Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!  (Read 6054 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Hasse

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 323
C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« on: April 30, 2016, 07:49:42 PM »

I know C#DG might not be the most common 3-row system round here, but any 2 or 3-row thought on this are very welcome

Gonna play tunes in mainly G, D, F, A  and the different related minors Gm, Dm, Am, Em, …

Bass side concerns:
I’ve put a stradella bass system on the layout below, but to be honest I’m not 100% confident when playing such system. Of course that might just be a habit issue, but nevertheless…

Been looking/testing different more traditional 12-18 bass setups for 3-row boxes, and there are so many variations! And when trying to make the bass side fit my treble side, this is the best 18 bass compromise I can come upp with:
D/A G/D G/G
A/E C/C  E/Eb
H/C# C/F F/Bb

Hard to choose - play it safe or go stradella...  ???

Treble side concerns:

I think I nailed it…, but I might be missing something?


Hopefully this post makes more sense than the original post?


Edit: New first post hopefully less confusing and more informative than the original post!
« Last Edit: May 10, 2016, 07:00:02 PM by Hasse »
Logged
Sweden, Skåne

Hasse

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 323
Re: C#DG basses - unisonoric or …
« Reply #1 on: May 10, 2016, 06:58:50 PM »

Changed the original first post. Hopefully it makes more sense now and are less confusing!

Been thinking about getting the C#DG system for a long while now, and after testing Chris Ryall’s box I decided - no more thinking and experimenting, its time to act! - but I’m not quite there yet and seem to enjoy the experimenting fare too much. So I need your help to finally place the order with Aaro Luukinen and start  :|||:

So please look at the first post!  (:)
Logged
Sweden, Skåne

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #2 on: May 10, 2016, 08:17:06 PM »

I'm not really qualified to judge, having not tried this system, but as a DGAcc player, can I just ask those who use it:  what is the benefit of having the F# and C repeats on the first and third row?  Wouldn't it be better to have reversals or something?  This is a genuine inquiry, because I don't really understand the principle of semitone-apart boxes - no axes to grind.  Your description of your intended playing needs closely matches mine.
Logged

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #3 on: May 10, 2016, 08:20:00 PM »

And I notice that on the bass you're missing F# and G# - you may want them later?
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #4 on: May 10, 2016, 08:34:47 PM »

I don't want to spoil your mood now that you are so close to a final decision, but my guess is that you won't find playing in F, Dm and Gm very easy with that layout. They are quite awkward on C#/D and I can't see how having a G row is going to make them significantly easier (on paper at least).

For those keys I think you would be better off with a C#/D/C, or a B/C/G, or a B/C/C#. Actually you'd be fine with just a B/C !

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #5 on: May 10, 2016, 09:02:56 PM »

I suppose I'm from the other side, Stiamh!: - if you want to stick to a few home keys, IMO DG/long Acc row offers a lot of advantages, and playing in 'slightly flat' keys may be one of them.  But I'm still curious to understand why, with a basically DG box, an extra semitone-apart row works better than a 'designed' row - however I'm willing to be convinced.
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #6 on: May 10, 2016, 09:16:34 PM »

I've no idea, Chris. Of course I would regard it as a basically C#/D box and am curious as to why anyone would tack a G row on there instead of more useful possibilties! (:)  However for serious playing in keys with one or two flats I reckon a plain old B/C would beat either of these possibilities.

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #7 on: May 10, 2016, 09:42:19 PM »

I agree  and would add that if going for a 3 row   so as to enable more keys the playing of  I  would very much recommend  going BCC#  , preferably with as many stradella as could be fitted to a particular box .

5 scales gives 12 keys ( and that includes on the row for 3 keys. Also all the 'accidentals'  with the exeption of Bb are available in both directions  ( there are 2 Bflats but both in same direction). The accidentals also fall readily to hand where you expect them to be.

Stradella bass is a lot easier to get the hang of than having to choose treble notes  to move the bellows in the right direction for a particular bisonoric bass note  .Just 12 thirdless  stadells  covers bass and major(neutral) chords  FCGDAE  aand 24 8x3 provided  bass, maj and minor chords  BbFCGDAEB. 

george
 
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #8 on: May 10, 2016, 09:48:53 PM »

I guess we'll never see eye to eye, Stiamh, on this, but I did like your comment.  I suppose for me it's about extending the home key playing possibilities, as opposed to being able to do everything somehow.  I'm trying to avoid entrenched viewpoints, but I'm still trying to understand how semitone systems offer intrinsically better logic than pre-designed Acc layouts - any comments on that one?
Logged

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #9 on: May 10, 2016, 09:56:06 PM »

And George, yes, the principle is understood - to the quint box player the efficiency in the home keys of the layout is the big attraction, however, and I think this was Hasse's starting point.  Is the best the enemy of the good?
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #10 on: May 10, 2016, 10:13:23 PM »

The DG home keys  of D&G!  are very easy on a BC and even easier on  a BCC#. This is particularly so if comparing  with  the popular 'row crossing to get better bass' on a DG.

G is all on the C row  exept for the Fsharps which are available in opposite directions on the inside and outside rows.

D, again, is nearly all on the C row exept for the aforementioned Fsharps and the Csharps which are also available in opposite directions on the inside and outside rows.

once you have got the hang of D & G you get  Eb and Ab thrown in entirely free of charge!

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Hasse

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 323
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #11 on: May 10, 2016, 10:41:54 PM »

Thanks all!  (:) I really needed this to rock my mind around a bit...

I am aware this is in most people view a very unpractical box. But it my twisted mind it’s almost perfect.

About playing Gm and Dm on the C#/D box:
Gm and Dm tunes do in fact work very well on the C#/D box … to a certain extend. ;D Tunes in some Gm mode play real easy,  Gm modes where the Eb note is rare and the F# and F frequently pops up, are really nice on the C#/D and very common in Swedish tunes. That also goes for Dm and even certain F tunes, but with that said the big weakness of the C#/D is the lack of reversed G, C, E and F. On a straight C#DG box you do of course get no reversed C,E or F unless you choose to put them there.

One reason I don’t go DG/acc is simply that it doesn’t work for me, I’ve tried and the flow just dies out and my brain/fingers go looking for the C# row. I’ve also been testing a G/C/acc box, a quite similar layout to my Anglo concertina, but for me the AC does a much better job with these tunes than a G/C/acc box.

And I do really get you point George about the BCC#, I've been thinking about going down that road, but for me I just tend to lose some of the obstinacy feeling of a melodeon and the C#/D when playing that system (mind you, not that I was never any good!!!).

The D/G and C#/D boxes are my home boxes and especially with the C#/D box I can see a lot of wasted potential in the ordinary approach to the box. Besides that I might just be getting too lazy learning yet another system.
« Last Edit: May 10, 2016, 10:51:53 PM by Hasse »
Logged
Sweden, Skåne

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #12 on: May 10, 2016, 10:51:51 PM »

Maybe you need a three row semitone system based on C#D either C#DD# or CC#D.  That would make George happy.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #13 on: May 11, 2016, 09:28:27 AM »

 :|glug
g
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #14 on: May 11, 2016, 09:46:20 AM »

I must say that from your latest post, Hasse,  I can see why you'd want the C#DG - you're effectively joining your other boxes together, aren't you?

Looking at home key playing, I must say personally I would find the lack of pull D and push C & E notes (except in one octave on the end of the row), quite limiting.  I suppose the main point of these reversals is to facilitate playing, which an end row button may not do?  However against this may be the possibilities of playing in other keys (not just the ones you mentioned), more easily, and your 12/18 bass proposal with its extra reversals rather than full range could certainly mean the RH reversals are less important.

I think that a decision on what to do will probably last you many decades of playing, and re-learning time is a significant issue to consider.

I think it's probably a wise decision you're making, but my own layout is so different in concept that I don't have the experience to comment further.
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #15 on: May 11, 2016, 12:57:59 PM »

You're right Hasse about Dm and Gm tunes being pleasant to play on C#/D - but it really depends on the type of tune. I play a few airs and a Carolan tune in Gm and they work well. It's a favourite key of mine for the fiddle and the moodiness carries over onto the box, equal temperament notwithstanding. My comments about Gm and Dm being awkward, Gm especially, were based on trying to get Irish reels flowing. Even when the Es are natural.

Throw in E-flats and it gets worse. Try to get that trendy tune Catharsis up to speed and report back on your experience... of course it can be done, but it's making life hard for yourself.

If you find the lack of reversals on C#/D limiting, I think a C row would make much more sense than a G row. Only B would be in the same direction as on your D row.

Hasse

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 323
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #16 on: May 11, 2016, 09:31:25 PM »

I must say that from your latest post, Hasse,  I can see why you'd want the C#DG - you're effectively joining your other boxes together, aren't you?
That’s true Chris, and I guess that´s why I’ve been both attracted and a little indecisive about the idea. It might actually be a waste of good reeds and this post have certainly served its purpose and given me a chance to rethink, reconsider and get new ideas!

I think it's probably a wise decision you're making, but my own layout is so different in concept that I don't have the experience to comment further.
Your comments so fare have indeed been very helpful, thanks!!!

Maybe you need a three row semitone system based on C#D either C#DD# or CC#D.  That would make George happy.
If you find the lack of reversals on C#/D limiting, I think a C row would make much more sense than a G row. Only B would be in the same direction as on your D row.
And both Theo’s  and Stiamh’s posts made me have a look at a C#DC layout I made a couple of months ago (basses incomplete), it could in fact after all be the best compromise for this 3-row. And who knows this layout might even make George happy  ;) even though I do put the C row on top in this layout...!  ;D

So I think I need to do some more time testing and thinking before making the final order.  :|||: 

Thanks for the help on this one!   (:)
« Last Edit: May 11, 2016, 09:54:12 PM by Hasse »
Logged
Sweden, Skåne

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #17 on: May 12, 2016, 08:34:04 AM »

Ah, there is something else I've found that might be worth sharing, if you're going for C#DC with bisonoric basses:

A year or two ago I experimented with the Atzarin system, which although very different from semitone systems, does shares the philosophy of not having home keys.  Unfortunately I immediately found I couldn't get on with Stradella basses because my LH fingers were the wrong shape to fit.  So I tried setting up RH Atzarin with LH bisonoric basses on my Roland FR18.  I stuck at this for a bit, but gave up.  I realised that a problem for me was the logic involved in working out whether on each note to play push or pull, which became too involved, if you also have to factor in the LH side considerations.  With the quint concept, bisonoric LH made sense to me because for many RH/LH combinations it works automatically, and all you have to do is to learn the exceptions where you need to change LH position or play a RH reversal.  With fully chromatic Atzarin RH, I would have still had to learn how to play pushes and pulls based on the LH, and that so restricted the RH fingering choice that it became little different from DGAcc, and then the other ergonomic disadvantages of that layout for playing in the home keys became apparent.

It seems to me that you might be better off with Stradella or unisonoric basses with your proposed layout, Hasse.  My working hypothesis is that bisonoric basses do actually work best with quint boxes.  others say that even then, unisonoric basses are better, and they may be right, I don't know.

An interesting question for me is this:  You've presumably learned both semitone and quint systems - from your experience, how do you see the lessons of each fitting together, or are you now abandoning the quint learning in your latest proposal?  Relearning can take very many years, I've found.
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #18 on: May 12, 2016, 08:55:18 AM »

Ah, there is something else I've found that might be worth sharing, if you're going for C#DC with bisonoric basses:
 .

It seems to me that you might be better off with Stradella or unisonoric basses with your proposed layout, Hasse.  My working hypothesis is that bisonoric basses do actually work best with quint boxes.  others say that even then, unisonoric basses are better, and they may be right, I don't know.

The big benefit of unisonoric bass is that you don't have to drive the treble end to fit the bass - both ends can be played separately so as to get the best out of each of them.  Compared to other unisonoric bass layouts stradella is entirely logical and is exactly the same to play in any  !  - you just start somewhere else and do the same.

As to the C#DC idea it makes much more sense, to me, to haave the C row first - you then have exactly the same scales as on  a BCC#  or other less common 3 row semitone boxes  which really are quite logical to play as all the accidentals you could ever want i.e. the full whack of them are readily to hand

 george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Chris Brimley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2038
Re: C#DG layout - feedback wanted, please!
« Reply #19 on: May 12, 2016, 10:04:35 AM »

3 row semitone boxes  which really are quite logical to play as all the accidentals you could ever want i.e. the full whack of them are readily to hand

George - for reasons of balance, and just to defend '2rowquint+longaccrow' here - this statement is equally true of DGAcc, but I think it's also true to say for the quint-based box the buttons are even more readily to hand in the home keys, but then often less so for others.  I see the quint-based system scoring better for easier and more expressive home key playing, the semitone system for other keys.  That choice is for the player to make, but I still think there's pros and cons for each.
Logged
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal