I'm pretty new to playing the melodeon, but have tried various ways of holding the few that I have. I found that my thumb ached somewhat when using the thumbstrap on my International 1-row, so after trying cobbled together single and double straps, eventually settled on a righthand wrist strap, with which I'm quite happy at the moment. My Hohner 1040 (1140, or whatever it is) is a tad bigger and heavier, but I seem to be getting away with the thumbstrap reasonably well on that. And, although I haven't played it very much as yet, the 3-stop National Band thing also seems quite comfy on just the thumbstrap.
Mind you, I've hardly played standing up, which might prove to be an entirely different kettle of fish!