Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Down

Author Topic: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)  (Read 10661 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« on: February 23, 2015, 06:58:06 PM »

To keep myself occupied while taking breaks from playing my box, I have been working on a new layout that I plan to transition to slowly, starting with doing a dutch reversal to my current box, and once I have more experience with that change and the box in general, starting to move towards something a little farther out. This layout probably won't appeal to some (most?), but I feel like it balances my interests nicely. If anyone has thoughts or comments on the layout, I'd love to hear them!

I want to get in to the theory behind my layout while maintaining some initial brevity, and I apologize in advance if this gets long winded. ***Yup, it got long. Feel free to run while you still can***

My goal was to maintain the structure of a two row diatonic box with a full row of accidentals. I listen to and am drawn to that kind of music, and have never been drawn to a PA, CBA, or semitone box. I want to be able to watch what quint box players are doing and have most of the mechanics match up on my layout. As some of you may know, I currently have a Bob Ellis layout D/G/Acc and it accomplishes entirely what I want it to at this point in my learning of the instrument. The only thing I am going to change is to do a dutch reversal, even though I already have D and E reversals on the third row. This will allow for different accidentals and reversals further down the line, though not on the instrument I currently have. If my initial trials with the dutch reversal work well, I can imagine this layout and my needs meshing nicely with a Big 18.

The way that Bob has set up the low octave of his layout, when playing in G it makes the most sense to jump down to the D row for D push and E pull, and then finish the scale back on the G row. The dutch reversal would continue this theme in the middle octave. By making the redundant D push on the G row in the lower octave an E push, it implies a dutch reversal. I decided to do the same thing in the high octave as well. What I ended up with was lots of extra space on the accidental row and at the same two row conclusion as ukebert's D/Em box (more info here: http://melodeonmusic.com/2012/02/18/inside-and-out-part-1-the-super-preciosa/)

My musical interests lead me away from the highest range of the instrument, and I decided to make the layout a fifth button start, leaving more room for reversals in the low octave and still going as high as E6, still higher than I have much use for. This left me with still more space on the toe end of the box, leading me to what I see as an extended third row, boxed out in red on the layout diagram. This leaves me with a layout that really leaves Bob's D row layout untouched, changes 4 notes on the G row (2 of them being the dutch reversal) and chopping of some of the highest notes.

Here is a quick in-progress Pros/Cons list, which I understand is totally subjective as everyone has different wants/needs in their layout. Many of these have to do with being able to cross row, but it is also just as able to play on the row in D, almost as able to play on the row in G, and allows for push/pull patterns in F, C, A, and E as well.

Right Hand Pros:
F major scale push C3 to E6 and both directions C4 to A5
C major scale in both directions E3 to D6 and Push C3 to E6
G major scale in both directions E3 to D6 and Push C3 to E6
D major scale in both directions E3 to D6 and Push D3 to E6
A major scale pull E3 to D6
E major scale pull E3 to D6
Fully chromatic from E3 to D6
Fully Chromatic on the pull from B3 to A5
Acc row repeats its pattern every 4 buttons
  • F always unisonoric
  • then Bb/G#
  • then C/(variable)
  • then C#/Eb
  • then back to unisonoric F button
Acc row ascends consecutively on push and ascends consecutively on pull
Acc row buttons are consistently either unisonoric or push/pull differs by a major second

Right Hand Cons:
Bb push only (except for Bb4)
Eb & G# pull only
Accidental row jumps out of sync with G row by one button starting with F4
Probably really confusing to everyone but me except for D row, and 5th button start at that!
Highest note is a perfect fifth lower than a normal 23 button D/G
No C3 or D3 reversals
No Eb3, C#3 or Eb6

I am still working out the bass end, but am fairly happy where it stands. Chords probably won't have thirds, but if they do, everything would be major except B and E, which would be minor.

Again, if anyone has thoughts on any of this, I'd love to hear about it. Again, it may not be any one else's cup of tea, but I am fascinated with this stuff and would love to hear how other people have approached Quint/Accidental boxes. I have had a blast reading the ones discussed here on the forum in the past).

Thanks,
Baron
« Last Edit: February 25, 2016, 05:56:58 PM by Baron Collins-Hill »
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #1 on: February 24, 2015, 09:00:57 AM »

Looking good! Here's a new layout I'm working on for the 18 bass G/C Van der Aa I recently acquired; hopefully before too long, it will be Theo'd into something like this. This is a fairly radical make over from where it currently is, but my view is that I'm looking to have an instrument that will be geared to my playing, and have no intention of selling it on, so we might as well have it right!

The attached file is in D/G format (since that's what I understand) - the real thing will be transposed to G/C.

This is a unisonoric bass layout (mostly); to be honest, I'm getting to the stage where I'm lost on a 12/18 bass box without it. I can play an 8 bass ok, but when 12 basses are added, mystically my playing goes to pot. Interesting things to note:

- The Van der Aa is a 11/10/9 treble, so a bit smaller than yours. There's no room for accidentals on the right.
- Accidental push notes are C, Eb and Bb, and repeat every 3 buttons. This keeps the accidental always in the same position as the rest of the keyboard, all the way up through the octaves. To allow that, I've sacrificed E and F which could also quite reasonably have appeared on the push.
- Accidental pull notes are F, G#, Bb and D, and repeat every 4 buttons. Again, this keeps the accidental always in the same position as the rest of the keyboard. I've sacrificed Eb which could quite reasonably have been on the pull; something's got to go if you don't have a dutch reversal (which would have meant I wouldn't need D on the accidental row). Dutch reversal (flipping the D/E note) is a step too far for me.
- Eb needs to be on the push for me to fit with tunes that need B major chords (the thirds on the basses are removable).
- There is no G# bass... at all. My view is the unisonoric F# is more useful; you need F# on the push for fitting in as a jumping chord when playing in D, but you need it on the pull for playing in B minor. It's also good for F# blues scale on the pull, not that I've done much of that.
- I considered a bass note only arrangement for a couple of buttons like yours, but I think that probably requires quite a bit of woodwork on the basses on a box that's already built, quite apart from making sure it works sensibly with the low reed and thirds stops. A step too far for this instrument I think.
- Anahata/G-Scale low end on the keyboard. I don't need accidentals down there, and this seems the most efficient use of the low notes.
- The highest accidental on the push is deliberately an E; if I followed the pattern, it would be a high Bb, which would be pretty useless. Better to have something more useful I think, even though there isn't a push E5.

I've tried the treble layout on my Streb (which I can now program keyboard layouts into), and it's pretty good I have to say. If you're looking for a semitone ornament on a given note, typically the accidental is in the right area, and usually in the right direction. It handles Gm and Dm reasonably, if not brilliantly, but has pretty much everything you could possibly want in the home keys.

So that's my plan... good luck with yours, but remember that layout is influenced by what you want to play which is why there are so many different systems. For me, the unisonoric sound is important, and the fact I have a unisonoric bass means I can make different choices about which direction the various accidentals go in.

Cheers,

Clive

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #2 on: February 24, 2015, 12:16:43 PM »

Again, if anyone has thoughts on any of this, I'd love to hear about it...

Actually... now I look at your design, I noticed you've got a 5th button start *and* accidentals on your rightmost slot. I think you've lost 2 sets of useful buttons off the top as a result. I think the F#/C and A/E buttons on the D row and their equivalents on the G row are pretty much essential for playing in the upper octave; I really wouldn't chop them, even if you want to steer clear of upper octave stuff - you are pretty much crippling half the instrument. Personally I'd start 4th button, and not have the rightmost accidentals, building the ones you need into the inner row instead.

Cheers,

Clive

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #3 on: February 24, 2015, 01:22:22 PM »

I think you need to be able to play (button wise) over 2 octaves in your main keys D G C Em Am Bb - though that does make more sense on the better voiced GC. It works well enough on D/G aided and abetted by 1. 4th start and 2. ML voicing.

eg my 11/10/9 layout plays over a useful 2.5 octaves in A minor modes (rising to D) same in Em (falling to B) both extendable by a couple of notes by switching to push at the limits. That also means you get ALL 4 voicings of the associated chords, nicely in the middle of the instrument. 

I also really enjoy all 12 basses both ways (see other thread) - yet it remains playable as a bog standard GD 2-row :|glug


Rodec:
push        ©  ºD    ©   ÂºG    ©  ºBâ™­
→ →→→   Â©  ºB    ©   ÂºC    ©  ºF♯
→ →→→  ºE  ºC♯  ºAâ™­ ºA  ºEâ™­  ºF    [error corrected]
-
→→   Â¹E  ºG   Â¹B    ¹G   Â²B    ²D    ²G    ³B   Â³D
→    ²C  ºF♯  ¹A    D   Â¹F♯  ²A    ²D   Â²F♯   Â³A   Â³D
    ¹C  ºF  ºAâ™­ ¹C♯  ¹F   Â¹Aâ™­  ²C♯  ²F   Â²Aâ™­  ³C♯   Â³F
=

pull          ©  ºA    ©   ÂºD   Â©  ºBâ™­
→ →→→   Â©  ºB    ©   ÂºC   Â©  ºEâ™­
→ →→→  ºE  ºC♯ ºAâ™­ ºG   ÂºF♯  ºF   [error corrected]
-
→→     Â¹D  ¹A  ¹F♯  ²A   Â²C   Â²E   Â²F♯   Â³A   Â³C
→      ²Ab  ¹B  ¹C♯  ¹E   Â¹G   Â²B   Â²C♯   Â²E  ²G   Â³B
     ÂºG  ¹Bâ™­ ¹C ¹Eâ™­ ¹F  ²Bâ™­ ²D  ²Eâ™­ ²F   Â³Bâ™­  ³D 
« Last Edit: February 27, 2015, 03:49:44 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #4 on: February 24, 2015, 01:26:31 PM »

Baron, this looks interesting, and I was struck particularly by your idea that the Dutch reversal permits additional notes on the acc row - obvious really, but I hadn't seen it in those terms, which fits the D/G/Acc cross-row concept well, I think.

It seems to me that D/G/Acc big-bass-end players are going down several different paths at the moment, and it's going to be interesting to see in due course what comes out of it.  I liked your explanation of the D/G/Acc philosophy, and I think you have a point.  I've recently been looking at the Atzarin layout, and one thing that has struck me about D/G/Acc is that the learning process is progressive, whereas with other complex but probably more logical layouts, the initial learning period is somewhat steeper and more daunting, perhaps explaining why there are a lot of 'diatos' about.  However, this is all about 'horses for courses', and any development ideas are to be applauded, to allow players to explore their potential.

Logged

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #5 on: February 24, 2015, 02:36:12 PM »

Right Hand Thoughts:


Rodec:
push        ©  ºD    ©   ÂºG   Â©  ºBâ™­
→ →→→   Â©  ºB    ©   ÂºC    ©  ºF♯
→ →→→  ºE  ºC♯  ºAâ™­ ºB  ºEâ™­  ºF
-
→→   Â¹E  ºG   Â¹B    ¹G   Â²B    ²D    ²G    ³B   Â³D
→    ²C  ºF♯  ¹A    D   Â¹F♯  ²A    ²D   Â²F♯   Â³A   Â³D
    ¹C  ºF  ºAâ™­ ¹C♯  ¹F   Â¹Aâ™­  ²C♯  ²F   Â²Aâ™­  ³C♯   Â³F
=

pull          ©  ºA    ©   ÂºD   Â©  ºBâ™­
→ →→→   Â©  ºB    ©   ÂºC   Â©  ºEâ™­
→ →→→  ºE  ºC♯ ºAâ™­ ºG   ÂºF♯  ºF
-
→→    ¹D  ¹A  ¹F♯  ²A   Â²C   Â²E   Â²F♯   Â³A   Â³C
→      ²C  ¹B  ¹C♯  ¹E   Â¹G   Â²B   Â²C♯   Â²E   Â²G   Â³B
     ÂºG  ¹Bâ™­ ¹C ¹Eâ™­ ¹F  ²Bâ™­ ²D  ²Eâ™­ ²F♯  ³Bâ™­  ³D 


I can't make sense of this sort of layout image quickly (too much time looking at the melnet layout section :o), but will keep an eye on it and slowly digest it. Is that a redundant B push in the bass on the inside row though?

I think you need to be able to play (button wise) over 2 octaves in your main keys D G C Em Am Bb - though that does make more sense on the better voiced GC. It works well enough on D/G aided and abetted by 1. 4th start and 2. ML voicing.

Actually... now I look at your design, I noticed you've got a 5th button start *and* accidentals on your rightmost slot. I think you've lost 2 sets of useful buttons off the top as a result.

I agree. Part of my scheme here was to create a G/C pitched box in D/G. I've got the range (C3 to E6) of A G/C box, and if you look at it as a really far out 3rd button start instrument, you are starting out a half step below G and C (F# on the "D" row and B on the "G" row). I would much rather have the lower octave then the highest notes, and MM is the sound for me. Not everyone's cup of tea, but that is what my ear prefers.

Another goal of my layout, and again it probably isn't what many folks would opt for, is to to play *reasonably* comfortably in different keys. F, C, G, D, and A major and their modes are the main 5 that show up in my musical world, with the occasional Bb major or E major. Chromaticism is an added bonus, but I'm more interested in fluency, opportunity, and flexibility within those keys, hence the focus on reversals across the range of the instrument. It would be much easier to have two boxes to accomplish this, but that would defeat the purpose (my purpose anyway) of designing a box with a full third row.

In terms of repertoire, my main focus is the melodies played by fiddlers (G3 to E6, and more reasonably C#6) I've yet to find a folk melody that goes higher. When playing in Irish and Quebecois sessions, I really like to play melodies down the octave, even if it earns me some funny looks. I also tend towards playing harmonies below the melody rather than above when harmonies are acceptable (smaller groups with friends rather than public Irish sessions). All of this leads me towards the lower register.

I briefly toyed with the idea of starting the standard D scale pattern in the low octave, making the box a tenor ranged 2nd button start box, but things get too spread out up top, and it looses some of what is important to me in the middle octave.

Also, by focusing on reversals across the octaves, when accidentals are needed and the playing needs to be smooth, I can (again, with lots of practice) line up my phrase in advance to reduce bellows direction changes before, through, and after the accidental. An example would be, if i need a low Bb, in the middle of a phrase in the key of F without changing directions, it has to be a push, so I can line up F, G, A, Bb, C, etc. all on the push. If it needs to be a low G# in the key of A (a neccessary pull), I can pull a E, F#, G#, A , B line.

Well, thats a lot of early morning brain gymnastics. Thanks for all the thoughts everyone, this is great fun!
Baron
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #6 on: February 24, 2015, 02:58:17 PM »

Left Hand Thoughts:

I also really enjoy all 12 basses both ways (see other thread) - yet it remains playable as a bog standard GD 2-row :|glug

This is a unisonoric bass layout (mostly); to be honest, I'm getting to the stage where I'm lost on a 12/18 bass box without it. I can play an 8 bass ok, but when 12 basses are added, mystically my playing goes to pot. Interesting things to note:

- I considered a bass note only arrangement for a couple of buttons like yours, but I think that probably requires quite a bit of woodwork on the basses on a box that's already built, quite apart from making sure it works sensibly with the low reed and thirds stops. A step too far for this instrument I think.

For me, the unisonoric sound is important, and the fact I have a unisonoric bass means I can make different choices about which direction the various accidentals go in.

As I mentioned in my first post, I've thought much less about my left hand. A few of the interests of my right hand layout were required to cross over though.

F, C, G, D, and A major I, IV, V chords (so Bb to E, and Eb to B to accomidate Bb and E major would be nice) need to have reversals and be located near each other so I'm not flailing around to play simple I, IV, V progressions. Chromaticity is second to that, but still nice if possible. I don't even know how many builders will do the bass-only thing, so I have some backup plans too.

I did do a little bit of thinking about a (mostly) unisonoric bass end, but for some reason steered away from it. I am going to continue to try different ideas out, and it may be that I end up back there.

One thing I don't like about this layout it that it moves the key of F to the hardest to reach corner. What it allows for is having Push A and Pull G a little closer to home though.

I am attaching my other bass layout idea, which brings F back to the out rows and puts the A/G button on the inner row in a fairly easy to get to position. It puts my bass only section in the inconvenient corner though, and further away from their neighbors at that.

Thanks,
Baron
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #7 on: February 24, 2015, 03:26:08 PM »

System Thoughts

Here's a little bit more on why I am sticking with D/G/Acc even though I want the flexibility to play in more keys.

One big reason is that there are more quint box players to watch, and I like being able to emulate the way their layouts work and the sounds they produce in the home keys. My system is attempting to keep the push/pull bounce of on the row playing available including where the pushes and pull land in terms of scale degree. Getting out of the home keys, you inevitably run in to limitations there (Bb push only in F major being one example). It is a little funny because I am going to have to consciously develop scale patterns that stick to the in/out bounce feel, even though I have really smooth options available to me.

I haven't looked in depth at the Atzarin layout, but at first glance it does seem to have a lot going for it, mainly the ability to play push/pull, push, and pull. What it seems to lack for me is the melodeon roots that initially drew me to the instrument. I will have to re read the thread on this system and give it some more thought. Looking at it, it seems a little strange that a lot of ascending scales involve a pattern that takes you closer to the chin end and then a bigger jump towards the toe. Perhaps a modified system would make the progression more linear? Also, once you got used to it it probably wouldn't matter.

B/C/C# seems to be a whole different animal, and it does have the ability to play in all keys with fewer fingering patterns. It does lack D and A on the push and a more limited palate for smooth playing however. Also, at some point I saw a list of what scale patterns were required for playing in all keys, and while the number was something like 5 patterns, the 5 patterns seemed to be for F, C, G, D, and A, which are the keys I am most interested in playing in, which diminishes the pro's for me somewhat. Again, I'm sure that spending time with the system would make it seem more logical.

The Loomes Chromatic runs in to the same disconnect for me as the other two. It looks great for bouncy playing but suffers in the cross row playing. The unisonoric bass end of these instruments would certainly smooth the playing though. I also haven't had my musical world blown apart (in a good way) by anyone playing these systems like I have with a quint based player. That's not to say they aren't out there, I just haven't found them yet.

Thanks,
Baron
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Atzarin

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
    • Atzarin - new keyboard layout for bisonoric bellows instruments.
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #8 on: February 24, 2015, 05:27:41 PM »

System Thoughts

I haven't looked in depth at the Atzarin layout, but at first glance it does seem to have a lot going for it, mainly the ability to play push/pull, push, and pull. What it seems to lack for me is the melodeon roots that initially drew me to the instrument. I will have to re read the thread on this system and give it some more thought. Looking at it, it seems a little strange that a lot of ascending scales involve a pattern that takes you closer to the chin end and then a bigger jump towards the toe. Perhaps a modified system would make the progression more linear? Also, once you got used to it it probably wouldn't matter.


The Atzarin fingering style is rooted firmly in Trikitixa cross rowing, but inverted to make it more ergonomic. When playing a scale cross rows on your D/G/acc layout starting push D, outer row button 5 then pull E on the same button, F# inner row button 4, you are also moving up closer to the chin end before "jumping" down to pull G on the outer row, up to pull A inner row, down to B outer row etc. On Atzarin the movement upwards seems greater because you move onto the third row. Like wise the "jump" is also bigger.

Also notice that the melodeon zig-zag for scale patterns crossing rows moves from outer to inner row. If you are pressing a pull E on the outer row with your middle finger, when you play pull F# on the inner row with your index finger, your middle fingers curls bringing the nail onto the button. The index finger has less reach, so it is more ergonomic to invert the direction of the zig-zag so that you move from inner to outer rows with the index finger staying on rows below the middle finger. That is what Atzarin does.

Atzarin uses this ergonomic concept in the 3 scale patterns required to play any major scale in all 12 keys and simply develops the cross row style from 2 to 3 rows.

A clearer explanation can be found on page two of this thread:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12692.msg156350.html#msg156350

By the way, does any Loomes Chromatic actually exist or is it just an idea? Has one actually been built yet?
« Last Edit: February 24, 2015, 05:30:04 PM by Atzarin »
Logged
Sebastian Brown Apraiz

www.atzarin.com

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #9 on: February 24, 2015, 05:44:54 PM »

1. Errors corrected - sorry - was in a rush and son mithering me!
2. Layout (as corrected) played nicely in Cmaj, Cmin, Bb/Gm, F/Dm D/Em/Eblues G/Am/Ablues all last week.

3. With respect to left end you need to analyse carefully how your right end scales run. eg on mine Bb & modes (own songs, accompany others in Gm, flat out Bb blues) is all on pull. This underlies (strongly) the stack of Bb/Eb/F running on pull down the left end extras. In this I find I need chords IV=Eb and F=V(especially!) in the same direction. The tonic I=Bb chord less so - I often just use the pull bass against right end chord or phrase. That because tonic is a chord of complete relaxation in its own key.

4. Crossovers The pull D and C chords get used a lot against those three Bb main basses and vice versa to get sus, and minor 7 chording.

5. When your scale is all pull I find I need at least one chord RH/LH for closing those bellows, ideally tonic or turnaround dominant V as these happen naturally at start/end of musical measures.

6. All of this appies to playing in F and C too - I use the 2-way C to lose air in the first case, and have right end G chords both ways when in C

Hope this helps
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #10 on: February 24, 2015, 10:35:49 PM »

Just finished plugging in my layout to Chord Finder. I'm still getting used to looking at two different views for the push and pull, but I am having fun poking at the buttons anyway  :||:

Here's the editor code if anyone else wants to plug it in

→ push↓ → ©  ºD  ©  ºG  ©  ºF
→→→→ →→ ©  ºB  ©  ºC  ©  ºBâ™­
→→→→ →→ ©  ºE  ©  ºA  ºF♯  ºC♯
→→ ºF  ¹Bâ™­  ¹C  ¹C♯  ¹F  ²Bâ™­  ²C  ²C♯  ²F  ³Bâ™­
→ ºE  ºG  ¹B  ¹E  ¹G  ²B  ²E  ²G  ³B  ³E  ³C
ºC ºD ºF♯  ¹A  ¹D  ¹F♯  ²A  ²D ²F♯  ³A  ³D  ³C♯
=
→ pull↓ → ©  ºA  ©  ºD  ©  ºF
→→→→ →→ ©  ºE  ©  ºC  ©  ºBâ™­
→→→→ →→ ©  ºB  ©  ºG  ºG♯  ºEâ™­
→→ ºF  ¹G♯  ¹D  ¹Eâ™­  ¹F  ²G♯  ²Bâ™­  ²Eâ™­  ²F  ³G♯
→ ºF♯ ¹A ¹C  ¹F♯ ²A  ²C  ²D  ²F♯ ³A  ³C  ³D
ºG ºE ¹B  ¹C♯ ¹E  ¹G  ²B  ²C♯ ²E  ²G  ³B  ³C♯
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #11 on: February 25, 2015, 09:36:54 AM »

that should do the job.  This thread is doing a lot to convince me of the merits of unisonorics for "off piste" chord support. In practice in Bb the only left ender that I "rock" on is Bb/F bass
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #12 on: February 25, 2015, 10:01:11 AM »

Yes, I've been recently thinking some of the benefits through, too, for a different reason.  I confess I haven't studied the details of Baron's layout as closely as it merits, I'm looking at underlying principles.

However, the question I'd pose to users of unisonoric layouts is this:  Is there any good reason (other than one's past experience, which is a perfectly valid reason IMO) why you should then have a 'quint diato-based' RHS? 

(The reason I ask is because I'm looking at this the other way round - a traditional bisonoric LHS, with an Atzarin RHS, of which more later.)

One reason that might be thought by many players to be relevant is because you want the 'bounce' associated with bellows reversals, and I've strongly supported the benefits of this elsewhere.  However, I do also recognise a diato layout (be it RHS or LHS) is not the only way of achieving that aim.  For example, if you had a system with unisonoric LHS and bisonoric RHS (fully chromatic in both directions), you could in theory learn fingering that allowed you to waggle the bellows about as often as you want.  And it may be that in the past the only reason that hasn't been done is that the LHS's are usually too heavy and not designed to be reversed frequently.  I remember many years ago listening to the player of a small PA, who managed to do just this, and a very effective dance musician he was too.

[[[ oops, sorry Chris, accidentally modified your message instead of replying; I've put it back :-) -- Clive ]]]
« Last Edit: February 25, 2015, 10:32:41 AM by Clive Williams »
Logged

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #13 on: February 25, 2015, 10:47:10 AM »

Quote
However, the question I'd pose to users of unisonoric layouts is this:  Is there any good reason (other than one's past experience, which is a perfectly valid reason IMO) why you should then have a 'quint diato-based' RHS? 

Partly because I'm one of those people who finds a melodeon layout far more intuitive than anything else, and have done since I started playing. Took only a day or two to make decent music on a melodeon, much to my surprise. Guitar/piano/CBA took far longer, and I *never* got the hang of guitar. Other people of course play a guitar or piano easily, but the melodeon is a mystery to them.

... and partly because the melodeon treble layout lends itself to, and indeed implies, dynamic punch and range - if adding that to a tune, I do it by thinking about what I want to do to the melody, not the bass. The bass happens to join in as a happy byproduct. A CBA doesn't do that as well as a melodeon in my experience; it's nice, and does other stuff, but if you get music with drive or pulse to it out of a CBA it's in spite of the instrument, rather than because of it.

I don't actually think whether a bass end is unisonoric on a melodeon or not influences the bounciness/dynamic abilities of an instrument much at all, but it is far easier for me to play, which means I can expend more effort on the treble than I'd otherwise have available.

It also does neato drony/chord effects too.

Cheers,

Clive

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #14 on: February 25, 2015, 11:32:26 AM »

Quote
I'm one of those people who finds a melodeon layout far more intuitive than anything else

Yes, on long reflection, I do think there's something to be said for this view - it puts all the usual notes in the key within easy reach.  But someone recently pointed out to me that the word 'intuitive' depends on where one has come from, and what one has learnt.  Logically, surely a piano keyboard is much more 'intuitive'?

[quote if you get music with drive or pulse to it out of a CBA it's in spite of the instrument, rather than because of it.
][/quote]

Not challenging this at all, partly because I don't really understand them anyway, but why should it be so, do you believe?
« Last Edit: February 25, 2015, 11:34:51 AM by Chris Brimley »
Logged

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #15 on: February 25, 2015, 11:55:44 AM »

Well, I can only go from what I've experienced, and I don't truly know!  I think the act of changing bellows direction implies a change in velocity of bellows and sound and it's easier to do that as different muscle movement (push then pull) than to try to do it on the same muscle movement (e.g. push then push).

Which is why it's so difficult to play like Mr Cutting et al; cross rows ==> same bellows direction ==> same muscle movement ==> hard to add dynamics. I believe if you watch Andy *really* closely, you'll see that rhythmic pulse in his playing comes from a *downward* pulse as he moves the bellows outwards, not a sideways one - so, so perhaps that's how he gets round it. Rather harder to do that on a 96 bass CBA!

I'm sure there are some marvellous piano and CBA players around that do great dynamic stuff, but I think they use different (and harder) techniques than us melodeon players use.

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #16 on: February 25, 2015, 01:17:32 PM »

Ah, that wasn't quite my point - I'm saying that you can still reverse bellows on a unisonoric system, or on one where the same chords and notes are available on push or pull.  CBA being an example?
Logged

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #17 on: February 25, 2015, 01:21:56 PM »

Well, you can if it's not a 5 row monster! I think it's a short hop to RSI if you try it :-) Somehow or other though, it doesn't feel right - it's like singing - there's a particular point in a song where it feels natural to take a breath. Ditto with a CBA type device; you change direction typically at the end of a phrase, which may or may not be after a fixed number of bars... but the way dance tunes are normally built, usually is.

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #18 on: February 25, 2015, 01:47:34 PM »

I suppose what I'm asking is really this - to what extent do the relatively light unisonoric 12, 14, or 18 bass layouts now available allow players of other RH systems than quint to achieve the dynamic advantages of frequent bellow direction changes?  I suspect that actually they're often just as good at it, but players with those LH systems have usually not yet had many years practising the required RH fingerings, to know.
Logged

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)
« Reply #19 on: February 25, 2015, 04:49:22 PM »

This is great! This is exactly what I am interested in! With all these layout choices and everyone's personal choices and needs, it is clear that there is no one "right", "perfect", or "best", or even "most logical" system. A person's choice of system seems to be affected by so many things, including (but in no particular order):

Musical/Instrumental influences (what initially drew you to the box in the first place)
Amount of time already in a system
How they want to use the system
The importance of bounce/bellows movement
The importance of smoothed out playing
The desired range of sound from the instrument (# of voices, pitch spread, swing, timbre(s), etc.)

Not having ever played a C#/D semitone box, my brain tends to justify the layout I designed in a similar home key way. It seems like on a C#/D, and maybe Chris (Ryall) or other C#/D players can confirm or deny this, you've got your classic push pull on the D row and can jump to the C# row for playing in other keys and nabbing accidentals (with a little bit of flexibility thanks to the F# and C# reversals). This makes much more sense (again, theoretically) to me than the B/C system, which allows for a different sound, longer on direction phrases in common keys, but looses the home row component.

With my system, keeping the "home row" of D/G (or Em, same notes, different order), allows me to play out of a home position and grab accidentals and reversals off the inside row. This idea meshes with my personal preference for quint based layouts over systems that offer greater flexibility but lack on row or home row fundamentals.

For me, treating my layout as a D/G even though it has D/Em characteristics allows me to interact conceptually and physically with other quint box players that I like to listen to. The trade off of modifying the G row in order to get more flexibility in to the third row is worth it to me, because I am fairly confident that I can rewire my brain to play out of G with the same bellow direction by ducking down to the D row. It's certainly not for everyone, and I would be more reluctant if I had spent more time on a standard D/G. My goal is to get the fundamentals of D/G down so that when I transition to D/Em, I can still make it sound like a D/G and also then learn to use the dutch reversal(s) as an extended part of the third row. If I wanted to play in every key, I would almost certainly pick a more logical, isomorphic system such as Atzarin (or buy a bunch of differently tuned boxes).

In terms of lightweight left hand ends allowing for rapid and sustained bellows-work, I would be interested to see how that would coincide with more isomorphic right hand layouts. My guess would be that the natural bellows pattern would deviate from the on row pattern of a quint box or one row, not in a bad way, but developing it's own style and feel that is distinct from quint box based systems.

I would love to hear the music that came out of a couple decades of Atzarin practice, I am sure it would be beautiful!

Thanks,
Baron
« Last Edit: February 25, 2015, 06:24:35 PM by Baron Collins-Hill »
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons
Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal