Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: The critique thread  (Read 6731 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

butimba

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 166
  • Oxford, UK
The critique thread
« on: January 27, 2015, 07:04:49 PM »

So… this idea might be a total flop, but I was wondering what everyone thinks about a thread where we can post our own recordings and ask for advice and ideas on how to improve them?

I think that general encouragement and positive feedback are so important – and I love the fact that there are so many generous people on melnet who give this in bucketloads – but I also think that constructive criticism is equally important if you really want to become a better player, and we don’t really have a dedicated space for it on this forum.  I know it can be difficult to say anything critical about someone’s playing when you don’t know if they actually want to hear it... so I thought maybe it would be a good idea to start a thread where people can openly invite constructive feedback on their playing, if they want it.

I think that being critiqued – and critiquing others – is scary but one of the best ways to learn. And of course it’s always useful to hear what you did well, in addition to what you could do better, so we don’t have to skimp on the praise either  ;)

Anyone up for it…?
Logged

Grape Ape

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1209
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #1 on: January 27, 2015, 07:23:29 PM »

Sure!
Logged

robotmay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 820
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #2 on: January 27, 2015, 07:29:39 PM »

I'm always looking for criticique! :D

I often focus on a single tune for a while until I'm happy with it, trying to learn something new whilst doing it, but I suspect forget to pay attention to various other things. If anyone wants to get started then I'll happily offer the recording I made last night up for some critiquing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkFpEi0FCDw
Logged

arty

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1465
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #3 on: January 27, 2015, 08:08:42 PM »

Now this sounds like a really helpful idea!
Logged
Pre-Pokerwork C/F, Castagnari Laura G/C, Beltuna Sara 3 A/D, Castagnari Sander Special D/G

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #4 on: January 27, 2015, 08:18:08 PM »

I will definitely contribute a video to be critiqued, but as a beginner, I won't take part in the critiquing.

I've been at it a week (with a lot of years playing fretted instruments behind me) and would love some critiquing of my technique, sound, and anything anyone can come up with. Here is a far from a clean recording, with plenty of fumbles and mistakes (and I actually had the melody slightly wrong, which I have since fixed):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3abU4NM5V1c

I look forward to following this thread!

Thanks,
Baron
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

robotmay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 820
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #5 on: January 27, 2015, 08:48:16 PM »

I will definitely contribute a video to be critiqued, but as a beginner, I won't take part in the critiquing.

I've been at it a week (with a lot of years playing fretted instruments behind me) and would love some critiquing of my technique, sound, and anything anyone can come up with. Here is a far from a clean recording, with plenty of fumbles and mistakes (and I actually had the melody slightly wrong, which I have since fixed):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3abU4NM5V1c

I look forward to following this thread!

Thanks,
Baron

I've only just noticed that I've been subscribed to your YouTube channel for quite a while for all your excellent mandolin videos ;D

One thing you might find helpful when practising tunes with only the treble end is to lightly depress the air button. With practice you get a better feel for the air button but using it when just playing the right hand actually helps make it a bit easier and will make it easier to keep the box stable on your chest (keeping the right-hand side of the instrument stable is important). It'll make the instrument feel a little more like it does when using the bass end, i.e. it gulps more air!

Also one thing that has helped me a lot most recently is to release and re-strike the button when changing bellows directions on the same button (e.g. going from G to A on the same button). It takes a bit of practice but it's good technique and it'll make the notes sound clearer.

Hope that helps! I look forward to seeing more box videos from you now too :D
Logged

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #6 on: January 27, 2015, 08:56:42 PM »

I will definitely contribute a video to be critiqued, but as a beginner, I won't take part in the critiquing.

I've been at it a week (with a lot of years playing fretted instruments behind me) and would love some critiquing of my technique, sound, and anything anyone can come up with. Here is a far from a clean recording, with plenty of fumbles and mistakes (and I actually had the melody slightly wrong, which I have since fixed):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3abU4NM5V1c

I look forward to following this thread!

Thanks,
Baron

For only one weeks playing that is outstanding, but
  • You should learn to use the air button as part of playing the tune. Currently you are playing a phrase then gulping some air. Look for parts of the tune where there is a run of suck note and operate the air button then.
  • I also notice that you retract your ring finger when not using it, it would be much better to have it above the keyboard.

Keep up the good work  (:)

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #7 on: January 27, 2015, 09:22:23 PM »

I will definitely contribute a video to be critiqued, but as a beginner, I won't take part in the critiquing.

I've been at it a week (with a lot of years playing fretted instruments behind me) and would love some critiquing of my technique, sound, and anything anyone can come up with. Here is a far from a clean recording, with plenty of fumbles and mistakes (and I actually had the melody slightly wrong, which I have since fixed):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3abU4NM5V1c

I look forward to following this thread!

Thanks,
Baron
Excellent progress so far, and I echo what Lester has already commented on!

However - you MUST MUST MUST start to use the left-hand basses and chords NOW. Don't fall into the trap of thinking that you can start to fit them in later, because in my experience of teaching beginners, the longer they have left it, the harder it is to pick up.

Get those hands going together, even if it is only a rudimentary oom-pah bass/chord.

Good stuff so far... well done! But get that LH going and keep it up!  You've paid for all those buttons and reeds so you have to make use of them.  :||:
Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #8 on: January 27, 2015, 09:27:19 PM »

For only one weeks playing that is outstanding, but
  • You should learn to use the air button as part of playing the tune. Currently you are playing a phrase then gulping some air. Look for parts of the tune where there is a run of suck note and operate the air button then.
  • I also notice that you retract your ring finger when not using it, it would be much better to have it above the keyboard.

Thanks Lester, I do notice myself gulping for air (sometimes with my lungs too, which hints that I might be a little tense as well. I am always telling my mandolin students to stay relaxed, and I guess it's time I take a little of my own medicine. Also, thanks for pointing out the ring finger! Is it advisable to keep my fingers lightly resting on the buttons, or is that too much like riding the clutch when driving a car?

I've only just noticed that I've been subscribed to your YouTube channel for quite a while for all your excellent mandolin videos ;D

One thing you might find helpful when practising tunes with only the treble end is to lightly depress the air button. With practice you get a better feel for the air button but using it when just playing the right hand actually helps make it a bit easier and will make it easier to keep the box stable on your chest (keeping the right-hand side of the instrument stable is important). It'll make the instrument feel a little more like it does when using the bass end, i.e. it gulps more air!

Also one thing that has helped me a lot most recently is to release and re-strike the button when changing bellows directions on the same button (e.g. going from G to A on the same button). It takes a bit of practice but it's good technique and it'll make the notes sound clearer.

Hope that helps! I look forward to seeing more box videos from you now too :D

Thanks for the tips robotmay,

I've been doing some cross row stuff as well and definitely can tell there is a lot more air moving through the box when the basses are in play. I should muster up the courage to get the left hand involved on some bouncy tunes soon, before I get to comfortable with the way the instrument operates using only the right hand.

Is the idea of re-striking a button when changing directions standard practice? I can see it would certainly give the tune a little more pop.

I'm glad you've been enjoying the mandolin videos, I enjoy making them. At this point, I am keeping the melodeon videos unlisted to avoid scaring off unsuspecting subscribers, but I am keeping a thread as a learning blog in the Teaching & Learning section, and all the melodeon videos can be found over there.

However - you MUST MUST MUST start to use the left-hand basses and chords NOW. Don't fall into the trap of thinking that you can start to fit them in later, because in my experience of teaching beginners, the longer they have left it, the harder it is to pick up.

Get those hands going together, even if it is only a rudimentary oom-pah bass/chord.

Good stuff so far... well done! But get that LH going and keep it up!  You've paid for all those buttons and reeds so you have to make use of them.  :||:

Thanks Steve, I think what I should do is get a less chordally complicated tune going so I can not feel as intimidated by the left hand. I will get to that!

Thanks for all the help everyone! This place is great!
Baron
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #9 on: January 27, 2015, 09:35:15 PM »

Thanks Lester, I do notice myself gulping for air (sometimes with my lungs too, which hints that I might be a little tense as well. I am always telling my mandolin students to stay relaxed, and I guess it's time I take a little of my own medicine. Also, thanks for pointing out the ring finger! Is it advisable to keep my fingers lightly resting on the buttons, or is that too much like riding the clutch when driving a car?

Re Breathing with the bellows, we all go through that, I still do it when working on a tune that has difficult air management sections. What you are doing with the other fingers is fine, just above the buttons, but your ring finger is getting pulled back into your palm so is just a bit slow being where it needs to be as it has further to travel.

+1 to what Steve said

butimba

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 166
  • Oxford, UK
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #10 on: January 27, 2015, 09:36:01 PM »

Thanks guys for getting things started! I'm hoping over time lots of people will want to contribute to this thread.

I'm always looking for criticique! :D

I often focus on a single tune for a while until I'm happy with it, trying to learn something new whilst doing it, but I suspect forget to pay attention to various other things. If anyone wants to get started then I'll happily offer the recording I made last night up for some critiquing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkFpEi0FCDw

I think this is lovely and you've got a nice strong sense of rhythm. I only have one small suggestion, which is that the little ornamental run in the B part kind of sticks out whenever it comes round (try listening back to your video with your eyes shut and you'll probably notice it). I think you do want to lean on that run (and the note it leads up to) as part of the tune, but perhaps just not quite so much? (One idea: play through the tune a few times without the chords and really listen to the dynamics of each phrase: try to hear if any notes are sticking out more than they should be, or whether you could give each phrase a bit more shape, dynamically speaking.)
Logged

butimba

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 166
  • Oxford, UK
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #11 on: January 27, 2015, 09:45:58 PM »

I will definitely contribute a video to be critiqued, but as a beginner, I won't take part in the critiquing.

I've been at it a week (with a lot of years playing fretted instruments behind me) and would love some critiquing of my technique, sound, and anything anyone can come up with. Here is a far from a clean recording, with plenty of fumbles and mistakes (and I actually had the melody slightly wrong, which I have since fixed):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3abU4NM5V1c

I look forward to following this thread!

Thanks,
Baron

Like others have said, brilliant playing for only a week. Something to think about further down the line: lifting your fingers off the buttons. Not all the time, but just to give the melody a bit of lift/articulation (i.e. so some notes sound staccato, rather than everything sounding legato). (I'm guessing as you play other instruments you know what I'm talking about, but if not then I can try and do a quick video at some point if it would help...)
Logged

robotmay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 820
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #12 on: January 27, 2015, 10:05:16 PM »

Is the idea of re-striking a button when changing directions standard practice? I can see it would certainly give the tune a little more pop.

I believe it is! It's often very subtle, and you might not notice it on a lot of recordings. I think I first learnt about it from John Spiers' tutor DVD.

I think this is lovely and you've got a nice strong sense of rhythm. I only have one small suggestion, which is that the little ornamental run in the B part kind of sticks out whenever it comes round (try listening back to your video with your eyes shut and you'll probably notice it). I think you do want to lean on that run (and the note it leads up to) as part of the tune, but perhaps just not quite so much? (One idea: play through the tune a few times without the chords and really listen to the dynamics of each phrase: try to hear if any notes are sticking out more than they should be, or whether you could give each phrase a bit more shape, dynamically speaking.)

Haha yes I was thinking that myself this morning when I re-listened to it. I started to find it really annoying after about the 9th time I did it, so I definitely think that has to go (at least for most of it!) >:E
I only recently learnt that sort of ornamentation of going from the F# as a grace note to the G on the pull, so I suspect I've been using it too much. I felt far too smart when I figured out that other people were doing that often in place of playing a push G on the start of the second octave. I also don't know if it has a proper name but I've been calling it 'the Sheffield twiddle' for the past few weeks as I picked it up from a few different tunes played by Ollie or Ukebert ;D
Logged

butimba

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 166
  • Oxford, UK
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #13 on: January 27, 2015, 10:22:35 PM »

Haha yes I was thinking that myself this morning when I re-listened to it. I started to find it really annoying after about the 9th time I did it, so I definitely think that has to go (at least for most of it!) >:E
I only recently learnt that sort of ornamentation of going from the F# as a grace note to the G on the pull, so I suspect I've been using it too much. I felt far too smart when I figured out that other people were doing that often in place of playing a push G on the start of the second octave. I also don't know if it has a proper name but I've been calling it 'the Sheffield twiddle' for the past few weeks as I picked it up from a few different tunes played by Ollie or Ukebert ;D

It's taken me a while to realise that one of the marks of a good musician is that they can play clever stuff without it sounding clever, in that it doesn't stand out but just adds to the overall effect of the music... I reckon the ornamentation works and you should mostly keep it in, but just work on making it stand out less.  (:)
Logged

Rob2Hook

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2278
  • Castagnaris, Hohners & Baffetti
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #14 on: January 28, 2015, 01:14:38 AM »

I was most impressed with your rythm and the use of bellows dynamics so early in your learning.  There are many seasoned players who would never think to continue the synchopation through a held note by pulsing the second beat.  Your phrasing is very good, showing all you've learnt on other instruments, obviously the mandoline has helped a lot in developing your  ability to interpret a melody way beyond what is written in a manuscript.

There are frequent arguments about the pros and cons of playing along the row as you were doing here or cross rowing to minimise the changes of bellows direction.  With such good progress so far, don't consider it as learnt yet - try to add the bass accompaniment before it becomes too fixed in the muscle memory as you may have to change some of the fingering to get the accompaniment you want.  Typically you may find that the faster runs of a tune can be cross rowed in whichever direction gives you the bass and chord you want.

Using the air button unobtusively does take some time as at first it seems to be an on/off affair, whereas it can be stroked to admit or expell a little air whilst playing.  Happily you are playing a box which has impeccable manners and will undoubtedly take you as far as you want to get in your playing.  Keep up the good work.

Rob.

Logged

forrest

  • Other Places::
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1009
  • digits still functioning
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #15 on: January 28, 2015, 01:25:55 AM »


It's taken me a while to realise that one of the marks of a good musician is that they can play clever stuff without it sounding clever, in that it doesn't stand out but just adds to the overall effect of the music... I reckon the ornamentation works and you should mostly keep it in, but just work on making it stand out less.  (:)

 It's also helpful for adding interest to not overdo the ornaments, but save the choice ones and use them sparingly. Same with phrasing...always a good idea to shift it a bit, drop a note, add a bit of syncopation, so that one is not mechanically repeating the same litany of tones. I see myself tripping over this many times.
Logged

Grape Ape

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1209
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #16 on: January 28, 2015, 03:46:29 AM »

Not qualified to critique as new to music having spent the better part of my life as a drummer, and only playing the melodeon for just shy of 3 yrs. By playing I mean practicing when I can between 50 hour work weeks and a two and a half year old.  That said, Butimba I really liked your playing and found it quite catchy, though it is true I can hear basses and chords in my head that I probably could not play myself.  Robot May, I have no idea what everyone else is talking about and quite enjoyed your piece as well, as I do all of your recordings.  Do not mistake my kind words for a plea on my own behalf for what I am about to post. I too am seeking constructive criticism to make me better rather than compliments or encouragement.  I am self taught as there is not to my knowledge another in Ohio trying to play French repretoire plus originals on a diatonic accordion.  I may be wrong, but if so, they have yet to reveal themself.

Here we go, and please don't hesitate to check out and have your say on my other videos, which up until now have been greeted mostly with silence on this site. Feel like I am about to dive into a swimming pool wearing a swim suit with a loose tie....

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=JXJadzdhGLw
Logged

Lyra

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 558
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #17 on: January 28, 2015, 08:15:29 AM »

Feel like I am about to dive into a swimming pool wearing a swim suit with a loose tie....
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=JXJadzdhGLw
Oh please, this is melnet - you'll be discreetly handed a towel and a range of helpful advice on which knots to choose and the best way to tie them in future.  >:E
Logged

Graham Spencer

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3548
  • MAD as a wet Hohner........
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #18 on: January 28, 2015, 08:39:25 AM »

Is the idea of re-striking a button when changing directions standard practice?

I don't know if there's such a thing as "standard practice"!  I know some players do advocate lifting, but it's something I've never done - at least not consciously.  There was a thread on this very topic some time back; I think it might have been titled something like "To lift or not to lift".  Might be worth a search.

Excellent playing for such a short time - I totally agree with Steve about left hand and air-button.

Graham
Logged
Among others, Saltarelle Pastourelle II D/G; Hohner 4-stop 1-rows in C & G; assorted Hohners; 3-voice German (?) G/C of uncertain parentage; lovely little Hlavacek 1-row Heligonka; Bâ™­/Eâ™­ Koch. Newly acquired G/C Hohner Viktoria. Also Fender Jazz bass, Telecaster, Stratocaster, Epiphone Sheraton, Charvel-Jackson 00-style acoustic guitar, Danelectro 12-string and other stuff..........

Squeezing in the Cyprus sunshine

Sebastian

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1056
Re: The critique thread
« Reply #19 on: January 28, 2015, 10:40:35 AM »

Here we go, and please don't hesitate to check out and have your say on my other videos, which up until now have been greeted mostly with silence on this site. Feel like I am about to dive into a swimming pool wearing a swim suit with a loose tie....

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=JXJadzdhGLw
I am by no means entitled to criticise the playing of others. What I would criticise in the playing of others are mostly things I am annoyed of in my own playing.

To my liking the notes don't have enogh 'attack' in the beginning, right after the button is pressed down (as if they would not have enough air in the beginning), especially when played together with a chord on the left hand side. You may want to compare these three other recordings (which, I'm sure, you already did). Especially the first one, which is played with a similarily dry discant.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqFHYcxxEfs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k9hzog0z6qk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O_IORcDkM4M

Also, your scale run on 1:25 and 2:25 don't sound convincing to me, but to .

I would like to read other opinions, particularly dissenting ones. (:)
Logged
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal