Any layout advice from those more knowledgeable than me would be most welcome!
Some time ago, upon hearing that Frans van der Aa was retiring, I squeezed in a just-in-time order. It is premature given my level of playing, but I had set my sights on his lightweight 3-row, so took the plunge on a G-C + acc 12 bass. Since then, I’ve considered going 18-bass, and Frans is OK with that switch.
Now is the time to decide, and for the keyboard layout. I’ve decided to stick on the left with what I have on my Casta Dony 2.5, since relearning fingerings will no doubt frustrate me no end. No dutch reversal, no pushed F, alas. So I am stuck with a less than optimal left hand, but that will be completely familiar.
The reason I am considering an 18 bass (thirdless, with the extra 6 buttons all basses without chords) is that it might compensate for occasional frustrations (no push f or b-flat to play against my pushed E-flat, for example). I know I could spend a lifetime with 12 bass - or 8 for that matter - but still tempted. I plan to grow into this. I don’t any reason I would regret the choice. Maybe?
In short: I’ve attached a draft of 18 bass layout. Does the left hand make sense, given the right? (I am, alas, not good at theory.) The first line of extra 6 bass buttons follows Pascale Rubens. The second, I think is almost Chris Ryall’s; it seems to make a bit more sense since the reversals are closer to their partner.
Any thoughts? See any howlers?