Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Interesting anecdote about Irish accordions  (Read 4056 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

KLR

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 640
Interesting anecdote about Irish accordions
« on: March 16, 2013, 02:21:50 PM »

Years ago I obtained a copy of singer/banjo etc player Mick Moloney's 1992 dissertation "“Irish Music in America: Continuity and Change."  Rereading it I noticed this intriguing item from box player Gene Kelly, who emigrated from Kilkenny to NYC in 1922:

Quote
But once you got working for the city it was a lot easier to play but the playing got scarce because most of the bars, most of the places were these speakeasies or saloons.  And they started going into the American side of music.  And that threw a lot of us guys who were just doing the ceili music, it threw us out of business.  That's how we came up with these double row button accordions that we got today.  We could play the jigs and reels but they couldn't play the American style, that they wanted.  And if you had to make dollar, you had to play the American style.  I gave up.  I wouldn't be bothered.

I've never come across the idea that the 1 1/2 row and subsequently the full 2 row accordion were developed strictly to play foxtrots and all that; I'd been under the assumption that it was musicians wanting to expand the possibilities of their instrument, to be more adaptable for playing Irish dance music per se. 

Listening to Gene Kelly himself play I notice he, like so many old time Irish musicians, simply dispenses with accidental notes that aren't in his instrument's scale, or recasts tunes into keys that work on his 1 row, caring not a fig for what fiddlers think of the results.  Examples of each approach are heard in his playing of Paddy Fahey's jig in the former case, and the Broken Pledge reel in the latter.  He was featured on an LP in 1970s, split between himself and Kerry melodeon player Terry 'Cuz' Teahan, which may be downloaded from this site.  More tracks of Gene may be heard at Comhaltas Archive. 

Another box player from those days in NYC was Tom Carmody, who played with fiddler James Morrison in Morrison's "Orchestra."  Tom may be heard on many band sides with Morrison; but these are all in melodeon-ready keys, near as I can tell; Morrison was about the most advanced fiddler of his day technique-wise, recording no end of tunes with accidentals, tunes or settings which required shifting position up the violin's neck, or tunes in remote keys such as C, F, Bb.  But Carmody never joins in on these recordings, sticking to material in the usual keys of D and G.  Interestingly enough Morrison played the melodeon himself - and even authored a tutor for the Globe box!  I wonder if he played a hand in having that extra 1/2 row grafted onto the old boxes.
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Interesting anecdote about Irish accordions
« Reply #1 on: March 16, 2013, 06:10:47 PM »

Hi Kevin,

Yes, when we talk about the evolution of the Irish-American D/C# boxes -- by adding one or more buttons of a C# row to the basic 10 keys in D -- both the issues you mentioned come to mind:
1) making it easier and more musical to play traditional tunes that have important notes that are not in the D major scale (in their customary keys), and
2) accommodating non-traditional, popular music that was more chromatic or in different keys (including tin pan alley songs with Irish themes but nontraditional melodies).

I personally think both were important in the evolutionary shift from D 1-row to D/C# box, but your thought that 2) was more important may have some merit.

By the 1920s, the 1-row melodeon had developed a wide and deep following both in Ireland and in the Irish emigrant communities.  A lot of people played, and some of them had gotten very good.  Clever musicians, many whose names are not remembered today, had found many ways to fit a wide variety of tunes into the procrustean bed of a 10-key box, so there were lots of great melodeon settings for traditional tunes around  -- some with a wonderful character of their own, but to me, seemingly different from the settings often played by fiddlers.  I hope it won't be misunderstood if I say that some of my older fiddler friends have privately expressed some frustration with *some* of the settings preferred by some of the older box players, sometimes.  But I love those melodeon settings and suppose I'm in good company on this forum.  At any rate, recordings in the teens, twenties, and thirties often show groups of musicians (including fiddlers, banjoists, etc who had "all the notes" available) accommodating the limitations of the 10-key box by playing in different keys than usual or using particular settings that avoid  the missing notes.

Definitely these bands often played other kinds of music for which those solutions were less practical, and that did create demand for boxes with C natural, G sharp, F natural, etc.

We discussed some of those issues of repertoire in Bill's threads about his grandfather Pat Corbett's Walters.  Pat evidently used the 1-row for some tunes but the band played a lot of more chromatic music for which Pat must have used his Hohner Carmen piano accordion:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,10508

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11281.0.html

A few early 1-row boxes are known where one or more buttons was added as a customization after the original sale (usually the C natural above middle C on draw, often paired with a duplicate press C#, is the first button added).  Then there were 13 key, 15 key, and 17 key boxes.  Usually 19 keys would be full size as discussed in this thread (though 20 keys, 21, 23 etc were also made):

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9187.msg115802.html#msg115802

Gene Kelly himself as well as many other players of the Irish-American accordions did use the C# row in playing traditional tunes (even in tunes like "the Sweeps" hornpipe in D, where his F and G# notes are really not essential to the melody).  Mick Moloney's liner notes to the Kelly and Teahan LP record identify the 2 row Walters that Gene used late in life as a C#/D but I have thought D/C# is more likely -- with C# row on the inside.  The difference between the two accordion designs is a very important ethnomusicological issue, so it would be good to get that resolved.

A third use of the inside C# row of a D/C# (though probably not the reason it was added originally) is to use the reversed-direction duplicate F# and C# notes for fingering convenience or special effects, and then I guess a fourth would be to use the notes of the inside row in making ornaments.  Jerry O'Brien and his students, including the great Joe Derrane (Happy birthday, Joe!), made extensive use of those techniques in playing traditional tunes as did many of the postwar players in the New York area.

Re: Tom Carmody, I imagine you know that in addition to the one-row box Tom is shown holding on the cover of the Teahan / Kelly LP, he also played a 17-key Iorio D/C# as can be seen in the video, "From Shore to Shore:"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3grRZKNMK9o  (full length version is also online somewhere)

Danny O'Mahony has that Carmody 17-key box now and you can find Danny's superb lecture on Carmody online:

http://source.pipers.ie/Search/SearchResult.aspx?searchTerm=NotesAndNarratives&startRowIndex=0&pageSize=12&mediaId=24084

A good photo of the Carmody Iorio is shown here, and scrolling down the photo of Tom and Gene with their early 1-row boxes is also reproduced:

http://www.tedmcgraw.com/EarlyBalWalt.html



PG

« Last Edit: March 16, 2013, 09:06:17 PM by pgroff »
Logged

KLR

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 640
Re: Interesting anecdote about Irish accordions
« Reply #2 on: March 16, 2013, 11:31:19 PM »

Thanks for the big reply, Paul.  Knew you'd chime in.   I did notice the Carmody lecture linked to on the Irish Trad Box Facebook page and mean to check it all out soon. 

Listening to Kelly play the Sweeps I hear that Fnat note you mention go by.  Funny thing but pipers play Enat there, but on the next phrase we play an Eb against the E, and Kelly plays an F# instead.  Maybe he didn't have that particular button...

Another thing about pipes:  Irish American pipers who chanced to make recordings in the old days can often be heard playing a C# where you'd expect a Cnat to be.  A well-known example is Patsy Touhey playing Scotch Mary; another is Mullaney and Stack (pipes + fiddle) playing the Four Courts of Dublin, in the 2nd part.  In the 3rd part of that tune you do hear a Cnat - it's in an easier place to play; with the chanters these fellows used you fingered a Bnat and pressed the Cnat key to get your note, which requires more motion than lifting the one finger you need for C#.  I've wondered if these pipers' ambivalence or indifference about pitch didn't rub off on box players somehow.  I know what you mean about their odd settings; Frank Quinn playing the Bunch of Green Rushes is the example I use for illustration when explaining this for people, everyone follows Frankie Gavin's lead for this tune from his first LP, Frankie following Paddy Canny's lead I'd imagine, in playing Fnat in the first part, F# in the second.  Quinn just F#s everywhere, which sounds a bit odd if you're used to hearing that note wafting back and forth from the "modern" players.  I believe that tune is in two sharps in O'Neill's, also.  You wonder how these things get started - was it always played that way in Clare?   Or did Canny put his own stamp on it this way?

Hope the quote from Gene Kelly was new to you.  I cracked up looking at Pat Corbett's set lists - those poor guys!  Mind you I enjoy the pop music of that time a great deal but that stuff is by and large extra corny for even me.  Good on him for not just chucking the button box out like John Clifford.
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Interesting anecdote about Irish accordions
« Reply #3 on: March 17, 2013, 12:31:02 AM »

Hi Kevin,

Lots of food for thought.

Well, a lot of the fiddlers, flute players, and whistle players that I like the most tend to use very sharp C natural or C# in G tunes, they obviously have the choice and are doing it because they like that flavor. 

What I meant about accommodating the box was the Flanagan brothers playing Frieze britches/Cook in the kitchen/ Lannigan's ball in the keys of A mix /D major /Bminor to suit a D box,* or this great set from Eddie Meehan's Rosaleen Orchestra where the Copper plate (usually played in G) and Ah Surely are transposed up a step:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V-rbKkJj6-I

Speaking of Frank Quinn, thanks for recommending the Arhoolie reissue cd.  I had heard some of those tracks, but not all of them before.  Frank Quinn's setting of the Bunch of Green Rushes is very close to John Kelly's concertina setting  (if transposed to G; not his fiddle setting), and Quinn's setting of Eddie Dunn's reel (the Bag of Spuds) is also close to John Kelly's concertina setting. 

PG


* track 11 here: 
http://www.cduniverse.com/search/xx/music/pid/1196030/a/Irish+Dance+Music.htm
Interestingly, if Joe Flanagan's settings here are played on a 1-row box in G (instead of D), all three tunes come out in their more usual keys (D, G, and E minor), but not exactly in the modes most commonly used by fiddlers.

« Last Edit: March 17, 2013, 01:03:18 AM by pgroff »
Logged

KLR

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 640
Re: Interesting anecdote about Irish accordions
« Reply #4 on: March 17, 2013, 02:29:07 PM »

Huh, didn't know Larry Redican had a YouTube channel.   8)  Years ago a fellow I was trading tapes with sent a list of all known tracks of Larry - think it was an even dozen?  But Comhaltas's online archives have a whole mess of them, he was a great fiddler - nice to hear a bit more, not to mention a few more cuts of Paddy O'Brien the 1st, one of my favorite box players.  Never thought about the Rosaleen Orchestra playing in A for the sake of the accordion - thought they were playing up a tone just so James Morrison could show off those high C#s.  What you're saying makes sense - melodeon keys.  I've noticed that on occasion, especially when trying to figure out what Kimmel was doing.  Those Darn Accordions Melodeons!

I play Irish music on the ADG accordion - tried the C#/D and just got irritated.  Thanks to Stephen Chambers we know why these semitone boxes are the norm in ITM - Wyper Brothers > Michael Grogan > Paddy O'Brien > Joe Burke.  But I bet if you could go back in time and hip a bunch of the old time 1 row players to the ADG they'd institutionalize that just as readily - it is just the thing for a melodeon player who wants the other keys, to say nothing of what you can do with one cross rowing, or playing chords.  But I'm definitely odd man out with my choice of instrument, which is nothing new - I also play the wood piccolo and C Melody sax.   ;D
Logged

Sage Herb

  • Steve Harrison
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 762
  • Slaithwaite, UK
    • The Black Box Band
Re: Interesting anecdote about Irish accordions
« Reply #5 on: March 17, 2013, 05:00:03 PM »

I'm not an Irish-style player. But I just want to give a big plug for Gene Kelly's playing - he was wonderful and every box player should give him a listen or ten. A great combination of energy, rhythm and precise triplets.

Cheers
Steve
Logged
Hohner Erikas & Club 2s
Hohner gob-harps:
Vega Senator 5-string banjo; Alex Burns plectrum guitar

Black Box Band - www.theblackboxband.co.uk
Annie Dearman & Steve Harrison - www.dearmanharrison.co.uk
Phoenix - www.phoenixdanceband.co.uk
http://soundcloud.com/sage-herb

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Interesting anecdote about Irish accordions
« Reply #6 on: March 17, 2013, 09:14:12 PM »

ler - nice to hear a bit more, not to mention a few more cuts of Paddy O'Brien the 1st, one of my favorite box players.  Never thought about the Rosaleen Orchestra playing in A for the sake of the accordion - thought they were playing up a tone just so James Morrison could show off those high C#s.  What you're saying makes sense - melodeon keys.

Hi Kevin,

Well this isn't some known truth, it's my opinion. You actually could play the Copper Plate and Ah Surely in the common keys (those common keys use basically the scale of G major for both tunes, though the second starts on an A note) on a D box; you would get the seventh note of the major scale (F#) but would have to use C# for the fourth degree of the scale.*  That's how Conlon, Sullivan, and other melodeon players handled some of the G tunes (such as the Banks of Newfoundland and the Flogging Reel).  But the Rosaleen Orchestra settings in A fit very comfortably on the D box, and give you a D note for the fourth degree of the scale; however they (mostly) omit the G# note from the settings of both tunes that would be the seventh note of the A scale.  In the RO recording you can hear just a bit of G natural (and maybe a bit of G# from the other instruments) in places.

You mentioned Scotch Mary earlier and the piping settings with a C#, putting the tune into A mixolydian.  That's the way Joe Flanagan recorded the tune on box, again fitting beautifully along the D row.  His setting is not far from John Kelly's setting of Tom Keane's reel on concertina (which would  be transposed to G, on a C/G concertina).  The most common german and cheap anglo concertinas had two rows, unlike the melodeons, so John Kelly's concertina settings in G that are comparable to D melodeon tunes often exploited the availability of both F# and F natural, but otherwise very similar.

PG

* And some musicians do play one or both these tunes in G with a C# (or a very sharp C natural) in places
« Last Edit: March 17, 2013, 09:19:50 PM by pgroff »
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal