Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6   Go Down

Author Topic: Different woods  (Read 23112 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Different woods
« Reply #60 on: September 29, 2014, 01:02:57 PM »

Interesting thread. Ian has summed it up quite well by saying that it isn't the material but how absorbent the surface of the interior of the case is that counts. Although Chris is right to say that if you can feel the case vibrating then *some* energy must be taken out of the sound, which *could* have an impact?

In my opinion, if you have several boxes with a case of a given stiffness then you might be able to tell the difference between plastic and foam, but you certainly wouldn't be able to tell the difference between different kinds of wood. I would like to think that you'd be able to tell the difference between varnished and unvarnished wood. As for varying the stiffness of the case wall, so that it noticeably vibrates then that is something else that I haven't really thought of.

On the subject of playing in, I would also submit that on a very new box, the reed wax is still quite supple and over time it will harden up a bit, drawing the reed tighter on to the block. Also as Ian says some stresses in the reeds will dissipate and the bellows will ease up. The comments on the player being played in as much as the box are perceptive - I think that the playing in phenomenon is more to do with the instrument (box or fiddle) 'settling down'.

And I wish that I knew why Hohner reeds sound so radically different to Italian reeds. I tried to do a Masters degree on that very subject but couldn't get funding :(

An interesting tale about fatigue cracking, if anyone's interested...

Cracks can grow slowly under repeated stress until they reach a critical size caused the Griffith length, which is short (less than a millimetre) for highly stresses brittle materials (like reeds) but long (several meters) for lightly stressed ductile ones (like steel ships). The best documented record of this was a Liberty ship in WWII where the cook came down one morning after a storm to find a crack in the galley floor. He called in the chief engineer who said "Och, that's perfectly safe" (or something similar, presumably being Scottish). Being of a tidy mind, the cook painted a marker and the date at the end of the crack. As the crack slowly grew over the next few days he kept on doing this, marking the date each time.

In the next big storm the ship broke in two and one half sank, but luckily for science the date markers were on the half that stayed afloat, along with the evidence that this crack was what caused the ship to break up...

(Liberty ships were the first rapidly-built all-welded steel ships, and quite a few broke apart and sank like this before the disadvantages of welding vs. rivets as far as stress relief goes were realised -- unwittingly, the cook significantly advanced knowledge about both shipbuilding and materials science)

-- from one of J.E. Gordon's fantastic books on structures and materials, which among other things explain why you can't put a crease in a worm...

Liberty ships also had problems with the steel becoming more and more brittle the further north they went... which also advanced materials science, in my old department!
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: Different woods
« Reply #61 on: September 29, 2014, 02:39:33 PM »

And I wish that I knew why Hohner reeds sound so radically different to Italian reeds. I tried to do a Masters degree on that very subject but couldn't get funding :(
And yet...
I have a nice 1930s Hohner Club I in C/F which has been restored with modern Cagnoni 'macchina'-grade reeds in the treble end. They behave and sound almost exactly like you'd expect of vintage Hohner reeds. I think even experienced listeners/players would have a hard job to tell they were not Hohner reeds. (:)

The same reeds in, say, a Music Room 'Sandpiper' melodeon, sound just like you'd expect Italian reeds to sound.

What's going on? It has to be something to do with the materials/construction of the reed block and casework.
Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Different woods
« Reply #62 on: September 29, 2014, 03:33:53 PM »

True... but when Microbot put some Hohner reeds and blocks in a casta Tommy it sounded very much like a slightly refined Hohner...

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7456.0.html

So it could be the reed/reedblock system which is distinctive... but Hohner used so many different reed block construction techniques...
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Different woods
« Reply #63 on: September 29, 2014, 05:00:24 PM »

My experience is the opposit of your Steve. I have a Hohner Club ll with Italian reeds and the sound is a bit Hohner and a bit Italian.  So while the reeds do have a substantial influence in the sound quality the box they are in does too.  Note I'm carefully avoiding saying it's the wood that makes the difference, it's the whole design of the instrument, I would not pick out one feature of construction as the cause.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Steve C.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2075
  • Erica, Morse Anglo
Re: Different woods
« Reply #64 on: September 29, 2014, 06:30:17 PM »

(this thread, a good one…)
(giving me a flash back to guys nearly coming to blows over Littman Cardiology III's vs. Master Cardiologies…..)
(a lot of what's here has to do with the "observer effect" does it not?)  :Ph
Logged
Located in Central North Carolina, USA; credit for picture: livingplanet.ca

John MacKenzie (Cugiok)

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2360
  • Fettling... Learning to reed and right.
Re: Different woods
« Reply #65 on: September 29, 2014, 08:03:25 PM »

Surely it is the quality of the box, i.e. the wooden box that, along with the bellows, surround the reeds. After all, one of the so called secrets of Strads, was supposed to be the glue that was used to assemble them. Inasmuch as you can hear a cracked bowl, just by tapping it. Surely the better, and closer fitting the joints on your melodeon are, and more it is "of a piece", then the better it will sound. Even if it's made out of old pallets?

Just a theory.


John
Logged
There is no beginning to my talent :)



: Hohner Club Modell 1. Bb/Eb, de-clubbed : Early Hohner Pressed Wood A/D : 1930's Varnished wood G/C:  Hohner Erika C/F: Bandoneon tuned D/G Pressed wood: Koch F/Bb; G/C Pre Corso

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Different woods
« Reply #66 on: September 29, 2014, 10:20:31 PM »

John, I'm sorry that is not a theory, its just speculation based on one of the many myths about Strads.  And in any case comparisons with fiddles are of little relevance because a fiddle produces sound in a completely different way and the wooden parts of a fiddle perform a completely different function from the wooden parts of an accordion.

A bowl, with or without cracks, is different again.  I have certainly seen a good number of boxes with cracks in the wood, or cracks in joints.  It can cause air leaks of course, but it seems to make little difference to the sound.

Sorry to sound negative, but musical instruments are complex things, there are so many variable in the materials and construction that it is almost impossible to reach any useful conclusions by applying everyday common sense arguments.

My take on this is that most of the misunderstanding comes from a lack of distinction between on the one hand actual observations of real instruments, and on the other hand attempting to explain differences we can hear.   I don't think anyone would disagree that not all melodeons sound the same even if tuned in the same way.  So much is uncontroversial.  The problems arise when we try to explain the observed differences by picking on one or other of the differences in construction or materials, such as species of wood, varnished or bare, rough or smooth etc etc.  It simply can't be done.  I've been repairing and tuning boxes for quite a few years now, and I feel I'm just beginning to get a hint of a suggestion of what some of the factors are that influence some of the playing qualities of a box.  There are all sorts of subtle effects at work, dozens, if not hundreds of differences that combine in ways that multiply the possible permutations of acoustic effects.

Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

squeezy

  • Quick starter (now lagging behind)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1317
  • Hohner Cornelia (mixte D/G/o&s)
    • www.johnspiers.co.uk
Re: Different woods
« Reply #67 on: September 29, 2014, 10:54:45 PM »

I love reading all the posts which are all attempting to understand the finer nuances of what makes our instrument sound like it does (with varying degrees of expertise in the field).

I'm sure that there is a fully scientific explanation which could predict exactly what combination of materials assembled together would create precisely the sound and response that is desired.  However, given the huge numbers of variables involved, I'm pretty sure that there is not the huge budget required anywhere that would fund such a thorough investigation of melodeon construction techniques and the effects on sound.

So I think we're left with what we have at present ... the building/repairing/modifying of melodeons is a craft, not a science.  We have to rely on the experience of people who are doing it, in the absence of thorough scientific modelling the experience is all we can really trust - at present all we're really going on is what's proven to work, instinct/gut reaction, and a little experimentation here and there. 

Personally I'm really glad to be at a time where some of the differences between the boxes remain a kind of magic and mystery that most of us can only really speculate on.  It kind of makes them more fun to play (and buy in copious amounts)
Logged
Squeezy

Sometimes wrong, sometimes right ... but always certain!

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: Different woods
« Reply #68 on: September 30, 2014, 02:15:22 AM »


"I'm sure that there is a fully scientific explanation which could predict exactly what combination of materials assembled together would create precisely the sound and response that is desired"

I disagree...

Simple observation.

Three Castagnari Tommy models  all cherry all D/G  .. same construction   reeds etc

All sound different.

"the building/repairing/modifying of melodeons is a craft, not a science"

Which counters the first quote.

However, I will agree and add  A R T .
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Different woods
« Reply #69 on: September 30, 2014, 07:09:21 AM »

Jeff, I agree with that,  why a box sounds a particular way is not amenable to scientific analysis.

 On the other hand we could have a whole new discussion on the differences between craft and art!
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

squeezy

  • Quick starter (now lagging behind)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1317
  • Hohner Cornelia (mixte D/G/o&s)
    • www.johnspiers.co.uk
Re: Different woods
« Reply #70 on: September 30, 2014, 07:26:12 AM »

I disagree...

Simple observation.

Three Castagnari Tommy models  all cherry all D/G  .. same construction   reeds etc

All sound different.

Then we shall have to agree to differ ...

In your example the scientific explanation would lie in a multitude of minute differences in the way the components are assembled.  And I suspect the human race does posess the ability to analyse this, but can't justify the huge cost and resources it would need to analyse.

That is not contradicting the part that says that melodeon making remains a craft while we cannot fully understand and control these minute differences in the make-up of a box.

What I suppose I was saying is that I think makers/repairers deserve the accolade of being called artists and craftsmen rather than being thought of as mere assemblers of parts.  I'm delighted to give them that respect ... However I'm not prepared to believe that the differences are magic or some kind of witchcraft ... There has to be an underlying reason based n physics.
Logged
Squeezy

Sometimes wrong, sometimes right ... but always certain!

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Different woods
« Reply #71 on: September 30, 2014, 07:53:49 AM »

I'd agree with squeezy here.
We can scientifically analyse the way sound is affected ( or not ) by the various things we've discussed.
The reason it's not been analysed is simply we are too much of a niche thing with no inherent commercial value. Yes melodeons cost a lot, but it's a very small industry in terms of global markets of -say - cars or the pharmaceutical industry. If it were of such economical significance then I'm sure we'd have the definitive answers, based on the nature of physics.
Q
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Owen Woods

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3894
  • melodeonmusic.com
    • The website and blog of Owen Woods
Re: Different woods
« Reply #72 on: September 30, 2014, 10:20:19 AM »

I seem to remember writing a blog post on this sort of thing...

http://melodeonmusic.com/2012/07/16/when-thinking-about-instruments/
Logged
Bergflodt D/G 4 voice, Saltarelle Bouebe D/G, Super Preciosa D/Em, Hohner Impiliput B/C+C#

Latest blog post: In Any Weather

http://melodeonmusic.com/blog

blafleur

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 530
Re: Different woods
« Reply #73 on: September 30, 2014, 02:24:27 PM »

I think we can all agree there is a huge number of variables at play, and at least one that the builder cannot control, and that's the variations in handmade reeds.  Even if it was accepted that wood type mattered, there are variations in specific types of wood.  Take cherry, for example.  The tree itself has variations, plus where it was harvested, what part of the tree the wood comes from, drying process, etc.

But I still think that if you made an accordion of cocobolo, and one of pine or some other soft wood, and moved the reeds and reed blocks from one to the other, there would be a tonal change, even if slight.  That being said, I do believe the wood choice is more about durability and aesthetics than sound.  I just don't see any of this being more than our own speculations, though, because, like Theo pointed out, even with scientific testing, how can sound quality be quantified?  It's the ears that matter, and we all have different ones

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Different woods
« Reply #74 on: September 30, 2014, 02:40:33 PM »

Talk of "science" in this context is not really appropriate either.  If anything its engineering.  Science and Engineering are related but have different goals.  Engineering is about making things to do a give task.  Science is about understanding the stuff our world is made of.  Clearly we are in Engineering territory when discussing the design and building of musical instruments.  In many engineering projects there are big uncertanties, which for example lead to the idea of a safety factor in many designs where life and limb are at stake, so bridges and other structures are made of thicker materials than are theoretically necessary because the theory is imperfect and the additional strength provides the safety factor.

An anectdote will illustrate the difference.

A scientist and an engineer each built a bridge.  Unfortunately the one built by the scientist collapsed after a while, but after some investigation the scientist was able to explain why it fell down.  The engineer was not able to explain exactly why the other bridge stayed up.  ;)

But it illustrates the important point that both science and engineering include uncertainty in almost all that they do.  Science is not exact, there is always room for a theory to be disproved and a better one put in it's place. Engineering is not exact either and if an artifact is to function well it needs to be built to allow for those uncertainties. Very much the case with our boxes I think.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Mike Carney

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 701
  • In sunny Sheffield
Re: Different woods
« Reply #75 on: September 30, 2014, 04:20:51 PM »

I think we can all agree there is a huge number of variables at play, and at least one that the builder cannot control, and that's the variations in handmade reeds.  Even if it was accepted that wood type mattered, there are variations in specific types of wood.  Take cherry, for example.  The tree itself has variations, plus where it was harvested, what part of the tree the wood comes from, drying process, etc.

But I still think that if you made an accordion of cocobolo, and one of pine or some other soft wood, and moved the reeds and reed blocks from one to the other, there would be a tonal change, even if slight.  That being said, I do believe the wood choice is more about durability and aesthetics than sound.  I just don't see any of this being more than our own speculations, though, because, like Theo pointed out, even with scientific testing, how can sound quality be quantified?  It's the ears that matter, and we all have different ones
Talking of aesthetics in wood I love the wide range of beautiful woods you show on your website!
M
Logged

boxer

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 380
  • B/C Pokerwork - ultimate ceili box
Re: Different woods
« Reply #76 on: September 30, 2014, 05:47:30 PM »

there's no more chance of a making a reliable analysis of the more subtle influences on sound production in boxes than there is of producing a reliable model of the economy, or the environment, or any other complex system.  Too many degrees of freedom.
Logged
Nuage, Tommy, Cairdin, 
Double Ray DLX 21x12, Black Dot,
Pre-Erica, Pokerwork
plus various stringed things

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Different woods
« Reply #77 on: September 30, 2014, 06:41:28 PM »

Don't think we need a holistic model to settle this perenial argumant about woods. Basically it needs identical blocks (or mini blocks) made in different woods (I'd say especially, different densities) and looked at in the same accoustic environment, which doesn't have to be a full melodeon. Probably needing a FFT to look at harmonics, and a 'scope for phase issues.

Standard science: clamp the multi-parameters and see what happens by varying one. It only fails if there is some complex interaction … eg the block's mass somehow affecting a modulation transfer somewhere else in the instument. But I'd be very surpised were something like that the case here. It does happen in bilogicsl systems as everything feed back into everything else.

I'm interested in blocks because it is … pretty central to the vibration. There may, or may not be an effect from the wood of the instrument itself, but several makers and reparers believe not. Even "by ear" I'm happy to simply accept that.

Yes, should do this myself, put up or shut up, but I don't have the necessary skills, or an oscilloscope.

Another easy experiment for anyone with such kit might be to look at blocks +/- the cross linking metal straps, or similarly swapping in the Z shaped straps that van der Aa thinks improve tone. But I digress; we'll return to this woods thing forever.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

boxer

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 380
  • B/C Pokerwork - ultimate ceili box
Re: Different woods
« Reply #78 on: September 30, 2014, 07:35:43 PM »

of the several boxes I play, the "stand out" different sound is the Nuage's.  I believe it's most to do with the aluminium plate on the soundboard (all the rest are just plywood boards).

I would have thought that some (not all) of the factors that influence tone in single-reed woodwind instruments - centuries of work on things like clarinets must have generated a substantial body of knowledge - might have some bearing on the box.
Logged
Nuage, Tommy, Cairdin, 
Double Ray DLX 21x12, Black Dot,
Pre-Erica, Pokerwork
plus various stringed things

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Different woods
« Reply #79 on: September 30, 2014, 07:45:36 PM »

… as would similar experimentation on banjos ;)
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal