Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6   Go Down

Author Topic: The relative merits of 3-row systems  (Read 17421 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Matt (Kings Norton)

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 304
  • West Midlands, UK
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #60 on: December 28, 2015, 06:48:06 PM »

Nice video Stiamh, very nice in fact, and I agree completely, that if you look at the corners of the bellows there is constant variation, in other words he is using the bellows to shape every note dynamically, and without that the tune would sound much worse.  Really enjoyed it and I found it a  great (and quite subtle)example of what I was trying to describe.

If the discussion is about English trad, time for me to butt out, great music but I should leave it to those who do it and know it.

As to whether quick bellows reversals are possible on a big fat accordion, here's Claudio Jacomucci: http://youtu.be/msFOWnOu3Es.  Now Claudio Jacomucci is roughly the size and physique of a brown bear, but the thing is these techniques aren't based on strength and if you try and achieve them through brute force your arm will come off. It's all about practising delicate control and then applying it.  (Listen to me talking as though I know what I'm doing...). So I feel that that answers that question.

It doesn't sound diatonic at all, so, as to whether changing bellows and getting a different note gets you a fundamentally different sound, most probably it does.  That and the basses having different notes on and being tuned differently.

Each system sounds different and I can totally understand why everyone feels passionate about their own preferred sound.  One good thing about this thread, I am now desperate to get the three row out again.

Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #61 on: December 28, 2015, 09:17:01 PM »

there is absolutely no reason why quick reversals can't be carried out on a big (120 bass) piano accordion  as not only can they but obviously  must be carried out on same size diatonics eg shand morino, borsini, excelsior etc etc.

However it is likely that most piano box players simply have no urge or reason so to do.

There is the technique of 'pulsing the bellows' which   works on both bisonoric and unisonoric boxes that from a distance could possibly be mistaken for reversals . Pulsing is delicate push- push - push etc  and does not include the 'back flick ' that on a diatonic gives a very brief sounding of the note on the back of a button so to speak.  On a piano box it would if attempted only provide a 'broken' note as both reeds on a reedplate are the same.

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #62 on: December 29, 2015, 03:02:09 AM »

I'd like to comment on a different aspect of this thread.

It has often struck me that as soon as one goes beyond the two-row fourth-apart 8-bass box, there is hardly any standardisation in design, and there are all sorts of individual approaches to what to have on the third row of ‘accidentals’, and for the extra basses.

I thought it might be a useful exercise to redesign mentally the boxes I’ve got, in keeping with what I’ve learned about playing them since I first got them.

The first thing is to have a set of principles about how to go about this.  My aim was and is to learn incrementally from the DG 2-row, so that additional opportunities become available, and that many of the serious musical limitations of that simple design are overcome.   (I can hear the words of many melnetters immediately:   â€˜Ah, that’s where you’re going wrong!’  But in my defence I believe that the economy of the clever 2-row 8 bass design, and the effectiveness of the bisonoric ‘bounce’ sound, are lasting benefits, which should be enhanced.) 

I'm going to talk in DG-speak in what follows, but I see no immediate reason why the same principles don't apply to GC box players, or any other fourth apart 2-row keys, with a spot of transposing.

The second principle is to enhance the ability to play in the home keys.  This means providing reversals where they don’t exist, providing the missing basses to allow better accompaniment, and adding missing right hand notes.  In terms of extending the basses, it provides extra opportunities if you add a few chords both flatwards and sharpwards, but I do not think it makes sense to try to design an instrument that will play in any key, as others have seen as the main goal.  To do that, you really would need to start from a different place, with a semitone or unisonoric RH layout, and stradella or unisonoric basses.  My philosophy is that if you want to play in significantly different keys to the home ones, you’re best off with another box, or an electronic one which can transpose.

So I’ll start with the LH.  Here’s my (14 bass) layout (thirds being removeable):

                   Ama/Ema   A/E   Dma/Ama  D/A   Gma/Dma   G/D   F#/C#
Basses:
                  Bbma/Fma  Bb/F  Bma/Emi   B/E   Cma/Cma    C/C   D#/G#

The idea of this layout is to allow some playing in a sharper key, A (using the Ama and Ema chords), or with flatter keys with the Fma and Bbma chords.  The Ema chord is somewhat redundant, since without thirds you already have it, so maybe a G pull or F#m pull might be more useful, some would say.   The button on the right hand end of each row gives useful bass notes for runs, and the two make the bass fully chromatic.  However from the point of view of this discussion, it’s the 12 basses that are important.

So what do we need on the third row RH?  First, the missing home key reversals – D pull, E push, C push and C# push.  Second, the missing other notes G#, Bb, Eb, and F.  I would suggest that the F and Bb should be available both ways, because they are frequently required in different contexts, whereas the G# and Eb could be just on the pull.

This gives Bb, C, C#, E, F on push, and G#, Bb, D, Eb and F on the pull, both 5-button repeats.  I have found that it is a good idea to have notes arranged so that they always increase in pitch as you go towards the floor, on either push or pull.  I have a case where two notes are reversed, and it sometimes confuses me because it seems somehow counter-intuitive.

This means it would be desirable to have a longer third row than usual.  It also means that the third row would not match the other rows for each octave.  I don’t personally think that’s a problem – they don’t match anyway between push and pull, and you get used to it.

The RH layout could therefore be this:

C#/D    E/Eb   F/F     Bb/G#   C/Bb    C#/D     E/Eb     F/F   Bb/G#   C/Bb   C#/D   

      G/C      B/E      D/F#   G/A       B/C     D/E      G/F#      B/A     D/C     G/E

D/G     F#/B    A/C#     D/E     F#/G     A/B     D/C#      F#/E    A/G      D/B      F#/C#

This gives a layout that is fully chromatic over two octaves, in both directions (except for G# and Eb).  The third row notes relate pretty well to the adjacent second row, in terms of stretch when playing ascending or descending runs.  You would have a very wide choice of RH chords, and you could pretty much do anything you like in terms of fingerings for a given tune.  This would mean you could choose exactly where to put your bellow-change bounces in, and when to have long passages of smooth legato.  You could do that on push or pull, so that running out of air should rarely be a problem.  And it would involve no immediate changes for those who learned to play on a simple two-row fourth-apart box – you could use more and more opportunities as your skills develop.

You could actually probably play in most keys and modes, if you really wanted to, though you’d need a lot of practice – I said earlier that I don’t see that as the best way forward, I would look towards transposing to the home keys.

I could actually very easily set this up on the Roland, to try it.  Actually, I don’t think I will, because I’ve already learned a different system, and I will just confuse myself if I try.  But, if only I was starting again, knowing what I do now ….!

Comments, anyone?
« Last Edit: December 29, 2015, 03:10:53 AM by Chris Brimley »
Logged

playandteach

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3526
  • Currently a music teacher in a high school.
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #63 on: December 29, 2015, 10:12:18 AM »

The second principle is to enhance the ability to play in the home keys.  This means providing reversals where they don’t exist, providing the missing basses to allow better accompaniment, and adding missing right hand notes.  In terms of extending the basses, it provides extra opportunities if you add a few chords both flatwards and sharpwards, but I do not think it makes sense to try to design an instrument that will play in any key, as others have seen as the main goal.
So what do we need on the third row RH?  First, the missing home key reversals – D pull, E push, C push and C# push.  Second, the missing other notes G#, Bb, Eb, and F.  I would suggest that the F and Bb should be available both ways, because they are frequently required in different contexts, whereas the G# and Eb could be just on the pull.

The RH layout could therefore be this:

C#/D    E/Eb   F/F     Bb/G#   C/Bb    C#/D     E/Eb     F/F   Bb/G#   C/Bb   C#/D   

      G/C      B/E      D/F#   G/A       B/C     D/E      G/F#      B/A     D/C     G/E

D/G     F#/B    A/C#     D/E     F#/G     A/B     D/C#      F#/E    A/G      D/B      F#/C#

This gives a layout that is fully chromatic over two octaves, in both directions (except for G# and Eb).  The third row notes relate pretty well to the adjacent second row, in terms of stretch when playing ascending or descending runs.  You would have a very wide choice of RH chords, and you could pretty much do anything you like in terms of fingerings for a given tune.  This would mean you could choose exactly where to put your bellow-change bounces in, and when to have long passages of smooth legato.  You could do that on push or pull, so that running out of air should rarely be a problem.  And it would involve no immediate changes for those who learned to play on a simple two-row fourth-apart box – you could use more and more opportunities as your skills develop.
This is interesting - does anyone do anything close to this, and what is the nearest 'standard' option?

For me, too, it wouldn't be about fully chromatic usage, just options and long runs in both directions. Thanks, though, for the tips on bellows changes. Although I fancy La Guinguette for Tune of the Month, I should learn the Hornpipe.
Logged
Serafini R2D2 GC, Serafini GC accs 18 bass

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #64 on: December 29, 2015, 01:41:12 PM »

The key to making it work is I think the spreading of the accs row onto a 5,5 button repetition pattern. Most are 4,4. 

Mine is based on a C# outer diatonic row, so that's 4 repeat on push, 5 on pull. Even so that leaves me one reed short of being chromatic - Ab is a push note (though having it 'same button' as my Bb is a good workaround for flat scales). I could get there with awkwardness had I gone Dutch reversal

I particularly like Chris's repeat of an F/F button, I've found that to be a real gateway into flat scale play. 
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #65 on: December 30, 2015, 02:40:38 AM »

Responding to playandteach's query, I don't think I've ever encountered such a layout in practice - the Roland FR18 allows that number of third row buttons, so can be configured to provide it.  In the manual there are quite a few sample button configurations, but none anything like this, it seems.

Chris, yes, I think the 5,5 repetition is the important concept - I just started thinking, why have short third rows, you need more notes here, not less!  I did wonder about adding G# and Eb pushes to the concept to give complete chromatics both ways, but this would have extended it to 7,5, probably a bit over the top, and you'd have to lose the end notes anyway with a 12 button max.  Just a query on your C# row, Chris - if you use the same nomenclature, don't you repeat after 3,4 rather than 4,5?  My current Tramontane layout is 4,4 on the inner row, but I realise it's not enough.
« Last Edit: December 30, 2015, 02:42:31 AM by Chris Brimley »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #66 on: December 30, 2015, 08:57:38 AM »

I started with a C#DG Oakwood set out on 11/10/9 layout, going cheap and decided to back my theory that the ideal source of accidentals was either ½ or tritone away from a main row, C# achieves both ;)

initially play strategy was aimed at flattening D row notes at will, exploring Blues, but as I tried the weirder stuff they do in Grenoble … loads of the "out" scales like to walk between C# and G rows, be that push or pull.

Eventually I optimised by filing outer pull F#s=>F and C=>D making it pull chromatic apart from Ab; both notes were duplicated on G row so no loss. It did break the symmetry of eg the important C blues run, but well worth it for extra chord possibilities.

So that was a 10+9 DG with an 11 (outer!) accs row "based" on C# diatonic scale. The latter intrinsically 4,5 repeat. To go 3,5, 5,5 for that matter would have needed butchery rather than surgery. That box is sold now (Xmas card says she is now ADG!) but my black vdAa and Gaillard (F#GC) are purposely "same system" - hair gone grey in the process and - in the end you have to just get on and know your own system.

I think that is more important than what it actually is? if you go 3-row all logic says you should practice be able to produce eg a Bb chord, add its 7th, or play some useful Bb scale stuff against someone elses Bb at drop of a hat. Which was why I took to the Dark Side.

In current avatar I'm improvising with (another!) Chris, great trumpeter, he's set off in G minor ::)  In British sessions I'm on the D and G rows like everyone else (:)
« Last Edit: December 30, 2015, 09:10:42 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #67 on: December 30, 2015, 10:23:24 AM »

Ah, Chris, you may have missed my question, which was simply that a 'diato' row in C#, which you describe, would presumably have a 3,4 pattern repeated, rather than the 4,5 one you referred to.  You said 'based on', rather than 'tuned as' and I was wondering whether that meant you had an extra button additional to the 3,4 pattern with other notes?  And if so, what it was?

Have you also taken my point that if you have a layout which is fully chromatic both ways, further discussion about suitability for particular styles largely becomes a matter of playing convenience rather than limitations, because then you will be able to play pretty much what you like?

The underlying question I'm posing is this:  If players like 2-row 4th-apart diatos but want to add extra buttons because they don't like their limitations, well why be satisfied with a '2 plus a few' layout?  Why not go the whole hog, because it's quite possible to do it with a long third row?
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #68 on: December 30, 2015, 11:43:20 AM »

?

Have you also taken my point that if you have a layout which is fully chromatic both ways, further discussion about suitability for particular styles largely becomes a matter of playing convenience rather than limitations, because then you will be able to play pretty much what you like?

 

? would there be   any advantage in a 'diatonic' box that is chromatic both ways when compared to the very logical continental chromatic which is just that and has the benefit of buttons?

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #69 on: December 30, 2015, 11:54:04 AM »

Not really, George. It wouldn't add to chording and 90%+ of improvisation happens on the pull. You'd also have to mess with main rows to get there, losing melodeon-ness.  yes CBA is the logical choice for anyone who likes to mess with melodic line, or chords a lot. But as discussed elsewhere the mass of the thing is less conducive to bellows nuance of all kinds, unless you are a genius like Milleret, or that
irish fella.

Chris: my C# row runs ran C# F G# C# push and  D# F# A# C D# on pull. I was referring to the notes repeating on holes 4 and 5 respectively, but mathematically you are right, 3 and 4 repeat pattern. Thinking about it that is a better way to describe it.

That makes French system accs a 3,3 repeat, and yours a 4,4?
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #70 on: December 30, 2015, 12:19:01 PM »

You bet, George!

1st off, an awful lot of people here (including myself) learned to play 2-row 4th apart boxes, and their skills immediately transfer, and can be added to quickly.  If I wanted to play continental chromatic, I'd have to have another lifetime, or a large part of one, to learn it properly.

2nd, stradella basses, and their apparent implications in terms of playing styles, just don't sound the same.  Not necessarily better or worse, just different.  We discussed earlier the concept of introducing 'airspring bounce' into other layout concepts.  I'm not saying it can't be done, I just haven't seen the evidence yet that it is being done as effectively.

3rd, as I learned from trying Atzarin, a valuable part of the 2R4A concept is its speed, economy, efficiency, and therefore precision, in the home keys - tiny finger movements are usually (though not always) possible, as opposed to large leaps.  The idea of an incremental row with extra but less frequently used notes, which require slightly greater stretches, is actually a sound one, as I have found over the years.  A layout which is 'logical' is not necessarily 'ergonomic'.

4th, the concept I propose does not have the steep initial learning curve, which appears from the popularity statistics to have put so many people off other layouts.  It would allow incremental learning.  For example, if I were a 1-rower and wanted to play 'Donkey Riding' on this 3-row, all I'd need is to know is which buttons to start on.
Logged

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #71 on: December 30, 2015, 12:37:42 PM »

Chris, yes that clarifies it, thanks.  My proposal using that repeat nomenclature is as I say earlier 5,5, and my current box has 4,4.  I'm not familiar with the French system 3,3.

Anyway, the substantive point is that I feel your system (and I suspect the French system?) is going to be short of a few (3 in your case, 4 with the French?) more notes than my proposed layout.  I was trying to work out what they would be, but my brain hurts!  My proposal, based on DGAcc-speak, is short of G# push and Eb push, but otherwise fully chromatic both ways, over the middle 2 main octaves.

You will I suspect be highly qualified to recognise the potential benefits of a layout that means you can play virtually anything you want, in either direction?  For example, you would no longer need to improvise just 'on the pull', you could do it 'on the push' too. 
« Last Edit: December 30, 2015, 12:41:10 PM by Chris Brimley »
Logged

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #72 on: December 30, 2015, 01:56:53 PM »

Just for clarification on the 3/3 vs 4/4 vs 5/5, could either (or both) Chris(s) tell me what number my Acc row would translate to? That way I can keep up with the conversation a little better.

Thanks,
Baron
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #73 on: December 30, 2015, 02:13:32 PM »

You seem to have a non-repeating Acc row, but it looks closest to a 4,4 to me.

And some innovative 1st and 2nd rows too!  What was the design philosophy?
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #74 on: December 30, 2015, 06:18:51 PM »

I'd call that essentially repeating as there is only one exception, and repeating every 1, 2, 3, 4th button. So 4,4 in chris's new descriptor (which he seems to be trying hard to disagree with)!  ;D
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Baron Collins-Hill

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 232
  • Maine, USA
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #75 on: December 30, 2015, 08:27:37 PM »

Briefly, the attached layout (with old bass layout) shows that the Acc row (outlined in red) actually takes a turn down the knee end, and continues the pattern, which is fairly regular. The one exception to the regularity of the acc row is the C/Bb button, as I already have D in both directions thanks to the dutch reversal.

The instrument is 5th button start and fully dutch reversed on the G row (aka D/Em ala ukebert). If you disregard the chin end buttons on the D and G rows and the extension of the acc row, the layout of the D/G rows is identical to Bob Ellis' 4th button start layout, the exception being the dutch reversals.

The chin end button on the G row is the logical extension of what is going on in the rest of the G row.
The chin end button on the D row gives me a low C and a (out of place, but there none the less) low G pull.

And a link to a more in depth exploration of the layout:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,16417.0.html
Logged
D/G/Acc Castagnari Big 18 (full Dutch reversals)
Mandolin & Tenor Guitarist: Velocipede
Free Online Mandolin Lessons: MandoLessons

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #76 on: December 31, 2015, 10:03:17 AM »

Apologies, Baron, I'd temporarily forgotten the connection with your previous extensive description - many thanks for reminding me of the link.

Just a query on your comprehensive chord diagrams - do you suggest learning the patterns, or just reconstructing them prior to learning to play a particular piece?  I only ask because I suppose I use a mixture of the two - I know the basic home key shapes, but when playing say Fma7, I would reconstruct it by thinking - hmm, that's got F, A, C major triad plus E near the top, I'll work out how best to play that within the piece, and then learn it in muscle memory, hopefully also remembering that shape for new future uses.
Logged

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #77 on: December 31, 2015, 11:17:43 AM »

Baron, I was studying your layout diagram, and although we ended up with pretty different button arrangements, it seems that in terms of available notes, we're remarkably similar:

I looked at your RHS middle two octaves, starting with G, i.e. 3G-5G, in your numbering.  With my proposed layout, it's fully chromatic both ways over 2 octaves, with the exception of G# and Eb push.  With yours, if I've got it right, it's the same in both octaves, but you also miss a Bb push in octave 3-4.

In terms of effective overall range, yours is slightly greater, reflecting the 12-11-10 vs 11-10-11 layout, and the greater button economy you achieve by having in-row Dutch reversals.  It seems your design also recognises the need for a long Acc row, which you have achieved by 'bending' the treble end round onto rows 1 and 2, presumably reflecting the available Castagnari models?

In terms of LH layout, although at first sight different because mine's 14 bass and yours 18 and the layouts aren't the same, there's considerable similarities - you use the extra buttons for E/B and F/Bb reversal (the latter probably handy because of the additional RHS Bb push omission?), but you keep the 14-bass concept of bass-only F#, C#, Eb and G#.  You also sensibly swap my dodgy E major pull for a G pull.

Am I right that you ended up with your Dutch reversal design because you were previously familiar with its use?  I only ask because I'm wondering what your view would be on this:  Was it something originally devised as a handy two-row improvement, but which loses some of its point with a 3-row layout with a long acc row?
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #78 on: December 31, 2015, 11:57:48 AM »

makes a lot of sense on a 3-row with a standard acc row though. has this "long acc row" ever been built ?

Ignoring my 11/10/9 with accs on the outside. 10/11/10 is a standard, but longer rows on inside as well might make some makers nervous?
« Last Edit: December 31, 2015, 11:59:46 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: The relative merits of 3-row systems
« Reply #79 on: December 31, 2015, 12:22:59 PM »

The FR18 is 12-13-12.  I have set mine up with an extended version of my Tramontane layout. I didn't use this as an example because I thought it would have been a bit too model-specific, and many acoustic players don't like them much anyway.

Logged
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal