Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6   Go Down

Author Topic: The end of the debate?  (Read 17524 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Bob Ellis

  • Hero?....Where's my medal, then?
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2878
  • Ain't I cute?
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #60 on: February 01, 2014, 12:14:59 AM »

The only things I have gained from gazing at my navel are a little piece of lint and a stomach chill. I hope others find the process more rewarding.  >:E
Logged
Bob in beautiful Wensleydale, Les Panards Dansants, Crook Morris and the Loose Knit Band.
Clément Guais 3-row D/G/acc.; Castagnari 1914 D/G; Karntnerland Steirische 3-row G/C/F; Ellis Pariselle 2.6-row D/G/acc.; Gabbanelli Compact 2-row D/G with lots of bling, pre-war Hohner Bb/F; Acadian one-row in D.

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #61 on: February 01, 2014, 12:20:58 AM »

The OP was demonstrably wrong - this clearly hasn't ended the debate.

I agree Howard, the debate hasn't ended sadly. Demonstrably wrong? I'm not convinced I'm afraid! Let the issue roll on as long as it will, only two posts in this thread have surprised me and that's because I believed those two people to have a greater knowledge of musical theory than I have. My take on this is simple, if the fourth/fifth apart terminology doesn't mean anything to you then don't use it, just refer to the box by the keys the rows are tuned in then there is no misunderstanding.

The point about this fourth apart/quint tuned box terminology not existing outside of this forum was fine until John Kirkpatrick (no less!) decided to refer to it in a commercial DVD. The cat's now out of the bag and those who decry the fourth apart tuning terminology are decrying JK's clear cut statement. Melodeon god he may not be but I won't be standing up in a workshop any time soon to tell him he's talking out of his air button, will you?
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

Ranzo

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 52
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #62 on: February 01, 2014, 02:26:35 AM »

Hmm, I think the debate can be settled.

Yes, in the most common arrangement - the instrument that some would call simply a 2-row accordion/melodeon without reference to the specific pitches to which it may be tuned - the outer row and inner row are at the interval of a fourth apart. It is perfectly correct to say they are rows tuned at a fourth apart.

That way probably makes more sense to people who are not thinking of the instrument being in two different keys, but rather as a second row offering more pitches and fingering combinations. In something like English "folk" music, the modulation between keys is not generally important. One therefore tends to view an instrument with two rows as offering more ease of play for melodies.

In the Germanic musical way of thinking, however, harmony is more emphasized. The Circle of Fifths (Quintenzirkel) is the foundation of 'Musik', and every bit of the layout of the Viennese accordion has been designed to give the player maximum functionality in both melody and harmony. (Compare Irish music where maximum functionality of melody is wanted, hence the semitone arrangement of rows.) The Viennese multi-row accordion was designed to play the common 'Musik' with the most ease.

It's a matter of form to modulate to other keys, and then to return "home." And one's return home is usually via the circle of fifths: from Dominant (V) to Tonic (I). One would not go from IV to I - or rather, one might, but that would be of limited use. The Germanic musical way of thinking, therefore, construes the two rows as being in a "fifth" relationship. ("Quint" is German for a musical fifth.) Again, it's not the relationship between the actual pitches (distance of a fourth), but rather the theoretical relationship between keys, in the harmonic system.

"Quint" relationship (Quintabstand) is therefore also acceptable. And it's used in German-speaking circles, evidently.

So I think if John Kirkpatrick says it is tuned "a fourth apart", he is correct.
If others says it is a "quint" accordion — which we understand is primarily being done just so as not to confuse with the "half-tone" (Halbton) arrangement — then they are also correct. They are not musically illiterate, but possibly more musically knowledgeable — though no more correct.
Logged
Hohner 114 in C, G/C Pokerwork, Rochelle concertina, C/F German concertina, Hohner Marine Band

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #63 on: February 01, 2014, 07:46:14 AM »

That is an interesting way of looking at it. In essence we have a division between the 4th way of thinking of people who put reeds into real boxes and the importance of the 5th interval (origin of the diatonic dominant chords) to players.  Certainly would move a tunes tone centre "up a fifth" (simply play A7 instead of Am) far more commonly than I would down (though like space junk, what goes up must eventually do that). However (talking DG) the whole D row operates as a weak dominant, so that can be done "as part of the tune" without special chords. There are hundreds of tunes in this form.

