Yes - what Theo said.
There will be a leak somewhere.
If the cause is a poorly seating pallet (what you called a 'paddle'), it is surprising how even the slightest leak will cause the reed to sound, especially the small, high reeds which only require very little air anyway.
One way to test for a leaky pallet is to get a 'Rizla' cigarette paper and cut a narrow tapered strip, and use it like a feeler gauge. Open the pallet (press the offending button) and insert the narrow end of the paper underneath an end of the pallet and then release the button so it traps the paper. Gently test how much resistance there is when you slowly withdraw the paper. If the pallet doesn't 'grab' the paper there will be a leak. Test the pallet with the paper at points all around - the pallet may be contacting the sound board in one place and not another.
If there is a poorly seating pallet, the cause could be a weak spring, or the pallet being out of alignment and not seating flat all the way round, or something getting in the way of the pallet or action. Other less common causes of leaks could be a failing wax seal around the reed plates, or (much more rarely) a leak between the reed chamber walls, so that air leaks from one chamber into another.
But try testing the pallet seating first with the fag paper strip, as described, and then take it from there. As Theo says, returning the box to your fixer-upper, if possible, is your best option at the moment.