Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4   Go Down

Author Topic: I've ditched the dots  (Read 11517 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #40 on: July 02, 2015, 03:35:43 PM »

but you are playing  your own arrangement of the tune which requires considerable skill!

george ;)
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Jack Campin

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 764
    • Jack Campin's Home Page
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #41 on: July 02, 2015, 07:10:05 PM »

Quote
having the dots or chords or whatever in front of you can actually inhibit the muscle-memory learning process

Muscle memory is an unmitigated liability and you certainly ought to inhibit it, by any means necessary.  It's the musical equivalent of painting by numbers.

If all you're learning is a sequence of mechanical actions you will be completely lost if you try another instrument (including your own voice) because you won't have learned the pitches in the melody (or the chord pattern, if we're talking left-hand stuff).  Learn by ear or by dot memorization and you can transfer what you've learned to any other instrument, once you've learned how to get the right notes or chords out of it.
Logged
http://www.campin.me.uk/

I can't figure out how to quit but I will no longer check this group and have deleted all shortcuts to it.

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #42 on: July 02, 2015, 07:40:42 PM »

Quote
Muscle memory is an unmitigated liability and you certainly ought to inhibit it, by any means necessary.  It's the musical equivalent of painting by numbers.

Jack, sorry, but that's completely wrong-headed!  The whole point is that musicians (whatever instrument they play) learn how to play a piece of music first (the bits you're talking about), but then spend time learning the physical actions necessary to achieve it.  Do you honestly imagine that virtuoso soloists on a concert stage have memorised some kind of image of the music stave, or whatever?  Of course they haven't, they've learned how to translate their knowledge into physical action - they are remembering a sequence of finger movements that a lot of rehearsal has taught them are the right ones to use.  That's what I mean by finger memory. Maybe you have a different technique, but I think most of us here are doing just that, just like those concert soloists. (Well, trying to, anyway.)
« Last Edit: July 02, 2015, 08:48:40 PM by Chris Brimley »
Logged

Jack Campin

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 764
    • Jack Campin's Home Page
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #43 on: July 02, 2015, 09:00:08 PM »

Church organists can typically play anything in their repertoire in any transposition.

For folk tunes it is pretty unusual, for any instrument, to encounter anything that requires specific physical movements to generate sounds at a specific pitch. I'm mainly a woodwind player. Nearly all the tunes in Lester's big file are things I could learn to play on the recorder. Once I've done that it's no stretch to play them in any reasonable key on the flute, clarinet, sax or ocarina; the fingering patterns are completely different, but as George said, the idea is to remember how the tune goes and to know how to hit the notes you need. Nobody is surprised by the concept of singing by ear - learn to control your instrument the way you control your voice box and playing by ear is no more arcane a skill.
Logged
http://www.campin.me.uk/

I can't figure out how to quit but I will no longer check this group and have deleted all shortcuts to it.

Jack Campin

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 764
    • Jack Campin's Home Page
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #44 on: July 03, 2015, 10:37:26 AM »

Here is an example of where you want to go beyond muscle memory.  A Highland pipe tune as it appears in the books:

Code: [Select]
X:1
T:Old Toasty
S:Gordon Highlanders book 1
C:Angus Lawrie, Strathclyde Police
M:2/4
L:1/16
K:A Mixolydian
   a2 |A2A2   c>BA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>f|a>fe>c B2a2 |
       A2A2   c>BA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  :|
   f>g|a2a2   f2e>c |e>fa>e f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>f|a>fe>c B2f>g|
[1     a2a2   f2e>c |e>fa>e f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  :|
[2     A2A2   c>BA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  ||
%
   a2 |c>cc>B A>AA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>f|a>fe>c B2a2 |
       c>cc>B A>AA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  :|
   c>d|e>fe>c a2e2  |f>ga>f e2f>g|a2a2 f2e>f|a>fe>c B2c>d|
[1     e>fe>c a2e2  |f>ga>f e2f>g|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  :|
[2     A2A2   c>BA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  |]

I was in Sandy Bells one afternoon when Iain Grant (multiple diatonic moothie) and George Macpherson (piano accordion) came up with this variant, which makes a more dramatic effect:

Code: [Select]
X:2
T:Old Toasty
S:Gordon Highlanders book 1
C:Angus Lawrie, Strathclyde Police
M:2/4
L:1/16
K:G Mixolydian
   g2 |G2G2   B>AG>B|d2B<d  e2d>e|g2g2 e2d>e|g>ed>B A2g2 |
       G2G2   B>AG>B|d2B<d  e2d>e|g2g2 e2d>B|A2G2   G2  :|
   e>f|g2g2   e2d>B |d>eg>d e2d>e|g2g2 e2d>e|g>ed>B A2e>f|
[1     g2g2   e2d>B |d>eg>d e2d>e|g2g2 e2d>B|A2G2   G2  :|
[2     G2G2   B>AG>B|d2B<d  e2d>e|g2g2 e2d>B|A2G2   G2  ||
K:A Mixolydian
   a2 |c>cc>B A>AA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>f|a>fe>c B2a2 |
       c>cc>B A>AA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  :|
   c>d|e>fe>c a2e2  |f>ga>f e2f>g|a2a2 f2e>f|a>fe>c B2c>d|
[1     e>fe>c a2e2  |f>ga>f e2f>g|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  :|
[2     A2A2   c>BA>c|e2c<e  f2e>f|a2a2 f2e>c|B2A2   A2  |]

Iain would probably have played the the (inconspicuous) sevenths sharpened, he used normal diatonic moothies in normal position.

The point is that the tune starts out mixolydian/major/lydian pentatonic, so you don't need C naturals - you can do either version of the whole thing on a two-sharps diatonic instrument.  But your fingering will be quite different if you do the first half in G.  Iain just switched to a different moothie on his 6-way spindle but George played the first half of the tune transposed (as did I, once I realized what was going on).
« Last Edit: July 03, 2015, 10:42:59 AM by Jack Campin »
Logged
http://www.campin.me.uk/

I can't figure out how to quit but I will no longer check this group and have deleted all shortcuts to it.

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #45 on: July 03, 2015, 10:59:26 AM »

Maybe we're using different terminology, because I don't understand the relevance of your point, Jack - you're referring to two different treatments of a similar tune, I think, which obviously require different fingerings.  Muscle memory for me is about the next stage - once you've decided how you want to play it, internalising that fingering for performance purposes, which I think was the OP's issue. 

I accept that a few highly skilled players could in theory get to a stage where they could directly play any piece at performance standard from dots, 'inner ears' or whatever, without ever having practised it. However for the great majority of us, good performance means rehearsal until the fingering patterns come naturally, or until you become an excellent direct reader (by no means easy on a box because of the alternative fingerings usually available).  Even virtuoso players of instruments I suspect rely heavily on learned patterns in their playing, and memorising their sound.
Logged

arty

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1465
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #46 on: July 03, 2015, 11:41:56 AM »

Some years ago, while waiting for a flight, I found myself seated next to a guy who had music spread out over the table in front of him in the airport. He was 'playing' the music with the fingers of both hands on the table.
We chatted a while and he explained that he was a concert pianist and busy learning a piece by heart for a forthcoming recital. I remember he said, that even while playing on the table, obviously with no sound coming from it, he could tell when he made a mistake.
Surely, that can only be about muscle memory.
It turns out he is quite famous and I have had the priviledge of hearing him in concert. Wonderful musician.
Logged
Pre-Pokerwork C/F, Castagnari Laura G/C, Beltuna Sara 3 A/D, Castagnari Sander Special D/G

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #47 on: July 03, 2015, 12:13:46 PM »

It seems to me that it not entirely one thing or the other.
If we didn't have muscle memory, our playing of a particular tune would hardly improve technically from the first time of playing at sight, but neither should we reply entirely on muscle memory for learning a tune. Actually we memorise the fingerings for patterns of notes, and those patterns makes up much of the music we play. I memorise the association between the sound I hear in my head and what my fingers are doing, so when I hear in my head where the tune's going next, that association tells me how to play the next few notes.

Memory is a strange thing, How you account for the fact that someone can't play along with a tune in a session, then you tell them the name of the tune and they realize they know the tune and can then play it?
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Jack Campin

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 764
    • Jack Campin's Home Page
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #48 on: July 03, 2015, 12:24:21 PM »

Quote
I accept that a few highly skilled players could in theory get to a stage where they could directly play any piece at performance standard from dots, 'inner ears' or whatever, without ever having practised it

I didn't say they hadn't practiced it at all - simply that they hadn't practiced the specific muscle movements involved in doing it in the key they were using.  Like I said, any competent church organist can do that with the entire hymn repertoire, harmonization and all.  George Macpherson was doing it on the occasion I described, I do it regularly, and it's not at all uncommon in sessions.  You just call out "G!" and see who follows.  Anybody with an ear who's learned to play a diatonic instrument in different positions can do it.
Logged
http://www.campin.me.uk/

I can't figure out how to quit but I will no longer check this group and have deleted all shortcuts to it.

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #49 on: July 03, 2015, 02:24:49 PM »

Quote
I didn't say they hadn't practiced it at all - simply that they hadn't practiced the specific muscle movements involved in doing it in the key they were using.

?

Quote
Muscle memory is an unmitigated liability
Logged

Jack Campin

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 764
    • Jack Campin's Home Page
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #50 on: July 03, 2015, 02:33:12 PM »

If I play a tune in A on a G ocarina (which I do a lot, pipe tunes work well that way) I'm using entirely different fingerings from those I would use playing the same tune in A on a flute.

For that matter if I play a tune in the low register on a clarinet and then take it up an octave, not one note is fingered the same.  (The difference is of the same order as playing a pentatonic tune in two different positions/keys on one row of a melodeon).
Logged
http://www.campin.me.uk/

I can't figure out how to quit but I will no longer check this group and have deleted all shortcuts to it.

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #51 on: July 03, 2015, 03:00:20 PM »

I think we are in danger here of over analysing the term " muscle memory. Of course muscles don't have any memory, al least I don't think there is evidence that.  It is a convenient simple shorthand for a much much more complicated process of how the brain and body together are able to learn highly complex actions such as how to play a musical instrument, or walk or speak, or any of the thousands of things we learn to do without consciously directing the complex combinations of muscle moments and touch feedback. So yes "muscle memory" does involve memory and muscles, but its much much more than that.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #52 on: July 03, 2015, 05:32:31 PM »

Theo, I'm grateful to you for that comment, because I think there is an important message for learners in what you say: 
Quote
or any of the thousands of things we learn to do without consciously directing the complex combinations of muscle moments and touch feedback.

It took me many years to realise that (for me at least, but I now believe for most musicians) the best way to perform is to rehearse thoroughly (until playing the piece is 'second nature'), and then just let it flow, concentrating on the overall dynamics (and perhaps the 'feel' of the music encompassing one's experience of the structure and harmony of the music) and letting the subconscious do the mechanics, just as you have set out.  I use the term 'muscle memory', because it closely covers the pattern of finger and arm movements that the memory is bringing out, and I have noticed that if I allow the (nervous) conscious mind to worry about those patterns, I will probably go wrong.

When I listen to skilled box players, it seems to me they are doing the same - few if any seem to be re-analysing the music as they play it, they're just doing it (and enjoying the feel).  They've worked out all the arrangement and theory in advance, that's an earlier stage.  Now I don't say that everybody plays like this, nor that it is necessarily appropriate if you are trying to play something you don't know (in a session for example), but I think it is an important learning method for learners to adopt.  I'm afraid there are no easy ways of avoiding rehearsal time through just understanding music theory - all competent musicians have got to rehearse. A lot.
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #53 on: July 03, 2015, 05:42:16 PM »

Agreed Chris. 
It's that 10,000 hours you have to put in to truly be at one with an instrument.  But the journey is full of interest and enjoyment.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #54 on: July 03, 2015, 07:51:16 PM »

I find that if I have to apply any concious thought to playing  there is a considerable chance of cocking  it up.  Good old autopilot and  an attentive ear seems to do the trick best for me

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Mike Carney

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 701
  • In sunny Sheffield
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #55 on: July 03, 2015, 08:22:23 PM »

I have just spent a long time reading through all the posts on this subject.

It seems to me, that some people are saying - 'you should play like me'
Others are saying - 'if I play like him I'll play better'
Some are saying - 'use all the bullets in your armory to learn and play, CDs, You Tube, sheet music'
Others are saying - 'muscle memory, that's what you need to develop'
Some say - 'put away the music, play by ear'
Others say - 'I can't, I have no memory and if I don't play by ear I am inadequate'
The majority say - 'this is what I do and it works for me, try it and find what's right for you'

And so it goes on and on - surely, there are as many ways of learning the instrument, the tune and playing it, as there are people. Everyone will do it slightly differently and what does it matter? The most important thing is to play the melodeon, play the tunes as well as one can and enjoy the whole process. If it makes you happy, then you are not doing much wrong.

For what it's worth, I come from a completely classical background, so reading music is no problem at all. Now, with the accordion, I listen to CDs and You Tube, I find the sheet music for my chosen piece, I learn to play it on my melodeon, all the time while not playing I sing it, hum it, whistle it. When I know it without mistakes, I put away the music and learn to play it from memory. I feel a lovely sense of freedom now, although when I first started this I didn't believe I could do it and felt tense as a result. Then, [and this will make you laugh], I practice playing it while watching TV at the same time and this helps me to 'pull back' a little bit and not concentrate so hard on which button I am pressing or which bass I'm playing. Also, with the TV playing as well, it forces me to listen harder to my own playing, which I think is one of the most important things for me to do. Listen to myself.....

But all that is my personal opinion and what seems to be working for me at the moment. I would encourage everyone to find their own way.
I was doing my best to resist replying to this thread but have given in! I really liked what Bob wrote about " becoming familiar with" the tune, as that is how the process of learning a tune feels to me. A bit like getting to know a person, which doesn't happen all at once.
Until Arty's contribution (above) I felt that it was the same round of points being made yet again, in the form of the seemingly age old struggle between the "ear learners" and the "notation readers" (the term "dots " felt like it was used in a less than positive way in some posts), but with people misunderstanding or not hearing the essence of the points on several sides of the debate. Much of it also seemed to miss the OP issue which I recall related in large part to how they managed in a session when they thought they had learned a tune enough to play it in public.
For me, Arty, your comments summed it up really well and left me feeling much more positive.  I now just need to do some research on the type of film that works best while using this new approach... I'm wondering about A Night at the Opera...
M
Logged

arty

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1465
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #56 on: July 04, 2015, 12:17:47 AM »

 :D :D :D
Sometimes I think we take it all a bit too seriously. Just play the thing and love it - a lot.  It'll all come right.

If I may borrow a phrase from Picasso, changing it slightly.... "I want to play like a child but with the intellect of a man".
The trouble is, men are full of inhibitions, preconceived ideas and inner doubts, well this one is -- but children just do it. Another thing, men like me at 66years of age, are in a bit of a rush, so we look for quick fixes, recipes for success, when really, all that is needed is a lot of bloody hard work. 10,000 hours equates to approximately 3hours a day for 10 years - what a frightening thought, better get on with it!
Might I suggest 'Thomas the Tank Engine', Oysterboy!

Logged
Pre-Pokerwork C/F, Castagnari Laura G/C, Beltuna Sara 3 A/D, Castagnari Sander Special D/G

blue eyed sailor

  • Melodeon renegade - partly reverted - Preciosa maniac
  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 264
  • since folk process is running, take an active part
    • My Sound Cloud
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #57 on: July 04, 2015, 11:12:52 AM »

The current TOTM is making a very good touchstone for exploring what is being discussed here for me: it has in fact what I called a rather structural melody, making for a persistent flow with arpeggio-like figures, scale-runs asf., so dots are positively helpful to make a start for me for getting it right and not just sort of...

Second, it's the first tune I'm learning in parallel on (unisonoric English) concertina (original Gmin) and my newly acquired Preciosa (Cmin). Learning the tune clearly works for both tasks, in addition to that there are fingering and bellows issues (and aspects of style too of course) which are very different, each settling in its own pace and way...

And after a day or two and several runs on each instruments I'm near the point of ditching the dots for this time...

Best wishes - Wolf
Logged
Hohners: 2x Preciosa Bb/Eb (tremolo / light swing) - Club IV Bb/Eb - Morino Club C/F
Presswood C/F - Pokerwork C - Verdi II (PA) - Lucia IV (PA) - Starlet (PA)

Weltmeister 509 G/C/F - Juwel (PA) -- Horch C/F (12 bass) -- Cantulia Bambi 26 (PA)
and: Castagnari Giordy G/C

be warned of my SC page, mainly concertina thus far

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #58 on: July 06, 2015, 12:37:12 PM »

Me too, Wolf - I've been trying to work out the duo's accompaniment (in Am as it's a DGAcc friendly key), which I think makes this tune such an earworm.  I've put it into dots, in order to learn how to play it smoothly, with melody and guitar/bass chords (which is my preferred learning technique).  It seems to me that Dave Shepherd is improvising against the chord structure, after setting out the melody.

I've not yet ditched the dots, because I need to learn how to do those triplet runs smoothly, and dots help me see possible fingering patterns (such as pull Dm against the FED triplet on bar 20).  I'm using the Roland FR18 to learn this one, because I want to be able to transpose to Gm. But also, I feel that this is one of those tunes that becomes so much easier to do harmonic justice to if you have a long third row, with a few reversals. 
Logged

Rob2Hook

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2278
  • Castagnaris, Hohners & Baffetti
Re: I've ditched the dots
« Reply #59 on: July 07, 2015, 02:09:40 AM »

Happily, I've found that most melodeon players do perform by ear.  There are exceptions, of course, partucularly when it is a newly learnt tune in one of its first performances.  But just as most professional musicians can play from the manuscript, a soloist more commonly plays from memory - it seems to allow them greater scope for interpretation and produces a more emotive presentation. 

In the context of folk music, I well remember a certain ceilidh band who played entirely from the page - and it produced the most lifeless and undanceable sound!  Playing well for dance also demands that the musicians should observe their audience (the dancers) and their fingers should be stepping along with them.  For this reason alone, I would encourage anyone to aspire to playing their repertoire from memory whichever way they learn it in the first place.

Having said that, Even tunes I've been playing for years at ceilidhs can slip completely out of my head, especially if I'm supposed to play the intro!  It certainly never hurts to have the first few bars of manuscript in your crib sheet if you can read the dots.  As to my own way of learning it depends on the source, but when I have the manuscript for a tune with phrases I cannot retrieve from existing muscle memory, I find it helpful to use a midi file to play it to me so the correct notes go into the brain.

Rob.
Logged
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal