Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Down

Author Topic: Reeds, different makes  (Read 11373 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Cooper

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 705
  • Gaillrd G/C/#,Casta Allain8 GC,Lofft CF, giord ad
    • Cooper's homepage
Re: Reeds, different makes
« Reply #40 on: August 25, 2016, 09:07:28 PM »


Yes, I use Binci Pro.

John Spiers was on my stall at FolkEast yesterday comparing the two. His comments were that the DIX are more "spongy" than the Binci  ::)
In other words, the Binci reeds build to maximum sonority very quickly with a small increase in pressure, whereas the DIX reeds follow a more gentle curve.

My comments - Binci, hard and loud. DIX, colourful, harmonious, pliable and slightly Hohner-ish. Both are very delicious reeds indeed.
Logged
Please correct my English, it's been a while, and i like to learn.
And don't be so polite! I know i must be typing tons of stuff that a native speaker would say differently...please enlighten me.

www.wouterkuyper.nl
www.lirio.nl
www.trekzakacademie.nl

JohannPascher

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 55
Re: Reeds, different makes
« Reply #41 on: October 31, 2017, 07:08:39 PM »

On the history of Salpa and Antonelli I believe you are confused.
Around the year 2000 Salpa and Antonelli merged, I don't know if one took over the other or if it was more a equal partnership.  The new company had a new name Voci Armoniche.
[]


Salpa Antonelli and Siva= VA (Not for sure i was around  2000 in Castelfidardo and Salpa was still working, on a location that is closed down now. I don't know where the facility's from Antonelli und Siva have been at this time but the location where VA is now did not look new as i did get there the fist time a few Years later.

As for reeds from Harmonikas i have had all type of reed the produce. Now the have reeds with Italian Nastrino steel tongs as well. Shoes are made with spark eroding. DIX in Brass i fitted as well. I also had reeds from all other reed makers in Italy except Binci (binci i only know by testing boxes with binci reeds). At the moment i fit again two sets of reeds from Ciccarelli to two boxes. I don't see any difference in steel quality independent if the are from Harmonikas or from other makes. Ladisalv Titelbach says his stell is the same as the steel used in Italy and comes from the same supplier. Still there is a major diffidence if the are reworked by hand. The surface of tongues are harder as the body if the are machined.  If the final process is a sanding by hand or with a small tape sander as Ciccarelli and others are doing this the harder surface is removed. The new nastrino a mano from Harmonikas are outstanding if one looks for something special, but difficult to handle if tuned. Very loud reeds. Full dynamic. Still the sound is more like the older sound i am used to from boxes made in Vienna, but definitely also different as it is the case with the new DIX reeds the are nice but not equal in sound to the old DIX reeds. Lower pitched DIX reeds are not preferable because the don't give the same punch as comparable other reeds. One major diffidence might be found in the shoes. Older shoes-slots and newer are different because the way the are made varies. Harmonikas and Cagnoni, and VA (not quite sure if for all reeds) use now nearly equal machinery. Binci and Atigiana still relay on the old machines what results in tapperd slots. VA orders some Shows at Harmonikas. So in the end not all that comes from Italy is completely made in Italy. In the end reed sets are never exactly the same so quality from the same factory and with the same grad varies. So it is nearly impossible to compare. No objective data is available. Reed tolerance is only presented by one Factory.
Best regards, Johann   

PS: " His comments were that the DIX are more "spongy" than the Binci " i would add more spongy as any others. What means spongy? DIX reeds dot have as much spring stiffness as others. This results in a different behavior. If stiffness of reeds is lower as with other comparable reeds one of the major difference is that with more air pressure the pitch of the tone lowers but less stiffens lead to better response at low pressure. DIX reeds are not suitable for people that only want a very loud box, for gently playing the DIX reeds are perfect.
« Last Edit: November 01, 2017, 08:32:03 AM by JohannPascher »
Logged

squeezy

  • Quick starter (now lagging behind)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1317
  • Hohner Cornelia (mixte D/G/o&s)
    • www.johnspiers.co.uk
Re: Reeds, different makes
« Reply #42 on: October 31, 2017, 09:46:07 PM »

Hi Johann ... it was my comment that the reed was "spongy" ... I was not referring to the material that makes the reed, but the way it feels to me when played.  When you apply pressure to the bellows in an instrument with new DIX reeds, it takes a much bigger force to get the increase in volume I am used to in an instrument with Binci reeds - so as a player, DIX reeds make the bellows feel more spongy to me.

However you could also argue that this same effect in the DIX reeds gives extra subtelty and control over reed volume ... it all depends what you want the reeds to do as a player.
Logged
Squeezy

Sometimes wrong, sometimes right ... but always certain!

JohannPascher

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 55
Re: Reeds, different makes
« Reply #43 on: November 01, 2017, 07:03:47 AM »

On the history of Salpa and Antonelli I believe you are confused.
Around the year 2000 Salpa and Antonelli merged, I don't know if one took over the other or if it was more a equal partnership.  The new company had a new name Voci Armoniche.
[]


Salpa Antonelli and Siva= VA (Not for sure i was around  2000 in Castelfidardo and Salpa was still working, on a location that is closed down now. I don't know where the facility's from Antonelli und Siva have been at this time but the location where VA is now did not look new as i did get there the fist time a few Years later.

As for reeds from Harmonikas i have had all type of reed the produce. Now the have reeds with Italian Nastrino steel tongs as well. Shoes are made with spark eroding. DIX in Brass i fitted as well. I also had reeds from all other reed makers in Italy except Binci (binci i only know by testing boxes with binci reeds). At the moment i fit again two sets of reeds from Ciccarelli to two boxes. I don't see any difference in steel quality independent if the are from Harmonikas or from other makes. Ladisalv Titelbach says his stell is the same as the steel used in Italy and comes from the same supplier. Still there is a major diffidence if the are reworked by hand. The surface of tongues are harder as the body if the are machined.  If the final process is a sanding by hand or with a small tape sander as Ciccarelli and others are doing this the harder surface is removed. The new nastrino a mano from Harmonikas are outstanding if one looks for something special, but difficult to handle if tuned. Very loud reeds. Full dynamic. Still the sound is more like the older sound i am used to from boxes made in Vienna, but definitely also different as it is the case with the new DIX reeds the are nice but not equal in sound to the old DIX reeds. Lower pitched DIX reeds are not preferable because the don't give the same punch as comparable other reeds. One major diffidence might be found in the shoes. Older shoes-slots and newer are different because the way the are made varies. Harmonikas and Cagnoni, and VA (not quite sure if for all reeds) use now nearly equal machinery. Binci and Atigiana still relay on the old machines what results in tapperd slots. VA orders some Shows at Harmonikas. So in the end not all that comes from Italy is completely made in Italy. In the end reed sets are never exactly the same so quality from the same factory and with the same grad varies. So it is nearly impossible to compare. No objective data is available. Reed tolerance is only presented by one Factory.
Best regards, Johann   

PS: " His comments were that the DIX are more "spongy" than the Binci " i would add more spongy as any others. What means spongy? DIX reeds dot have as much spring stiffness as others. This results in a different behavior. If stiffness of reeds is lower as with other comparable reeds one of the major difference is that with more air pressure the pitch of the tone lowers but less stiffens lead to better response at low pressure. DIX reeds are not suitable for people that only want a very loud box, for gently playing the DIX reeds are perfect.

Thank for replay. It surly also makes a difference in witch box the reeds are fitted. But if i think about you because you are used to Binci reeds you are then happy with reeds that are on the top end if it come to volume only, reeds from Harmonikas with professional nastrno a mano wold top the volume.  DIX aren't comparable in this case the never produce the same or nearly the same Volume and if you try to use the reeds the same way it feels like you have described  - to push the bellows much harder. But if you do, the sound quality is really bad and you produce a sound that trops in pitch to much for most ears. On the other hand if the type of Musik and the way the instrument is played differ a lot so the musician may very much prefer the DIX reeds. It always depend on the viewpoint and that is also way there is never a absolut good or bad if it comes to reeds. Sure some reeds nearly every one would dislike but in most cases it depends what one wants or what one is used to. In most cases reeds don't behave the same all over the pitch range. Old reeds and DIX or other brass reeds never use the same thickness for shoes. Thinner Aluminium or brass on low pitch also results in less volume on the opposite thinner on high pitch reeds results in higher Volume. So if the same thickness of Aluminium or Brass as on DIX is used this also leads to a different balance from low to high pitch notes. There are even more differences if it comes to sound quality aspects.   Best regards Johann
« Last Edit: November 01, 2017, 08:37:24 AM by JohannPascher »
Logged

blafleur

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 530
Re: Reeds, different makes
« Reply #44 on: November 02, 2017, 12:48:28 PM »


[/quote]

As for reeds from Harmonikas i have had all type of reed the produce. Now the have reeds with Italian Nastrino steel tongs as well. Shoes are made with spark eroding. DIX in Brass i fitted as well. I also had reeds from all other reed makers in Italy except Binci (binci i only know by testing boxes with binci reeds). At the moment i fit again two sets of reeds from Ciccarelli to two boxes. I don't see any difference in steel quality independent if the are from Harmonikas or from other makes. Ladisalv Titelbach says his stell is the same as the steel used in Italy and comes from the same supplier. Still there is a major diffidence if the are reworked by hand. The surface of tongues are harder as the body if the are machined.  If the final process is a sanding by hand or with a small tape sander as Ciccarelli and others are doing this the harder surface is removed. The new nastrino a mano from Harmonikas are outstanding if one looks for something special, but difficult to handle if tuned. Very loud reeds. Full dynamic. Still the sound is more like the older sound i am used to from boxes made in Vienna, but definitely also different as it is the case with the new DIX reeds the are nice but not equal in sound to the old DIX reeds. Lower pitched DIX reeds are not preferable because the don't give the same punch as comparable other reeds. One major diffidence might be found in the shoes. Older shoes-slots and newer are different because the way the are made varies. Harmonikas and Cagnoni, and VA (not quite sure if for all reeds) use now nearly equal machinery. Binci and Atigiana still relay on the old machines what results in tapperd slots. VA orders some Shows at Harmonikas. So in the end not all that comes from Italy is completely made in Italy. In the end reed sets are never exactly the same so quality from the same factory and with the same grad varies. So it is nearly impossible to compare. No objective data is available. Reed tolerance is only presented by one Factory.
Best regards, Johann   

[/quote]

I had completely forgotten about this thread.  That is the report I was hoping for.  Johann, what do you mean "but difficult to handle if tuned"?

JohannPascher

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 55
Re: Reeds, different makes
« Reply #45 on: November 02, 2017, 03:06:15 PM »

Johann, what do you mean "but difficult to handle if tuned"?

Because the precision is much higher as on other reeds and the the shoes - frame slots are not tapered each little scratch on the edge of a tongue leads to blocked tongues, especially if one need to higher the pitch. So in most cases i have to use very fine grade sanding paper that i stick to a wooden stick with double sided tape instead of using files. Scratches to lower the pitch work as usual. Tuning work is all together a little bit more difficult as with less expensive reeds.  Also keep in mid that in changed temperature in colder environment the reeds tend to block more easily.
Logged
Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal