Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Down

Author Topic: J. Collis Bird, Concertina record  (Read 11181 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: J. Collis Bird, Concertina record
« Reply #40 on: February 10, 2014, 06:49:53 PM »

Great stuff Wes, thanks!

In Gold Medal position its.......
    Salvation Army Staff Captain LINACRE who recorded 'Glory to God' on Thursday, 1 September, 1898.
    (yes, he's new to me too!!)

And that recording was Berliner E9100, the first in the Concertina series.

Quote
In Silver Medal position its ........
    PERCY HONRI who recorded 'Onward Christian Soldiers' on Thursday, 15 September, 1898.
    (not typical of Percy's repertoire, is it? Percy also recorded on Wednesday, 21 September 1898)

Which was E9101 in the Concertina series.

Maybe not typical of what he usually recorded, but there's a newsreel in which Percy plays "singalong" songs (whilst mouthing the words of them to the audience) and I guess "Onward Christian Soldiers" could be seen in terms of that part of his repertoire; a crowd pleaser...
 
I'd already concluded that the issued record of "Happy Darkies" couldn't have been the "first recording" and the tale of that may well be apocryphal, though (given the circumstances described) I wonder if it might possibly have been done simply as a "test" recording for the new equipment and never given a number or released, then re-recorded (properly) a few weeks later? (As well as again in January 1949.)

(In which case, Percy would still have made "the first recording" but not "the first commercial recording".  ??? )
 
Quote
In Bronze Medal position its .....
     J COLLIS BIRD who recorded 'March of the Men of Harlech' on Monday, 26 September, 1898.

Do you know if there's any evidence that E9105 got issued, or the other two (E9100 or E9101) for that matter, since none of them are listed in the Gramophone Record Catalogue 1899?

If J.Collis Bird's one was, Nick may have a hope of finding a copy, other than that "lost" recording in EMI's Archives...

And if Staff Captain Linacre's one wasn't, Percy Honri would still have made "the first commercially-released record" of a concertina.

{posted both here and on Concertina.net}

wes williams

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6
Re: J. Collis Bird, Concertina record
« Reply #41 on: February 11, 2014, 01:09:59 AM »

I managed to find the first 23 of the concertina series. Since all these are allocated numbers, its fairly safe to assume they were released, or at least intended to be. The date of that catalogue wasn't stated last time I looked; it could be up to October 1901. Later entries in the database show recordings made but not issued, but with the earliest ones they aren't listed. The last of the 23 is Maccann on 12 September 1900 when he recorded 9118 to 9122, which are the first in the series to have matrix numbers. I couldn't find any more on the database until Dutch Daly's 9137: "Wedding March and Carnival" recorded 13 August 1903, but the database is slightly cranky with its search terms, so they could be there somewhere. The recording dates of Zonophone issued concertina records exclude them as possibles from this missing period. I've added the list below, all are 7 inch, and 'Berliner'.

 

As I said earlier on melodeon.net, the number of records that could be pressed from a master was very limited, so most of these records are extremely rare, and that was made even worse by the 'trade-in' policy which allowed one third of the original cost of a returned record against a new purchase. I was outbid at £165 for one of Maccann's on ebay, which gives you some kind of indicator, although they normally sell at around £50 up.

 

9100: Glory to God; Salvation Army Staff Captain LINACRE;Thursday, 1 September, 1898
9101: Onward Christian soldiers (Sullivan), PERCY HONRI, Thursday, 15 September, 1898
9102: Honeymoon, March; PERCY HONRI; Thursday, 15 September, 1898
9103: The marauders, March;PERCY HONRI; Wednesday, 21 September, 1898
9104: Killarney (Balfe); PERCY HONRI; Wednesday, 21 September, 1898
9105: March of the Men of Harlech; J COLLIS BIRD; Monday, 26 September, 1898
9106: Castilda, march;PERCY HONRI; Saturday, 1 October, 1898
9107: Happy darkies (Honri); PERCY HONRI; Saturday, 1 October, 1898
9108:The lost chord (Sullivan); PERCY HONRI; Saturday, 1 October, 1898
9109: Santiago, Waltz (Corbin); PERCY HONRI (with piano); Tuesday, 11 October, 1898
9110: Toreador, Waltz; PERCY HONRI (with piano);Tuesday, 11 October, 1898
9111: Medley of popular airs; PERCY HONRI (with piano); Tuesday, 11 October, 1898
9112: The Geisha: Selection (S Jones); PERCY HONRI ; Monday, 31 October, 1898
9113: Austrian Hymn; PERCY HONRI; Monday, 31 October, 1898
9114: Lyceum, March; PERCY HONRI, Monday, 31 October, 1898
9115: Gramophone March; PERCY HONRI; Monday, 31 October, 1898
9116: Coon's delight (Honri);PERCY HONRI; Monday, 31 October, 1898
9117: High School Cadets, March (Sousa); PERCY HONRI; Monday, 31 October, 1898
9118: The coral pearl, Gavotte; Professor McCANN; 12-9-00 (Recorded by Fred Gaisberg)
9119: ’A Frangesa, March (Costa); Professor McCANN; 12-9-00 (Recorded by Fred Gaisberg)
9120: The Beatrix Schottisch; Professor McCANN;12-9-00 (Recorded by Fred Gaisberg)
9121: The Princess, Schottisch; Professor McCANN; 12-9-00 (Recorded by Fred Gaisberg)
9122: The Empire, March; Professor McCANN; 12-9-00 (Recorded by Fred Gaisberg)

{posted both here and on concertina.net}
Logged

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: J. Collis Bird, Concertina record
« Reply #42 on: February 11, 2014, 01:07:43 PM »

I managed to find the first 23 of the concertina series. Since all these are allocated numbers, its fairly safe to assume they were released, or at least intended to be.

Great, so it's not impossible that Nick might be able to find a copy of J.Collis Bird's one somewhere!

Quote
The date of that catalogue wasn't stated last time I looked; it could be up to October 1901.

I took the year from The British Library website, where it is listed for 1899, but maybe that's wrong...  ???

Quote
Later entries in the database show recordings made but not issued, but with the earliest ones they aren't listed.

So Percy Honri could have made "the first recording" but it wouldn't show up if it was only a "test" and never issued?
 
Quote
As I said earlier on melodeon.net, the number of records that could be pressed from a master was very limited, so most of these records are extremely rare, and that was made even worse by the 'trade-in' policy which allowed one third of the original cost of a returned record against a new purchase.

No wonder Percy Honri's records are so rare then, seeing that these seem to be the bulk of the ones he recorded.

{posted both here and on Concertina.net}

wes williams

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6
Re: J. Collis Bird, Concertina record
« Reply #43 on: February 11, 2014, 04:45:10 PM »

Nick might be able to locate a copy, but its a long shot. I'd suggest he contacts the CLPGS http://www.clpgs.org.uk in case one of their members has it. I'll post it on a few sites.

The British Library site dates aren't reliable, and should only be taken as a guide. For instance they list a '1910 HMV Records of Unique and Historical Interest' that must be over a decade later since it lists recordings by 'the late' Enrico Caruso who died in 1921. And the catalogues and supplements don't contain the whole available range. I have a 1912 HMV Trade List that has far more records than the catalogues show.

There's no way we can prove or disprove any earlier recordings by Honri, but I'm tempted to think the recording mentioned was 9102. After a restrained performance of Onward Christian Soldiers, Honri and Gaisberg probably let rip on Honeymoon March.

The Berliner/G&T recordings are only about half of the Honri recordings I've managed to list so far. The others are much more likely to appear at some point.

{posted both here and on concertina.net}
« Last Edit: February 11, 2014, 05:28:16 PM by wes williams »
Logged

KLR

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 640
Re: J. Collis Bird, Concertina record
« Reply #44 on: February 18, 2014, 12:44:00 AM »

Regarding confusing catalogs, in an interview published in the book The Golden Age of the Accordion John Reuther remarks on how old catalogs would often mislabel accordion and concertina players - the companies didn't bother to find out these niggling details on occasion, it seems.  The example John brought up was Finto-Piano accordion player Pietro Frosini, who was listed in one catalog as a player of the "Grand Concertina," whatever that is - 'tina version of the grand piano?  That would be an 81 key duet, I'd think...actually Frosini's instruments with their single note left hand keyboards actually were duet-ish in nature, so maybe we can give the companies a pass there.
Logged

KLR

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 640
Re: J. Collis Bird, Concertina record
« Reply #45 on: February 19, 2014, 07:07:07 PM »

Speaking of xylophones:  Flowers of Adrigole, hornpipe ; and other hornpipes / Ed Gagan and His Orchestra, instrumental group.  Not to mention the clarinet and woodblock(s)!  What a whacky sound.  Ed Geoghean was actually one of the better sidemen in those days, you hear him play the tune off and on on his piano here. 
Logged
Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal