My kit is full 3 row F#GC Gaillard, and C#DG van der Aa, 18 bass (12chords, otherwise 12 basx chromatic both directions) “same systemâ€.
I’d say that the Gaillard is the better made, but that the lightness of the vdA more or less balances. He gives me LMM 3 voice at the same weight as Bertrand’s LM bandonèon 2 voice. I play the vdAa much more, but that is in an English mixed song/music session context.
Little to choose between them overall. The vdAa is the more “attacking†in terms of tone. But that’s mostly due to having the 3rd voice.