Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players  (Read 3480 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« on: October 29, 2016, 03:36:01 AM »

There's occasionally been talk along the lines of "why don't they make B/C (or other semitone-system) concertinas for box players?"

So here's something on the subject that I contributed to the thread Anglo Concertina In B/c Tuning? on the subject, on Concertina.net tonight:

Quote
Bear with me for a minute, but there are two technical issues to confuse the concept of such a beast as a B/C concertina.

1) B/C is a button accordion system, and (by definition) the lower key of B is therefore on the outside row (closest to the player's hand), and C is on the inside, furthest from the player's hand. So to achieve the same relationship between the rows you'd have to put the B row where the G row normally is on a C/G Anglo (so should we call it a C/B Anglo?  ???), and C would still be C, except see below...

2) The normal relationship between the buttons on the C row would work without problems on the left-hand side, but it would be wrong on the right-hand side because the sixth button of the B row (B/A#) on the B/C box should be located (inboard of and) between the fifth and sixth buttons on the C row (G/A and C/B) - but there's no button in that location in a normal 20-key Anglo layout...

So you'd need to shift the C row reeds "along one" on that side, and lose the top note. (It might even be useful to put an extra fifth pair of reeds (G/A) onto the (now empty) former C/B button, so that either hand could play those notes.

That way you'd end up with the layout:

                              LEFT                                                          RIGHT

 
       (E/A)     (G/B)    (C/D)    (E/F)    (G/A)       (G/A)   (C/B)   (E/D)   (G/F)   (C/A)

 
(D#/G#) (F#/A#) (B/C#) (D#/E) (F#/G#)              (B/A#) (D#/C#) (F#/E) (B/G#) (D#/A#)

 

Otherwise, the alignment of the two rows on the right could be modified if such an instrument actually went into production, so that you'd finish up with:

                             LEFT                                                            RIGHT

 
       (E/A)     (G/B)    (C/D)    (E/F)    (G/A)                  (C/B)    (E/D)   (G/F)    (C/A)   (E/B)

 
(D#/G#) (F#/A#) (B/C#) (D#/E) (F#/G#)               (B/A#) (D#/C#) (F#/E) (B/G#) (D#/A#)

 

Or (though this might be getting a bit too radical for the Anglo players! ;)) you could go for what box players call a fourth button start:

                              LEFT                                                             RIGHT

 
     (C/F)     (E/A)     (G/B)    (C/D)    (E/F)                      (G/A)   (C/B)    (E/D)   (G/F)   (C/A)

 
(B/E)  (D#/G#) (F#/A#) (B/C#)  (D#/E)                   (F#/G#) (B/A#) (D#/C#) (F#/E) (B/G#)

 
 

Hmmm!  :-\

Thoughts welcome!

richard.fleming

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #1 on: October 29, 2016, 08:42:54 AM »

How about a Csharp/D version too?
Logged
Old Paolo Sopranis in C#/D and D/D#

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #2 on: October 29, 2016, 09:12:37 AM »

My first thoughts are that it might be fine for melodic playing in the Irish style, just as you would on a semitone-tuned melodeon. But I wonder how useful it would be for anyone who wanted to play in the 'harmonic style', i.e. the melody mainly on the RH side and chords/accompaniment on the LH side.

The chord options on the B/C layout shown are somewhat limited. C major, A major, E minor, D minor, Bb major, B major and C# minor would be available with varying degrees of ease of fingering.

But as far as I can see, it is not possible to play the commonly useful chords such as G major, D major, F major, or A minor. To me, the absence of these chords and the lack of push/pull reversals other than B and E would be a severe handicap.

I think that if the B/C layout was going to be remotely useful for a two-row concertina, it would have been done by now.
I'll stick to my standard Wheatstone layout 30-key C/G anglo*, thanks!  :Ph

* on which it is possible to play all sorts of music (including Irish) very nicely.
Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #3 on: October 29, 2016, 09:55:24 AM »

the 4th button start looks as if it might be the best way to go and as most concertinas have 3 rows on each end why not add a C# row?

however, and nice as the idea of a semitone concertina is I would probably have a great deal of difficulty with the left hand stuff that the right hand is used to doing on a bc box and the left hand doing something completely different  on either 8 bass or stradella.

it might work for somebody starting from scratch or even for  concertina players  starting from scratch. Maybe  duet concertinerists would cope but  to me a better bet for a concertina like sound in a very small box would be a BC lilly with a handful  of single reed bass notes to enable chords to be formed as required  or maybe 12 or 14 stradella with very small (mouthie) reeds so as to fit!
george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #4 on: October 29, 2016, 12:18:45 PM »

... it might be fine for melodic playing in the Irish style, just as you would on a semitone-tuned melodeon. But I wonder how useful it would be for anyone who wanted to play in the 'harmonic style', i.e. the melody mainly on the RH side and chords/accompaniment on the LH side.

You're right about the 'harmonic style' of course Steve, but "melodic playing in the Irish style" is all I was thinking of it for, and B/C accordion players generally don't use the basses much, if at all (in many cases).

Quote
I think that if the B/C layout was going to be remotely useful for a two-row concertina, it would have been done by now.
I'll stick to my standard Wheatstone layout 30-key C/G anglo*, thanks!  :Ph

* on which it is possible to play all sorts of music (including Irish) very nicely.

And of course your standard Wheatstone layout 30-key C/G anglo is much superior as a concertina, but there are button box players who would like to have a concertina they can play easily, without having to relearn everything all over again.

Even Jackie Daly (who owns, and has been recorded on, a semi-miniature Jeffries) has said to me that he'd like to get a C#/D Anglo...

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #5 on: October 29, 2016, 01:05:30 PM »

How about a Csharp/D version too?

As a matter of fact, I've been thinking about that for a while, especially since Jackie Daly told me he'd like to try one.

And I've a likely candidate to convert too, in that I've a 24-key rosewood-ended Lachenal with problematic reeds (on mild steel reedplates that have rusted) just crying out to be re-reeded...

So that could be made into a full-blown 23-key C#/D keyboard:

                             LEFT                                                             RIGHT

 

       (D/G)   (F#/B)  (A/C#)  (D/E)   (F#/G)   (A/B)          (   )  (D/C#)  (F#/E)   (A/G)   (D/B)  (F#/C#)

 

(C#/F#) (F/A#) (G#/C) (C#/D#) (F/F#) (G#/A#)                 (C#/C)  (F/D#) (G#/F#) (C#/A#)  (F/C)  (G#/D#)

 

Malcolm Clapp

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1119
  • Loving my Hohner-reeded wet MMM CastaTommy
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #6 on: October 29, 2016, 01:26:04 PM »


... mild steel reedplates ...


Hmmm. I've got a set of these too. Don't know why I've kept them.
Were they Lachenal-made or replacements from elsewhere?
Whatever, they seem to have been a disaster.

(Apologies, as always, for thread drift/hijack).
Logged
Tuner/repairer, now retired.

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #7 on: October 29, 2016, 02:26:34 PM »


... mild steel reedplates ...

Hmmm. I've got a set of these too. Don't know why I've kept them.
Were they Lachenal-made or replacements from elsewhere?
Whatever, they seem to have been a disaster.

They seem to have been a short-lived experiment at Lachenal's, and only on cheaper models in the early 1900's, and (fortunately) they seem to be pretty rare. The one I'm talking about is #189633.

Quote
(Apologies, as always, for thread drift/hijack).

Accepted, as always!   ;)

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #8 on: October 29, 2016, 03:29:48 PM »

... as most concertinas have 3 rows on each end why not add a C# row?

Because, so far, the people talking of such a system have all been 2-row players George and, seeing that something like half the Anglos ever made have been 2-rows and those can be bought cheaply today because everybody wants 3-row ones, it's much more affordable/feasible to make a 2-row concertina (semitone-system) "chromatic".

But of course it could be done with a 3-row, preferably 36-key, Anglo - only they're expensive to buy, and space is short inside them, so the conversion would be much more complicated/expensive.  :(

Quote
however, and nice as the idea of a semitone concertina is I would probably have a great deal of difficulty with the left hand stuff that the right hand is used to doing on a bc box and the left hand doing something completely different  on either 8 bass or stradella.

You could try turning it upside-down to play the low buttons with your left hand - as (box player) Paddy Hayes did (for the same reason) when he borrowed Raymond Roland's 30-key Wheatsone and won the All-Ireland Concertina Championship on it in the 1980s. (I know because I was there, and knew the pair of them!)  ;)

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #9 on: October 29, 2016, 03:31:31 PM »

I have read about attempts to put a semitone system on Anglos before - among others, Jim Coogan had a D/C# made. IIRC he didn't get on with it at all, and neither did anybody else...

Bear with me now: I'm convinced that the killer advantage of the inside-out format of semitone button boxes (over outside-in layouts) is the ability to perform what I call the "semitone dips" that occur in many tunes that have chromatic passages in them or brief forays into accidental territory. These are often extremely easy to perform since the note that is a semitone below a "main" note (in the key of the piece, on the inner row) is always in the same bellows direction as the main note. With fingers sitting on or above the main row, there is usually an adjacent finger that can drop back to get the semitone on the outer row, or it can be sounded with a quick finger slide.

(Experiments have convinced me that these passages are much harder to execute on an outside-in box e.g. D/D# because the semitone below a main note is usually in the other bellows direction.)

Now I don't know much about fingering on the Anglo but am I right in assuming that each finger has a little group of buttons assigned to it? If that is so, how easy is it to play (for example) the notes d-c#-d? Would you have to hit them all with the same finger? If so... wouldn't this make a semitone system on the Anglo a lot less handy than it is on a button box?

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #10 on: October 29, 2016, 04:04:49 PM »

... how easy is it to play (for example) the notes d-c#-d? Would you have to hit them all with the same finger? If so... wouldn't this make a semitone system on the Anglo a lot less handy than it is on a button box?

There's a very good way to find out, and that'd be if I converted an Anglo into the C#/D one that Jackie Daly has been thinking about...

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #11 on: October 29, 2016, 04:36:50 PM »

how easy is it to play (for example) the notes d-c#-d? Would you have to hit them all with the same finger? If so... wouldn't this make a semitone system on the Anglo a lot less handy than it is on a button box?

The note sequence d-c#-d is very easy on a C/G anglo. C# is on the third row on the push on a Wheatstone layout, and usually both push and pull on a Jeffries layout. The notes D are available on the G-row push and on the C-row pull and either can easily be played with a different finger from the C# (in the most usual octave, C#5 is normally played with the RH index finger).
Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #12 on: October 29, 2016, 05:01:55 PM »

That's good to know, Steve, but I should have made clear that I was asking about the putative C#/D layout. I picked d-c#-d as an example but I'm thinking of all such sequences: a-g#-a, e-d#-e etc. in order to gauge whether the semitone layout would work well on a semitone concertina.
« Last Edit: October 29, 2016, 05:03:33 PM by Stiamh »
Logged

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #13 on: October 29, 2016, 06:15:39 PM »

That's good to know, Steve, but I should have made clear that I was asking about the putative C#/D layout.
OK - sorry, I misunderstood your question.  :|bl
Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #14 on: October 31, 2016, 12:50:32 AM »

That's good to know, Steve, but I should have made clear that I was asking about the putative C#/D layout. I picked d-c#-d as an example but I'm thinking of all such sequences: a-g#-a, e-d#-e etc. in order to gauge whether the semitone layout would work well on a semitone concertina.

Surely it would be exactly the same as it is on the box, with the adjusted row alignment I'm suggesting...  ???

(That's why I'm suggesting making it the same as an accordion, whilst previous problems with semitone-tuned concertinas may not have been helped by not doing so  :-\)

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #15 on: October 31, 2016, 09:31:20 AM »

Whilst this overlooks is that with these layouts you would need to train the left hand to play melody, and also learn how to swap the tune between hands where it changes sides. This is a very different approach from the melodeon, and would be a considerable learning curve, especially for semitone box players who may make little or no use of the left hand. It would not be as simple as pick-up-an-play.





Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #16 on: October 31, 2016, 11:14:22 AM »

Irish C/G/+ players are used to playing the melody on the left hand, so nothing new there. (And as has been discussed on here before, there are quite a few B/C box players who are very adept on C/G concertina). But can no tina player, Irish-style or not, answer my question by looking at Steve C's keyboard diagrams and tell me whether (without adopting an awkward fingering strategy) you would have to play those note/semitone-below/note patterns by pecking with the same finger?

deltasalmon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1002
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #17 on: October 31, 2016, 12:42:54 PM »

Someone, I think on this forum, had a semitone concertina that I tried. I think it was a C#/C? It doesn't really matter but it was a semitone system.

Before playing the melodeon, I played an Anglo C/G/+ box. Then I moved to B/C melodeon and finally C#/D melodeon. When I play melodeon for the most part I only ever use 3 fingers on my right hand. When playing the Anglo I would use all four on both hands and one general "rule" that I was told was to try to use the alternate keys to make it so that you never play two separate buttons with the same finger. With the semitone Anglo this was easy to do in the "home" key, playing a long the row, but I found it a lot more difficult to play in other keys while following that rule. The melodeon has larger keys that are closer together than the Anglo and it seemed a lot more choppy playing two buttons with the same finger on the Anglo than it does on the melodeon.

This was just what I thought, I think a few other people played the same semitone Anglo so maybe they had a similar or conflicting experience.
Logged
Sean McGinnis
Bordentown City, NJ, USA

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #18 on: October 31, 2016, 01:09:07 PM »

Irish C/G/+ players are used to playing the melody on the left hand, so nothing new there. (And as has been discussed on here before, there are quite a few B/C box players who are very adept on C/G concertina). But can no tina player, Irish-style or not, answer my question by looking at Steve C's keyboard diagrams and tell me whether (without adopting an awkward fingering strategy) you would have to play those note/semitone-below/note patterns by pecking with the same finger?

In my understated way I've already answered you Stiamh, though not outrightly because no such instrument exists at present to confirm it by actually playing on - so all anybody can definitely assert is that to play the normal notes assigned to those buttons on a C/G Anglo (e-g-e) is an absolute piece of cake with no problems whatsoever. Only, I'm a great believer in a practical trial and "the proof of the pudding is in the eating"!

But if the button allocations on the right-hand D row (or C row, depending on whether the concertina was C#/D or B/C system) were not offset as I'm suggesting, that combination (then equivalent to fingering c-g-c on a C/G Anglo) would be slightly less easy (for me anyway) and become problematic because it wouldn't be the same fingering as on a box...

Like I said, what I'm advocating is the need to align the buttons on the two rows the same as they are on a button accordion, instead of how they normally are on a concertina.

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: Designing a B/C concertina, for box players
« Reply #19 on: October 31, 2016, 01:24:47 PM »

Someone, I think on this forum, had a semitone concertina that I tried. I think it was a C#/C? It doesn't really matter but it was a semitone system.

But it does matter, very much - not only the key, but also which way around the two rows were, and how the button allocations on the two rows were offset...

That's why I'm talking about designing it for box players, to play across the rows, and not for straight-row concertina players - which it seems may have been the problem with previous attempts at such an instrument!
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal