Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4   Go Down

Author Topic: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)  (Read 9146 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall

Minor third, Eggy. That’s very different to my ear. Think of the Empire tune in Star wars.

The effect can be very powerful. eg In my Xray department every time the motor the tilted the table ran, I heard “Coronation Street” playing in my head. Brought in an instrument. It was spot on Bb!
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Little Eggy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 843

Minor third, Eggy. That’s very different to my ear. Think of the Empire tune in Star wars.

The effect can be very powerful. eg In my Xray department every time the motor the tilted the table ran, I heard “Coronation Street” playing in my head. Brought in an instrument. It was spot on Bb!

?Hang on a minute? I tried on my guitar and I started the Corrie Theme Tune on a B which was in my head. Just played it on You Tube and it starts with a C.
(I mean the NAAAAAA, na na ni na na first note)   
Logged

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band

Spot on Steve!
But given that so many hear Eb as soft, D as bright it’s more likely cultural

Shoot me down but, just to play devil's advocate and be a bit cynical… Are these perceived emotional differences felt by listeners who aren’t musically literate?  Looking at the link Little Eggy supplied and concentrating just on the major keys for the sake of simplicity, I can’t help noticing a relationship between the perceived emotion and the number of flats or sharps. 
C major (no sharps or flats) is described as pure, innocent, naive.
G major (1 sharp) is calm, gentle, peaceful
D major (2 sharps) is triumphant
A major (3 sharps) is suggestive of hope, love, innocent cheerfulness
E major (4 sharps) suggests noisy shouts of joy
B major – wild passions

Apart from A major, there seems to be a clear progression there: the more sharps in the key sig, the greater the excitement.

Going the other way, with one exception again (Bb), increasing numbers of flats lead us from complaisance and calm (F), through conversation with God (Eb), to death (Ab)!

Just thought I'd throw it out there  >:E
Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall

ie it IS cultural?
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here

Who would have thought

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...

To add to Thrupenny's comment, equal temperament is very rarely encountered in the wild.  Pianos, for example, aren't actually tuned to 12-TET.  They all have a modified system that tweaks those frequencies to achieve better resonance, harmonics, "color," etc.  So in practice they do exactly what Thrupenny describes - fit it to certain keys.  It's not unheard of to retune a concert grand for a specific performance, in a specific key.

I think the only way you're going to experience a mathematically pure 12-TET scale is through software.

And as -Y- says, in the real world, resonances are going to depend on many physical factors, like material density, thickness, shape and size of internal chambers, air column properties, on and on.

Pianos have tuning which is "stretched" along the keyboard to make the octaves sound true; the bass strings are stiff so the harmonics are sharp compared to the fundamental, so they're tuned slightly flat. The same is done at the treble end but they're tunes sharp. If you plot pitch vs. ET pitch it forms a smooth "S" curve, curving flat at the bottom and sharp at the top. But this has no effect on the differences between keys, the basic tuning follows ET so there should be no difference. The only exception is of the piano is tuned away from ET for a particular piece in a particular key (closer to mean temperament or quarter-comma or...), but AFAIK this is not common.

There's a lot of rubbish talked about many things to do with music and instruments, for example the "differences between keys" used to be true (very!) in the days before ET was adopted but isn't any more -- IIRC English concertinas originally had separate D# and Eb keys (where the "wolf interval" was in the tuning used at the time). I could give a whole list of other examples but it would only start arguments, so I won't... ;-)
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here

Do you mean that for instance if you'd have to tune an instrument so that it was in tune in D, and then tune it so that it was in tune for G, thirds were not the same ?

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...

Do you mean that for instance if you'd have to tune an instrument so that it was in tune in D, and then tune it so that it was in tune for G, thirds were not the same ?
Yes.
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here

Feels odd (don't really understand why you'd want to do that), but interesting to know.
« Last Edit: September 11, 2020, 04:07:13 PM by -Y- »
Logged

Gonk

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 507
  • (Mudlark Music)
    • Mudlark Music

Pianos have tuning which is "stretched" along the keyboard to make the octaves sound true; the bass strings are stiff so the harmonics are sharp compared to the fundamental, so they're tuned slightly flat. The same is done at the treble end but they're tunes sharp. If you plot pitch vs. ET pitch it forms a smooth "S" curve, curving flat at the bottom and sharp at the top. But this has no effect on the differences between keys, the basic tuning follows ET so there should be no difference. The only exception is of the piano is tuned away from ET for a particular piece in a particular key (closer to mean temperament or quarter-comma or...), but AFAIK this is not common.

This is interesting to me; I'm not a [real world] piano tuner, but I find it fascinating.  When I was younger, I used to have long conversations with the tuner who came too infrequently to tune the family piano.  He's the source of my claim that concert grands are sometimes tweaked to sound better in a certain key, even in ET.  My understanding is that the S-curve you describe, also called the Railsback curve, has the fortunate effect of also mitigating the effect of the increasingly dissonant fifths as one maintains ET and also consonant octaves.  But it doesn't do so perfectly, and there are still advantages in tweaking those resonances and colors slightly to produce good intervals within a key.  The rich harmonics produced by the strings means that fine adjustments can produce profound effects.  The shape of the soundboard, the shape of the bracing, and the ratios in string core/winding widths, lengths, and so on, are all real-world variables that complicate the problem to the point where predictive models can fail us.

I have an interesting electronic instrument (a Roland digital piano) that aspires to allow modeling of the sounds that different tuning systems produce, as well as virtual adjustments for things like degree of lid openness, damper resonance, soundboard bracing styles, and so on.  It also allows each note to be fine-tuned individually.  The Railsback curve is present in the preset tunings it offers, but it's not smooth - it's quite a spiky graph, actually, as certain bass notes are even raised to give the desired harmonic effects.  I don't imagine that these models are completely relevant to actual grand pianos, but I do think it's interesting that even in a digital instrument, those apparent "aberrations" are preserved.  I've made some tunings presets of my own, designed to actually reduce tonal color for a clear, crisp sound for use on stage.  I made them by tuning the middle octave to 12-TET, then using that octave to tune the harmonic over- and under-tones from the rest of the range, with a stroboscopic tuner.  It is likewise not the smooth S-curve that one might expect from a digital instrument.  It does achieve the desired effect very nicely: dry, little color, good for making a percussive and clean sound in muddy, echoing spaces filled with dancers.

I hope this isn't too much thread drift from melodeons and reeds.  As Greg said a ways back, a box with MM (or MMM) reeds is a very different beast.  But the discussion of the chaotic effects of string gauge and length are relevant to reeds, with their thicknesses, parallel or tapered sides, weighted tips, flat or vertical mounting systems, etc.  And certainly the box has an effect on the tone as well.  Despite the fact that the soundboard "shouldn't" resonate (soundboard in name only) it certainly does, and so does the rest of the instrument - and each vibrating surface has one or more pitches at which this effect is more pronounced.  I think the most relevant message I take back to the melodeon discussion is: in a physical system, we can't always use logic and math to make an accurate predictive model.  We can start there, but we also have to give the wood and metal its say.

I don't think this touches the question of emotions and keys, which is perceptual, except to say that if physical systems are this chaotic, one can only imagine trying to make a predictive model for the mind of an individual within a lifetime and a culture.
Logged
Mudlark Music - restoration, repairs, lessons, and sales.  (USA)  http://mudlark-music.com

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon

Thank you Gonk. I'm learning along the way!
Q
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...

Any piano tuner who deliberately tuned away from ET to make them sound better in one key must be making an assumption (maybe wrong...) about what keys of music will be played on it, since by definition this will make it sound worse in other keys. There are instrument tunings which do sound better (especialy thirds and fifths) than ET in most of the keys related to the root, for example Aaron's quarter-comma meantone which I independently came up with about 30 years ago, only to find later that I'd been beaten to it by several hundred years.

If a two-row melodeon was tuned like this it would sound better in all the keys playable on it. The price to be paid is that each key away from the root key is slightly shifted in pitch away from ET -- for example if G was in concert pitch, IIRC going down the cycle of fifths (C...) they get flatter and going up (D...) they get sharper, which is great playing solo but hideous if you play with other instruments...

What Gonk is saying -- that different notes sound different on one instruments, and between different instruments -- is perfectly correct, also that a tune often has a "right" sounding key on a given instrument, which can of course be different for different tunes depending on which part of the scale they use relative to the tonic. But this is nothing to do with the "emotional feel" of different keys, for which there is no evidence or rational basis in ET tuning.
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall

All of the above.

Are we back to the sad sound of Bb, or the bright quality of A, as generally but not universally agreed, being some property of the human ear or brain?
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Calum

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 97

I wonder, however, even with these mean-tone (and similar more equally distributed) tunings, if people with perfect absolute pitch can discern a different flavoring of keys, than the rest of us mortals who have acceptable relative pitch only.

My experience of people with perfect pitch is the opposite: they assign pitch labels to any sound they hear without reference to tuning (and for this reason they can often have terrible intonation).  I did some experiments with a student of mine with perfect pitch and they would label any pitch as a specific note if it was up to 40 cents sharp or 60 cents flat.  Only right on that border would they have any hesitation at all. 
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place

I have a counter example.  A friend of mine who plays concertina has perfect pitch.  I gave her a concertina to try that was not in concert pitch, as soon as she played it she reacted as if she had received a shock and refused to play it again.  She also plays fiddle and has superb intonation.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Chris Rayner

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 467

As a long term (60 years) player of fretted strings (Guitar/banjo/ukulele etc.) I spent much of my musical career tuning my own instruments.  Initially using pitch pipes (Satan’s spawn) then to other players’ instruments, latterly using electronic gizmos, I have often found myself retuning slightly when switching from one key to another.  I had always assumed it was a feature of the deficiencies of the instrument and its strings, but I have now begun to wonder if it was my unconscious wish to tune to some more harmonious temperament.
Logged
Elderly amateur musician hoping to stave off dementia by learning to play the melodeon.  Main instrument a Tommy, also D/G and G/C pokerworks,  a single row 2 stop Hohner, and a new addition to the free reedery, a rather splendid Paolo Soprani four voice 120 bass c-system chromatic button accordion.  Very shiny, very loud, and about the same size and weight as a small car.  Now I’ve traded me Benny with (ahem) a cash adjustment, to a three voice 60 bass Castagnari K3.

Calum

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 97

That's interesting Theo.  I wonder what way round the fiddle and the intonation skills went.  Certainly my student has improved drastically with practice, though I suspect I'm never going to manage to teach him to hear intervals by quality than by calculation. 
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon

I remember years ago one of our Morris band members proudly played her new to her Overton whistle, only to be told quite firmly it was flat by another one of our musician friends who had perfect pitch. The wincing facial expression was incredible to see, and like Theo's friend, conveyed genuine pain on our musician friends' face.
 
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris

I remember years ago one of our Morris band members proudly played her new to her Overton whistle, only to be told quite firmly it was flat by another one of our musician friends who had perfect pitch. The wincing facial expression was incredible to see, and like Theo's friend, conveyed genuine pain on our musician friends' face.

Something I don't understand about perfect pitch (actually, one of the many things) is why it should be calibrated at A=440 and why it makes painful listening to those cursed if it varies. Surely a variation to this, isn't imperfect, just conventionally different.
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon

I dunno, but it seems to affect those 'gifted' (?) with it quite considerably.
Perhaps the affect is similar to us mere mortals when someone is singing badly out of tune sufficiently enough to wince.
I think we've all experienced it, and Les Dawson made an act out of playing way out of tune.
Q
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal