Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2]   Go Down

Author Topic: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person  (Read 5556 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Schnorbitz

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 199
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #20 on: April 27, 2020, 04:50:42 PM »

Hi Luke

Quote
This actually raises another question for me, since I haven't closely studied the layout charts: I thought the .5 on a 2.5 was specifically to give you accidentals/reversals not available on the other two rows, and a full third row was to provide a scale in the next key (i.e., A/D/G). Is there any difference here? Do I get all the same notes on a 3-row that I'd get on a 2.5-row, plus some?

The third row can be entirely accidentals and extends them throughout the entire keyboard. If you look at 3 row players on the continent (and there are a lot of them) they almost all have their 3rd row as accidentals. As Steve correctly points out you have to look at different layouts and this is where is does get complicated. Part of the question is therefore what is your aim? Do you want to help the existing main keys that your box plays in - so give the key of G, for example, more flexibility by including reversed G's, C's and E's. Or, are you looking to extend the keys of your box. For example, allow playing in D minor, G minor and A minor by adding accidentals such as F, Bb, Eb. A full third row of accidentals gives you this option at both the chin and knee end and most systems have a repeating pattern that fits with the layout on the main rows.

I say it gets complicated when you are looking at layouts as there are so many options with each player having a preference. I started off with a 'Heim' 3rd row (which is the standard Castagnari layout for a 3 row box), but ended up changing to a 'Corgeron' system when I ditched the push 'E's' for push F's. It helped massively with D minor and G minor and I found I did not miss the push E. Oh what I would do for a pull Bb.............and there lies the problem. You can't have everything, it is a melodeon after all, the lack of flexibility is its greatest strength (:) Your style of playing will also dictate what sort of arrangement will work. In regard to a 2.5 row, you are in reality just restricting the number of accidentals along the range of the keyboard, that is the only difference to a full 3rd row. This may be absolutely fine if it fits with the keys / reversals you are looking for and to be honest it has never done Andy Cutting any harm.

For me the A/D/G setup is almost pointless. It does allow for ease of playing in the different main row keys and associated modes. But.......you get a massive replication of buttons on the push and pull and a loss of the flexibility a 3rd row can bring. But then my father in law played successfully in ceilidh bands for 40 years with a A/D/G box so what do I know..........

One last thing, re the discussion regarding a fourth button start, my Handry has a fourth button start so I have a low G etc on the main rows (there are no accidentals on the main rows). Really useful for a lot of fiddle tunes. The temptation with a 3 row box is to think you will just kick in the L voice for tunes that need it and move down the keyboard to play. My experience has been that sometimes you do and and sometimes you don't. It is nice to have that flexibility and something I have on all my D/G boxes. 
« Last Edit: April 27, 2020, 04:52:56 PM by Schnorbitz »
Logged

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #21 on: April 27, 2020, 06:01:30 PM »

A nice 2.5 row layout I've seen recently is on Paul Young's site. he uses my low note layout but adds a low and mid pull D, and has F naturals in both directions in both octaves too. As you can see from his description, it's a useful layout that enables playing in a good range of keys, and If I was going to get a 2/5 row box now I'd probably choose that layout.

I had not seen this (only dead links in old forum posts), so, thank you for linking it. That is actually a pretty sick layout, I like it! The justifications are surely tried & tested by Paul, and resonate with my current thinking (unisonoric Fs, in particular). I particularly like that the new plates are all close to unisonoric pitches, too, which would aid conversion. My only pause would be, I've been playing a lot of RHS chords recently and my two frustrations are 1) no pull D and 2) nothing lower than E4 for an Emin chord. #2 there, this layout doesn't help with, so depending on how keen you are on being chromatic from G3, I might suggest considering if that low G# could be a low pull B. Also no idea why we all put F# minor on when we could play F# + A chord for F#m7 and then we could have F# major instead - that seems like it would be good.

In some ways, this thread is somehow both funny and somehow terrifying to me:

Any thoughts or tips about things I should be considering that I haven't mentioned here are most welcome. Thanks!
The main thing I'd say to you Luke is that, as soon as half rows and 3rd rows become involved, the layout of the instrument typically becomes personalised to someone's way of playing. Buying any used box, regardless of the original maker, often means wading into someone else's preferred keyboard layout. The extra notes & basses really can just be anything - it's very easy for them to be something that isn't what you want. I would expect that you'll either have to a) be choosy & find one that falls in line with your desires, or b) make do, or c) be planning to get some of the instrument's reed plates changed in some way.

Being that you don't currently play one of these systems, I'd advise you have a think about specifically what you'd want your half row to offer you, because others will probably have a different opinion. What's right for you will ultimately depend on you. - I also am a big fan of LMM and honestly my favourite octave to play on my 2 row is the low G octave that the Low G/Anahata layout offers me.
Logged

Schnorbitz

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 199
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #22 on: April 27, 2020, 06:11:04 PM »

Another vote for having F on the push and pull acc row. It really is useful on a D/G.
Logged

Luke Hillman

  • MAD hatter
  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 77
  • Berkeley, CA
    • Anglo Piano
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #23 on: April 28, 2020, 01:24:04 AM »

Thanks for the layout link, Steve & Thrupenny.
You should take the time to study them; they could inform your decision about what instrument could be the best choice for you.
Absolutely. Since differences range so widely, I'll certainly be paying more attention to who plays what kind of instrument, and what their repertoire sounds like. But as someone who plays (nearly) entirely by ear and through trial and error, a lot of my preferences are somewhat loosely held until I've been constrained by limitations to the point of annoyance. I had my little Baffetti/Oakwood box for quite a while before I had the chin-end accidentals reversed, and if I were buying it new, I'd get a 4th-button start (I am repelled by the squeakiness of the upper registers and often have to tweak tunes to avoid it, which hurts). Which seems to get me most of the way to Anahata's layout, and since he and Paul Young are among my most admired YouTube, er, influencers (heh), I'd likely trust that layout to work for me, for at least a while.

Now, with a 2.5 row box, what you can do is use the chin end buttons for low pitched accidentals.
My Saltarelle Connemara III had the usual four end button accidentals but an octave lower, and middle and higher accidentals and reversals on the half row. With the G-scale modification It was thus fully chromatic for nearly all of its three octave range.

A nice 2.5 row layout I've seen recently is on Paul Young's site. he uses my low note layout but adds a low and mid pull D, and has F naturals in both directions in both octaves too. As you can see from his description, it's a useful layout that enables playing in a good range of keys, and If I was going to get a 2/5 row box now I'd probably choose that layout.
So noted, and thank you. This is exactly the kind of thing I was interested in hearing about, particularly since I find myself playing so many of your arrangements!

The third row can be entirely accidentals and extends them throughout the entire keyboard. [...] what is your aim? Do you want to help the existing main keys that your box plays in - so give the key of G, for example, more flexibility by including reversed G's, C's and E's. Or, are you looking to extend the keys of your box.
Thanks for the breakdown of a third row of accidentals vs. the A/D/G setup. I've been so used to seeing product descriptions of three-row melodeons referring to the A/D/G setup that the accidental row wasn't even something I knew to research. Feeling a bit very stupid right now.

I think personally (though see the above note about loosely-held opinions), I'm slightly more interested in opening up options for the keys I usually play in, but one thing I wish I was able to do more of is switching to different keys in the middle of a tune to make things more interesting. So I guess the answer is "yes."

In some ways, this thread is somehow both funny and somehow terrifying to me [...]
You and me both! ;D I'll admit my level of ignorance is certainly terrifying. Coming from the world of two-rows where everything is standardized and finding that a jump to an additional half row literally catapults you into the customization Twilight Zone is a bit much. But my M.O. thus far has been to dive in and figure things out by doing... really, what have I got to lose? (Money. I could lose vast sums of money. This is like the folk musician version of the Trolley Problem  :-\ ).

Buying any used box, regardless of the original maker, often means wading into someone else's preferred keyboard layout. The extra notes & basses really can just be anything - it's very easy for them to be something that isn't what you want. I would expect that you'll either have to a) be choosy & find one that falls in line with your desires, or b) make do, or c) be planning to get some of the instrument's reed plates changed in some way.
Solid advice and a neat statement of the dilemma. I suspect if I were to go after the absolute perfect box, I'd spend quite a bit, and then find later that I'd gotten it wrong, or my tastes would change. I'm leaning toward looking for a box that can be easily modified to Anahata's or Paul's layout, and going from there.

Editing to add a technical question: Looking at this thread, it seems like a fairly easy and straightforward job to convert a 3rd-button start to a 4th-button start. I want to double-check on this point before I consider buying a used 3rd-button start; I once had a repair person tell me that the conversion would be a lot of work and would involve significant changes to the box, which caused me to stick with the 3rd button on my current Baffetti.

Many thanks to everyone here for the extremely valuable input.
« Last Edit: April 28, 2020, 03:39:37 AM by Luke Hillman »
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #24 on: April 28, 2020, 08:31:15 AM »

I am a repair person  and I can tell you that switching from third button start to 4th button start can be a big job, especially on a three row three voice instrument. All the reeds have to be taken out, cleaned of wax, re-fitted possible with some modifications to the reed blocks.  Re-waxed and then it’s essential to do a full retune.  You also need new matching reed plates for the low notes you add.

If you know that a 4th button start is essential then think vey carefully before buying a 3rd button start.  Find a good repair person with an excellent reputation and get prices for the conversion before you buy.


Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

rees

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5055
  • Windjammer
    • Wesson Accordions
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #25 on: April 28, 2020, 01:08:43 PM »

I am a repair person  and I can tell you that switching from third button start to 4th button start can be a big job, especially on a three row three voice instrument. All the reeds have to be taken out, cleaned of wax, re-fitted possible with some modifications to the reed blocks.  Re-waxed and then it’s essential to do a full retune.  You also need new matching reed plates for the low notes you add.

If you know that a 4th button start is essential then think vey carefully before buying a 3rd button start.  Find a good repair person with an excellent reputation and get prices for the conversion before you buy.

I also am a repair person. This job is time consuming and very, very costly.
Logged
Rees Wesson (accordion builder and mechanic)
Gungrog, Welshpool, Wales, UK
www.melodeons.com

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #26 on: April 28, 2020, 03:37:29 PM »

It was either £100 or £120 to get my Lily 4th buttoned, also clubbed but that didn’t add a lot as the D/E reed was out anyway.Well worth that, the top end was shrill enough to upset animals.

I chose Anahata's  options for my extra low buttons. It offered a lot of rt end chords and arpeggios. With an accs row  I’d have extended the scale

But that's for a single voice box. The maths isn’t all that hard.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Luke Hillman

  • MAD hatter
  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 77
  • Berkeley, CA
    • Anglo Piano
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #27 on: April 28, 2020, 08:44:04 PM »

I am a repair person  and I can tell you that switching from third button start to 4th button start can be a big job, especially on a three row three voice instrument.
I also am a repair person. This job is time consuming and very, very costly.

Well, that settles that, then. Thanks Theo and Rees.
Logged

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #28 on: April 28, 2020, 09:58:20 PM »

Something that... seems absent from this conversation somehow? For a 2.x or 3 row instrument, 3rd or 4th button start doesn't really necessarily mean the same thing as it does for a 2 row. With 3rd start, you have space what is considered 'low notes' or accidentals, but not both. 4th start on a 2 row makes room for both. On instruments with extra buttons, you can have extra room for both, even with a 3rd button start.

A 3rd button start with a 6 button half row VS a 4th button start with a 4 button half row might well offer you the exact same pallet of low notes and accidentals as one another.
Logged

smiley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1021
  • Folk music: it's not as bad as it sounds
    • a few sound clips
Re: An American humbly begs advice on instruments he can't see in person
« Reply #29 on: April 28, 2020, 11:39:23 PM »

I am a repair person  and I can tell you that switching from third button start to 4th button start can be a big job, especially on a three row three voice instrument. All the reeds have to be taken out, cleaned of wax, re-fitted possible with some modifications to the reed blocks.  Re-waxed and then it’s essential to do a full retune.  You also need new matching reed plates for the low notes you add.

If you know that a 4th button start is essential then think vey carefully before buying a 3rd button start.  Find a good repair person with an excellent reputation and get prices for the conversion before you buy.

I also am a repair person. This job is time consuming and very, very costly.

I've just realised how fortunate I was to have the new D/G Sandpiper I bought in 2011 (for a very reasonable price) from the Music Room's stall at Chippenham converted to 4th button start, accidentals reversed and collected at Cleckheaton a couple of days later when I was flying out from Manchester - for no extra cost.

I suppose its a bit late to thank them now ...
Logged
Pages: 1 [2]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal