Hi Ted,
As you know I have my preliminary thoughts on this subject but I am far from an expert. I have been amazed at the amount of information posted on this site by triskel and others. Particularly those with old catalogues (and I think he has mentioned one from around 1930) may in the best position to organize the discussion. I may have some photos and new data to contribute in a month or two. But here is one thought in the meantime for public comment:
To a biologist like me, with an interest in taxonomy/classification and evolutionary relationships of living things, a number of "morphogical groups" seem recognizable among the early Baldoni Bartolis. First, the early Carmody one-row box whose picture you showed me, that is very close to the McNulty Baldoni you played for me and that you picture on your website. Next, the William Sullivan box, which is like a couple others I have seen over the years with the flags on the main casework (not the keyboard). Then there is a *relatively* more numerous group of early Baldoni Bartolis with flags on the keyboard, a particularly angular ("bowlegged") pattern of lyre (not the harp or the rounded lyre), and an inset into the left-hand casework around the bass buttons. I don't meant here to imply a chronological order between these groups, necessarily. But this last group I mention (as I circumscribe it) includes the 13 key O'Rourke Baldoni Bartoli pictured on your website as well as the yellow, unlabeled one from the Rata Collection, shown in Concertina & Squeezebox III:1-2, and seemingly also the one triskel has pictured on this site and the one pictured by hibbs.
Among this latter group, some have the fancier keyboard silhouette with an indent at either end, and in others the keyboard has a simpler lyre-shaped silhouette. I wonder if the ones with a fancier keyboard silhouette (Rata, O'Rourke 13 key) might be older than the ones with the simpler silhouette (triskel and others I have seen). Someone with a catalogue might be able to answer this. I am making this speculation because the internal pencilled number (repeated several times throughout the instrument) is "2" in the O'Rourke 13-key and "15" and "19" in the two I have seen (or whose photos I have seen) with the simpler silhouette. But of course those numbers may not have been in sequence, or maybe not in the same sequence (they may have started over for different models or different batches). I would be interested to know if there are multiple, identical pencilled numbers in the Rata or triskel yellow/white instruments.
As I mentioned, I hope to be able to add more photos etc. in about a month. Aldo Mencacini could add a lot of information here if he can be coaxed into the discussion (and possibly onto the internet!). Triskel I'm sure knows other experts as well.
Thanks again Ted for all you are doing to help us understand, and to promote interest in, these wonderful instruments and their historic music.
Paul Groff