Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6   Go Down

Author Topic: B/C Melodeon  (Read 19269 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #40 on: January 09, 2020, 06:45:00 PM »

Why would it be any different on the box?

Because they are completely different instruments. People sometimes say the same thing about piano playing: no pianist would not use the little finger, so why shouldn't a diatonic box player? The answer to that lies in the fact that the piano has keys several inches long that make using all five fingers possible, whereas the the box has a straight line of buttons the size of a fingertip.

I played fiddle for decades before taking up the box and naturally I thought that using the fourth finger as much as the others would be a given. After a couple of months of playing I had a 5-minute lesson from a good player who strongly recommended - nay, insisted - that I should stop using the digit in question. I decided, with some misgivings, to try his advice. The effect on my playing was instant and dramatic. Passages that had constantly tripped me up suddenly became a piece of cake. I never looked back and give the same advice to other beginners on semitone boxes.

Sure the fourth finger can come in handy sometimes. But it is valuable advice for a beginner, I think, to make a determined effort to learn to scoot about the keyboard without the little fella.

Careful scrutiny of top Irish semitone box players in the flesh or on video will prove very instructive, too.  :|glug

[Edited to add a missing word.]
« Last Edit: January 09, 2020, 07:25:12 PM by Stiamh »
Logged

Barlow

  • Bad player, good talker apparently
  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 111
  • Castagnari Lilly B/C Erica D/G
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #41 on: January 09, 2020, 06:48:38 PM »

It would be daft to instruct a beginner on banjo or fiddle, for instance, not to use their little finger.
Why would it be any different on the box?
I feel that is comparing oranges with apples.
Why would it be any different on the box? Well, no need for a start. Everything you want or need to do can be done with three fingers only. I suppose one could go into the micro decisions the brain has to make (and remember). With 3 fingers there is just a choice of two for the next note, with 4 there is a choice of 3.
The fourth finger, poor thing, is a bit of a ginger cousin. A bit of a runt. Weak and shorter than the rest. It gets in the way unless it is held back. It provides balance maybe and if there is a really awkward piece that required that high B, then I may allow it to do something. Of course when it comes to harmonies, chords and counter melodies, the good ol' little finger can join in by all means, but that is for another thread.
I play guitar and fiddle, and use the little finger extensively. Especially fiddle as I like to avoid open strings, and on the guitar a lot for lead playing.

So, back to the button accordion. As George Orwell might have said: 4 fingers bad, 3 fingers good.
I say that after 3 years of pretty intense learning using 4 fingers, until I saw the light (or rather was shown the light on this forum)

However, all that said, on the bass end I use all 4 fingers. Which perhaps contradicts much of above. The left hand little finger does a lot of work.

But whatever way works best for a player is best.

(Edited to add - cross post with Stiamh above. Now, I wonder where I picked up the suggestion to drop the little finger...)
« Last Edit: January 09, 2020, 06:50:28 PM by Barlow »
Logged
. . .

Pearse Rossa

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 723
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #42 on: January 09, 2020, 07:35:04 PM »

It would be daft to instruct a beginner on banjo or fiddle, for instance, not to use their little finger.
Why would it be any different on the box?
I feel that is comparing oranges with apples.
Why would it be any different on the box? Well, no need for a start. Everything you want or need to do can be done with three fingers only.

The three fingers technique is what most people will use, but if you find that using your little finger comes
readily to you, then all the better.
I look at it like this; you could play a tune using only one finger, but using two is an improvement on that.
It follows that three fingers are better still, and four (if it comes naturally to you) gives you an edge.

Why would it be any different on the box?

Because they are completely different instruments. People sometimes say the thing about piano playing: no pianist would not use the little finger, so why shouldn't a diatonic box player? The answer to that lies in the fact that the piano has keys several inches long that make using all five fingers possible, whereas the the box has a straight line of buttons the size of a fingertip.

I don't quite follow your logic there Steve. I think the principle applies regardless of the instrument.
Being able to use all four fingers allows for more options.
I don't think we are going to agree on this point.

Logged

richard.fleming

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #43 on: January 09, 2020, 07:47:14 PM »

Why would it be any different on the box?
the piano has keys several inches long that make using all five fingers possible, whereas the the box has a straight line of buttons the size of a fingertip.
When you half-curl your fingers to play the box the tips are all in a straight line, or at least mine are, and that would be true of anyone playing with the box braced by the thumb against the fingerboard because you have to curl the fingers in order to play the buttons with the fingertips. So there is no problem with the little finger and the comparison with the PA is spurious.
I think we should have a spam folder for the three fingers 'controversy' - we always end up saying - or at least good old tolerant George saying - that you can do what you want anyway.
Logged
Old Paolo Sopranis in C#/D and D/D#

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #44 on: January 09, 2020, 07:58:12 PM »

Why would it be any different on the box?

Because they are completely different instruments. People sometimes say the thing about piano playing: no pianist would not use the little finger, so why shouldn't a diatonic box player? The answer to that lies in the fact that the piano has keys several inches long that make using all five fingers possible, whereas the the box has a straight line of buttons the size of a fingertip.

I don't quite follow your logic there Steve. I think the principle applies regardless of the instrument.
Being able to use all four fingers allows for more options.
I don't think we are going to agree on this point.


The point about the piano is purely one of body mechanics. Piano players use the entire length of the keys to compensate for the fact that the thumb and little finger are much shorter than the other fingers. If they just had a line of tiny buttons they wouldn't manage very well.

I agree that - at least in principle - more options makes sense. And we all have different sized and shaped hands (Richard's must be pretty special). Despite this, because of my own experience (and lots of experimentation), I can't be talked out of telling any beginner who wants to get up to speed with Irish music (or get Irish music up to speed) that you'll get there faster and more reliably by relying on three fingers. Practice trumps theory, quoi.

And, as I have said more than once on here, when a passage is too difficult with three fingers, try using two. :P

Lighten up department: There's a fine box player in Ireland, Peter Carberry, who lost the tip of a finger on his right hand in an industrial accident, which forced him to adapt his technique. (On this video he appears to use mainly index and ring finger, with the pinky coming into play occasionally.)  Apparently some helpful soul seriously suggested it might make matters easier to cut off the ends of the undamaged digits, so they'd all be the same length...  ::)

Graham Wood

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 132
  • Old Fumble Fingers
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #45 on: January 09, 2020, 08:30:20 PM »

As a complete novice, I would have thought that how many fingers you use depends on the span of how many buttons you need to press. I tried running up and down the major scale on one row and I am more accurate and smoother using two fingers than three. I guess it's because there is a bigger distance to jump using three fingers than two. On a piano keyboard I use the thumb which going up the scale curls under three fingers, and going down the scale you still use the thumb but the third finger crosses over it. You can't do this on a button box so I guess piano scales are irrelevant.
Logged
Graham Wood - Third Planet from The Sun
Hohner Morgane B/C,   Junior Martin 1 Row in 'D' with knobs on top,   Acadian 1 Row in 'C' with more knobs on top.

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #46 on: January 09, 2020, 08:47:21 PM »

I think we should have a spam folder for the three fingers 'controversy' - we always end up saying - or at least good old tolerant George saying - that you can do what you want anyway.

Actually Richard, I am pretty sick of talking about this subject. I think I'll hand the torch (or should that be the cross) over to my good disciple Barlow.  ;)

Last contribution: of course people should do what they want, or what they find works best for them.

BUT in my view, Graham our OP needs to know that there is a serious case to be made for "three fingers good". It might prove extremely helpful (and I mean extremely helpful, in practice) to him, as it has to me, Barlow, Rees, and doubtless many others.

I just wish you would acknowledge the fact that our advice is born of experience. If you (or anyone else whose focus is Irish trad) told me that you had a) given the three-finger method a serious trial at an early stage, before ingrained habits were formed, and found it wanting, or b) that you had played with three fingers for some time and experienced a dramatic improvement when you tried four, then we could have a serious discussion.

 :|glug :Ph :|glug :P

richard.fleming

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #47 on: January 10, 2020, 12:04:42 AM »

I've always played with four fingers. I've always walked with two legs. I'm not going to change now. I've been playing for more than fifty years. I dread the possibility of age and infirmity spoiling my playing, and I'm certainly not going to give up using any of my fingers before I'm forced to.
Logged
Old Paolo Sopranis in C#/D and D/D#

Pearse Rossa

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 723
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #48 on: January 10, 2020, 12:15:33 AM »

... There's a fine box player in Ireland, Peter Carberry, who lost the tip of a finger on his right hand in an industrial accident, which forced him to adapt his technique.

Actually, he had to switch from playing B/C to C#/D style, which sort of supports my position that it's all fingers on deck for B/C style.
I agree that he is indeed a very fine box player.
Logged

JohnS

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 64
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #49 on: January 10, 2020, 09:35:03 AM »

Try this.  Sit with your right forearm resting on a table, palm facing down, fingers arched and do a little drum roll with your first and second finger.  I'd imagine you can sustain a good, fast rhythm.  Now try the same with your third and fourth fingers.  Probably quite poor by comparison.  Other finger combinations are likely to fall somewhere between.

Therein lies the problem.  If your goal is to play Irish box at session speeds then you're going to need to play pretty fast and by and large your little finger isn't up to the task.

My approach is to only use it where nothing else makes sense and where it's not being asked to do anything too demanding.  For example, top note of a four note arpeggio where you go back down afterwards will save you two position changes.  As you use it it will get stronger, but your other fingers are getting stronger too so the pinkie will always be the weakest link.
Logged

Euan Brown

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 21
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #50 on: January 10, 2020, 10:00:52 AM »

Well yes, but the reason the little finger is 'slow' is that it needs to practice!  the more you practice the faster it will get!  (this is known as neuromuscular plasticity and it takes time and practice).  A couple of years ago I realised I was only using three fingers.  As I have the  luxury now  of playing when I want, I set out to get the pinkie working as well. This was  very useful as I play BCC# but it was quite frustrating at the beginning and I really struggled,  as you say the pinkie was slow.  Its still not perfect but is much better,  and very useful to hit high notes without changing hand position too much. If you look at the numerous videos by Ian Cruikshanks you will see that the pinkie is deployed a lot https://youtu.be/7ccnel4qay8?list=PLX8x1kE6LoMACbEja9Cjj-UscQ7t2CsLr

Euan
Logged

JohnS

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 64
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #51 on: January 10, 2020, 11:30:36 AM »

Yes, plenty of good players use it, plenty don't.  The key thing is to realise that it isn't a straight binary choice between using it or not.  There is middle ground with regard to the amount that you use it. 

For me it's a bit-part player rather than a main actor.
Logged

MikeK

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 354
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #52 on: January 10, 2020, 11:55:54 AM »

After I retired,I started to learn to play music on a piano accordion and at that time my pinkie was very weak.
Pretty much useless. With time it improved and  later I switched  to B/C/C# and now I am on a 2 row B/C.
Using all 4 fingers now come naturally as I mostly play Marches,which are in the keys of D and A.
My playing reminds me of Taggart. I can always "Murder" a tune. :(
« Last Edit: January 10, 2020, 01:22:17 PM by havaLaff »
Logged
I always respect my elders but they are getting fewer in numbers.

playandteach

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3526
  • Currently a music teacher in a high school.
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #53 on: January 10, 2020, 02:09:37 PM »

Well yes, but the reason the little finger is 'slow' is that it needs to practice!  the more you practice the faster it will get!  (this is known as neuromuscular plasticity and it takes time and practice). 
Euan
There are physical reasons for the little finger not being independent (rather than weak), as it isn't independent - sharing a tendon further up with the ring finger, where the other fingers don't share.
You can see the effect on the ring finger if you try to tap it on the table with all the other fingers remaining in contact with the table top.
Having said that, I disagree with the alignment point - especially if you play across the rows because then a natural place for the little finger is the outside row.
It is hampered for dexterity for certain functions, and maybe these occur more more frequently in heavily ornamented music.
Logged
Serafini R2D2 GC, Serafini GC accs 18 bass

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #54 on: January 10, 2020, 02:35:31 PM »

Bear in mind everyone that this is a thread started by someone who wants to play Irish music on the B/C box.

John says it all here:

If your goal is to play Irish box at session speeds then you're going to need to play pretty fast and by and large your little finger isn't up to the task.

The advice being offered is this: we all, especially those of us who come to the box from other instruments, immediately assume that it makes perfect sense to develop the little finger, just as you would have to do on the piano, fiddle, banjo, etc.

However, if you make a deliberate decision - as you learn Irish music on the B/C or C#/D (and probably D/G as well) with the goal of playing dance tunes fast - NOT to use the little finger for a considerable period, then you will learn ways of moving around the keyboard that are faster, more efficient and above all more reliable than if you try to use the little finger as much as the others.

Reliable is a key word. If you want to play this music at the proper speed, you can't afford to have anything hit-or-miss about your playing.

That's my experience and that of quite a few others too. If you can get Irish reels in a variety of keys happening reliably at speeds above 112 bpm using your little finger lots, then I will certainly take my hat off to you and cite you as evidence that it can be done by some. :|glug

Gromit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 588
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #55 on: January 10, 2020, 02:48:55 PM »

Quote
You can see the effect on the ring finger if you try to tap it on the table with all the other fingers remaining in contact with the table top
I'm either misunderstanding you or I'm a freak but I can tap my ring finger on the table with all the other fingers remaining in contact and the same with my little finger.
Logged

Gromit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 588
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #56 on: January 10, 2020, 03:37:47 PM »

Quote
If you can get Irish reels in a variety of keys happening reliably at speeds above 112 bpm using your little finger lots

In the Silver Spear / Sally Gardens / Merry Blacksmith I use my little finger to play the f♯ at that sort of speed, I don't use it 'lots' but in some cases it's useful.

Luke Daniels who's a handy box player here in the UK taught me a waltz that has a series of 4 note appegios and the easiest way to play them was using the little finger. Played here on a C♯/D but with the same fingering as on a B/C.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-kmSE0tOAk
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #57 on: January 10, 2020, 04:25:09 PM »

I'm sorry I chimed in on this now, LOL. Up-and-down four-finger arpeggios are one exception I allow myself. As long as they are on consecutive buttons.

Did a quick scan of YouTube videos. Joe Burke uses his little finger a fair bit for topmost notes. I know Damien Connolly does too. Mick McAuley definitely uses it for high f#s and top notes. Dermot Byrne was using it at the age of 12 but I can't tell in later clips.

Peter Browne no, Damien Mullane no (as far as I can tell), Tony MacMahon no to all intents and purposes. Noel Scott (the player who gave me the vital piece of advice) no, obviously.

Cannot be bothered to spend more time on the matter or talk about it any more. Apologies all round. Stand by my own experience though!

playandteach

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3526
  • Currently a music teacher in a high school.
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #58 on: January 10, 2020, 05:20:02 PM »

Quote
You can see the effect on the ring finger if you try to tap it on the table with all the other fingers remaining in contact with the table top
I'm either misunderstanding you or I'm a freak but I can tap my ring finger on the table with all the other fingers remaining in contact and the same with my little finger.
Little finger is no problem here, but can you really do it at the same speed and volume with your ring finger?
Logged
Serafini R2D2 GC, Serafini GC accs 18 bass

MartinW

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 202
Re: B/C Melodeon
« Reply #59 on: January 10, 2020, 11:32:33 PM »

Curiously I find that I have a lot more independent control of my little finger than of my ring finger. I can tap it up and down a lot more quickly than my ring finger, and with about as much strength. Any attempt to go faster with my ring finger results in neighbouring fingers moving in sympathy.

I think that if I ever had to sacrifice one finger when playing I’d probably choose to lose my ring finger before my little finger. Hopefully I’ll never have to make that choice.

Martin

Logged
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal