Hi Charlie
Among my B/C boxes is a Black Dot Deluxe with 12 stradella basses - F, C, G, D, A and E. The chords have no thirds.
I chiefly play Irish dance tunes on this and several other B/Cs which mostly have "modern Irish" melodeon bass arrangements.
When I got hold of the black dot I thought that the basses would be far more useful and indeed they are, when I play English tunes. For Irish tunes they're not significantly better than melodeon basses.
This may be in part (or whole) due to my lack of skill, but I think it has a lot to do with the extent to which the bass buttons - melodeon or stradella - rob the bellows of air, usually at a point at which it's needed to stress notes on the right hand side.
I don't try to play Irish with the full bass accompaniment of the English style, and although I endeavour to tap the bass keys as lightly and crisply as possible, the tunes just don't work as well as they do without bass.
I think the problem is down to my right hand style. I've spent a decade trying hard to inject a more driving rhythmic pulse into the melody, so my right hand style is focused on hitting the notes I want to stress really hard. I don't often use the basses. My right hand drives the tune and keeps time.
When I played English tunes on D/G (some years ago now) the reverse was true - the left hand bass patterns drove the rhythm of the melody. I used to find it difficult to keep a melody in time without a full bass accompaniment.
So, my suggestion is this: if you want to play English style on B/C, a stradella bass setup like the one on my Black Dot (or even a 16 bass, the same 12, but adding Bb at the bottom and B at the top) might be worth the trouble and expense. I think George Garside may have things to say.
If you're going to play Irish style, 8 melodeon basses in "modern Irish" are probably sufficient.
That's been my experience. I'm sure that others will think differently, and I'm sure they'll be right as well. No two players do it the same way, so in the end the only way to find out what's best for you is to try everything.
But it can be expensive.
Good luck