Folks - I"m primarily a concertina player, but enjoying playing some melodeon on the side. I have a D/G Black Pearl Special, which I really like and use primarily for Morris, but I'm getting a hankering for a G/C to broaden my horizons - perhaps a little French, a little modern Euro.
Since melodeon is not my primary instrument, I don't want to spend a lot. I'm looking at three instruments and - while I know advice is no substitute for hands-on experience - I could use some input about the virtues and shortcomings of each.
- a Hohner Galaad. I'm attracted by the 12 basses; with my D/G, I feel limited by having only 8. But I worry about build quality.
- a Castagnari Nik or Brio. I've always liked the Castagnari sound, and the ones I've played have great action.
- a Castagnari Lilly. Yes, I know it's single voice, but I have fragile tendons and the light weight is a plus. The D/Gs I've heard are real powerhouses, and this could double as a Morris instrument when playing solo. The basses sound reasonably rich and compensate to a small degree for the single voice treble.
Any advice? The Hohner is the most attractive because of the extra basses, but I'm used to a pretty good action (ie my Black Pearl) and suspect I would find it a downgrade in that respect.
Thanks.