Mode geeks like me can't stay out of that missing 'D' thing though. Fact is that B dorian and B mixolydian are exactly the same in the upper half of the octave - one reason you can play major or minor over Blues progressions. It is only that D v D# note that discriminates the scales!
So the tune could equally be mixolydian? Except that it isn't!! It clearly sounds minor. Music theory can be a cruel bedfellow at times ::)
I have wondered in the past why a pentatonic ("thirdless") tune such as Toss the Feathers (below) should automatically be interpreted as sounding minor. Why not play E major chords to accompany it? Nobody does and doubtless we'd all go "eurgh" if anybody did.
In the course of a long discussion about the subject a friend proposed that the E scale used is a really a subset or a mode of the D major scale... it seemed the most plausible explanation. So if you wanted to add the missing notes they would come from D major, and not E major or minor. There was probably more to his reasoning than that but I can't recall the details.
Modes are very helpful in describing and understanding Irish traditional tunes. But they only take you so far, and trying to shoehorn some tunes into a conventional mode just ties you in knots. We need a Grand Unified Theory to tie it all together. ;)
X:58
T:RS2(c) TOSS THE FEATHERS
R:reel
Z:id:hn-reel-163
M:C|
L:1/8
K:Edor
% E pentatonic!
EBBB dBBB|EBBA FEFA|BEEE B2AB|1 dffe dBAF:|2 dffe dBAd||
Beed e2de|fede fee2|febe febe|fede feed|
Beed e2de|fede faa2|b3f a3f|effe dBAF||"Last time"effe d2 z2|]