I'm using EasyABC1.3.7.7
I'm currently looking at a couple of William Marshall's strathspeys from '
Richard
Robinson's Tune Book'. Many (most?) of these are presented as 2-voice tunes.
I've noticed a couple of instances where the melody and accompaniment get
out of step. Here's an example (stripped of all extraneous ABC directives):
X:1
T:Mr Gordon of Hallhead's Strathspey
M:C
L:1/8
R:Strathspey
K:G
%%staves {1 2}
V:1
(G>D)(B,>D) G/F/E/D/ .B,.D | G<G,B<D F<A-A>.B |\
G>DB,>D (G/F/)E/F/ Gg | !trill!d>B c/B/A/G/ D<G- G2 |
(G>D)(B,>D) (G/F/)E/D/ (.B,.D) | G<G,B<D F<A-A>.B |\
(G>D)(B,>D) (G/F/)E/F/ (Gg) | !trill!d>B c/B/A/G/ D<G- G2 |]
(!trill!g/f/g/a/) g2 (!trill!g/f/g/a/) g2 | (e/f/)g/a/ (g/f/)e/d/ e<a-a>!wedge!f |\
!trill!g>b g<d egdB | ceAd B<G-~G.d |
(!trill!g/f/g/a/) g z (!trill!g/f/g/a/) g z | (g/a/)b/a/ (g/f/)e/d/ e<a- a g/f/ |\
g<be<g d<g~B>G | !trill!c>A (c/B/)(A/G/) D<G- G2 |]
V:2 clef=bass octave=-2
L:1/4
GGGG | GGdd | GGGG | BcdG | GGGG | GGdd | GGGG | BcdG |] \
gbgb | c'a c'/^c'/d' | gbc'g | cdGG | Gg Gg | dBcd | gc'bg | c'dgg |]
The score looks OK, but when I play it back, the whole thing gets out of step, and
the last 2 crotchets in the accompaniment play after the melody has finished.
Cut to the chase - if I replace
!trill! with
~, it plays correctly, with 1st and 2nd
voice in proper alignment.
Do any of the ABC experts out there have any idea why this should be the case?
Thank you.
I'd like to get to the bottom of this because I really like these (slow) strathspeys. Strong men are overcome with emotion,
and weep into their beer when I play one of these tunes with 'feeling'. That's what they tell me, anyway...