Thanks for that feedback, Katie. Since starting this thread, I've been playing close attention to how other one-row players use their fingers which has been very instructive. Most of them did indeed only use three fingers, with the fourth finger coming into use occasionally. I decided to experiment a little myself, as there were certain aspects of my playing that I had been struggling with at the time of starting this thread. Here's what I've done...
While learning new tunes, I began to use three fingers more prominently, using the pinkie finger only as necessary. This meant that my hand would travel up and down the row a little more frequently than I was accustomed to, having in the past always used four fingers for four buttons and kept hand movement to a minimum, a practice I had assumed was considered "good form". I assumed that anything different would be considered poor form and would actually limit my playing. However, now that I've been trying it out, I must admit to noticing some real benefit! I still use my pinkie, but I use it less, and the greater degree of control I'm experiencing favouring the first three fingers has been worth it. I would definitely say that this is improving my playing.
Making a change of this nature is, as someone in an earlier post or thread once mentioned, not something that necessarily happens overnight. It's not without its challenges. It's like learning a new language. With the increased finger movement, I now have to rethink my choice of fingerings when learning a new tune. There suddenly seems to be a whole lot more options about how to navigate the keyboard on a tune, whereas with four fingers on four buttons it was a little more straightforward, albeit at a cost. On tunes that I already know and play well, I stuck with my old fingerings. New tunes and tunes that needed work are being approached from a different angle now.
Three fingers or four, in ITM I'm still amazed how you sometimes need to go from one end of the keyboard to the other, and then back again in a very short span of time, and still play about every single available note in between...