I've observed a similar split in fingering charts. By convention all the ones on the site, and for that matter from makers are in my view awkwardly set out

  F/Eb D/F# G/A B/C D/E G/F# etc

… whereas in crossrow play (yes, there are other ways!) your bellows are either expanding or contracting and the musical line will run either over the push or pull notes. Even 20 years ago I found "waxing in" charts something of a pain planning scales of note runs. Whereas on a simple eg pull chart one can map out say a blues scale with a few strokes of the pen.

Slight digression there, but I wanted to expand the difference in conception, essentially between organology and music orientated thought.

I remain a "sweet FA" man m'self ;)
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #64 on: February 01, 2014, 08:17:16 AM »

I've observed a similar split in fingering charts. By convention all the ones on the site, and for that matter from makers are in my view awkwardly set out

  F/Eb D/F# G/A B/C D/E G/F# etc

… whereas in crossrow play (yes, there are other ways!) your bellows are either expanding or contracting and the musical line will run either over the push or pull notes. Even 20 years ago I found "waxing in" charts something of a pain planning scales of note runs. Whereas on a simple eg pull chart one can map out say a blues scale with a few strokes of the pen.
Chris, you've highlighted a difference of the potential use of these two types of layout charts:
The layout charts available from this forum homepage are excellent for showing 'what's there on the box'. It's easy to see in a single diagram the entire push-pull layout. I also find these layouts very useful when carrying out tuning work, e.g. I can print off a diagram and record tuning errors or off-sets next to the relevant button.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard.html

In contrast, your layout system, being organised by bellows direction, is excellent in showing how scales and harmonies can be built up especially on the RH. It is an aid to playing, rather than construction.
http://chrisryall.net/chords/
Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

Malcolm Clapp

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1119
  • Loving my Hohner-reeded wet MMM CastaTommy
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #65 on: February 01, 2014, 09:10:06 AM »

I'm with Theo on this one.... almost.
5 semitones from D to G  = quint.
7 semitones from G to D = um? er? sept or hept.
Hmmm. Doesn't quite sound right somehow....

I think the best way to describe a melodeon is just by naming the keys; D/G, C/F, whatever. It is therefore clear it isn't a semitone box. Why put a further name or description to it?



Logged
Tuner/repairer, now retired.

squeezy

  • Quick starter (now lagging behind)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1317
  • Hohner Cornelia (mixte D/G/o&s)
    • www.johnspiers.co.uk
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #66 on: February 01, 2014, 09:22:50 AM »


Let the issue roll on as long as it will, only two posts in this thread have surprised me and that's because I believed those two people to have a greater knowledge of musical theory than I have. My take on this is simple, if the fourth/fifth apart terminology doesn't mean anything to you then don't use it, just refer to the box by the keys the rows are tuned in then there is no misunderstanding.

I'm possibly flattering myself to think you might be referring to me when talking about being surprised about lack of musical theory knowledge.  But whoever you're talking about I think that there are many ways of thinking about music - classical musical theory is only one of those ways.

I have to work with the conventions of classical musical theory a lot and especially when working with formally trained musicians it is often frustrating the way it makes notes absolute - which in turn makes exactly the same melody transposed or played in a different octave a completely different thing.  For the purposes of making music on the melodeon thinking in terms of classical musical theory alone can be a hinderance to me.  I'm not dismissing it completely though - it is near impossible to arrange large and complicated music for many instruments without it's conventions.

I think the only real underlying disagreement here stems from whether we are talking about absolute notes or the concept of keys when trying to describe the relationship between rows.  If you're simply describing absolute pitch between similarly placed buttons on the two rows then the interval between the lowest D on the D row and the lowest G on the G row is indeed a fourth and not a fifth - I get that!   

However when you're talking about the concept of keys as different entities (as in how many flats and sharps there are in the major scale) - then the cycle of fifths applies - and the circle is closed.  So going one way round the circle you lose one flat/add one sharp and that way is a fifth ... but the other way you gain one flat/lose one sharp and that way is a fourth.  Because the key of G is still the key of G whether you're an octave up or an octave down, the relationship between the keys is BOTH A FOURTH AND A FIFTH.

My justification for thinking in the latter way when regarding the melodeon is that the half of the instrument that kind of dictates the proceedings with respect to harmony (i.e. the left hand) has buttons which play in many octaves and chords that you have no choice in the voicings as a player - so the natural way of thinking about them is as discrete chunks of harmony rather than the individual notes they're built from.

And my initial frustration with the thread stems only from not believing that systematic nomenclature is needed at all in this case ... because it is highly unlikely that we will need to describe instruments with rows a second, third or sixth apart.  In general we are only ever talking about intervals of a semitone or a fourth up (with very rare examples of instruments a semitone down or a fifth up) - I have never encountered boxes with any other configuration - so only 2 words are really needed - and they need not be systematic.

« Last Edit: February 01, 2014, 09:25:43 AM by squeezy »
Logged
Squeezy

Sometimes wrong, sometimes right ... but always certain!

oggiesnr

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 995
  • Dino BPII, Alfred Arnold Bandoneon, Loffet G/C
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #67 on: February 01, 2014, 09:45:54 AM »

Earliest reference I have found so far to "quint" is 1999 in rec.musicinstruments.  Also 2007 on The Session so it's not just us :)

I did wonder if a source of the confusion could also be that the stradella bass is referred to as a quint system (it follows the cycle of fifths so that's correct) and of course it goes G/D/A.

Totally irrelevant but a fun digression  (:)  The important thing is we (and it looks like others) understand what is meant by a quint box and so the word is fullfilling the function of language (accordeon on the other hand requires a modifier so we know which variety of accordeon it actually is).

Steve
Logged

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #68 on: February 01, 2014, 10:31:52 AM »

I think we should refer to D/G boxes as 'quint' as they are Quint-essentially English!

I'll get my coat  ;)

Nick Collis Bird

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3785
  • Been squeezing melodeons for over 48 years (badly)
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #69 on: February 01, 2014, 10:51:22 AM »

I think we should refer to D/G boxes as 'quint' as they are Quint-essentially English!

I'll get my coat  ;)

AAAARRRGH !  ;D

I've been reading this thread with a squint
Lost the glasses, though they were mint
The wife and the dog said look in the bog ( bathroom)
There were five pairs, could this be a quint?

OK ,that really is coat time  :|glug
 
Logged
Has anyone heard of the song. “ Broken Alarm-clock Blues” ? It starts   â€œI woke up this Afternoon”

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #70 on: February 01, 2014, 10:54:31 AM »


 
 - so the natural way of thinking about them is as discrete chunks of harmony  .

 

I like that.  To me 'chunks' is a great  bit of traditional music terminology as it neatly sidesteps  the need for more precise descriptive measures! :D :||: :|glug

Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #71 on: February 01, 2014, 11:05:03 AM »

on the basis that the end is not yet nigh   the fourth ( or looking arse upardly fifth) apart  descriptions  are only used /mostly used/ doubtfully needed etc  to differentiate between  such boxess and the semitone apart BC etc.   

My personal way of differentiating is to refer simply to ''DG etc''  ( to cover DG,AD,CF,GC etcetc)  and '' BC etc '' to cover all semitone tunings.

I suppose  a more long winded way round it would be diatonic  and  diatonic chromatic  but the above simple way seems to be readily understood by all (I think!)

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Nick Collis Bird

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3785
  • Been squeezing melodeons for over 48 years (badly)
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #72 on: February 01, 2014, 11:21:56 AM »

on the basis that the end is not yet nigh   the fourth ( or looking arse upardly fifth) apart  descriptions  are only used /mostly used/ doubtfully needed etc  to differentiate between  such boxess and the semitone apart BC etc.   

My personal way of differentiating is to refer simply to ''DG etc''  ( to cover DG,AD,CF,GC etcetc)  and '' BC etc '' to cover all semitone tunings.

I suppose  a more long winded way round it would be diatonic  and  diatonic chromatic  but the above simple way seems to be readily understood by all (I think!)

george

'Cept me :-\
Logged
Has anyone heard of the song. “ Broken Alarm-clock Blues” ? It starts   â€œI woke up this Afternoon”

Pat.

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 176
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #73 on: February 01, 2014, 11:27:07 AM »

I think we should refer to D/G boxes as 'quint' as they are Quint-essentially English!

I'll get my coat  ;)
    ;D ;D ;D
Logged

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #74 on: February 01, 2014, 01:09:27 PM »

I'm with Theo on this one.... almost.
5 semitones from D to G  = quint.
7 semitones from G to D = um? er? sept or hept.
Hmmm. Doesn't quite sound right somehow....

I think the best way to describe a melodeon is just by naming the keys; D/G, C/F, whatever. It is therefore clear it isn't a semitone box. Why put a further name or description to it?

The first part of this is nonsense because all it proves is that there are twelves semitones in an octave. An interval is the distance between two degrees of a scale, the key note of which is is the first degree of the scale. So in in the key of D then D=1 E=2 F=3 G=4 the interval between D and G (which contains five semitones) is a fourth. Reference to the number of semitones between any two degrees of the scale does not represent an interval and simply serves to muddy the waters.

The second part of your post I now believe to be clear, precise, succinct and absolutely correct. The reason I will never again refer to a box as anything other than D/G C/F etc requires another post as I need thank several other forum members for helping the penny to drop!
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

Sage Herb

  • Steve Harrison
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 762
  • Slaithwaite, UK
    • The Black Box Band
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #75 on: February 01, 2014, 01:50:18 PM »

I'm with Theo on this one.... almost.
5 semitones from D to G  = quint.
7 semitones from G to D = um? er? sept or hept.
Hmmm. Doesn't quite sound right somehow....

I think the best way to describe a melodeon is just by naming the keys; D/G, C/F, whatever. It is therefore clear it isn't a semitone box. Why put a further name or description to it?

The first part of this is nonsense because all it proves is that there are twelves semitones in an octave. An interval is the distance between two degrees of a scale, the key note of which is is the first degree of the scale. So in in the key of D then D=1 E=2 F=3 G=4 the interval between D and G (which contains five semitones) is a fourth. Reference to the number of semitones between any two degrees of the scale does not represent an interval and simply serves to muddy the waters.
Logically then, wouldn't the thing that we generically refer to as a 'semitone box' properly be termed a 'minor second box'?
cheers
Steve
Logged
Hohner Erikas & Club 2s
Hohner gob-harps:
Vega Senator 5-string banjo; Alex Burns plectrum guitar

Black Box Band - www.theblackboxband.co.uk
Annie Dearman & Steve Harrison - www.dearmanharrison.co.uk
Phoenix - www.phoenixdanceband.co.uk
http://soundcloud.com/sage-herb

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #76 on: February 01, 2014, 01:58:07 PM »

Logically then, wouldn't the thing that we generically refer to as a 'semitone box' properly be termed a 'minor second box'?
cheers
Steve

Absolutely! I think 'semitone box' is equally correct though and it's in more commonly understood terminology, but that's just my opinion of course.
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

Sage Herb

  • Steve Harrison
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 762
  • Slaithwaite, UK
    • The Black Box Band
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #77 on: February 01, 2014, 02:04:59 PM »

Logically then, wouldn't the thing that we generically refer to as a 'semitone box' properly be termed a 'minor second box'?
cheers
Steve

Absolutely! I think 'semitone box' is equally correct though and it's in more commonly understood terminology, but that's just my opinion of course.
But aren't you contradicting your own argument here? If I understand correctly, you're saying (a) that intervals are defined in relation to a scale, not just a number of semitones and (b) that the difference between rows on a melodeon should be defined as intervals, then it follows that 'semitone box' would be illicit.
cheers
Steve
Logged
Hohner Erikas & Club 2s
Hohner gob-harps:
Vega Senator 5-string banjo; Alex Burns plectrum guitar

Black Box Band - www.theblackboxband.co.uk
Annie Dearman & Steve Harrison - www.dearmanharrison.co.uk
Phoenix - www.phoenixdanceband.co.uk
http://soundcloud.com/sage-herb

waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #78 on: February 01, 2014, 02:06:46 PM »

I'm with Theo on this one.... almost.
5 semitones from D to G  = quint.
7 semitones from G to D = um? er? sept or hept.
Hmmm. Doesn't quite sound right somehow....

I think the best way to describe a melodeon is just by naming the keys; D/G, C/F, whatever. It is therefore clear it isn't a semitone box. Why put a further name or description to it?

The first part of this is nonsense because all it proves is that there are twelves semitones in an octave. An interval is the distance between two degrees of a scale, the key note of which is is the first degree of the scale. So in in the key of D then D=1 E=2 F=3 G=4 the interval between D and G (which contains five semitones) is a fourth. Reference to the number of semitones between any two degrees of the scale does not represent an interval and simply serves to muddy the waters.

The second part of your post I now believe to be clear, precise, succinct and absolutely correct. The reason I will never again refer to a box as anything other than D/G C/F etc requires another post as I need thank several other forum members for helping the penny to drop!


The main point of your original post seemed to be that labeling a D/G box as a 'fifth apart' box is an example of musical ignorance.  I do think this thread clearly has settled that point.  There are musically valid reasons for looking at these boxes that way.  I've always looked at my A/D/G box as circle of fifth key centers and the term 'quint' was never an issue for me.
Logged

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: The end of the debate?
« Reply #79 on: February 01, 2014, 03:09:51 PM »

The main point of your original post seemed to be that labeling a D/G box as a 'fifth apart' box is an example of musical ignorance.  I do think this thread clearly has settled that point.  There are musically valid reasons for looking at these boxes that way.  I've always looked at my A/D/G box as circle of fifth key centers and the term 'quint' was never an issue for me.

I did say in a post over an hour ago that the penny had finally dropped and that I need to formulate another post in order to explain the reason for that and thank those posters that clarified some points about the musical center of boxes tuned to D/G C/F etc. I still need time to collect my thoughts in order to write a coherent post that won't raise any hackles! Many posters on here have more in-depth knowledge of musical theory than I have particularly in the field of harmony which is I believe the crux of this issue. I need to explain that to my own satisfaction and hopefully bring a satisfactory end to the debate!

But aren't you contradicting your own argument here? If I understand correctly, you're saying (a) that intervals are defined in relation to a scale, not just a number of semitones and (b) that the difference between rows on a melodeon should be defined as intervals, then it follows that 'semitone box' would be illicit.
cheers
Steve

I said that five semitones between two notes cannot be described as an interval of a fifth!

Let's look at a box tuned in B/C, assuming the lower pitched row to be the starting point (and this is the most debatable bit!) then B = 1 and C = 2. In the key of B all C notes are sharp so in fact B = 1 and C# = 2. If you tune the rows B/C then there is only a semitone interval between the two keynotes. Whether you describe that interval as a minor second or a major seventh take us back to the original discussion!

Edit: Didn't have my thinking head on! See below.
« Last Edit: February 02, 2014, 06:11:08 PM by tallship »
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal