Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4   Go Down

Author Topic: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)  (Read 9165 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music

If played in certain keys there is resonance between the bowed string and the ope strings.  This reinforces the notes of the open strings, ADGE and that clearly has different effects in different keys. Whether that amounts to an emotional difference I don’t know.
Handel certainly liked to use D major for a bright and triumphant sound. The extra brightness and ringing from all those open strings would have made an audible difference, and players will choose between open strings or the equivalent stopped notes depending on the character of the music.

I did listen to a radio 4 piece a few years ago on the subject of linking keys to emotions and I thought it was a case of the kings new clothes.
Strongly related to this is the association of colours with specific keys. For people with synaesthesia this definitely happens. Many people have at least some key-colour associations, though they aren't necessarily the same from one person to another.

Quote
a pianist who had convinced himself that there was a difference in feeling when a piece in D# major was then played in Eb major.
I agree that's pushing it a bit too far, especially on a piano. But composers (especially someone like Alkan) might make a definite choice of key when writing such a piece.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Blake

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 132

I understand the business of equal temperament and how that washed out a lot of the flavor of the keys.

I wonder, however, even with these mean-tone (and similar more equally distributed) tunings, if people with perfect absolute pitch can discern a different flavoring of keys, than the rest of us mortals who have acceptable relative pitch only.

Do any among you have perfect pitch? What's your feel?
« Last Edit: September 09, 2020, 12:36:04 PM by Blake »
Logged
Castagnari Benny GC#, Mory DG#, Geordy GC, Mignon C
Cajun Custom in C by L'Anse Grise
Hohner Pokerwork GC and DG
Morse Baritone English Concertina, and some busted up Wheatstone trebles I need to work over.

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris

I understand the business of equal temperament and how that washed out a lot of the flavor of the keys.

I wonder, however, even with these mean-tone tunings, if people with perfect absolute pitch can discern a different flavoring of keys, than the rest of us mortals who have acceptable relative pitch only.

Do any among you have perfect pitch? What's your feel?

I think the differences are very detectable as differences in the way notes blend and harmonise even to those of us without perfect pitch, though we may not be able to say exactly what the differences are. It's quite a dramatic effect.

I am still looking through (and listening through) Steve's article and videos, below. Worth examining closely, for their own sakes.
« Last Edit: September 09, 2020, 12:43:59 PM by Tone Dumb Greg »
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here

If played in certain keys there is resonance between the bowed string and the ope strings.  This reinforces the notes of the open strings, ADGE and that clearly has different effects in different keys. Whether that amounts to an emotional difference I don’t know.

I feel it's more related to how the instrument sounds than to the alleged instrisic emotion associated with a given key.

I understand the business of equal temperament and how that washed out a lot of the flavor of the keys.

Here is a thing I don't understand : the scale remains the same, irrespective of the base note you chose (you have the same difference in cents compared to the tonic). So why, apart from the pitch shift, should the keys have different flavours if the scale remains the same ?

Gonk

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 507
  • (Mudlark Music)
    • Mudlark Music

-Y-, I think the answer lies in perception, which is less mathematically pure than any other method for measuring frequency.  Unfortunately, that's more of a rabbit hole than an answer.

There are so many mental factors that go into our perception of a sound, including memory and association.  Timbre is almost inseparable from these connections, and I suspect that informs our sense of a Bb/Eb box vs. a C/F.  How can we restrict our examination to pitch alone?  I expect the difference in feeling we're talking about would be diminished greatly if you used a pure sine wave as the tone, and modulated it using software instead of a real-world system of metal, wax, and wood.  The technology to make an experiment like that wasn't around when these theories of pitches/keys and their associated emotions were most popular.

Another oddity is the way the ear itself works to translate vibrations sensed by multiple hairs in the cochlea to what can be perceived as pitch.  Which isn't well understood, as far as I can tell.  From https://psych.athabascau.ca/html/Psych402/Biotutorials/25/part1.html:

Knowledge of how perceptual qualities of hearing are derived from neurophysiological events is weaker than our knowledge of visual perception. Amongst the three perceptual qualities of pitch, loudness, and timbre, pitch has been studied the most. Two theories have been offered to explain perception of pitch, the Place and Frequency Theories. Place Theory (Hermann von Helmholtz, 1863) maintains that perception of pitch depends on the vibration of different portions of the membrane formed by the receptive cells of the inner ear. That is, receptive cells in each region of the membrane are specialized for the detection of specific sound frequencies. Frequency Theory (Rutherford, 1886) holds that pitch perception corresponds to the rate of vibration of all receptive cells along the inner ear membrane. For example, a sound of frequency 2000 Hz would cause the whole membrane to vibrate at a rate of 2000 Hz. The brain then detects the frequency based on the rate of neuronal firing that matches the rate of vibration.
Logged
Mudlark Music - restoration, repairs, lessons, and sales.  (USA)  http://mudlark-music.com

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon

I think that when equal temperament was designed, some notes within the scale of a given key fitted mathematically better than others. Therefore in some keys the notes of the scale fit better and so sound easier on the ear.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here

I don't say it's related to pitch only. But I've not seen any convincing evidence that, intrinsically, keys should convey any specific emotion. Which is not the same as saying that we perceive instruments differently, or that other factors are not notable.
I think for instance, that some boxes will sound better in certain keys, but it's not to say that it's related to the key itself.

Gonk

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 507
  • (Mudlark Music)
    • Mudlark Music

To add to Thrupenny's comment, equal temperament is very rarely encountered in the wild.  Pianos, for example, aren't actually tuned to 12-TET.  They all have a modified system that tweaks those frequencies to achieve better resonance, harmonics, "color," etc.  So in practice they do exactly what Thrupenny describes - fit it to certain keys.  It's not unheard of to retune a concert grand for a specific performance, in a specific key.

I think the only way you're going to experience a mathematically pure 12-TET scale is through software.

And as -Y- says, in the real world, resonances are going to depend on many physical factors, like material density, thickness, shape and size of internal chambers, air column properties, on and on.
« Last Edit: September 09, 2020, 02:07:06 PM by Gonk »
Logged
Mudlark Music - restoration, repairs, lessons, and sales.  (USA)  http://mudlark-music.com

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris

I'm not sure if Just v. Equal intonation is very relevant to MM with tremolo, anyway.
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Gonk

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 507
  • (Mudlark Music)
    • Mudlark Music

I'm not sure if Just v. Equal intonation is very relevant to MM with tremolo, anyway.

Totally true.  If you listen to the two scales superimposed with sine waves, it just sounds like a box that needs the tremolo tweaked.

https://pages.mtu.edu/~suits/scales.wav

I should add that the sound file comes from this page, which also lists the degree of difference in cents within the "middle" octave.  https://pages.mtu.edu/~suits/scales.html
« Last Edit: September 09, 2020, 02:24:29 PM by Gonk »
Logged
Mudlark Music - restoration, repairs, lessons, and sales.  (USA)  http://mudlark-music.com

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧

I understand the business of equal temperament and how that washed out a lot of the flavor of the keys.

To me, this is actually a bit like remarking on how different the water tastes depending on which pond you're drinking from - the flavour wasn't really there on purpose, and honestly it probably doesn't always taste all that great. But the perceivable differences created by unintended intonation differences would all be real things, but they're ones that you could have anywhere, at any time - just idk dip a frog to your cup of tea? (don't hurt frogs.)

I'm stuck with the mental dichotomy of;
a) 'Keys' don't exist.
b) However, keys are a relatively effective label for the particular expectations and experiences people who're saturated in western music generally seem to get from listening to music which occupies particular frequency ranges and is composed for certain instruments, and have implications for how it's played.
c) Therefore, keys can be a useful and sensible way to label likely true and observable trends in (our) music. Thus:
d) 'Keys' exist.

I came across this recently and it sets out an amazing differentiation between the different keys
http://www.gradfree.com/kevin/some_theory_on_musical_keys.htm

This, however, honestly reads like a horoscope. Plus is likely based on experiences and knowledge of western music from 18th century Europe.

When we say a tune is in G, we think about where we can expect melodies to be, pitch wise, and how they can occupy that space and how they'll interact with other instruments. We probably don't think about a tune that is pitched around either G8, or G1. But those are still G, aren't they? If we adjust our pitch standard for A down by a halfstep, and then play in G#, are we then playing in G again or is it still G#? What if we tune down by a quartertone? Would we have to find some new emotions to correspond with it?

Those are all rhetorical questions, really. There's a lot of unknowable things that it's easy to hypothesise about forever, and I don't really have any real answers.
Logged

Gonk

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 507
  • (Mudlark Music)
    • Mudlark Music

All of this makes me think of Johannes Itten and his color system, or Wassily Kandinsky.  An attractive pseudoscience.  The theory is something like: the senses clearly affect emotion, and that means we can break the senses into their components and quantify exactly how they do this.  A periodic table for everything.  The term "spiritual" is thrown about a lot, as a sort of logical spackle.  It seems to me to dovetail nicely with some of the pseudoscience cults that appeared in the mid 1800s to early 1900s, with their claims to the ideal and most pure lifestyle, or the ideal diet.

I will say that a lot of interesting things can result from these convictions, even if they're a bit bizarre.  Whatever you think of Kandinsky, or Schoenberg, or anyone else who believes they have found "the code," their respective bodies of work have an internal consistency that I find appealing.
« Last Edit: September 09, 2020, 03:55:40 PM by Gonk »
Logged
Mudlark Music - restoration, repairs, lessons, and sales.  (USA)  http://mudlark-music.com

ursamyna

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 37

Why not try an experiment ?
Download a copy of a tune from youtube (quicker than doing your own recording). Choose a fairly obscure one which has no association with lyrics.
Load it into something like Riffstation or Audacity. Change the pitch (not tempo) and save it, so you now have different versions with the same dynamics etc but in different keys. Play them to someone without telling them anything which makes them pre-judge the situation, and get them to explain if they have different emotional responses.
I accept that different modes could have an influence on moods, but with equal temperament would a semitone shift from Gmajor (said to be rustic/idyllic etc) to Ab major (death/putrefaction etc) really be a significant  move.
Could be a good idea for some of the "pagan" border sides I suppose😉
Logged

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris

Why not try an experiment ?
Download a copy of a tune from youtube (quicker than doing your own recording). Choose a fairly obscure one which has no association with lyrics.
Load it into something like Riffstation or Audacity. Change the pitch (not tempo)

Trouble is, key shifting creates artifacts which affect the way the music will sound. The farther you go from the recorded pitch, the worse they sound.

Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band

Our modern A=440 can be a good semi-tone sharp or flat of some historical tunings so Handel's D, say, might well have sounded more like C# or Eb to us.
Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris

Our modern A=440 can be a good semi-tone sharp or flat of some historical tunings so Handel's D, say, might well have sounded more like C# or Eb to us.

That's one of the reasons why I think intonation, rather than absolute pitch, is behind the ancient theory. Otherwise it doesn't seem logical.
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640

I do not have perfect pitch, but I do have very well developed "relative" pitch and can generally identify they key of any piece I hear.  When I hear a tune in something other than its usual or standard key, it can grate on my ear a bit.

A long-time friend (Bill) you was in a coma near the end of his life.  As a "godfather" of the local traditional music scene, he was visited constantly by dozens of his former band mates and students who would serenade him in his hospital bed. 

One accordionist started playing an old standard waltz and a few bars into the tune, Bill started groaning and twitching restlessly until another visitor said, "That's
a G tune, not Bb."

Upon switching to G, Bill quieted down and a smile crossed his lips.
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

Steve C.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2075
  • Erica, Morse Anglo

On a Streb, where you have over a hundred voices, certain ones sound "better" in different keys; especially notable in the free reed voices.
After having it for a couple years, I was interested/surprised to note that of the eight diatonic patches (installed switchable voices) I set up, two were in C/F, four in A/D, one in Bb/Eb and one in G/C.
None in D/G.
Logged
Located in Central North Carolina, USA; credit for picture: livingplanet.ca

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall

Spot on Steve!

We seem equally divided here between those who hear tune nuances differently on a different tonic, and those to who it doesn’t matter. Similar to … wine tasting in some respects.  Suggests to me that the sense is as much in the listener’s physiology as in the music itself. We might for example have different neurone distribution in inner ear?

But given that so many hear Eb as soft, D as bright it’s more likely cultural
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Little Eggy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 843

I'm glad I started this thread. I've learned a lot from the very knowledgeable folk on the forum.  Thanks.
First - recognising different keys - It seems to me that you 'get it' fully; you get it in part or you don't get it at all.
I don't get it and I'm not sure you can be taught it.
Second - attributing emotional differences to different keys - this goes right over my head and out of the window I'm afraid!
But I have learned that tunes written in one key, with one particular instrument in mind should generally be played on that instrument and in that key.
My favourite story is the old man in hospital who could distinguish G from Bflat which is not really very far away on the scale is it!
Logged
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal