My vintage Gaillard and my new Saphir differ . . .
I have decided to order an 18 bass Handry with standard bass near the chin. Now I am pondering which of my Gaillard right hand accidental row layout to mimic. The attached layouts show Handry 18s that are like the vintage Gaillard or the Saphir accidentals. The seven differences are highlighted in blue.
Having learned several tunes on both Gaillards I can only say they differ, rather than having decided that one is more comfortable than the other. To make switching between all three boxes as easy as possible, I want to converge on one layout.
I am inclined to select the Saphir as my standard and have the Handry resemble that. Eventually I may have the Vintage Gaillard's bass (and perhaps its accidentals) rearranged to mimic the Saphir.
Any advice about the tradeoff of selecting the Saphir's accidental row pattern rather than the Vintage Gaillard's pattern for the Handry?
Doc