When I first started this thread, I imagined that the other RH systems than DGAcc must have inherent simplicity and common sense, the benefits of which would become clear, if I learned to play them - they weren't just 'random' designs.
I am now becoming increasingly confused, because it seems that they although may have logic, it's not yet been demonstrated that that makes them easier to play in practice. It looks as if they are just as difficult to learn - unless anyone can explain something whose importance I've missed?
Moreover, it now seems that one claimed simplifying benefit, having unisonoric basses, is not exclusive to those systems, and may also have its disadvantages.
Could I add to the general level of uncertainty still more by making this comment - it's not exactly in favour of bisonoric basses, but it may reduce one's objections to them:
It's necessary with bisonoric basses to plan in advance how you are going to play a complex piece, because you probably have to choose each note with regard to bellows direction and RH fingering. I used to think that this was a very difficult process. However, I now realise that your LH fingers learn to go automatically to the appropriate chord, presumably just in the same way as they would go to the appropriate stradella chord. Therefore learning how to play a tune is probably no more difficult in DGAcc, given this understanding - with BCC# you still need to choose a button and bellows direction, and you still need to select a LH chord. The difficult and time-consuming process is learning muscle-memory, which I would imagine is much the same with each system. So the lesson I think I'm beginning now to appreciate is that if it's actually possible to play a complex tune on DGAcc in the first place, it probably isn't any more difficult to do so than on another system.
And may well be physically easier, if the box is lighter, and have other benefits?
This is in no way intended to deny the obvious disadvantage of the lack of comprehensive keys, in the first place. But if you can play a tune on a DGAcc, then actually, why not do so?