Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Excelsior 'Baton Rouge' melodeon. An objective assessment.  (Read 2795 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

savantuk

  • A Shropshire lad
  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 401
  • Location - Whitchurch, Shropshire.
Excelsior 'Baton Rouge' melodeon. An objective assessment.
« on: July 03, 2015, 03:31:38 PM »

Hi,

I took delivery of this used melodeon this morning, bought from this very forum, for what I consider to be a real bargain price of £300. 

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,16931.0.html

The pics are 'clickies'  Left click to enlarge.







There has been a lot of posts written on this forum regarding these boxes, some of it informes, some of it not so, some good, and I suspect, some bad written by people who have never laid eyes, never mind hands on one of these.

Here are my thoughts, based around my experience of those I've owned, and played.

My initial reaction was equivocal.  An Italian box of good quality, well put together, with a good grade of knot free cherry, excellent first grade italian bellows, good quality Italian leather straps, but woeful plastic buttons, and poorly executed pallet levers levers.  I know these are always just bent wire, but they looked 'unfinished'.  Pallets were ok, nicely shaped, well felted, but attached to the levers with what looked like reed wax, covered with fillets of gold bellows tape.  The faceboard is nicely decorated with scrollwork, and the brand name.

Casework is really excellent.  Typical Italian/French style, the woodwork is profiled, rather like that of those made by one of the Sensei members here, with mitres all round rather than butt joints.  This at least should please 'Melodeon'.  The pro's and con's of case construction have been debated many times here, and need no further discussion, save for me saying this one is neat and well executed, and further re-inforced al la 'Cajun' style.

Hand grips, buttons, air button and handstrap on the bass end are all well done. I felt that the air button was thoughtfully placed.

What I did not like about the case was the fact that there was some overspray on the face plate, which will, at length, polish out, but it will take considerable effort.  How I dislike polyeurathane varnish.

The bellows, as has been intimated are excellent, both inside and out, and good quality tape has been used to finish them.

Inside the case, the reedblocks bear the legend 'Cajun Tuned', which I'd say is about right.  Straight tuned, and with a very powerful 'Cajun' sound, as good as any I've heard on boxes costing less than £1k.  Almost as good as those on my E Martin 1 row box which had Binci handmade reeds.  The reeds on this box are all Antonelli, not to shabby at all, but obviously macchina at this price.

What is it like compared to others at a sub £1000 price??  I believe it stacks up well.  Quality is far superior, both in terms of workmanship and materials to the venerated HA114, and the Hohner Ariette looks to be well below the standard of the Excelsior.  I used to sell Chinese 1 row boxes, marketed under various names in the UK, but all the same box, ie those sold by Hobgoblin and Boorinwood, and others sold with fake Italian names eg Scarlatti, Peredie, and Stephanelli by Steve Klinkscale for around the £600 mark.  The Zydeco Bonetti from the US could be considered also to be of that ilk.

Some may argue that the 114 has better reeds.  I'm not so certain.  The reeds on this box sound faster, and individually, sound sweeter.
Also, I'm not certain, but the newer 114's have, I think, Chinese reeds.

The Excelsior has Italian reeds, Italian casework, and Italian components.  It looks good, and sounds great.  What's not to like?  Other members who have genuine experience of this model, may agree, or disagree, but at around £900, it has to be considered as a competitor to the Weltmeister, and newer model Hohners, eg Cajun IV.  For the £300 I paid, well it was a BARGAIN!

But, were I to buy new, at a similar price, I think I would be tempted with the Weltmeister.  This is a very good box.

Doug

Logged
Regards,

Doug

Castagnari Tommy D/G ~  Castagnari Max in C ~ Irish Dancemaster converted toy in C with Cagnoni reeds
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal