Though I'm pretty confident on the 1-row playing the right-hand melodies that I know from mandolin and tinwhistle experience, I've never really had much grasp of using the two bass/chord spoons. Just this evening I found
a YouTube tutorial with the simple but brilliant suggestion of just playing scales up and down over and over with a simple 1-2-1-2 bass side, so now I'm finally getting at least the basics down.
I generally grasp that my push gives me the box's root chord/bass-note, and pulling the V chord, so I get a I-V thing by going in and out. Though I'm a little confused as to why my V note (A on a D melodeon) is a push while my V chord is a pull, but I'll take it on faith that system has worked fine for a century plus.
What I don't entirely get is what to do with the 2-bass on, say, a Dorian tune. So D melodeon, those tunes which are based on the E, so 3rd button pull. A huge chunk of Irish Dorian tunes work fine with a basic Em-D-Em-D chord progression, so I see where the push-Dmaj would be handy, but is there any use for the pull-Amaj, or do I just use my push chord for Dorian tunes? Or do I use the pull-Amaj chord and accept some dissonance on the theory that the bass-chords are really just there for rhythm anyway?
The majority of 1-row clips I see on YouTube appear to be playing tunes based on the root-note of the box, so where the standard 1-2 bass works fine. I did however find a neat old clip of Bobby Gardiner playing a jig and reel, in this video he switches to The Swallow's Tail around 1:02 in:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhOj9vCR0cQI can't quite see in the video due to speed and poor quality, but what is he doing with the bass/chord side while playing that Dorian reel? Any suggestions on in general how to use them in Dorian?
Once I figure out the answer to that, what about playing songs based in Mixolydian (A on a D melodeon) like John Hardy? Just standard 1-2 as though it were based on the root? That appear to be what Catmelodeon is doing in his cover here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cyz5E-5rUCMWhat about songs starting on the B note (B minor scale, or Aeolian mode)?
If anyone has favourite clips that demonstrate proper bass-chord use for tunes in other than the basic major scale, I could really use some good examples to observe. Thanks!