andy

I'm a musician, I love music -- both playing it and hearing it -- and I don't claim that science knows everything. But it does know an awful lot...

I don't see that this is in any way incompatible with wanting to stop unsubstantiated -- actually, proven to be wrong -- opinions or conjecture being put forwards as facts. Once this happens they worm their way into becoming accepted, then stated as true by people who should know better.

Anyone is quite entitled to put forward their opinion or observation about what they think causes something; once they say it as if it's a fact, they should expect to be challenged unless they can back their opinion up. This is the way that the sum of human knowledge -- as opposed to conjecture -- advances, by finding out how the world really ticks.

The real reason for wanting to do this is that once you know how something *really* works and why, you stand a much better chance of being able to improve it instead of relying on guesswork -- or going off down a complete blind alley because you believe something that's wrong.

Ian

-- It was widely known that modern violins can't ever compare with a Strad, it was blindingly obvious -- and wrong.

-- It was widely known that playing in a fiddle a lot affects the sound, it was also obvious -- and wrong.

-- How many other widely known "facts" about musical instruments are equally wrong? Anyone care to make a guess?
« Last Edit: December 15, 2008, 11:42:36 PM by IanD »
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #25 on: December 15, 2008, 11:29:55 PM »

Hmm ...
Vital bit of information was left out of your posting  - you said -

The same instrument maker who did the "new-vs-old" Strad blind test also compared two of his "new Strads", one fresh-out-of-the-box and one which had been heavily played for some time.

which seems to indicate one was newly built and one was an older instrument - an instrument of the same age which is kept tuned even if it is not played will settle in as the tensions are there to move the wood to its working position - if left untuned the same will not happen. The same goes for the strings left untuned they will not stretch and become stable they take time to reach their ultimate length.

So why should a box be any different - ok there will be minimal effect on the sound from the change of the box/bellows but there will be some and there will be minimal change in the reeds but there will be some - I could go on but the point is that something that is made from materials that undergo stresses and flexion will change over time until they reach their optimum settled state - so some change will happen - if it is dicernable by the human ear I don't know but that the change will happen I am certain of - so the fact that some people say they can tell the difference doesn't surprise me.

if asked if I would fund the testing of this as a theory the answer is a definite no - but I'm sure the instrument makers will have some research on the effects of time and playing on reeds - the material and their life expectancy - isn't that why there is the difference between brass reeded instruments and steel reeded - didn't someone somewhere try to improve what was already being made because they noted differences somewhere?

If you followed up the "powertwins" link you'd have found that the comparison was precisely valid, two instruments made at the same time, checked to be indistinguishable when they were made, both kept tuned up and maintained for several years but one played a lot and the other hardly at all.

And it's not that "some people" couldn't hear the difference, this included professional violin players -- if they couldn't tell any difference, it's difficult to see who could.

I think you're still missing the big point here -- of course people will change instrument designs to try and improve them. Some of the time they'll think they've succeeded and have, other times they might think they've succeeded but actually have made no real difference. There are innumerable cases in all fields of people believing that some change makes a difference which is then shown not to exist when exposed to rigorous testing -- it's not intentional, it's just that people often see (and hear) what they expect to see (and hear). Instrument makers are no different to anyone else in this regard; some of the time (hopefully often) they'll be right, some of the time (hopefully seldom) they'll be wrong.

If somebody says they can hear the difference then of course they could be right -- or, like many hi-fi cable reviewers, not. And if they claim they can hear a difference they should be able to prove this in a blind test, and if they can *then* I'll believe them. It's really not that difficult -- turn your back, get someone to play "before" and "after" instruments lots of times without saying which is which, and see if you can reliably spot the difference. It's what I'd do if I was making instruments, otherwise how do I know I'm not deluding myself?

It's undoubtedly true that the structure of any instrument could change over time in some way or another; the question is, does this actually have any significant effect on the sound?

If it doesn't, we should stop worrying about it (and saying it makes a difference) and concentrate on other ways of making it sound better.

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #26 on: December 16, 2008, 12:01:36 AM »

Well, well, thread-drift (:

A new set of reeds WILL sound better the more you play for the first year (and even years). New reeds seem to be rather shrill in sound compared to those "broken in". Many players I know who fiddle around with reedwork will not tune a new set of reeds until they've played them alot with plenty of force, just to get over the first break-in. Not that they won't stay in tune, but to get a better idea of what their 'true' sound is. When the reeds have been played hard for a month or so, some find that they sound "sweeter" than when new, so it's easier to get a perspective of the melodeon's potential.

[snip]


Meanwhile, back at the ranch...

Here's a question for you all. If people say that reeds WILL sound better with playing, how do we know that they're any more correct than all the people who said that violins change their sound with playing?

Ian ;-)
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Martin J

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 902
  • Poole, Dorset
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #27 on: December 16, 2008, 12:58:58 AM »

If you soak the listener with whisky both the box and the playing sound better !
Logged
Castagnari, Weltmeister, Giustozzi, Streb, too many Hohners.  No Strings Attached ceilidh band

an bosca ceoil

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 347
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #28 on: December 16, 2008, 01:17:14 AM »

If you soak the listener with whisky both the box and the playing sound better !
Maybe so but, after extensive research, I can state catagorically that Poteen does a better job!
Logged

Hasse

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 323
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #29 on: December 16, 2008, 07:45:12 AM »

If it ain't true for high-class fiddles -- regardless of popular belief -- it sure ain't true for boxes...

Ian

Let’s make it clear - a melodeon is not a fiddle! A fiddle doesn’t contain materials like Leather, wax, felts and different kinds of metal alloys. And maybe a fiddle is just a inert piece of wood making sound.

But…

A new melodeon is more like a pair of good leather shoes that gives you blisters and aching toes the first couple of weeks. But then after using them some weeks the shoes start to smoothen and become real comfortable.

And a good old melodeon is like a pair of good old winter leather booths. When not used all summer they become hard and uncomfortable, maybe soiled with old dirt and corroded metal parts. But once cleaned up it only takes a week or so before they start feeling smooth and comfortable again.

You see!!! Melodeons are more like shoes and not at all like fiddles.  ;)
« Last Edit: December 16, 2008, 07:54:19 AM by Hasse »
Logged
Sweden, Skåne

stillicidia

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 26
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #30 on: December 16, 2008, 07:53:34 AM »

 ;DCan I volunteer to be internally soaked with whisky whilst listening to you all play - then if I'm still concious at the end of the test I'll tell you what sounded best to me? ::)
Logged
Dyslexic fingers and deaf as a post!
member of accordions anonymous - I admit it I am an accordion addict!
it all started with just one! just a little one! then another, and another...

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #31 on: December 16, 2008, 11:47:54 AM »

If it ain't true for high-class fiddles -- regardless of popular belief -- it sure ain't true for boxes...

Ian

Let’s make it clear - a melodeon is not a fiddle! A fiddle doesn’t contain materials like Leather, wax, felts and different kinds of metal alloys. And maybe a fiddle is just a inert piece of wood making sound.

But…

A new melodeon is more like a pair of good leather shoes that gives you blisters and aching toes the first couple of weeks. But then after using them some weeks the shoes start to smoothen and become real comfortable.

And a good old melodeon is like a pair of good old winter leather booths. When not used all summer they become hard and uncomfortable, maybe soiled with old dirt and corroded metal parts. But once cleaned up it only takes a week or so before they start feeling smooth and comfortable again.

You see!!! Melodeons are more like shoes and not at all like fiddles.  ;)


One quick way of "breaking in" new boots is to sit in the bath with them for several hours, then walk around for several more hours until they're dry.

Are you suggesting the same treatment would help with a new (or unplayed for some time) melodeon?

Ian

P.S. How about a piano accordion? Ahhh -- *now* I understand what you're getting at... :-)
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #32 on: December 16, 2008, 01:12:26 PM »

-- It was widely known that modern violins can't ever compare with a Strad, it was blindingly obvious -- and wrong.

Ian,
The interesting thing here is that this didn't require scientific experiments to prove it wrong.
Years ago, Isaac Stern got a violin made by a Brooklyn maker.  The story goes that he took it to a recording session where it was mistaken for a Strad by a rather famous cellist -- after a day of playing music together! 
It's just an anecdote but it was enough for me to "know" without "science," and in my estimation it constitutes greater proof than a blind test.  No aspect of the cellist was removed in the interest of narrowing down the variables.  And yet he still mistook the Zygmuntovich fiddle for a Strad. 
-Andy

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #33 on: December 16, 2008, 01:33:23 PM »

-- It was widely known that modern violins can't ever compare with a Strad, it was blindingly obvious -- and wrong.

Ian,
The interesting thing here is that this didn't require scientific experiments to prove it wrong.
Years ago, Isaac Stern got a violin made by a Brooklyn maker.  The story goes that he took it to a recording session where it was mistaken for a Strad by a rather famous cellist -- after a day of playing music together! 
It's just an anecdote but it was enough for me to "know" without "science," and in my estimation it constitutes greater proof than a blind test.  No aspect of the cellist was removed in the interest of narrowing down the variables.  And yet he still mistook the Zygmuntovich fiddle for a Strad. 
-Andy

There were also many other examples of the same thing, including the one at the BBC referred to in an earlier post, which lead to a very strong suspicion that this was "the emperor's new clothes" syndrome.

It was the stubborn proponents of the "Strads are best" position that refused to believe these and dismissed them as anecdotal evidence or flukes; Dr Navygeny's blind test was intended to convince them, and since some of them were in the audience (and couldn't tell the difference, or preferred the modern violin) it must have been at least partially successful.

The problem with people "knowing" without science (or blind tests) is that they're often wrong, no matter how sincerely they believe what they're saying; people "knew" that the sun rotated around the earth, they "knew" that cholera was spread by miasmas (bad smells), they "knew" that passengers on trains would asphyxiate due to lack of air if the train exceeded a certain speed, they *knew* that the MMR vaccine caused autism, they "knew" that fiddles change with playing, and they "knew" that no modern violin could equal or surpass a Strad...

The purpose of blind tests is to separate out what differences people can actually detect from those they think they can detect, and show that this isn't a one-off or fluke or abnormal result (which something like the Isaac Stern story will be said to be by those who don't want to believe it).

In other words it does need "scientific" comparison to *prove* it wrong -- otherwise for every story like the Isaac Sterns one the opposing parties pull out an anecdote which seems to show the exact opposite. In this case "scientific" simply means "statistically valid under controlled conditions after eliminating outside influences and observer bias".

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #34 on: December 16, 2008, 04:54:33 PM »

Ian,
"Science" has also been wrong, plenty of times, in the past.  I'm sure that you know enough history of science to cite some examples.  It is also painfully slow at discerning truths that should be obvious to anyone who uses his or her brain and observes what is going on.  Case in point, the connection between smoking and lung cancer.  In the case of nutrition, scientists took over 80 years to identify the differing levels of polyphenols in green vegetables grown with chemical pesticides versus those grown without them.  I'm glad that I didn't wait around for the statistically valid tests done under controlled conditions.  Scientists also led millions of people to consume hydrogenated butter substitutes before coming to the *ahem* rather painful realization that the presumptions on which their previous statistically valid tests were incorrect, and that their results led millions of people down a path toward worse health.  Those of us who were more in-tune with our sense observations didn't require statistically valid tests under controlled conditions to discern that hydrogenated oils had a detrimental effect on our bodies.
Personally, I'm more interested in hearing individuals' accounts of their observations concerning melodeons and music played with melodeons.  The last time I checked, that is what this forum is for: it is not a scientific journal with a board of reviewers who must account for the validity of each item that is published.
I'm with you, the "soundboard" explanation of melodeon acoustics has been repeated far too many times on the internet forums.  It's too bad. 
-Andy

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #35 on: December 16, 2008, 05:10:56 PM »

Ian,
"Science" has also been wrong, plenty of times, in the past.  I'm sure that you know enough history of science to cite some examples.  It is also painfully slow at discerning truths that should be obvious to anyone who uses his or her brain and observes what is going on.  Case in point, the connection between smoking and lung cancer.  In the case of nutrition, scientists took over 80 years to identify the differing levels of polyphenols in green vegetables grown with chemical pesticides versus those grown without them.  I'm glad that I didn't wait around for the statistically valid tests done under controlled conditions.  Scientists also led millions of people to consume hydrogenated butter substitutes before coming to the *ahem* rather painful realization that the presumptions on which their previous statistically valid tests were incorrect, and that their results led millions of people down a path toward worse health.  Those of us who were more in-tune with our sense observations didn't require statistically valid tests under controlled conditions to discern that hydrogenated oils had a detrimental effect on our bodies.
Personally, I'm more interested in hearing individuals' accounts of their observations concerning melodeons and music played with melodeons.  The last time I checked, that is what this forum is for: it is not a scientific journal with a board of reviewers who must account for the validity of each item that is published.
I'm with you, the "soundboard" explanation of melodeon acoustics has been repeated far too many times on the internet forums.  It's too bad. 
-Andy

Hindsight is a wonderful thing, it makes it *much* easier to see when people were wrong :-)

People who were more "in-tune" with their senses and intuition have equally been proved completely wrong on many occasions, sometimes with quite horrible consequences in areas like vaccination and disease spreading/immunity.

I'm perfectly happy to discuss melodeons and their sound and playing and construction and music until the cows come home, as you say that's what this forum is for.

So long as people don't keep repeating knowledgeable-sounding -- but almost certainly erroneous -- "facts" -- as if they're true -- because then lots of other people who don't know the difference take them on as true and repeat them, and before you know it you've got another "well-known fact" which is nothing of the sort.

Ian

P.S.
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Hasse

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 323
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #36 on: December 16, 2008, 06:54:13 PM »


One quick way of "breaking in" new boots is to sit in the bath with them for several hours, then walk around for several more hours until they're dry.

Are you suggesting the same treatment would help with a new (or unplayed for some time) melodeon?

Ian

P.S. How about a piano accordion? Ahhh -- *now* I understand what you're getting at... :-)

I've got one really trashed melodeon, maybe I should give it a try and see how long it takes before the box totally dissolves  ;D

By the way, as a conservator I wouldn't recommend putting old or new boots in water for several hours. It's going dry and weaken the leather, even if you treat them with leather dressing afterwards,  just wear them out prematurely, so it’s better to take the foot pain!?!  :P

  DO REEDS REALLY GET SWEETER WITH PLAYNG AND AGE OR IS THIS UNTRUE? DO THEY CHANGE IN ANY WAY WITH CONTINUOUS PLAYING AND WHAT SORT OF TIME FRAME IS INVOLVED? 

   In my limited experience, there's a "break-in" for new reeds.  Then they have a "middle life" where they sound good stably (for many years, if they're quality reeds), then they begin to go "off" and lose their tone.  Of course, a dramatic event happening - like a reed rusting, or cracking, or being fouled from cigarette smoke, etc. will affect the tone at any time and pretty quickly, too.
   But, "will a good-quality reed sound better when it's 15 years old versus when it's 5 years old", no I don't think so (not in general anyway).

BH NC USA

I really like ??? this thread with lot of discussions concerning aspects of deterioration. ;D ;D But I must admit it seems like Bruce Henderson answered the first question very well indeed! At least after a melodeon playing conservators opinion  :)
« Last Edit: December 17, 2008, 06:42:29 AM by Hasse »
Logged
Sweden, Skåne

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #37 on: December 16, 2008, 07:01:52 PM »


One quick way of "breaking in" new boots is to sit in the bath with them for several hours, then walk around for several more hours until they're dry.

Are you suggesting the same treatment would help with a new (or unplayed for some time) melodeon?

Ian

P.S. How about a piano accordion? Ahhh -- *now* I understand what you're getting at... :-)

I've got one really trashed melodeon, maybe I should give it a try and see how long it takes before the box totally dissolves  ;D

By the way, as a conservator I wouldn't recommend putting old or new boots in water for several hours. It's going dry and weaken the leather, even if you treat them with leather dressing afterwards,  just wear them out prematurely, so it’s better to take the foot pain!?!  :P

  DO REEDS REALLY GET SWEETER WITH PLAYNG AND AGE OR IS THIS UNTRUE? DO THEY CHANGE IN ANY WAY WITH CONTINUOUS PLAYING AND WHAT SORT OF TIME FRAME IS INVOLVED? 

   In my limited experience, there's a "break-in" for new reeds.  Then they have a "middle life" where they sound good stably (for many years, if they're quality reeds), then they begin to go "off" and lose their tone.  Of course, a dramatic event happening - like a reed rusting, or cracking, or being fouled from cigarette smoke, etc. will affect the tone at any time and pretty quickly, too.
   But, "will a good-quality reed sound better when it's 15 years old versus when it's 5 years old", no I don't think so (not in general anyway).

BH NC USA

I really like this thread with lot of discussions concerning aspects of deterioration. ;D ;D But I must admit it seems like Bruce Henderson answered the first question very well indeed! At least after a melodeon playing conservators opinion  :)

I didn't say it was a *good* way of breaking in new boots...

Incidentally, I agree with Bruce too -- but I might still be wrong :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #38 on: December 16, 2008, 09:45:30 PM »

So long as people don't keep repeating knowledgeable-sounding -- but almost certainly erroneous -- "facts" -- as if they're true -- because then lots of other people who don't know the difference take them on as true and repeat them, and before you know it you've got another "well-known fact" which is nothing of the sort.

Which ones are you referring to, specifically?  I'm not sure that I've seen any "facts" that were shakier in their claims than your percentages of influence on melodeon sound, which you listed in another thread.  Citing percentages, despite disclaimers, seems to lend an air of solid grounding which the opinion should not have claimed.  Perhaps ranking their importance would have been more appropriate?  Before you know it, people will be going around the internet citing "reeds are 40% of the melodeon's sound" etc., thanks to the pseudo-science in your other post.  It seems to me that you are holding others to a standard that you are imposing on them (positivist scientific data backing declarative statements) that you do not fulfill in your own posts.
Just playing devil's advocate, as you say.
-Andy
p.s. I agree that the "soundboard" is not a soundboard, in the sense of a stringed instruments soundboard, but you still have "proven" that the soundboard's material has no influence on tone etc.

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: aging of reeds - the older the sweeter?
« Reply #39 on: December 17, 2008, 10:51:59 AM »

So long as people don't keep repeating knowledgeable-sounding -- but almost certainly erroneous -- "facts" -- as if they're true -- because then lots of other people who don't know the difference take them on as true and repeat them, and before you know it you've got another "well-known fact" which is nothing of the sort.

Which ones are you referring to, specifically?  I'm not sure that I've seen any "facts" that were shakier in their claims than your percentages of influence on melodeon sound, which you listed in another thread.  Citing percentages, despite disclaimers, seems to lend an air of solid grounding which the opinion should not have claimed.  Perhaps ranking their importance would have been more appropriate?  Before you know it, people will be going around the internet citing "reeds are 40% of the melodeon's sound" etc., thanks to the pseudo-science in your other post.  It seems to me that you are holding others to a standard that you are imposing on them (positivist scientific data backing declarative statements) that you do not fulfill in your own posts.
Just playing devil's advocate, as you say.
-Andy
p.s. I agree that the "soundboard" is not a soundboard, in the sense of a stringed instruments soundboard, but you still have "proven" that the soundboard's material has no influence on tone etc.

"fiddles change sound with playing due to vibrations affecting the wood"

"soundboard wood in accordions makes a big difference to the tone because it radiates sound"

I very carefully said that the percentages I came up with were a guesstimate, and invited anyone else to come up with different figures if they disagreed -- the hope was that we could reach some kind of consensus (including the fact that "soundboard" material -- as opposed to thickness -- has very little effect) which might help people understand the issues both now and the next time such questions come up. I was trying to get a bit of clear thinking on the matter instead of just perpetuating oft-quoted but very possible erroneous pseudo-facts.

Unfortunately it seems that such a consensus is impossible for the same reasons that "a Strad is unsurpassable" -- beliefs not facts.

It's like trying to argue with Jehovah's Witnesses on the doorstep -- you can use fact and logic to shoot their arguments down in flames, but they just rewind back to the beginning and repeat the same things over again.

I guess I might as well give up trying to shine any light on things like this and just let people wallow unchallenged in their comfortable mudbath of pseudo-scientific misunderstanding, along with the snake-oil cable salesmen :-)

Ian
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses
Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal