Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics  (Read 1734 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Peter Hamlin

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6
Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« on: September 27, 2020, 02:20:08 PM »

I'm curious how auxiliary (chromatic) accidental keys are used on diatonic accordions.

The standard button layout on this site and elsewhere is different than the layout used on the Italian video lessons I'm taking. They are reversed from the standard so you can play the leading tone in minor keys with the chord. (You can't do that in the standard layout because, for example, the F# major chord in b-minor is push and the A# of that chord is pull.) I'm in the process of swapping the reeds to reverse the push-pull on my D/A accordion so I can learn some really cool minor key tunes on the video lessons.

I also have a F/C/G and was thinking of swapping the auxiliaries on that one too. But I wanted to first ask if I'm missing something. I see that there are some minor chords you could play in the standard layout (assuming you have the thirds turned off on the chords), but that seems less useful to me than having minor-key leading tones. I haven't really found any information about the intended use of the auxiliary keys other than the lessons I've taken with the push/pull reversed. Would love to hear any insights into this!
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #1 on: September 27, 2020, 05:20:55 PM »

You sort of hint at the answer in your question. In theory the right end of a 2 row 4th apart melodeon, with 4 accs can  play in any key, but some are cool cats … basically the common modes of the main row scales … and some are dogs 😕. A three row only needs 3 accidentals, but if you want to play off piste scales you might ba better filling the 3rd row with octave accidentals and reverse notes

The key to making the diato play “out” keys, scales or modes actually lies in its left end 🤔  Using extremes to illustrate

Approach 1 is to add more bases. 12 bass gets you quite a long way, My 12 bass Oakwood accsDG had reverse A and B chords, and more “accidental” F and F#. The reverses, and its F# truly opened up all the modes of D for me … Bm, B blues, A minor or major. F# blues is “built in” on any D/G, but great to have a IV B chord to go with that. No C# (V7) though. You had to fudge that with AFAIR C with a Bb dabbed in on the right.

The big surprise was how easy playing in C was, including its modes Am, F, G mixolydian and blues, and Cm pentatonic of blues. The link is the 2-way

It turned out that the brass friendly Bb major or blurs scales played like rockets, almost all pull on my C# bases accs row, but … the only help from the left end was its F chord.  Are you getting my drift?  🙂

I sold it, here, to a good home, and got an 18 bass with the same C#DG right end, and 12 left chords with extras flat relative to my main rows, opening up F, Bb and even Eb. Short of a 24 or stradella base you have to choose whether extras are that, or sharper chords, opening up A, E, and perhaps B tunes (and their modes).

My other 6 notes are all basses, either reversals or monotonics. Add that up and you have all 12 basses in both directions. It was truly liberating! The bass sets your brains jnterpretation of a note set, so chording on right end I could accompany in all keys, albeit Ab is a … dog 😕  i’m a singer. I can now chord ot play motifs to suit my baritone 😎

Method 2 is quite the opposite. Build 2 diatonic rows either a semitone, or “devils interval” 3 tones apart. Both will
supply all needed accidentals and in theory you can play in any key. Some Irish top people do that with a tune, 12 times through, as a party piece. Sharon Shannon plays Tune for a Found Harmonium in Eb! I think the box is a C/C#? Whatever. Its all technique, and very melody led. These virtuosos often ignore the left end buttons. A few get monotonic basses of their choice

Those are the extremes, for illustration. You do really need a third row, and 12 bass to explore this properly, but … a DGaccs is not unhappy in C, particularly if clubbed, with a C/F bass. But other stuff is hard.

The other compromise is to build 3 rows semitone apart. George Garside of this parish, and incidentally of my own real one, is a master on the BCC# “British” system. Others are John K and Jimmy Shand. They come with full stradella, and are heavy. Bizarrely hardest to play on their main row scales as a result.

That’s how I see it.
« Last Edit: September 27, 2020, 05:27:05 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #2 on: September 27, 2020, 06:34:29 PM »

I'm curious how auxiliary (chromatic) accidental keys are used on diatonic accordions.

Your post here can be also referred to as like, some spin on the words 'accidental direction' or 'choice' or 'flip' or similar - that can help you find other people talk about it with the 'google search' option. Honestly though I've never really found anything conclusive other than 'it depends on your repertoire'.

Best I can tell, I don't think there is really a true 'standard' and it tends to depend on where the instrument was made and what the people who made it were asked to do. I've even come across several instruments that had one button but not both, 'flipped' from either perspective.

I also like (really cool) minor tunes and have had both of my 2 rows' accidental buttons set up opposite from the 'norm'. Do you have a 3rds stop for your bass end (or 3rdless chords)? If so, my preference was to flip both so (in A/D speak) I'd have a push F natural to play with the normally push only D major chord, and, a D# to play over what would normally be your pull B minor chord.

Generally, I've found few true disadvantages to this approach and I'm much more driven by music that works in this way, right now at least, but I can mention some of the disadvantages I've found:

  • Push C natural can be combined with push D chord + RHS D chord to create D7 chord
  • Pull Bb and Pull F are useful tritones over the pull E and B basses, and will crop up from time to time. You have bass reversal options for F over Bm (eg F# or more likely D) though.
  • Thinking of Bb as only being A# makes it easy to forget it is indeed also Bb, which can form the useful G minor chord when playing in D. While the G chord is available 'both ways' it still feels pretty weird to play it on the press rather than the draw in this situation.

Really I think more than anything it's the tritones that are going to come up way more in some kinds of music than others, and, flipping your plates one way or the other either really embraces them or really kinda shuns them.

When it comes to like, when I've tried to do more fancy chromatic music, my experience has been that one orientation seems to favour the accidental buttons feeling sensible vs the inside row tune 'major'ish playing, and the other vs the outside row 'major'ish tune playing, for the purposes of chromatic runs anyway. I think certain patterns hold true but it gets messy to try and describe them - it's mostly just little things and factors more into like air management etc than if you can/can't play something.

When it comes to a three row, motivations will be slightly different, because you'll have one of those accs already on the 'lowest' main row and chords to match. These boxes tend to provide you with a 3rd acc button that is the lower octave + 'flipped' version of your innermost row button. The main thing is to look at the RHS chords you can form that use 2 of the normally opposed accidental buttons. I'd probably still set them up for the best harmonic minor experiences.
Logged

Peter Hamlin

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #3 on: September 29, 2020, 01:54:33 PM »

Chris Ryall, Thanks for all this detail!!! I appreciate the information.

I'll probably give myself some time with the swapped keys when the G/D instrument returns with the keys flipped, and meanwhile I'll explore the "standard" layout on my G/C/F to help me decide whether to also swap that one later. I hadn't known all those details about other layouts -- really interesting!

I do have a really nice 78-bass Brandoni piano accordion so that's an option if I want to play in A-flat or something like that. But meanwhile there are a couple of specific tunes I really want to learn on the G/D box that require the flip, so I'll see how that goes.

Thanks again!
« Last Edit: September 29, 2020, 01:57:27 PM by Peter Hamlin »
Logged

Peter Hamlin

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #4 on: September 29, 2020, 02:02:55 PM »

Gena Crisman: Thank you! Very helpful!

I have some specific tunes I want to learn when I get the D/G accordion back after the reeds have been flipped, and it'll be fun to see how it goes! I've had my diatonics for a few years but have only just started to try to figure out the chromatic buttons. It's very interesting!
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #5 on: September 29, 2020, 02:42:47 PM »

I play quite a few minor (often Swedish) waltzes in Emi, and for these it's pretty much essential to have the major third accidental on push to go with the Bma chord on push when the tunes use this, which dictates which way round the accidentals have to be. Other people may have different reasons...
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #6 on: September 29, 2020, 03:04:08 PM »

I play quite a few minor (often Swedish) waltzes in Emi, and for these it's pretty much essential to have the major third accidental on push to go with the Bma chord on push when the tunes use this, which dictates which way round the accidentals have to be. Other people may have different reasons...

The directional "problem" occurs ON the beat, so if you simply offset the note half a beat or support it with a moving harmonic line (or both), you solve a great percentage of the challenges. 

That said, I would like to have an 11/10/4
setup with both standard and flipped on the helper row so as not to lose the ability to use counter-motion in harmony lines.
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #7 on: September 29, 2020, 03:10:09 PM »

To reinforce, and “put another way” the Eb  acc, the major 3rd of B7 chord should be push for these Em, in Scandinavia commonly E  harmonic minor. Although you might have 3rds out in your B left chord, the tune “wants” the strong turnaround effect that is intrinsic to B7, and that chord has major 3rd, minor 7th

Whereas the Emharm scale runs EF#GABCD#E. Yup minor third and major 7, confusing but it works like magic. You can see the B, D#=Eb, F#, A notes of B7 chord in there too.

This usually throws your F acc into pull, spoiling your G7 melody line. Anahata layout solved that.

In “more English” modal tunes where the V chord is Bm7 there is no problem. As ever … it depends what you play.

Back to my point about 12+ basses, my own Eb acc is pull, but “no problem” as I have a B push bass 😉 Larger bass sets don’t just help with keys. They also liberate the melody runs we make on the other end that happen to be “wrong way”
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #8 on: September 30, 2020, 07:56:57 PM »

A question for you Peter, can you tell us the titles of the minor tunes you are interested to learn from that Italian site?

Now, asking for a G/C melodeon to an Italian maker you'll probably obtain an instrument with a G sharp on the push and a B flat on the pull on top of the C row, and a C sharp on the push and an E flat on the pull on top of the G row.

On a D/G instrument that means a D sharp pushing the bellows and an F on the pull on top of the G row, and a G sharp on the push and a B flat on the pull on top of the D row.

In other words, the accidentals on top of the inner row are inverted, if you are used to the Hohner standard, but the ones on the outer row aren't.

Yet, as a number of Italian makers sell they instruments abroad, and since the Hohner boxes are often chosen by the beginners because they are light and cheap, some of them probably follow the Hohner standard anyway. The traditional Italian  two row instruments – I mean until the second world war – had no accidentals (and often 19 buttons), and all the chords were major.

Now, to have a D sharp pulling the bellows on a D/G melodeon, considering that the note is the third of the B major chords, really makes sense. It's the fact that the B chord is major that is a nonsense, but on an instrument with a stop to mute the thirds you can really use it a minor chord both playing in D and in G.

On my old D/G box, following the advice of the great Emmanuelle Pariselle, I inverted the button at the top of the D row too. That made sense considering that at the same time I muted the thirds in three chords: the A chord, to use it as a major chord playing in D and as a minor chord playing in G; the B chord, since the B minor is a pretty useful diatonic chord both playing in D and ing G; the E chord, that with the  G sharp pulling the bellow could be used as a major chord. For the record, since the A/D/G melodeon is an expansion of the D/G instruments, and in it the G sharp is available pulling the bellows on the A row, again the G sharp on the push makes little sense (although, at least  in continental Europe, the three row instruments in three key are rare as a dodo).

To be totally honest, as far as my experience goes, whatever your choice the number of tunes in which this or that accidental should preferably be played pulling rather than pulling the bellows is equivalent to the number of tunes in which you should preferably playing on the other bellows direction...


I'm not sure that inverting the accidentals on a three row instrument in three keys, like a G/C/F, makes sense. Actually I don't know which are the accidentals on your instrument, and whether you have a stop to mute the thirds, or have at least muted some of them. My A/D/G melodeon, for the record,  has a customised  layout for both the right and the left keyboard. What I can tell, as far as the D sharp is concerned (please transpose up a tone for the G/C/F) is that you have (again, transpose up a tone) the B chord   (that in the standard instrument is major, like in the D/G) and pulling the bellows (that in the standard instruments is a minor chord), so if you can mute the thirds, or have muted those of the B chords, if the note is available pulling rather than pushing the bellows is irrelevant. On my A/D/G box I left the D sharp on top of the G row on the push, for backward compatibility, but the other one, that's an octave lower, is a pull note.

 
 
Logged

Peter Hamlin

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #9 on: October 02, 2020, 03:19:39 PM »

A question for you Peter, can you tell us the titles of the minor tunes you are interested to learn from that Italian site?

One is "Tanz Yiddeleck" which he plays on a G/C in a klezmer mode of E. So  E F G# A B C D E. So E major is the tonic and you play the piece with the thirds off and the G# is common harmoniizing the E on strong beats.
Another tune I want to learn is Kurt Weill, Youkali, which is a tango in a-(harmonic) minor.

Quote

Now, asking for a G/C melodeon to an Italian maker you'll probably obtain an instrument with a G sharp on the push and a B flat on the pull on top of the C row, and a C sharp on the push and an E flat on the pull on top of the G row. So far the only one I need is the G# push but I'm reversing the other one also to match the teacher's layout.


The layout he uses on his G/C is G# push on the C row and Eb (D#) push on the G row, allowing leading tones in a-minor and e-minor, so I guess I will have what you describe here:

Quote


On my old D/G box, following the advice of the great Emmanuelle Pariselle, I inverted the button at the top of the D row too.


(I usually mute the thirds -- I just like the sound in general, even on standard major key tunes.)

Quote

To be totally honest, as far as my experience goes, whatever your choice the number of tunes in which this or that accidental should preferably be played pulling rather than pulling the bellows is equivalent to the number of tunes in which you should preferably playing on the other bellows direction...


Good point. So far the vast majority of tunes I've learned don't use the chromatic keys at all and as a retired music theory teacher, not having that leading tone with the V chord in minor drove me nuts!

Quote

I'm not sure that inverting the accidentals on a three row instrument in three keys, like a G/C/F, makes sense. Actually I don't know which are the accidentals on your instrument, and whether you have a stop to mute the thirds, or have at least muted some of them. My A/D/G melodeon, for the record,  has a customised  layout for both the right and the left keyboard. What I can tell, as far as the D sharp is concerned (please transpose up a tone for the G/C/F) is that you have (again, transpose up a tone) the B chord   (that in the standard instrument is major, like in the D/G) and pulling the bellows (that in the standard instruments is a minor chord), so if you can mute the thirds, or have muted those of the B chords, if the note is available pulling rather than pushing the bellows is irrelevant. On my A/D/G box I left the D sharp on top of the G row on the push, for backward compatibility, but the other one, that's an octave lower, is a pull note.

Thanks for all this detail. After I get the D/G back with the swapped keys, I plan to wait and see on the F/C/G. If I swap the chromatic notes, then I can play the same tunes/fingerings in a different key. If I don't swap them, I'll have an alternate layout available for different tunes. So I'll have to decide what's more useful. I really love the harmonic minor sound so I think that's an avenue I'll enjoy a lot. I've played the diatonics for a few years but haven't used the chromatic keys at all until now. Thanks for your help!
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Auxiliary (chromatic) keys on diatonics
« Reply #10 on: October 03, 2020, 02:08:10 PM »

I play quite a few minor (often Swedish) waltzes in Emi, and for these it's pretty much essential to have the major third accidental on push to go with the Bma chord on push when the tunes use this, which dictates which way round the accidentals have to be. Other people may have different reasons...

The directional "problem" occurs ON the beat, so if you simply offset the note half a beat or support it with a moving harmonic line (or both), you solve a great percentage of the challenges. 

That said, I would like to have an 11/10/4
setup with both standard and flipped on the helper row so as not to lose the ability to use counter-motion in harmony lines.

Doesn't work on the tunes I'm thinking of which have the major third as a long note at the start of a bar over a B bass note, nothing else fits and moving the bass or the note mangles the tune horribly...
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal