Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: They are Soundboards  (Read 3080 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
They are Soundboards
« on: June 24, 2017, 05:58:44 PM »

Hi all,

herewith a nicely provocative discussion for the Festival Season!

I carried out the experiment described below 2 or 3 years ago. But I always seemed to have a batch of orders and better things to do than write it up.

The subject of ‘Soundboards’ often meets with the insistence that the material of a soundboard has no influence on the tone of an instrument. Indeed, the very word ‘soundboard’ is claimed to be a misnomer. Similarly, the material of a melodeon’s case is held to have no relevance on tone; anyone who thinks otherwise is portrayed as either ill-informed of acoustic theory and/or ‘hearing things’ … one contributor emphatically states ... "First of all: a ‘soundboard’ is not a soundboard and it's not about ‘transmitting vibrations’...."

I beg to differ ... strongly. ‘Transmitting vibrations’ is what it is all about, as the experiment below demonstrates.

They are Soundboards

Paul Groff has good insight into the matter where he states, "for my part when I use the word ‘soundboard’ I don't mean to imply that this part of an accordion functions like the soundboard of a guitar, or of a piano, concertina, etc.... My view is that I think the parts of many different kinds of instruments that have traditionally been called "soundboards" in english function in many different ways, so it would be wrong to assume that the name implies a particular function that is the same in every instrument."

Exactly … the claim that a melodeon “doesn’t have a soundboard”,  because this “doesn’t function in the same way as a violin/mandolin” is trotted out every time the discussion takes place. But this is a ‘fallacy based on a statement of the obvious’. Of course, an accordian/melodeon doesn’t have a soundboard which functions in the same way as in a violin or guitar … it functions in the way a soundboard works in an accordion/melodeon.

So, what is a soundboard? Wikipaedia states (I haven’t the time to source a more academic authority), "… any hard surface can act as a soundboard. An example is when a tuning fork is struck and placed against a table top to amplify its sound."… and if you place a tuning fork against different surfaces, you will get completely different sounds/timbres, depending on the nature of the material. Moreover, that sound vibration will travel along the surface with an efficiency that depends on the nature of the material.

If you think about it – a free reed is not so different from a tuning fork. You can take a melodeon reedplate and ping the reed, placing it against different surfaces to hear the varied results.

Method

The experiment below was done using a Hohner 1040. Anyone who has played, worked on and examined a Hohner 1040, where the reeds are mounted on chambers flat against the soundboard, can be in no doubt that the soundboard is integrally associated with the immense sound that roars out of these fantastic boxes. When you play one of these 1040s the sound is so obviously flooding from the entire treble end. You can touch the outer surface of the soundboard when playing a 1040 and the whole thing is buzzing and alive with vibration. The notion that this strongly vibrating surface makes no contribution to the perceived sound/tone etc is, at the least, unlikely.

The experiment I devised to test this involved muffling the outer surface of the soundboard on a 1040 with thick carpet underlay, whilst leaving the pallets clear to open. I did this under (reasonably) controlled test conditions, with the underlay in different positions. The 1040 was then allowed to fall to a closed position, with the same series of notes being played in each case. I made sound recordings of the results. Those sound recordings and visual display through Cubase are shown in the following (‘continued’) post. Owing to the compressed quality of the soundfile, the visual displays are probably more convincing.

Photo A shows the experimental set-up, using Brian’s 1040 in all its full ‘roaring glory’, which was then allowed to fall to a closed position playing a series of notes. This was done from the same height in each test, using the ruler as shown.

Photo B shows the Instrument set up with most of the soundboard outer surface muffled with Carpet underlay.

Photo C shows the area immediately surrounding the pallets blocked off with underlay – this was as a ‘control’ so it could not be argued that the change in sound between A and B was due to the underlay blocking lateral transmission of sound from around the open pallets

Photo D shows not only the soundboard, but the entire treble end outer case covered with carpet underlay.

(Continued next post)
Logged

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #1 on: June 24, 2017, 06:08:54 PM »

(continued from above)

Results and discussion.

According to the ‘it’s-not-a-soundboard’ argument, there should be no significant change in tone or volume between A, B, C or D, since the only role of the fondo/soundboard is to provide a neutral, stable interface between the reedblocks and pallets, with the entirety of the sound emanating through the fondo/soundboard apertures.

In fact, there is a noticeable change in tone and volume when you muffle the soundboard.  Furthermore, there's not only a noticeable change when you muffle the soundboard - if you ALSO muffle the outer casework, there's an additional drop in volume and change in tone. Photo/test D suggests that the soundboard (and/or resonance throughout the treble end) also transmits vibrations to the casework, whose own vibration then contributes to the perceived tone.

The Cubase visual display of the 4 recordings, A B C and D, demonstrates beyond ANY dispute that muffling the soundboard of a 1040, and also its outer case, reduces the resulting volume and tone.

But why should this be such startling news? Why should these be such contentious assertions? On many well-built melodeons (not just the 1040 model), you can actually feel the casework and soundboard buzzing … they are alive, like electricity... not dead pieces of wood whose only function is to hold the reeds rigid whilst these make the air vibrate.

But there’s more. The equally important counterpart to this transmission of energy by vibration of the soundboard/case is that the sound/tone within the chambers, and emanating through the apertures, will have been altered as a consequence. A vibrating soundboard means that sound within the chambers has undergone partial and selective absorption within the instrument, which means that the remaining sound - the element and spectrum of the sound exiting through the apertures - will be altered as a consequence. Thus the vibration of the soundboard has, in a sense, a secondary effect. All of these subtle effects interplay and contribute to the overall audible tone of a melodeon, by vibration, absorption, transmission and dissipation.

If you add to these considerations the acoustic effect of the volume/space within the chambers and between the reedblocks, the quality of tone in a melodeon is probably as complex and subtle in origin as the elements of construction producing good tone in a top violin. With a melodeon/accordion, it is not just the reeds you are hearing … it is the sound of the reeds interacting in a myriad ways with the wooden and metal structures and spaces that hold and encase those reeds.

Of course, it is possible to construct a melodeon where the soundboard is completely unresponsive and the case is so thick, that the energy transmitted to the soundboard/case is lost/dissipated. Many modern melodeons are, indeed, so heavily-built that the dominant sound coming out is indeed from the soundboard apertures. As one pro-player commented to me “top end reeds buried in a bloody wardrobe”. But it doesn’t have to be that way …. as the ‘light-build’ nature of Hohner and Oakwood instruments show.
One of the tragedies of this soundboard debate, and the reason for posting this, is that a potentially valuable and fruitful line of discussion and development has been killed off by the imperious statements that "it's not a soundboard"...

Well it jolly well is!

That's what this stance has done - it has killed debate. I contend that the soundboard in a melodeon influences the sound (a) by its outer surface vibrating and thus contributing to the audible tone, and (b) by transmitting those vibrations to the outer case, which then similarly vibrate and contribute to tone and (c) by selectively absorbing energy and thus altering the remaining air-born sounds that exit through the apertures. If these contentions are to any extent true, it then follows that the material of the soundboard and of the outer case will both influence that vibration, transmission, absorption and resulting aggregate sound.

Just a final point – I’m definitely NOT arguing that you need to ‘maximise’ the soundboard’s role in absorbing/transmitting vibration – there is an optimum in everything. My aim is just to argue that this function occurs and account should be taken of it, and also its corollary in absorbing/altering the sound emanating through the apertures. The pursuit of good tone in a melodeon will be a balance between acoustics and the properties of the materials used – rigidity/thickness/transmission/ absorption. It’s a matter of more fully understanding what the heck is going on in these wonderfully complex instruments.

These absolutely are soundboards… they are melodeon soundboards, and the materials of this, and of the case, absolutely matters.

As a final comment, and an example of why this debate is so important … in recent years I have produced a fair number of 3-voice Pokerwork/pressedwood/Erica and Erika instruments, converting these from standard 2-voice instruments. When designing and making prototypes of these some 4 or 5 years ago, the instruments tended to suffer from the common malady of 3-voice boxes, where the inner row has slightly muted volume/tone… due in part to lower pallet-lift of the inner row.
I then decided to experiment with glueing down the innermost reedblock. I’ll leave Paul Groff to explain the rationale in a discussion by him about vintage Scandalli instruments …

“One of the best-balanced examples of these I have had has its reedblock for the inside row glued right to the soundboard, while the outside-row reedblock is removable via screws as is more typical. While the glued-in reedblock is more trouble to tune, it does couple the reed vibrations to the box more efficiently. So the volume and timbre of the inside row of that one is nice and bright, a perfect match to the outside row!”

Oll an Gwella, Paul!

Mike Rowbotham

Logged

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #2 on: June 24, 2017, 06:17:48 PM »

(continued from above)

MP3 of Soundboards Experiment ... Tests A, B, C and D played in sequence

Logged

Phil B

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 118
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #3 on: June 24, 2017, 06:42:22 PM »

Michael, I have heard on several occasions verbal explanations of your experiment, I am pleased you have found the time to assemble it together in print , photo and sound .
I look forward to reading the discussion it generates Phil B
Logged

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #4 on: June 24, 2017, 06:52:11 PM »

cheers Phil, and we'll see you all tmrw at Frogmore!

Mike and Elli
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #5 on: June 24, 2017, 06:55:43 PM »

Hi Mike,

Thanks for your work on this! 

I will take photos of the Scandallis (various similar but not identical small 2 row, 2 voice diatonics, each with 2 melody reedblocks) that I was comparing in that earlier discussion and post those pics to this thread. 

Re: gluing down the melody-side reedblocks, serious makers such as Olav Bergflodt who have experimented in pursuit of (their personal ) ideal tone quality and response have also advocated for this type of construction. 

What is interesting about the comparison of several somewhat-similar Scandallis is that in some of them both melody reedblocks are removable. But in the one with a single reedblock glued down (the one corresponding to the inside row of buttons, with shorter pallet levers and pallets closer to the keyboard), the fact that it's glued down seems to compensate for the "muted" tone quality we often hear from that inside-row reedblock. It's a very intriguing comparison.

I've also seen modified instruments where the design was altered so that the soft leather gasket was removed and once-removable reedblocks have been glued down (*), with a goal to improve the coupling of vibrations between the block and the soundboard. 

It seems you have done this with some of your modified boxes, but I don't know if you have tried doing so without any other modifications (i.e. with no reedblocks added etc). That latter experiment could be done on any box (sacrificial pokerwork?) and you could design your modification to keep the distance of the airway constant (by inserting a shim of wood etc, drilled for the airways) when removing the soft leather gasket to couple the blocks more rigidly to the soundboard.  Might be interesting to try the inside row block first (as with that Scandalli), then the block for the outside row, to test for an audible effect.

PG

*or the gasket replaced with two closely-fitted machined aluminum surfaces, in the case of one modified Amatona

« Last Edit: June 24, 2017, 06:58:22 PM by pgroff »
Logged

bellowpin

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 119
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #6 on: July 02, 2017, 05:12:30 PM »

Hi all,

 



The experiment below was done using a Hohner 1040. Anyone who has played, worked on and examined a Hohner 1040, where the reeds are mounted on chambers flat against the soundboard, can be in no doubt that the soundboard is integrally associated with the immense sound that roars out of these fantastic boxes. When you play one of these 1040s the sound is so obviously flooding from the entire treble end. You can touch the outer surface of the soundboard when playing a 1040 and the whole thing is buzzing and alive with vibration. The notion that this strongly vibrating surface makes no contribution to the perceived sound/tone etc is, at the least, unlikely.

              I note that on many boxes the keyboard is mounted directly onto the lower part of the "fondo"/soundboard with two screws . could this dampen that part used by the inner row of buttons?     the sound is "different" with the keyboard removed.   would it be better to mount the keyboard to the outer casing somehow?..      just a thought,  brian..
Logged
whole life in the shropshire hills. on the slow track and enjoying it.

Broadland Boy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1243
  • Awful noises from Pokerwork, HA114G, BbEb Liliputs
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #7 on: July 06, 2017, 12:17:01 AM »

Would recording the sound or vibration (mic or transducer) sufficiently capture the variations so that run through something like a spectrum analyser these could be defined ? Throughout all the discussions on sound issues like this, and particularly materials / geometry, contributors have done their level best to convey the perceived effects or differences - experienced tuners know how to produce (or supress!) particular sounds but with everybody's ear being different it always seems to fall over in the communication.

Perhaps this might be an opportunity for science to quantify what you chaps are able to produce from maybe less than perfect conditions using experience, skill, instinct and quite possibly black magic and establish some general design or construction principles which future box designers or makers could adopt (or avoid).

'Fraid I have neither the knowledge or equipment to offer my services in experimentation, however, assuming I could grasp the requirements, I'd be happy to help with some data collating or wrangling.

If starting to invent the melodeon these days soundboard or fondo would probably be valveboard or portface !

PS, delighted that you are remaining with us Mr R :) 

« Last Edit: July 06, 2017, 12:18:45 AM by Broadland Boy »
Logged
Richard A
Venit ventus contrarius ventus egrediente,
Omnes prope quid ventum est circa

malcolmbebb

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2628
  • In dampest Dorset, on the soggy south coast.
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #8 on: July 06, 2017, 08:34:37 AM »

One effect of fixing either a reedblock or a fingerboard would be to stiffen the "soundboard" and make it less likely to vibrate, at least at lower frequencies.
Gluing or rigidly fixing will improve the coupling, but also improve the stiffening.

Similarly, it is rigidly fixed along all four edges to a stiff framework.

In addition, it has one or more rows of spring loaded felted dampers across its middle which will not do wonders for its ability to vibrate. 

It might seem reasonable to conclude that this form of sound transmission occurs in spite of, rather than because of, the construction.
Logged
Dino BPII.
"Tradition is not the worship of ashes, but the preservation of fire."

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #9 on: July 06, 2017, 10:43:43 AM »

As usual, I'm not afraid to comment from my default position of complete ignorance!
It seems obvious (to me) that a vibrating reed mounted absolutely rigidly, will produce its pure sound. Anything and everything which "softens" the mounting will have an effect on the sound, even a different direction of the grain in a particular piece of the wooden construction. Some differences may well be indistinguishable to human ears, but I'm persuaded that they will be there, nevertheless.
The same goes for the shape and size of reed chambers and appertures, and consequent flow of air/sound waves. The size and shape of the surrounding casework is also bound to have an effect on the sound, although I imagine that this would be more because of air/wave flow than of any deadening effect of any particular construction material.
Microbot's experiment with felt on the soundboard, would surely have a partial effect on the movement of air, as the felt would absorb and "filter" at least some of the air (and sound waves), changing wave frequency and dissipating the speed/volume of air travelling directly between reed and the outside of the grille, or the open air.
A (very) simple experiment showing the effects of rigidity and air/wave flow is to hold a reedplate between a finger and thumb and twang the reed in the open air. The tighter one grips, the purer the note. Conducting the same experiment in an open shoe box gives more space for variation, which can only be due to the movement of the air/waves.
In conclusion, I would venture that, as construction technique/materials/design etc etc are as infinitely variable as our individual auditory preferences, we're wasting time discussing such intricacies when we could, instead, be playing our "favourite box of the moment"!
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

Stockaryd

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 255
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #10 on: July 06, 2017, 11:30:54 AM »

Nice to see this thread.

I have missed this. Perhaps because Midsummer (June 24) is a big weekend in Sweden. BIG. !

Microbot's thoughts and opinions seem logical to me.   
The experiments seem totally convincing.

My own skill is far too low to make my own judgments.

I like when you think outside the box (and inside too).

Hope it's OK if I continue to use the term fondo? 
Logged
Hohner Corso, Hohner Erica, Emmanuel Pariselle, Gessner,   Koch,   Mariotti,    "China  NoName",   4 Toy,     -and now some more

Rob2Hook

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2278
  • Castagnaris, Hohners & Baffetti
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #11 on: July 06, 2017, 03:27:44 PM »

I was stuck by the parallel with the story of the development of the Les Paul electric guitar.  Of course, being electric, there is no direct benefit from the choice of material for the neck and body yet Les Paul himself said that the materials should ideally not transmit vibration, allowing the string to vibrate uninfluenced by the structure of the guitar.  In practice the original choice was a mahogany body capped with 3/8" of maple, a mahogany neck with either rosewood or ebony fingerboard.  Even Gibson admit that their all mahogany bodied models have a different tone.  LP commenting on the DeLuxe model said it sustained better and it had a maple neck.

All this suggests that even when the material does not have a primary effect on its function, it will give some coloration to the tone.  All things considered (no - too many variables) I have always thought there was a pronounced difference in tone between a wooden soundboard or an ali one in a melodeon.  Perhaps my ears are too old and insensitive to take it further, or maybe it's just that there are indeed too many variables to pick out the smaller nuances.

Rob.
Logged

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #12 on: July 06, 2017, 04:02:45 PM »

The original objection to the term soundboard was that, in contrast with stringed instruments, it's not the PRIMARY sound of sound in a free reed instrument. What ever else happens in a free reed instrument, most of the sound results from the air flow though the reed being chopped by the reed alternately obscuring and clearing the slot in the reed plate, and a fair amount of shaping of the tone results from resonances in air cavities near the reed both inside and outside the box.

Of course the case vibrates a bit and thus transmits some sound, and quite a lot of sound inside is transmitted though the bellows, but these are all secondary effects. They will affect the sound you hear, as Microbot has confirmed, but they only make a small difference.

If you wrap a towel round the bellows, it will sound different, but it will still sound like a melodeon.
If you could place a microphone near the bellows and somehow acoustically block all the sound coming out of the grille, it would sound much quieter, and very different.
A contact transducer picking up the case vibrations would also sound very unlike a melodeon, probably picking up lots of key and handling noise and the ringing of reeds continuing to vibrate after a note has finished - quite different and not nice at all.

Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #13 on: July 07, 2017, 05:58:46 PM »

I hate to point this out, but by doing this you haven't proved that the "soundboard" radiates a significant amount of sound and that the material it's made of makes a big difference...

What you've shown is that putting a lot of sound-absorbing material on the soundboard around/near the pallets affects the sound -- which is not surprising, it would do this even if the soundboard was infinitely rigid and not moving at all, because the material also absorbs radiated sound from the pallet holes, especially at high frequencies.

If you want to prove what you claim, then you need to do two tests; one with the material glued down to the soundboard so it damps the vibration, and one with it suspended just above the soundboard but not touching it so it absorbs the same amount of sound from the air but doesn't damp the soundboard.

My prediction is that there will be very little difference, because most of the sound comes from the air passing through the reeds, not radiation from the soundboard...
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Garry Probert

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 296
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #14 on: July 10, 2017, 08:19:28 PM »

Hi guys, no expert on melodeon soundboards but mine must be defective as the reeds seem louder outside on the tuning rig lol
on the project i,m making an aluminium fondo like one of the swanky makers listed on the forum ,and my liliputs are all just plywood?do other melodeons expensive ones have solid wood /spruce? fondo,s

Would it be better to "NOT" mount the buttons on the fondo i,m just making the button mechanism so could easily mount differently?   
Excuse my stupidity but don't the pallets dampen? I thought rigidity was what was wanted? my fettled liliput that has a brace between the reed blocks and extra blocking and is the loudest,but is volume the primary aim?

Crap chinese stings on a quality fiddle equal a crap sound,quality string on a mediocre fiddle can be wonderful
are the reeds effectively the strings? is there a build formula one could use?

Melodeons are strange beasts my preferences seem to change with my perceived ability lol,as i,m backing off and more fluent with the bellows and buttons the Bb/Eb (airtight quick responce bright) thats seemed harder to play at first feels easier now ,that the less dynamic? one       

I,m not really knowledgeable enough with melodeons to know what i,m actually trying to achieve,I have some wonderful rosewood guitars sets left?           
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #15 on: July 10, 2017, 09:54:24 PM »

I agree that reeds sound louder on a reed block outside the instrument. I don't think the rondo acts like the soundboard of a stringed instrument.  On a free reed box all the other parts of the instrument are to some extent in the sound path to our ears and the sound has to find its way through the materials or through relatively small spaces.  All these obstacles act as filters which selectively absorb parts of the the sound and in that way give each type of box a recognisable sound quality.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Garry Probert

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 296
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #16 on: July 10, 2017, 10:55:14 PM »

Hi theo
Quote
All these obstacles act as filters which selectively absorb parts of the the sound and in that way give each type of box a recognisable sound quality.
I suppose that's the difficult bit,and the different components used all have a subtle difference  ,like even just removing the grill

The only experimenting i've really done is swapping hohner reeds with possibly the lightest cheapest reeds available " junior bontempi accordion" and even to my untrained ear they were thin and shrill in the hohner liliput ,as i,ve changed parts of the layout and didn't want to mess with the original liliput bass and chord reeds. I used zinc ones from an old quality pa and they sound great and matched the others really well

I bet top quality reeds would be even better than liliput reeds irrespective of the housing,I've seen ads for vintage melodeons with upgraded handmade italian reeds and the boxes we obviously not originally designed for these reeds so i,m assuming  the box doesn't have the level of impact i was assuming it had.

Can one buy a swanky Castagnari (quality) melodeon same box different  quality reeds?or is each box designed specifically for
Quote
All these obstacles act as filters which selectively absorb parts of the the sound and in that way give each type of box a recognisable sound quality.
really like that summing up ,i can get my head around it           
Logged

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: They are Soundboards
« Reply #17 on: February 07, 2018, 11:48:18 AM »

I've been redirected here thanks to Steve_freereeder, and wow, the work here is impressive.
If I've read other soundboard related posts correctly, that's the first documented attempt at assessing the influence of soundboard over accordion sound. So kudos to you Microbot.

As for what you demonstrated, I'm not really convinced. Said without any mean intention, I'm rather under the impression that you demonstrated how one can muffle the sound of an accordion. Personnaly, I didn't hear any difference in terms of sound quality or timbre, except maybe for set-up D, which is softer and quieter. Regarding the soundwaves, well, I beg to differ on the fact that it constitutes an indisputable proof. A and C are quite evenly matched in terms of volume, as are B and D, and, it would need a 2-D spectrogram to confirm an influence over the tone.

I feel it has to do with the protocol: is muffling the soundboard really the most relevant course of action to investigate the soundboard effect ? Let's say it is: how can you disentangle the effect of the soundboard itself from the filter effect of the carpet you use ? In the case of set-up D, the fact that you changed more than one factor (by covering the remaining of the accordion) is not ideal to compare to the others.

That being said, I concur with the remaining of your argument. The complexity of the accordion (it has a great many number of parts, mechanisms and such) cannot be summed up as: the soundboard has no influence. I feel that your explanation about the soundboard as good as proves that what we call soundboard is not even close to having the same role in an accordion than in, say, a violin. Hence, I think, the initial objection about using the same term. In the sense that in an accordion, the so-called soundboard doesn't amplify the sound as it does in stringed instruments (or at least, it isn't demonstrated yet), it acts, as Theo said, as a filter (and also a transmitter). Which is also very important on the sound quality. And I think I'm not the only one that would be interested in caracterising in an objective way the influence over tone and volume of several materials that can be used as a soundboard.

(I want to say again that all the above is just a curious scientific discussion of the work done by Microbot, and that it's by no mean an attack or an ill-intended post).
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal