The practice for pallet facing is to have the nap (the furry side) in contact with the fondo to create an air seal. However this doesn't necessarily make a completely air tight seal, if you think about it, because air could leak through the permeable nap if it isn't pressed hard against the fondo. An extreme example of this leakiness can be seen when somebody glues the pallet facings on the wrong way round, with the felt in contact with the fondo.
On old concertinas the pads are faced with leather furry/nap side down, but on new pads the shiny side is face down, and it does make a very good seal. I recently repadded an old concertina (shiny side down) and immediately noticed an increase in bellows pressure, which *might* be because the shiny side of the leather is forming a good air seal. And on Nick CBs Organette I got a much better key seal by using pads with shiny side down (though, actually perhaps they should have been cork...but no matter)..
I'm not proposing it's being done wrong - who am I to argue with decades of standard practice? But would anyone care to comment?