Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).  (Read 4971 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Jack Humphreys

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 709
    • tunesbyjackhumphreys
Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« on: November 18, 2013, 12:45:52 PM »

I've been reading and trying to understand the discussions on Clive's thread about his new three row. But I haven't  got my head round it, and I'd appreciate your help with my slightly different challenge.

I'm planning to change from  2.6  to  3-row.  I had intended to keep  my existing 6 button row the same, so I can transfer my repertoire across painlessly to the new instrument. I dread trying to  relearn all my chords, tunes, and scales.

But from Clive's discussion I find that popular three-row layouts are very different from what I'm used to.

All of what follows is in DG-speak

My accidental row is in threes:  (Push/pull), .

Bb/G#,   E/D,   D#/F;     Bb/G#,   E/D,   D#/F

and I also have a low D# on the outside row.

Loffet's diagram of my box includes some greyed out buttons, extending the same pattern to 9 buttons.

So extending this to my projected  11-button accidental row, I might propose:

Bb/G#,   E/D,   D#/F;        Bb/G#,   E/D,   D#/F;        Bb/G#,   E/D,   D#/F;        Bb/G#,   E/D,

So this has my six accidentals all near their respective main-row octaves, with some regularity that might help the brain.

The most similar published diagram I could find other than Loffet's is the J-P Leray scheme on the Maison de l'Accordeon site.

He repeats the same six accidentals as mine  (Bb, G#, E,  D,  D#, F)  three times up the keyboard, but in a different arrangements to mine,  plus a couple of  changes at the very top to give more useful notes.

So like my proposal he has a repeated pattern, with accidentals near their non-accidental octaves. He doesn't feel the need for a wider range of accidentals than "my" six.     But he misses out on goodies like  a C on the pull and more.

As background:  I'm not looking for multi-key versatility as much as Clive is. Almost entirely French style repertoire.    Traditional push-pull 12-basses, and (DG-speak) I'll be playing mostly in pull keys of   E, A, D minor;  with some push keys D, G and a bit of  B minor maybe.    (I won't be playing in C or F, and F# minor is not a priority).

So my request for advice:   Keeping my familiar pattern of 6 will save me from having the relearn the keyboard, but at the cost of losing the potential benefits of  more reversals.  What do you think?  Are the benefits of a different system so great as to make the relearning worth while?   For example would I do better to change to a familar popular system such as  Corgeron, or Heim? 

Looking forward for some assistance in this excess of choice.   (It was never like this with the piano.)

A bientot

Jack
« Last Edit: November 18, 2013, 02:55:27 PM by Jackhumphreys »
Logged

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #1 on: November 18, 2013, 02:05:10 PM »

I came to the conclusion that:

1) Always ascending notes on the keyboard are a good thing
2) An octave gap of every 3 buttons on the push, and 4 buttons on the pull is a good thing.

I would consider changing the frequency of your pull notes if possible to 4 notes per octave. The main reason to do this are that you can get closer to being chromatic on the pull within the space of 4 notes x 3 rows (just 1 note missing rather than two) and avoid the chaos of having accidentals in different places relative to their main row cousins in different octaves.

The accidentals you choose on the push are very much a matter of personal choice, and where the variation between the main (non wacky) layouts lie; I went for C/Eb/E, but Bb is certainly a sensible choice too, and many (most) layouts prioritise that. I think that's mostly because the standard Castagnari 12 bass/18 bass layout has the Bb chord on the push, but it also may help with D minor.

Good luck!

Clive

Cooper

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 705
  • Gaillrd G/C/#,Casta Allain8 GC,Lofft CF, giord ad
    • Cooper's homepage
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #2 on: November 19, 2013, 01:17:53 AM »

If you wnt me to thnk along, you should keep it GC. Thinking in DG is a lot of work :-)
W
Logged
Please correct my English, it's been a while, and i like to learn.
And don't be so polite! I know i must be typing tons of stuff that a native speaker would say differently...please enlighten me.

www.wouterkuyper.nl
www.lirio.nl
www.trekzakacademie.nl

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #3 on: November 19, 2013, 09:14:59 AM »

Mine is a one row in C with two rows of accidentals

george >:E
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #4 on: November 19, 2013, 09:26:06 AM »

If you wnt me to thnk along, you should keep it GC. Thinking in DG is a lot of work :-)
W

As is thinking in G/C for me :P
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #5 on: November 19, 2013, 10:13:18 AM »

Jack,

My system is a slightly extended version of Andy Cutting's original design for Saltarelle, I believe.  The 9-button third row (also in D/G speak) below has a lot of similarities to your proposal, I think:

(C/Bb)   E/D     D#/F    Bb/G#   C/Bb    E/D      D#/F   Bb/G#  (C/Bb)

The end buttons are in brackets because they are omitted on my otherwise similar 7-button third row box.

This is a four-button repeat idea, and effectively you get push C's and pull Bb's extra, and yes, both are really useful.

The only common sense 'down not up' reversal which has confused my fingers a little are the E/D then D#/F buttons, only because the D# is lower than the E.  But it really isn't that difficult to learn, in the overall scheme of things.

You might care to consider the implications of a 3-button repeat push/4-button repeat pull layout, as Clive suggests, because of course the relationships between nearby notes on the other rows would then match for all octaves.  I would have some difficulty working out which push note to miss out, however!

There are other keys that you may care to consider playing in - I found it useful to play occasionally also in C and Gm, because of the C push and Bb pull capabilities, which allow you to use those notes with the LH chords.  I actually even play something jazzy in E, because I found some useful ma7th RH chords for a tune in that key.

Quote
Are the benefits of a different system so great as to make the relearning worth while?   For example would I do better to change to a familar popular system such as  Corgeron, or Heim?

The big benefit of what you're proposing is that you won't have to re-learn two-row stuff - you'll just be able to add to your learning.  I think the answer to your question about other popular systems is actually that nobody knows, because it is unlikely that anyone will have learnt all of the various systems, and thus be in a position to compare them in practice.  So the concept of designing by philosophy is probably right.  I think you may need some care if you adopt Clive's system, because his unisonoric basses to my mind must surely completely change the goalposts - and probably allow all sorts of new RH ideas that just wouldn't work on a more traditional LH layout.  I don't know enough about the implications to understand whether unisonoric basses carry any practical disadvantages, but I would have thought you need more LH buttons for the same flexibility.

Which brings me to my last point - the LH bass layout should also have an effect on your decision.  I've always thought my layout is better for 'sharp' keys than some others I've seen, because of the reversible A basses (similar to the D chord layout) - and probably less suitable for flat keys, therefore.  Thus I can fairly easily play notes and basses throughout on Atholl Highlanders in A (utilising the push A frequently to allow air out of the bellows), but might struggle to play a tune in F, because I have only pull F basses and pull RH F note.

Hope this is of some help - by all means come and try mine out if you're ever round my way (Essex, England).
Logged

Jack Humphreys

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 709
    • tunesbyjackhumphreys
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #6 on: November 19, 2013, 05:24:15 PM »

(Thanks to Chris, but haven't digested it yet)

Replying to Clive:
Thanks so much for your prompt reply. Really helpful.   I now "get it" about designing the pull layout separately from the push layout, to give 4 pull accidentals before repeating.
Previously I had made an inadvertent assumption that push-pull pairs of accidentals had to stay paired in every octave.
I haven't yet done the redesign, but i can see that it makes sense to  move the second octave group of accidentals up one button. Then both octaves on the pull will be in a similar relationship with the nonaccidental pull notes.  So my relearning will be limited to playing the top octave the same as I already play the lower one.  So now I'll reexamine the existing layouts in this light. 

a bientot
Jack.

Jack Humphreys

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 709
    • tunesbyjackhumphreys
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #7 on: December 08, 2013, 08:16:17 PM »

Thanks again to Chris and Clive for your detailed and very helpful comments.

I think I've reached a conclusion for my accidental row.  (All what follows is in DG-speak)

My principle is to retain my existing Loffet 6 button pattern as far as possible--  to minimise relearning my repertoire. 
But I'll take Clive's advice to have 4-note sequence on the pull and a 3-note sequence on the push. 
My Loffet  2.6  a  3-note sequence for both push and pull.
So for PUSH, I'll keep the Loffet arrangement which repeats  Bb,  E, D#.
For PULL  I'll keep the Loffet sequence of   D, F, G#  so that the D and F in top octave can stay where they are.
For the lower octave I'll move the D, F, G# sequence one button nearer the chin.
This will leave both pull octaves with accidentals in the same relationship with their mainstream cousins.
So then I'll have a spare pull button in the gap I've created.  And I'm proposing a pull D#, as  I often stumble on  runs up to the E ( B,C#, D# E)

So my proposal is this

PUSH           Bb         E          D#           Bb        E         D#           Bb        E        D#         Bb        E
PULL            F           G#       D#           D          F         G#           D#       D        F           G#        D#   


This offends against Clive's principle of placing notes in order of pitch: the Pull D# comes before the D instead of after it. But I'm already used to the wrong sequence in the push (E followed by  D#)

I'm sad that having the five extra buttons will only give me one extra note: the D# reversal.  They will extend range.
If this was really a DG box, i would miss the push C for playing against G chords. But it's really a CF box, used mostly for the easy pull minors, and I haven't noticed needing a push C.  And I think a pull-only F will be OK, as it's mostly played against F and D pull chords.  I'm not planning to play in distant keys, and it's only 12 bass.

The benefit for me could be that the fingerings will be more similar in both octaves, whereas I often slip up now when trying to play in the other octave without specific practice.

I'd be really grateful if  you, Clive and Chris and other keyboard cogniscenti   could have a look and let me know of any snags.

For the two main rows, Ive just used the standard sequences with no modifications at the end of the rows. I'm wondering: have you suggestions for changing the sequences just at the top and/or bottom, for those times you run out of notes. 
I'm proposing an 11 + 12 + 11 layout.

Provided no one comes back with snags, I'll be translating this to CF and sending it off in a few days.


Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #8 on: December 10, 2013, 09:23:57 AM »

That all looks good and logical to me, given the 3/4-note sequence principle.

Continuing in D/G-speak:

Not a snag as such, but maybe a thought to consider (and probably dismiss as a minor and not easily-rectifiable issue):   Assuming you will have in your bass buttons Bb push/F pull, as I do, you may find you miss on your third row the F push (as I do), and the Bb pull. Of the two, I think F push would be the most useful to have, because of the lack of a pull G LH chord on standard layouts.  I do miss the ability to play a nice G7 chord using LH and RH, because that instantly makes it difficult to join in happily with some of the more bluesy stuff I frequently hear. 

Personally I might have prioritised a repeated pull Bb over a repeated pull D#, because it's likely to be the more used note, bearing in mind that it comes in the F major scale, and Eb doesn't.  I understand your point about pitch order, and this would perhaps also remove that issue on the pull?  In fact it then occurred to me that if you also reversed the E and D# notes on the 3rd row push, you would remove the remaining problem with pitch order too.   

I see the pull Bb as having use in G 'major/minor' French tunes, as I believe they're called, and also facilitating playing with a Dm chord (I know you've got the D's in both directions on the LH, so it doesn't really matter, but for some reason which I haven't really worked out, trying to play in Dm twists my fingers!)

But please just take these as my thoughts only - it all depends on how you want to play (and on the bass layout, which I'm not entirely clear on, as I'm not quite sure which layout is generally regarded as the standard.)

It's a fairly lonely path, this!  But I do think what you're designing is a very good way of extending the powers of the box - I did a spot of 'session musician' recording yesterday for someone I'd not previously met who's written and is recording a song in D major with some lovely chromatic runs against E major, A major, and B major chords.  He asked me to do it because he wanted the 'human' feel of an accordion's dynamics in the song, though he knew nothing about the instrument.  He was very specific about what he wanted me to play, and I really enjoyed the experience.  After we'd finished, I explained to him that he had been lucky to pick someone who happened to have a 3-row with extended basses, if he wanted those chromatic runs!

 

Logged

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #9 on: December 10, 2013, 11:05:35 AM »

Yep, looks good to me too - only comment I'd make is to beware against having reeds on the same reedplate that are too far apart from each other if possible; not so much of a problem at the high/low ends, but can cause tonality issues around the middle (because a reed chamber can't be optimal for both if they're too far apart). I think a few semitones either way is ok (4 or 5 or so?) - Theo/Mike would be able to tell you more. Your D#/G# is a little close to that wire...

Cheers,

Clive

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #10 on: December 10, 2013, 11:28:09 AM »

I'm saying now't

george ;)
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #11 on: December 10, 2013, 12:22:32 PM »

George, I am not familiar with the alternative semitone system at all, but I do think that the concept of starting with 2-row D/G's and moving to more complexity within a limited key range (maybe with boxes in different keys) is a valid one, for various reasons - first:  much less relearning involved for 2-row D/G'ers;  and second:  I notice someone  ;) recently said (and I appreciate that this is partly out of context):

Quote
For once I will not plug the BCC#  as the original poster is very new to the melodeon.  In those circumstances and for  English & Scottish music I would come down on the side of the simple 2 row DG  . I am advocating the Dg rather than the BC  because it ( the DG) has the wherewithal to play rhythmic and reasonably harmonic bass whereas the BC bass is extremely limited in comparison.

Now (and without going to stradella basses), I am perfectly willing to be convinced by any examples to the contrary, but it seems to me that the D/G dynamic 'feel' , which largely comes from the useful basses and the diatonic principle, is still there with a 3-row D/G/Acc.  This is a worthwhile goal, I think - it's just a different way of going about the idea, with its pros and cons.

Logged

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #12 on: December 10, 2013, 12:59:08 PM »

It depends on what purpose you want your extra row really. If you want it to augment what you already have then you will be able to play in a handful of keys with pretty much the scope of a normal D/G. But the question then is whether it is worth the extra weight and complexity. If you want to play in any key then I really don't think that you will be able to get the rhythmic and harmonic qualities of a D/G without, say, stradella bass like squeezy has, or with a properly chromatic right hand like a B/C/C#, Loomes or Atzarin.

If you are thinking of playing in a few extra keys, being able to use "accidentals" more fluidly, expanded bass and so on and you are willing to accept the increase in weight, then a D/G/acc is a fine system. But I am yet to be convinced about it's applicability to playing in any key.
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #13 on: December 10, 2013, 01:25:41 PM »

Quote
But I am yet to be convinced about it's applicability to playing in any key.

I absolutely agree (and I'm pretty sure Jack would too) - you need several, in different keys, if you wanted to do that.  This is a compromise in terms of weight, flexibility, speed, and sound - but IMO a good one.
« Last Edit: December 10, 2013, 01:28:29 PM by Chris Brimley »
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #14 on: December 10, 2013, 04:02:21 PM »

It depends on what purpose you want your extra row really. If you want it to augment what you already have then you will be able to play in a handful of keys with pretty much the scope of a normal D/G. But the question then is whether it is worth the extra weight and complexity. If you want to play in any key then I really don't think that you will be able to get the rhythmic and harmonic qualities of a D/G without, say, stradella bass like squeezy has, or with a properly chromatic right hand like a B/C/C#, Loomes or Atzarin.

If you are thinking of playing in a few extra keys, being able to use "accidentals" more fluidly, expanded bass and so on and you are willing to accept the increase in weight, then a D/G/acc is a fine system. But I am yet to be convinced about it's applicability to playing in any key.

I agree with most of the above  and don't see any contradiction or difficulty in playing BCC# and  DG. 

 The BCC# with stradella will do whatever is required in whatever keys are required  and is every bit as rhythmic as a DG.  The simple 2 row DG ( with chin end accidentals) is, to me , ideal for situations where only D or G will be required ( plus maybe a bitof A)  as it is a sort of pocket rocket providing arguably more 'umph' than a large piano box  with minimum weight and maximum portability.

The BC  with melodeon bass I am not over keen on due precisely to the lack of ability to drive a rhythm  and the awkward fingering for some keys on an instrument that is technically chromatic but not easlily so played.  The double ray with 12 stradella bass gets round  the rhythm problems and puts it more or less on a par with a DG.

I think it may be something to do with the fact that BC's are often seen as  'fast, maybe too fast, irish  trad music boxes and of course this they are good at.  However  learning to play a BC(C#) in the 5 keys needed to  give t'other 7 free of charge  is  not the massive jump into another world that many perceive it to be  and to me is definitely much more logical to learn than playing in as many keys as can on a DG with row of accidentals, whilst still being far short of 12!

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #15 on: December 10, 2013, 06:14:41 PM »

For me, the real disadvantage with the B/C/C#, apart from limited RH harmony in some keys, is that there isn't a small, compact model with decent stradella bass. Whereas if you are going to get a D/G/Acc then there are many to choose from.
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #16 on: December 10, 2013, 06:25:42 PM »

Is the reason that it's not easy to pack lots of reeds and buttons into the LHS without making it too heavy to throw around? 
Logged

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #17 on: December 10, 2013, 06:34:23 PM »

I feel somewhat nervous that this is becoming way off-topic!  I hope we would all agree, whatever the pros and cons of the different competing systems, that Jack's design, as a D/G/Acc (or C/F/Acc), is well thought-out? 

So I would say, go for it, Jack!
Logged

Jack Humphreys

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 709
    • tunesbyjackhumphreys
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #18 on: December 10, 2013, 07:09:02 PM »

Thanks Guys
As ever,  I'm so grateful for the careful and detailed thought you have given this. You've been really generous with your time and attention.
Clive, I will follow up with the maker the possible issue of  D# G# being too far apart in pitch to go on the same reedplate.
Chris. thanks for thoughts about the Bb.   I can see that a pull Bb is helpful for playing in F.
But my DG-speak "F" scale   is  really   Eb  on my CF box  and I won't be  playing in that key much. I think that the same might apply to your preference for a push F, to make a G7 chord on a DG box.   On my CF box,  that would correspond to an F7, for the Bb scale.  Again, I'm not planning much Bb playing, however many brass players turn up. 

So it's interesting to think that decisions about which notes to include maybe should  depend on the keys the box is in...

.... rather than (as I'd thought) just transposing the standard Corgeron or other layouts to other keys, when they presumably evolved to be suited for GC playing in France and Italy.

So that's an end of it.  I'll transpose the diagram and send it to Marc tomorrow.

Merci mes amis,  et joyeux noel!

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Deciding about accidentals on a three-row (again).
« Reply #19 on: December 11, 2013, 09:21:53 AM »

Is the reason that it's not easy to pack lots of reeds and buttons into the LHS without making it too heavy to throw around?

Because I have to have the last word...

In terms of reeds, an 18 melodeon bass system is comparable to a stradella system. And the mechanism is really not that heavy. Plus the stradella system delivers an awful lot.
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal