Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Big multiple reeds plate versus small reed plates  (Read 1294 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Andrej

  • New Starter
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1
Big multiple reeds plate versus small reed plates
« on: February 01, 2014, 11:59:48 AM »

Hi All

I am very very interesting into melodeons and all things around them.

I am thinking about to get build new melodeon but I am not sure what
reeds to put into it.

I am contacting You All and I would really ask You please find a little of
time to read and if possible to answer my questions .

I believe that You based on You experience with accordions and can
help to answer couple of questions I still have about accordion reeds.

I tried to write questions the way that it should be possible to
answer them "YES-NO" or just with little comments.

Questions about big multiple reeds reed plate :

Please consider the same material of reed ( tongue ) , the same shape
of reed (tongue) , the same shape of reed slot , the same material of
reed plate, the same reed plate thickness, the same air pressure
causing reed (tongue ) to vibrate and the same accordion box.

Please try to answer “ YES-NO” if possible :

1.Is loudness of sound generated from big multiple reeds plate bigger
than the loudness of sound generated from normal ( small –common )
reed plate ?


2. If Yes if possible can You say how many % loudness of big multiple
reed plate is comparing to loudness of small common reed plate ?


3. Is “color ( harmonious )” of sound generated from big multiple
reeds plate better that the “color ( harmonious )” of sound
generated from normal ( small –common ) reed plate ?


4. Does it have any sense to get produce big multiple reed plate for
to install it into diatonic accordion to get stronger and more
harmonious sound of instrument ?


5. Can You state positive points and negative points please for big
multiple reeds reed plate ?


Questions about reed plates made off different materials:

Please consider the same material of reed ( tongue ) , the same shape
of reed (tongue) , the same shape of reed slot , the same reed plate
thickness, the same air pressure causing reed (tongue ) to vibrate and
the same accordion box.

Please try to answer “ YES-NO” if possible :

1. Does loudness of sound generated from different metals reed plates
differ from Zinc reed plate to Brass reed plate to Duralalumin reed
plate ?

If Yes if possible can You say how many % loudness differs comparing
different metals of reed plate ?

2. Does “color ( harmonious )” of sound generated from different
metals reed plates differs from Zinc reed plate to Brass reed plate to
Duralalumin reed plate ?

3. Is it possible to tune up reeds on Duralaluminium reed plates that
it will generate the same “color-harmonious” of sound that reed on
Zinc or Brass reed plate ? Consider same accordion box.

4. Is it possible to tune up reeds on Duralaluminium reed plates that
it will generate the same loudness of sound that reed on Zinc or Brass
reed plate ? Consider same accordion box.

5. Is it possible to tune up reeds on Duralaluminium reed plates that
it will generate the same loudness of sound and the same “color-
harmonious “ of sound that reed on Zinc or Brass reed plate but in
different accordion box made off other kind of wood ?

6. If question 5. answer is YES please what kind of wood use ?

Thank You All very much for Your answers and help

Best Regards
Andrej
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Big multiple reeds plate versus small reed plates
« Reply #1 on: February 01, 2014, 03:53:32 PM »

Hi Andrej,

I have had many of the same questions myself!

You might have to build a few -- or many -- accordions yourself before you can answer them to your satisfaction.

I'm not a builder, but I've seen and played and studied many accordions made during the last century and all over the world, and I have my own ideas about some of these questions.  But I think many different materials and construction styles can succeed in making a wonderful sounding accordion.  IMO, differences in quality may be more a matter of how an individual builder follows up and refines his original design, making changes and retaining the ones that seem to be an improvement while trying to weed out the materials and features that seem responsible for problems or interfere with his sense of an ideal sound. 

So I think builders (and designers in the larger factories) have pursued their own ideas often, and sometimes with great results but leading in different design directions. Often (not always), they have consulted with musicians for their feedback.

On the other hand, at times when a very wide variety of designs were offered by the makers, certain particular models (or time periods for construction) seem to have been selected out as most successful by the best musicians.  It can be interesting, but not trivial, to try to figure out which materials and design features and techniques of craftsmanship make those great instruments so great.

There are some answers to some of your questions here from another melnet member, diatonix.  Diatonix builds accordions that I have never had the pleasure to hear or play in person, but from the videos and recordings I've seen I understand them to be superb.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4445.msg56266.html

PG
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal