Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Down

Author Topic: Are melodeons transposing instruments?  (Read 9371 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #20 on: March 27, 2014, 11:55:15 AM »

IMO there is no such thing as a transposing instrument. You could notate saxophones etc. in the actually sounding key...
That would be horribly inconvenient and almost unworkable in practice.
The whole point about clarinets and saxophones being transposing instruments is that it allows players of different sizes (and keys) of instruments in the same family to use the same fingering for the written notes, regardless of what instrument they are playing.

So - staking my claim as a clarinettist here - the 'normal' clarinet in Bb, its siblings in A and C, the piccolo version in high Eb, the alto version in low Eb, the basset-horn in F, bass clarinet in low Bb, the contra-alto clarinet in very low Eb, and the contra-bass clarinet in ultra-low Bb; all of them are fingered the same. The written music parts are transposed by the composer/arranger/transcriber so that all the clarinettist has to do is read the notes and use the standard, normal fingering. 

If it wasn't like that, clarinettists would need to learn different fingerings for every instrument in the family, and since they (orchestral players at least) often need to swap instruments during the course of a piece of music, it would get very confusing and the risk of playing wrong notes would be very high indeed.

The same applies to saxophones.

That's why we have transposing instruments.
Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

deltasalmon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1002
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #21 on: March 27, 2014, 12:17:38 PM »

With Steve's explanation above I'd think that some people use a melodeon the same way. Squeezy said it earlier and I've heard Lester say the same. I know I do it as well. My main instrument is C#/D so I like reading music written in D. When I play my one-row in C, I play it as if I'm playing the D-row on my C#/D. If I'm going to learn music from sheet music I'll transpose it from whatever key its in to the key of D (even though its tuned to C) because that's what I'm most comfortable reading.
Logged
Sean McGinnis
Bordentown City, NJ, USA

Idelone

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 135
  • Now that's what I call a-peeling.
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #22 on: March 27, 2014, 12:20:58 PM »

By using the same sheet of music and changing boxes, all you are doing is changing the key of the piece
It is the same for transposing woodwind instruments.

Perhaps but only if the same pitched instruments wish to play together.  Tenor sax, clarinet, and trumpet  are all pitched in Bb so therefore could play from the same piece of concert pitched music (although they would not be playing in the intended key) but the Eb pitched alto and baritone saxes would not be able to join in.

IMO there is no such thing as a transposing instrument.
Unfortunately this is not the case. Apart from the instruments mentioned above, the soprano sax, bass sax, French horn in F, English horn in F are all transposing instruments; there are many, many more. These all have to have music transposed into their respective pitches for them to play together as an ensemble.

By using the same sheet of music and changing boxes, all you are doing is changing the key of the piece
You could notate saxophones etc. in the actually sounding key or you could treat melodeons as transposing instrument, e.g. by using tabulature.
Yes, you could, but that is not the convention, which has been established over time, and what would it achieve ? Essentially making concert pitch instruments play in a key that would only suit one of the transposing instruments pitches. If you chose to play with a clarinet for example your humble diatonic melodeon would have to play in the key of Bb, but you would not be able to add alto and baritone saxes without providing even more transposed scores. Perhaps not the way to go.

Logged

Idelone

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 135
  • Now that's what I call a-peeling.
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #23 on: March 27, 2014, 12:37:23 PM »

With Steve's explanation above I'd think that some people use a melodeon the same way. Squeezy said it earlier and I've heard Lester say the same. I know I do it as well. My main instrument is C#/D so I like reading music written in D. When I play my one-row in C, I play it as if I'm playing the D-row on my C#/D. If I'm going to learn music from sheet music I'll transpose it from whatever key its in to the key of D (even though its tuned to C) because that's what I'm most comfortable reading.

Sean, I couldn't agree more, if you are playing at home, it doesn't actually matter what key you play it in. You rewrite the piece to suit your box and its available home key/keys.  I do exactly the same with my G/C, because it allows me to use the available diatonic chords on the bass side. But if I change a piece of music that is conventionally played in the key of A, to say G and got used to playing it that way at home, the moment I went to an open session in which everyone else was play the said tune A, I would be well and truly stuffed. This approach will work if you have your own band and are able to dictate which keys the tunes are played in, but once again all you have done is to alter the key of the piece to suit your instrument, but it still doesn't make your instrument a transposing one.

« Last Edit: March 27, 2014, 12:39:53 PM by Idelone »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #24 on: March 27, 2014, 02:15:10 PM »

.
I think a lot of people are missing the point here. Although music theory talks of "transposing instruments" the "transposing" bit is about the sheet music - not the instument itself. So an Eb clarinet still plays that note where A Bb'er would play Bb.

While melodeons come in different keys, they would only become "transposing instuments" if someone devised a score system that took advantage of this: We'd be talking "speed the plough" scored as "C" (F natural) but playing out on the G row (in G). Whereas on a C/G you'd actually score it with an F# to acheive the same actual key, etc etc

Tab is the only system that comes remotely close to that, and I don't think that is the issue.  Melodeons.net-land might "decide" to call these boxes "transposing instuments", but the other 99.9% of musicians wouldn't have a clue what we were talking about; it is a well define musical term.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Graham Spencer

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3548
  • MAD as a wet Hohner........
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #25 on: March 27, 2014, 02:40:29 PM »

I must admit, when I first looked at this thread I was sorely tempted to reply with a 2-letter monosyllable and leave it at that.......
Logged
Among others, Saltarelle Pastourelle II D/G; Hohner 4-stop 1-rows in C & G; assorted Hohners; 3-voice German (?) G/C of uncertain parentage; lovely little Hlavacek 1-row Heligonka; Bâ™­/Eâ™­ Koch. Newly acquired G/C Hohner Viktoria. Also Fender Jazz bass, Telecaster, Stratocaster, Epiphone Sheraton, Charvel-Jackson 00-style acoustic guitar, Danelectro 12-string and other stuff..........

Squeezing in the Cyprus sunshine

Ollie

  • Grumpy Young Git
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1900
    • Ollie King
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #26 on: March 27, 2014, 03:01:08 PM »

.
I think a lot of people are missing the point here. Although music theory talks of "transposing instruments" the "transposing" bit is about the sheet music - not the instument itself. So an Eb clarinet still plays that note where A Bb'er would play Bb.


And some of us work like this. As both myself, Squeezy and others have said, we need the sheet music to be in D or G in order to play in different keys on different boxes. If someone put down some sheet music in front of me in Bb and told me to play it on my Bb/Eb, I'd struggle. I'd get there eventually, but if it was in D, I could sight read it almost perfectly. My mind still thinks I'm playing in D, even though I'm actually playing in Bb. This is exactly the same as if a clarinet was looking at a score in C, was thinking in C, but was actually playing in Bb.

The melodeon can be used as a transposing instrument, but isn't always.
Logged
Hohner Erika 12 bass D/G : Hohner Erika Bb/Eb : Hohner 1 row 4 stop D : Hohner Erica 9 bass D/G :

http://www.olliekingmusic.com/

Free-Reed Specialist, Hobgoblin Leeds

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #27 on: March 27, 2014, 03:16:32 PM »

I have perfect pitch, so hate transposing instruments. But what Steve says is true. The recorder is a good example of different sizes of instruments which have different fingering and the saxophone could easily be adapted like this. Make everybody play C and F saxes instead of Bb and Eb and you're there (especially since the lower octave of clarinet would work out as the F fingering and the upper octave the C fingering). But clarinets, breaking up a twelth, would be so much more tricky. Clarinetists do play clarinets in all those keys that Steve mentioned, because the standard design of clarinet sounds different in those keys. I'm not sure why we don't make an A clarinet with the same bore but with fingerwork in different positions such that it plays like a C Basset clarinet mind.
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

IvanM

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 76
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #28 on: March 27, 2014, 03:20:08 PM »

Although I know some theory, I'm not a professional musician and have never got any formal musical education, so I might use terms wrong. I simply knew the situation with garmons and supposed that the term "transposing instrument" is the most appropriate. If you know the better one, I'd glad to know. And I wanted to know how this may apply to melodeons.

If one has learned a melody with C (A, D - doesn't matter) garmon, he can play it with any other. The melody would sound differently, but the fingering would be the same. And sheet music also. It's very convenient. The only problem can arise while playing two or more differently tuned garmons in ensemble, but there are some solutions for that as I know.

So what if one learned a melody in DG melodeon, how will he play in AD, CF, BC etc. melodeons? Should he press the same buttons or not? As I understand the layouts are perfectly up or down to each other.
AD is 5 semitones down of DG, CF is 3 semitones up of AD or 2 semitones down of DG (if I'm not mistaken). So while it is similar to garmon, playing the same buttons will only lead to the melody sounding lower or higher. But BC is a different story, pressing the same buttons as if in DG will lead to the distortion of the melody. May be there are other issues, but you must know better.
Logged

Idelone

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 135
  • Now that's what I call a-peeling.
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #29 on: March 27, 2014, 03:23:08 PM »

.
I think a lot of people are missing the point here. Although music theory talks of "transposing instruments" the "transposing" bit is about the sheet music - not the instument itself. So an Eb clarinet still plays that note where A Bb'er would play Bb.

While melodeons come in different keys, they would only become "transposing instuments" if someone devised a score system that took advantage of this: We'd be talking "speed the plough" scored as "C" (F natural) but playing out on the G row (in G). Whereas on a C/G you'd actually score it with an F# to acheive the same actual key, etc etc

Tab is the only system that comes remotely close to that, and I don't think that is the issue.  Melodeons.net-land might "decide" to call these boxes "transposing instuments", but the other 99.9% of musicians wouldn't have a clue what we were talking about; it is a well define musical term.

Chris, I'm not sure if I can following your thinking, so rather than try to reply to something that's seriously moving into thread drift territory, I will re-iterate the question, "Are melodeons transposing instruments?"  The simple answer is NO, they are concert pitch instruments so do not require transposing to get them to play in concert pitch. This forum is supposed to be instructive, as well as factual, so it would be misleading to lead anyone to believe otherwise.


Logged

deltasalmon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1002
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #30 on: March 27, 2014, 03:32:53 PM »

So what if one learned a melody in DG melodeon, how will he play in AD, CF, BC etc. melodeons? Should he press the same buttons or not? As I understand the layouts are perfectly up or down to each other.
AD is 5 semitones down of DG, CF is 3 semitones up of AD or 2 semitones down of DG (if I'm not mistaken). So while it is similar to garmon, playing the same buttons will only lead to the melody sounding lower or higher. But BC is a different story, pressing the same buttons as if in DG will lead to the distortion of the melody. May be there are other issues, but you must know better.

If you learned some tunes on a DG and tried to play them on a CF, AD or any other 4th/5th system the tune would come out fine but in another key. If you tried on a BC it would not come out well at all unless the tune in question was played only "along the row".
Logged
Sean McGinnis
Bordentown City, NJ, USA

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #31 on: March 27, 2014, 03:38:12 PM »

And some of us work like this. As both myself, Squeezy and others have said, we need the sheet music to be in D or G in order to play in different keys on different boxes.

So what you are saying is that you are a non-transposing instrumentalist.

(:)

No wait, you are transposing...

... because you can't transpose.

:(

Oh who cares.

 8)

Idelone

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 135
  • Now that's what I call a-peeling.
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #32 on: March 27, 2014, 03:54:39 PM »


I digress, but ..........

I have perfect pitch, so hate transposing instruments.

"Hate", that's a bit harsh. As a Bb and an Eb player, to me, it makes sense to have the same finger names, but with different pitches, rather than learn different fingerings for the concert pitch notes on each instrument; nightmare !  So you feel we should all be relegated to the C-melody ?   ;)

Logged

Jack Humphreys

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 709
    • tunesbyjackhumphreys
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #33 on: March 27, 2014, 04:33:07 PM »

.
I think a lot of people are missing the point here. Although music theory talks of "transposing instruments" the "transposing" bit is about the sheet music - not the instument itself. So an Eb clarinet still plays that note where A Bb'er would play Bb.


And some of us work like this. As both myself, Squeezy and others have said, we need the sheet music to be in D or G in order to play in different keys on different boxes. If someone put down some sheet music in front of me in Bb and told me to play it on my Bb/Eb, I'd struggle. I'd get there eventually, but if it was in D, I could sight read it almost perfectly. My mind still thinks I'm playing in D, even though I'm actually playing in Bb. This is exactly the same as if a clarinet was looking at a score in C, was thinking in C, but was actually playing in Bb.

The melodeon can be used as a transposing instrument, but isn't always.

I agree.  When I write out G minor tunes for playing on my CF box,   I write them in the key of A minor. Then I can use my familiar DG fingerings for the written notes.
So then I'm choosing to treat my CF box as a transposing instrument.  It transposes a tone down from my written tune.
But this is not an agreed convention. So maybe I'm a transposing player rather than a user of a transposing box.

DDickie

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 32
    • Richard Hambridge
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #34 on: March 27, 2014, 04:33:56 PM »

And some of us work like this. As both myself, Squeezy and others have said, we need the sheet music to be in D or G in order to play in different keys on different boxes. If someone put down some sheet music in front of me in Bb and told me to play it on my Bb/Eb, I'd struggle.

I operate a variation on this theme:  I find that if I have a tune which is notated in, say, Eb, then I can play it on my D/G box by telling myself that it is now a Bb/Eb box (i.e. that the button which sounds the root G note now sounds an Eb, and so on for the other buttons), and just playing it (albeit now transposed into G) straight from the music, using D/G fingering.  Simples!  (:)

I am mainly involved with Morris Dance music, so by doing it this way I can get the gist of a tune - and the other Morris musicians who prefer to learn by ear can play along after a few repeats!
Logged
DDickie

Portsmouth, UK

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #35 on: March 27, 2014, 05:50:05 PM »


I digress, but ..........

I have perfect pitch, so hate transposing instruments.

"Hate", that's a bit harsh. As a Bb and an Eb player, to me, it makes sense to have the same finger names, but with different pitches, rather than learn different fingerings for the concert pitch notes on each instrument; nightmare !  So you feel we should all be relegated to the C-melody ?   ;)

Hate? Yes. Although that should be "Hate to play". I learned clarinet for years and it did my head in. I now have a C clarinet and I've had a c melody sax in the past, although I don't play reeds very often now. I learned cornet a little while back (very badly) and learned the valve positions in concert. As I said, learning two sets of fingerings isn't difficult (C and F saxes), but for a clarinet it's a nightmare, because you actually have to learn 4!
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

Idelone

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 135
  • Now that's what I call a-peeling.
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #36 on: March 27, 2014, 06:43:42 PM »


Hate? Yes. Although that should be "Hate to play". I learned clarinet for years and it did my head in. I now have a C clarinet and I've had a c melody sax in the past, although I don't play reeds very often now. I learned cornet a little while back (very badly) and learned the valve positions in concert. As I said, learning two sets of fingerings isn't difficult (C and F saxes), but for a clarinet it's a nightmare, because you actually have to learn 4!

Well, rather you than me, and I thought I was doing well when I taught myself to transpose on the fly from concert parts. These days I have trouble remembering my name and where I live, without having to think about new fingerings. But like you I find little time to play the saxes now, what with the melodeon, the CBA, and work.   :||:    :|||:    :Ph

Logged

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #37 on: March 27, 2014, 07:01:51 PM »

We're in danger of serious thread drift here, but just to take your comment a bit further...

....I'm not sure why we don't make an A clarinet with the same bore but with fingerwork in different positions such that it plays like a C Basset clarinet mind.
I don't quite follow this.
Mozart's famous concerto was written for a basset clarinet in A; like a normal A clarinet but with an extended lower range to go down to bottom (written) C, sounding A2. Vintage instruments like this exist, but also are being made today; most professional Mozart clarinet specialist players will shell out the dosh to have one made for them. It's most definitely a transposing instrument.

But perhaps you were meaning a soprano C clarinet but with extended bore and keywork to go down to bottom C3; i.e. a third lower than the conventional C clarinet? It would be non-transposing but I don't know of any such instrument ever being made.

Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #38 on: March 27, 2014, 08:08:13 PM »

I don't quite follow this.
Mozart's famous concerto was written for a basset clarinet in A; like a normal A clarinet but with an extended lower range to go down to bottom (written) C, sounding A2. Vintage instruments like this exist, but also are being made today; most professional Mozart clarinet specialist players will shell out the dosh to have one made for them. It's most definitely a transposing instrument.

But perhaps you were meaning a soprano C clarinet but with extended bore and keywork to go down to bottom C3; i.e. a third lower than the conventional C clarinet? It would be non-transposing but I don't know of any such instrument ever being made.

Exactly (:) The sound of a clarinet comes from the bore, a lot of it anyway (disclaimer: not my field). A clarinets sound different to Bb clarinets because they are longer and the way that the bore changes along its length is different. If you took that bore profile and fitted keywork for a C clarinet on it then you would have a C clarinet fingered to low C which would have the range and sound of an A clarinet.

http://www.sfoxclarinets.com/Basset_clarinet.html
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

TomBom

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 471
Re: Are melodeons transposing instruments?
« Reply #39 on: March 28, 2014, 04:37:46 PM »

If it wasn't like that, clarinettists would need to learn different fingerings for every instrument in the family, and since they (orchestral players at least) often need to swap instruments during the course of a piece of music, it would get very confusing and the risk of playing wrong notes would be very high indeed.

Thanks for the explanation!

So how do you players with boxes in different keys manage that? Do you learn by ear?
Do you read music for playing your main box? Or are you able to read  and play from notation with any of your boxes?
Posted before reading the rest of the discussion ... My questions are already answered.

Thomas
« Last Edit: March 28, 2014, 04:41:18 PM by TomBom »
Logged
Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal