Stiamh, I said something very like it, but now I check I see it was in another thread, two or three days ago,started by a member unsure which kind of box to get. Quote " On a B/C or other semitone box these notes [accidentals] are where you need them, in a progression of notes running up and down the keyboard, rather than as extra notes somewhere else on the keyboard that your finger has to fly off to and back from in the middle of the tune". I agree you may have put it better, but I think we can agree to agree here!