Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18  (Read 8198 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Schnorbitz

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 199
Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« on: August 10, 2016, 09:23:12 PM »

I've had the luck to play 3 different Castagnari Handry 12's over the past couple of weeks. All were absolutely lovely and probably the direction I'll go when I decide to upgrade to a much bigger box. Aside from the '3rd row tuning' debate, of which there are some really good threads already in the forum, I am interested in peoples view re the 12 / 18 bass options. I've not had a go on a Handry 18 so I do not know how much more weight the bases add or whether most people find the Handry 12 covers most of the options that people need bass wise. I would be really interested to hear peoples views.
Logged

benammiswift

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 158
  • Squeezing for Derbyshire
    • benammiswift.co.uk
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #1 on: August 10, 2016, 10:19:04 PM »

Hi there

First of all, if you want to try and handry 18 and are near Derbyshire it going to Whitby, drop me a PM and well sort something because you can have a go with both of my Handry 18s if you want to.

I have played quite a few handrys and really haven't noticed a difference between the 12 and 18 when it comes to weight, a weight difference between the handrys may change the feel of a smaller box entirely but because the Handrys are so big, it doesn't make much difference.

I'm glad I had 18 basses because I would have regretted just have 12, I love my 18 basses and couldn't live without them honestly. Everyone says that the Handry is quite and not rhythmic at all but I've found both of mine can beat any Dino binci that you can throw at it in terms of volume, tone, playability and in the end options because of the extra buttons.

To be honest go with what you feel is right, some people are confused by 18 basses and just can't handle them but I've found that I have no problem with all my basses and because I designed the system myself I know it through and through.

Just a few thoughts


Benammi
Logged
Castagnari Handry 18

robotmay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 820
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #2 on: August 10, 2016, 10:22:28 PM »

I've played 3 of the 18 bass ones, and about the same of the Mory (which is identical to the 12-bass, with 6 fewer treble buttons). I only really liked one of the 18 bass instruments, but all of the 12 basses I played I liked. I haven't really noticed the weight difference much, but it could be a factor for a lot of people. I'm not sure what it was about the 18 bass boxes that I didn't like, they just didn't feel very responsive to me. However all of the ones I've tried have been used, and likely set up quite differently.

Strangely, I'm finding myself less inclined towards 18 basses recently, as I've found that I'm actually very happy with the possibilities from a 12 bass. I don't even use the extra 2 basses on my 14 bass box very often ;D
Logged

pikey

  • Addicted to squeezeboxes since 1975
  • Thread mod
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3364
  • If it moves, I'll squeeze it....
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #3 on: August 11, 2016, 08:32:05 AM »

I think Acorn Instruments have a couple of Handrys for sake at the moment , and they'll be at Whitby .
Logged
Still squeezing after all these years.
Mostly on hohners , with a couple of Dinos and a smattering of anglos - and now a Jeffries duet

Kelpie

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #4 on: August 11, 2016, 02:11:11 PM »

I can only offer my thoughts from when I found myself having to make the same Handry decision a couple of years ago. These are things that could factor into your decision but I'm not coming down one way or the other.

I had always thought 18 bases to be superior, no question, but when I started to gather information two options presented themselves: retain the D/G dominance I had learned with (including style, finger patterns etc.); or try to create the most flexible system possible. This was the most important consideration for me, everything below is just incidental information.

It always depends what you want to use it for but my personal circumstances meant I stuck with the D/G system 12 base and used my extra row to maximise the utility of the bases (reversals and the like). To my mind there are more effective ways to achieve a flexible/chromatic layout on a three row (stradella base being the obvious one). Otherwise you run the risk of being in the same position as Benammi and having to kit out multiple, potentially quite expensive instruments (not many people can afford two Handrys).

I was completely converted from 18 to 12 over the course of my planning purely by what I saw in development (no-one ever told me one was better). I should mention the only reason I got the full third row not a half row was because the weight and cost increase was minimal for a significant return in the options it gives you. I found 12 bases reduces the weight on the left hand enough to make something of that size remarkably manoeuverable.

Disclaimer: I am not a huge base fanatic; whenever I have seen an 18 base in Britain (an increasingly common occurrence), most of the buttons never seem to get used and so are basically dead weight. This extremely anecdotal observation put me off 18 bases even further.

I don't like to comment on things like this because it's difficult not to get bogged down in information that is important to me but irrelevant to you, but I found this forum helpful when I had to make my decision and I learned a lot about my playing and what I wanted from the whole experience. I don't regret my decision and 18 bases have never started to look more appealing as a result.


Logged

benammiswift

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 158
  • Squeezing for Derbyshire
    • benammiswift.co.uk
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #5 on: August 11, 2016, 02:38:31 PM »

Hi

Just to reply to kelpie and add a few more thoughts.

Unlike kelpie, i am a bass fanatic and so I think that's why the 18 basses suit me better. There reason I have 2 handrys is because although I have DG Accidentals that can play on C and F quite easily, I decided that I'd buy a CF Accidentals Handry so I can tranpose down a tone easily and quickly, it's a very common thing to do, J Spiers, nick cooke, Saul Rose, Andy C all have a DG and CF for that reason. It also opens flat keys up a lot.

Having now had my Handry for nearly a year I've found that I would have struggled with just 12 basses as I do so much with my 18 basses but as kelpie said, it's whether you want to do a lot with the bass or not so much.

Just to add another point, I don't believe there is much if any tone difference between the two models because of the different grilles and bass sides.

Benammi
Logged
Castagnari Handry 18

Schnorbitz

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 199
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #6 on: August 12, 2016, 08:44:13 AM »

Thanks for the answers :-)

Whitby is a no for me (unfortunately), I have too much work on at the moment.

I am a fan of basses, the extra weight of the 18 would be a potential put off though (I suppose I will not know until I have given one a spin).

Kelpie, Benammiswift and Robotmay, as you have been through the same process as am currently going through, I would be really interested in what you chose on your 3rd row in the end for a G/D.

Logged

robotmay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 820
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #7 on: August 12, 2016, 01:45:40 PM »

I don't have a full 3-row yet, as I've only just played enough different boxes to find out what I fancy, but my 3-row layout will be very similar to my 2.6 row layout (when I eventually have the money for one). It'll also be in C/F, as I'm happy with my 2-row D/G box.

My 2.6 row layout is a slight alteration of the Francois Heim standard layout. So when I move up to a few more buttons I'll be getting that standard layout. It makes an awful lot of sense for me, as it works well for ornamentation, chords, and playing in other keys.
Logged

benammiswift

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 158
  • Squeezing for Derbyshire
    • benammiswift.co.uk
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #8 on: August 12, 2016, 05:48:30 PM »

Hi schnorbitz

If you give me a bell on Benammiswift@gmail.com then I'll send you my layout when I'm back off holiday but I have a full custom 3 row layout in DG Accidentals then CF Accidentals on the other which is the same just a tone lower.

Benammi
« Last Edit: August 12, 2016, 09:24:46 PM by benammiswift »
Logged
Castagnari Handry 18

Grape Ape

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1209
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #9 on: August 12, 2016, 06:08:51 PM »

I have an 18 bass box, with the extra buttons comprised of reversals.  While the twelve are all used fairly often, the extra basses almost never get touched.  I think the primary reason is that higher end larger boxes never seem to run out of air making the reversals rather unecessary.
Logged

Schnorbitz

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 199
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #10 on: August 16, 2016, 08:35:20 AM »

Quote
I have an 18 bass box, with the extra buttons comprised of reversals.  While the twelve are all used fairly often, the extra basses almost never get touched.  I think the primary reason is that higher end larger boxes never seem to run out of air making the reversals rather unnecessary.

Grape Ape - that is one of my main concerns with the extra bases. I can see where there 12 will take you, but am unclear how much you would use the additional 6 buttons. I had not thought of the physical dimensions of the box making the use of reversals less of an issue anyway.

Benammi - thanks, I have emailed you :-)
Logged

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #11 on: August 16, 2016, 03:02:38 PM »

My 2 cents here.

I'm using a 18 bass melodeon (a Handry) and I really think 18 basses are nice. I've attached the layout (it was transposed in D/G for better understanding). I do not pretend that it's the all-around best, but it suits me. I honestly couldn't play on a full 3-rows without it, not necessarily for solo playing but most of all when playing in a band.
When playing solo, most of the time I either play the regular bass/chord alternatively (as you would expect for any box) or just some counterpoint / bass line (often without the deep bass). The layout is somewhat versatile in that purpose, in that it has the bass/chord pairs for the home keys, and all the basses pulled and pushed (which helps a great deal when harmonizing, I do not have to overthink the bellows changes).
When playing in a band, especially when accompanying with right-hand chords, having all the notes (all the more in both directions) is really really nice and I wouldn't advocate for a 12-bass model in this respect, except if weight is a health issue for you. The weight difference would be somewhat negligible between 12 and 18 basses: you'll still have to adapt to a bigger box anyway, so why not have the benefits of a 18-bass model anyway ?

The rationale behind the suppression of additional chords on the third row is that it's difficult to have a standard melodeon playing in keys that are far from the home keys. It would be very difficult to achieve standard bass/chord alternates say in F♯ major for instance, so you'd as much drop them and benefit from having all the notes in both directions. That's the same kind of logic behind the left-hand layout from Stéphane Milleret and Norbert Pignol. If you're affrayed of not having additional chords, regular 18-bass layouts are fine, at least in my opinion preferable to 12-bass layouts.
« Last Edit: August 16, 2016, 03:52:38 PM by -Y- »
Logged

Schnorbitz

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 199
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #12 on: August 16, 2016, 08:03:04 PM »

- Y -, from your diagram do you just have basses in your third row with no chords?
Logged

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #13 on: August 16, 2016, 08:56:02 PM »

Yes that's it.
Sorry if I was unclear in the explanations above.
The idea is that as I wouldn't use the extra chords (I had them on my previous box but did not use them), I chose to remove them to benefit from having all the notes in both directions.
« Last Edit: August 16, 2016, 09:09:55 PM by -Y- »
Logged

Schnorbitz

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 199
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #14 on: August 16, 2016, 11:00:33 PM »

- Y-, ok that makes sense. Do you not miss being able to fork chords (on the top row) to bases on the other two rows?
Logged

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #15 on: August 16, 2016, 11:44:25 PM »

Not that much actually. I guess it really depends on what you want to play. All in all it's a matter of compromise, and the versatility of having the notes on both directions clearly makes up for the lack of additional chords.
If I had to buy one now, I would strongly consider going for a stradella system (like on chromatic accordions), you have roughly the same number of reeds, and not that much heavier (depends on the models actually, for instance Tania Rutkowski makes pretty lightweight ones), but with the advantage of having numerous chords and more logic in the layout.

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #16 on: August 17, 2016, 09:57:19 AM »

Not that much actually. I guess it really depends on what you want to play. All in all it's a matter of compromise, and the versatility of having the notes on both directions clearly makes up for the lack of additional chords.

While the "it all depends" is so, so true of all melodeon organology … be aware that there are 2 very different appraches to 18 bass. One is to extend from 6 chord pairs to 9. These might commonly be reversals of say your push G (enabling the pull Gm scales) or relative minors. You can actually do a lot of the latter on 12 bass by playing eg C against A bass to get a minor 7 chord, this available for all chords a minor 3rd apart and playing same direction ;) 

To do the same in major 7 territory you need 3rds out - many big basses have this anyway due to lack of space, an I think you'd be silly not to pay for an 18 without some sort of register at least

The "other" approach is full chromaticity. The layout was pioneered by Milleret and Pignol in Grenoble and first implemented by Gaillard. It is now available from many makers. Basically it is a 12 bass with an inner row of "bass only" are are just enough to fill in all the gaps! 

If your style is towards running a nice left end line and playing against that you might do better with 9 chords (Gaillards saphir offers only 8, but you get full 3 note maj/min triads and a switch)

The more you like jazzy stuff, and tend to make chords, express major/minor'ness on the right end keyboard, and play across the rows to get say a cool Cm dorian scale - the more I'd recommend the chromatic. As with the bass line in a group that bass "sets" the mode of chord to the ear, and in real play a run of basses can "feel" like full chords (more melodeon magic)!

This is my bass on accs/D/G - it plays nicely for usual scales, Bb,F,Gm,Cm and most blues. Note the 'standard set' core, outer 2 rows, head end. I have no 3rds, and never miss them

 F/Bb    Eb/F#  A/G  C#/C#  Ab/Ab  B/E
F#/Eb   chord   C/C   chord    E/ B  chord
Bb/F     chord   G/D   chord    D/A   chord

"Grenoble standard" would have Eb/F#s the other way to suit a different right end layout. 


[ed] apologies to -Y- it has just clicked that his diagram is "luthier layour" other way up. Mine is as seen by my left hand. There is much convergence, with difference that his chords extend into more sharps, mine into more flats. Again "it depends on what you play" and as such was a considered decision chez moi … I like blue notes ;) So there is another parameter to consider!
« Last Edit: August 17, 2016, 10:04:55 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #17 on: August 17, 2016, 12:13:15 PM »

I'm fully aware of the two approaches (I've been trying to explain them but I think that you've nailed it  (:)), and I fully agree with your views.

The Milleret/Pignol layout is probably a better compromise than mine, in the sense that it has the Eb chord, but I preferred to have more notes at the same place (easier for drones). It's a matter of choices and all in all doesn't change that much the philosophy. I find myself more and more composing manually chords without the deep bass register, it really isn't that difficult, and renders great.

Going back to 12-bass vs 18-bass, I find that full 3 rows with 12 basses lack the means to use all the potential of the full 3rd row, they feel to me as oversized 2.5 rows (and again, I'm not saying that as gospel, that's only my point of view). Moving from 2 or 2.5 rows to 3 rows is not an instantaneous phenomenon, and one day or another it's very likely that notes are going to be missing (otherwise it usually means that you're not using fully the 3rd row and that you'll better off with less buttons, it's lighter and cheaper), so it's a sensible approach to go directly for 18-bass models, if the budget follows (and for Handrys we're talking about big sums).
I want to point out that regarding specifically Handrys, there used to be a difference between 12 and 18 basses : the first was fitted with tipo a mano reeds while the latter was fitted with a mano reeds : it's no longer the case, they're both tipo a mano (but sometimes the price difference stayed... go figure).

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #18 on: August 18, 2016, 09:42:45 AM »

The Eb/F# direction decision was quite difficult for me and I originally ordered these 'other way up' - so a pull F# chord. This was in essence to run against the fluent F# pull Blues scale, that is sat there on any D/G.

But I discovered after a month or so that the benefits to Bb, Eb (and related C minor play) of having all three F/Bb/Eb chords on the pull were more attractive, the issue being that I sing in those keys. In essence the notes for these are all pull too (albeit in a strange sort of 'knight's tour' layout) on the right.

It cost about £20 to have the plates turned over by a box fettler, but I could have done it myself.  That was always my plan B(b)  ;) so don't be scared of a bit of experimentation. The best 'compromise' - and it is always a compromise - for chords in particular really does depend on what you play!   

But I would recommend both 'no 3rds' and the Grenoble 12 basses in both directions as truly liberating! I use them all now. (Yes, Stradella would be logical, but at 2-3 times the weight)

I can now express eg C major v minor on the right by playing E or Eb, and can easily hang a finger there while others diddle onto tune notes. And in songs like Caddick's Unicorns I get quite exquisite control of the change of mood.

OK .. so that's what happens to suit me, but I hope the concepts are more generally useful :|glug
« Last Edit: August 18, 2016, 09:44:31 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: Castagnari Handry 12 vs Handry 18
« Reply #19 on: August 18, 2016, 10:24:55 AM »

Yes, Stradella would be logical, but at 2-3 times the weight

Couldn't agree more with your message, except for this part. It depends on what you're comparing. If you're comparing to a regular 18-bass model, the weight difference is not that much. Compared to a Gaillard's left hand, yeah, right :D
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal