Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout  (Read 3322 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Robin

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 101
D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« on: November 20, 2020, 08:12:12 PM »

Hello,

I'm ordering an accordion in D/C#. I'm trying to choose a layout for the bass side.
I was wondering if some of you (particularly D/C# & C#/D players) might have some thoughts & advices on the matter.
Here are a few of the possibilities I'm considering:

(all chords are thirdless)

1) No bass at all - a bit radical maybe (but some players - Denis Pépin, Susie Lemay, Gilles Poutoux - seem to be happy with the system). Don't think I would go there, but I'm interested to hear what you think about this  (:)

2) A simple 8 bass system I already use on a Hohner:
Top out | a/e  A/E | d/a  D/A | Bottom out
Top in   | b/c  B/C | g/g  G/G | Bottom in

3) A 12 bass extension of the previous layout (with the advantages of having the more usual F#/B, plus a B on the push)
Top out | b/c#  B/C# |  a/e    A/E  | d/a  D/A | Bottom out
Top in   |  f/c     F/C   | f#/b  F#/B | g/g  G/G | Bottom in

3b) A variant of the previous 12 bass layout, with | e/c#  E/C# | instead of | b/c#  B/C# | . Basically Jackie Daly's layout though in a different order.
I guess an E on the push could come in handy.

4) Joe Derrane's 14 bass system
Top out | F#/F#  | b/b  B/B | a/a  A/A | f/c  F/C | Bottom out
Top in   | C#/C# | e/e  E/E | d/d  D/D | g/g  G/G | Bottom in
Which gives most common bass/chords in both directions. But is a completely new system to learn...

5) 12 bass Serafini system (with a stop to remove the low reeds, giving the possibility to play melody lines, or create chords by combining notes)
Top out | G# | F# | E | D | C | Bb | Bottom out
Top in   | C# | B | A | G | F | Eb | Bottom in
Also a new system to me. But seems easier to learn.

Thank you for your help  (:)

Robin
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #1 on: November 20, 2020, 08:48:51 PM »

On a 12-bass system, I would put the least frequently used pairs at the bottom. They are the hardest to reach and a long way from your air button.

The system I currently have is your 3), only with your top pairs down at the bottom. Consider the fact that your essential C chord is most often used when playing in G and in D mixolydian. I think you might regret not having it close to your G and D pairs.

I have often said that the really essential pair missing from a standard 8-bass is F/C and that the other two buttons are a toss-up. Jackie has E/C# and the C# is really used for walking basses using the bass note only. The chord on the pull is really in the wrong direction. If you actually needed a C# chord in a tune, say a tune in F#m, then you would be more likely to need it on the push against G# and push C# (based on my limited experience of trying to accompany F#m tunes).

I chose a B push because there are places I like to use it - mainly in Dmaj tunes as it happens. But lately I have realised that an E push would probably get more use. If you play a lot of tunes in Amaj, you will need it. If I had to order another box I would be seriously torn between the E and the B push.

I can't comment on 4) and 5). I'd be interested in trying them without having to pay for a new box with those layouts.  :P

Regarding your 1), I can't imagine being without F# opposite B. As I think I might have said to you somewhere else, I'd rather be without the C and put an X against accompanying in tunes in G so that I can do justice to Bm tunes and have the F# for use in D and A and Em tunes.

Robin

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 101
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #2 on: November 21, 2020, 06:45:28 AM »

Hi Stiamh,

Thanks for the comments.

I see your point concerning the least frequently used pairs at the bottom. I should have mentioned I did this on purpose.
I also play a lot on fourth-apart boxes and I'm quite used to that kind of layout (for instance, for playing in C on a D/G, F on a G/C, or G on a A/D). I just assumed it would be easier to use a system I already know well. Hence the (slightly modified) A/D bass layout I used for option  3). But I realise how uncommon it may seem for a semitone box... Thanks for pointing this out!

Good point about the C# on the pull. How about (still on the pull) a C# bass with a D chord (which could be useful too...)? Or just a D pair on the pull?
An other possibility would be to have only bass buttons on this pair, for instance | E/D  B/C# | ?

I'm torn between B and E on the push too  :-\

Quote
I can't comment on 4) and 5). I'd be interested in trying them without having to pay for a new box with those layouts.  :P
Yes, that would be nice  :D  I have arranged a visit to a fellow player who has a Serafini box in G/C/acc to test option 5).
I doubt I'll find someone using Joe Derrane's layout around here though...

Quote
Regarding your 1), I can't imagine being without F# opposite B. As I think I might have said to you somewhere else, I'd rather be without the C and put an X against accompanying in tunes in G so that I can do justice to Bm tunes and have the F# for use in D and A and Em tunes.
It's been discussed by Mike Averill and Paul Groff, here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19540.msg237856.html#msg237856
I guess both options work, depending on what tunes you play the most. The 12 bass layout sort of solves the problem.
« Last Edit: November 21, 2020, 06:47:19 AM by Robin »
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #3 on: November 21, 2020, 04:13:18 PM »

For me, having the pairs I use most often (D/A and G/G) on the bottom would be very tiresome. It may depend on the size of your hands and the size of your box, I suppose (I have large hands and short fingers!), but using those buttons constantly with my thumb on the air button constantly (which it is) would be a pain, probably literally.

Curiously the idea of four bass buttons came to me overnight. It's an idea worth contemplating. If your maker agrees to it...

Mike Averill

  • suffering from MAD
  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 325
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #4 on: November 22, 2020, 06:51:44 PM »

It's been discussed by Mike Averill and Paul Groff, here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19540.msg237856.html#msg237856
I guess both options work, depending on what tunes you play the most. The 12 bass layout sort of solves the problem.
I have to be honest here,  when playing  DC# I very rarely touch the bass these days. Since I got the 4 voice Walters the red black dot has stayed on the shelf. The walters has an |a/e A/E |d/g D/G| layout so I generally leave chords/ bass to the band.

Mike  A
« Last Edit: November 22, 2020, 06:53:41 PM by Mike Averill »
Logged
Hohner - 1 row 4 stop C and G, pokerwork DG, DoubleRay DC#, Corso CC#, Corona III ADG, CLUB X CF, Elysium II CF
Saltarelle 1 row 4 stop D, Castagnari Giordy DG, Sander DG
Sonola CC#, Walters DC#

Pearse Rossa

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 723
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #5 on: November 22, 2020, 06:56:09 PM »

I can't imagine being without F# opposite B. As I think I might have said to you somewhere else, I'd rather be without the C and put an X against accompanying in tunes in G so that I can do justice to Bm tunes and have the F# for use in D and A and Em tunes.

Spot on, and this is what I had in mind when I 'built' my 1 row, 8 bass D melodeon.
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #6 on: November 22, 2020, 07:34:11 PM »


It's been discussed by Mike Averill and Paul Groff, here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19540.msg237856.html#msg237856


Just to clarify, I personally like many different options for small ( 2 - 16) sets of diatonic basses, but I actually never use  the combination "B/C" for a pair of bass/chord buttons,  myself

My comments in that other thread were just entertaining the positive options of someone else's idea.

I'm a piano, organ, and guitar player so from my perspective, being used to great choice of chords and voicings, any accordion layout  of 2 - 16 basses seems very simplistic and minimal. Even the anglo concertina offers more choice of harmonization.

I do love the accordion! But I have never expected the basses to provide all the harmony options that I hear in my head. I'd pick up a different instrument, or find an accompanist, if I wanted those.

So from my particular perspective I see the basses of a diatonic accordion in terms of "less is more"

I love the raw effects of just 2 basses, or getting as much as possible from different possibilities of 8 or 12. But I don't fret about what's not included. Most harmony options that I can imagine are not included in such a bass layout.

On the other hand, boxes that are heavy on the left hand are a misery to me.  I know other players have mastered the art of taming large beasts but that's not my life goal. Hats off to Emil Vacher, Jimmy Shand, Joe Derrane (in his later years), and many more!

So to chase after an illusion of harmonic completeness, with an extensive bass layout, is not an attractive compromise for me, if it makes the box much heavier on the left side. Not surprised to see that some players much more advanced than myself have gone for the "no basses" option!

For a DC# the traditional 4 basses are one very playable and lightweight compromise offering a bit of harmony and accent options. 8 basses, not too bad. But it seems to me that in adding more basses you could quickly lose the nimbleness and "melodeon roots" that can be an attractive quality in many of the traditional DC# boxes.


PG
« Last Edit: November 22, 2020, 07:50:22 PM by pgroff »
Logged

Peadar

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2039
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #7 on: November 22, 2020, 08:55:29 PM »



 I see the basses of a diatonic accordion in terms of "less is more"

.........I love the raw effects of just 2 basses, or getting as much as possible from different possibilities of 8 or 12. But I don't fret about what's not included. Most harmony options that I can imagine are not included in such a bass layout.

On the other hand, boxes that are heavy on the left hand are a misery to me. ............

So to chase after an illusion of harmonic completeness, with an extensive bass layout, is not an attractive compromise for me, if it makes the box much heavier on the left side. Not surprised to see that some players much more advanced than myself have gone for the "no basses" option!

For a DC# the traditional 4 basses are one very playable and lightweight compromise offering a bit of harmony and accent options. 8 basses, not too bad. But it seems to me that in adding more basses you could quickly lose the nimbleness and "melodeon roots" that can be an attractive quality in many of the traditional DC# boxes.


PG

Semi-idle curiousity from a dabbler in Scottish  4 bass C&C# / B&C : On a DC#  are the "traditional 4 basses" a D/A pair and a C#/G# pair?
 
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #8 on: November 22, 2020, 09:06:44 PM »



 I see the basses of a diatonic accordion in terms of "less is more"

.........I love the raw effects of just 2 basses, or getting as much as possible from different possibilities of 8 or 12. But I don't fret about what's not included. Most harmony options that I can imagine are not included in such a bass layout.

On the other hand, boxes that are heavy on the left hand are a misery to me. ............

So to chase after an illusion of harmonic completeness, with an extensive bass layout, is not an attractive compromise for me, if it makes the box much heavier on the left side. Not surprised to see that some players much more advanced than myself have gone for the "no basses" option!

For a DC# the traditional 4 basses are one very playable and lightweight compromise offering a bit of harmony and accent options. 8 basses, not too bad. But it seems to me that in adding more basses you could quickly lose the nimbleness and "melodeon roots" that can be an attractive quality in many of the traditional DC# boxes.


PG

Semi-idle curiousity from a dabbler in Scottish  4 bass C&C# / B&C : On a DC#  are the "traditional 4 basses" a D/A pair and a C#/G# pair?

Hi Peadar,

Yes, you do see that sometimes!  Not my favorite choice even for a "full" 19 key D/C# but you see it even for 15 key boxes with only 5 buttons in C#.  But if you have a 19 key box with 9 buttons for the C# row I guess I could see the point. In an emergency where something is wrong with the D row you might be able to finish the gig in C#, if you are playing solo. Or could play with a fiddler tuned down half a step.

But more common to see D/A and D/G. D/A and G/G also works well. Or D/A and A/E.

My intent was really that a traditional DC# box built with 4 basses allows those options for some harmony while potentially having a very lighweight bass side. Not only fewer reeds (which BTW can be flat mounted, if there are only 12 or 16 bass/chord reedplates which is typical for 4 bass buttons,  for a gruntier melodeon sound), but also the whole left casework can be built narrower with a single column of 4 bass buttons.

PG
« Last Edit: November 22, 2020, 09:08:53 PM by pgroff »
Logged

tirpous

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1403
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #9 on: November 22, 2020, 11:13:09 PM »

I have a C#/D Double Ray Deluxe with 12-button Stradella bass.  Plus: no need to worry about bellows direction, your bass/chords are always 'there'.  Minus: well, of course, 6 bass/chord combinations are missing.  I live with it, but replacing 1 or 2 less-used chord(s) with 1 or to missing  bass(es) has occured to me more than once.  Taken all the way this would lead to all bass no chords (Serafini, your number 5). 

... and also a D/C#, with simple D/A and D/G bass as Paul (pgroff) just described.  This is basically a one-row with 2 rows (!), more rythmic accompaniment with limited harmony. 

No matter which way you go, it will be a compromise (don't forget weight...).  It depends on the personality you envision for the box, number of treble voices, etc...

Good luck !
Logged

Robin

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 101
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #10 on: November 26, 2020, 06:50:44 AM »

Many thanks for all your answers.
It's all very interesting. And much appreciated!

Quote
I do love the accordion! But I have never expected the basses to provide all the harmony options that I hear in my head. I'd pick up a different instrument, or find an accompanist, if I wanted those.
and
Quote
So to chase after an illusion of harmonic completeness, with an extensive bass layout, is not an attractive compromise for me, if it makes the box much heavier on the left side. Not surprised to see that some players much more advanced than myself have gone for the "no basses" option!

Good point, of course... Much of what I have in mind in term of accompaniment can not be played on a basic bass layout. And a good accompanist will always have more options. On the other hand, it's very tempting to be able to play some chords/basses/drones/emulate fiddle double stops(...) in some cases.

Weight is definitely an issue to consider. I guess, the best thing to do is to try a few box with similar weights and layout to those I was mentioning. And play tunes on the row to emulate what I'd get on a one row melodeon.

Here is yet another option to consider:
6) A 12 bass layout variant based on Joe Derrane's idea. With 5 unisonoric pairs in G D A E B and a sixth bisonoric pair in F#/C.
This would give most common chords both ways (on the same buttons) plus 2 handy (but slightly less used) chords in just one direction.
With the sacrifice of F and C# that are maybe less essential. I guess this would give lots of possibility, without chasing
Quote
after an illusion of harmonic completeness, with an extensive bass layout
.

Feel free to comment!
« Last Edit: November 26, 2020, 06:53:19 AM by Robin »
Logged

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #11 on: November 26, 2020, 09:22:29 AM »

3) A 12 bass extension of the previous layout (with the advantages of having the more usual F#/B, plus a B on the push)
Top out | b/c#  B/C# |  a/e    A/E  | d/a  D/A | Bottom out
Top in   |  f/c     F/C   | f#/b  F#/B | g/g  G/G | Bottom in

3b) A variant of the previous 12 bass layout, with | e/c#  E/C# | instead of | b/c#  B/C# | . Basically Jackie Daly's layout though in a different order.
I guess an E on the push could come in handy.

For the 12 basses layouts, I'd be all in favour of having a D in both bellows directions, and in general to have all the drones of the usual keys available in both directions (that is, D, A, G, and their minor relatives B, F#, E).
 
4) Joe Derrane's 14 bass system
Top out | F#/F#  | b/b  B/B | a/a  A/A | f/c  F/C | Bottom out
Top in   | C#/C# | e/e  E/E | d/d  D/D | g/g  G/G | Bottom in
Which gives most common bass/chords in both directions. But is a completely new system to learn...

I didn't notice but this system is very close to what Basque players (trikitixia players) use on 2 row, 4th apart accordions.

5) 12 bass Serafini system (with a stop to remove the low reeds, giving the possibility to play melody lines, or create chords by combining notes)
Top out | G# | F# | E | D | C | Bb | Bottom out
Top in   | C# | B | A | G | F | Eb | Bottom in

It's also known in the concertina world as the Wicki-Hayden system (invented a first time at the end of the 19th century by Kaspar Wicki, a second time in the 80's by Brian Hayden, and some 10 years ago by Marc Sérafini).
I'm all in favour of any 12 unisonoric bass system, but that's also due to the fact that I don't use the chords that much when playing Irish music or music from Québec, much more like drones and/or small dropplets in the style of uillean pipes regulators. If you don't make alternated bass/chords accompaniments that much, it'll be very easy

Robin

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 101
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #12 on: November 30, 2020, 08:52:23 PM »

Quote
I didn't notice but this system is very close to what Basque players (trikitixia players) use on 2 row, 4th apart accordions.
Well spotted! Thank you for pointing this out  (:)  I was contemplating option 6) and trying to work out how to organise the potential layout.
This could work:
Top out   | b/b  B/B | d/d  D/D | g/g  G/G | Bottom out
Top in     | e/e  E/E | a/a  A/A  | f#/c  F#/C | Bottom in

Last week I (briefly) tested a Serafini Darwin. The bass layout is very logical and easy to use.
It did feel it would be very interesting to have on a fourth-apart 3 row box. But probably not what I'm looking for in this case.

Logged

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #13 on: November 30, 2020, 09:59:25 PM »

As a D/C# player I use the traditional bass layout for an A/D, which is the same system used by some C#/D players (I *think*), and can be found here (bass side only, obviously):

http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20A_D%20-%20with%20accidentals.jpg

For an 8-bass system, I find it a good compromise and seems to cover the most ground for playing in the standard session keys.  This is the same as 8 of your 12 buttons on option #3, only losing the four pairs on your chin end.  I know that some C#/D players prefer having a G/E instead of a G/G, but I just can't get my head around that!

Regarding Stiamh's suggestion of having the D/A and G/G pairs on the top instead of the bottom, I'd never really considered that but it makes sense!  I guess I haven't contributed anything new here, but as a (newer) D/C# player I thought I'd throw my hat in the ring.
« Last Edit: November 30, 2020, 10:01:30 PM by mselic »
Logged
C#/D player

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #14 on: November 30, 2020, 10:15:41 PM »

Robin, to whom are you planning to order your accordion?
The option to have 4x3 buttons is also a good one I think, perhaps better than 2x6, because you can reach it without moving that much your hand.
If you go for unisonoric basses, you could have something like

Code: [Select]
d/d   D/D   g/g  G/G
e/e   E/E   a/a  A/A
f#/f# F#/F# b/b B/B
Which would go in fifths vertically and one tone horizontally.

Also, regarding the Darwin layout, it depends on whether or not you'll need chords. If you don't, then the layout is still valid with 12 buttons.

Peadar

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2039
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #15 on: November 30, 2020, 11:57:36 PM »

Just don't forget that the more basses you have the heavier is the left hand end and the harder it is to waggle the bellows. I was under the impression that the main point of the "Irish" C#/D and Irish-American D/C# boxes is to be able to play tunes in D "on the row", so the lighter the back end the better - which is where the old German type spoon basses might really win out.
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #16 on: December 01, 2020, 12:12:41 AM »

I know that some C#/D players prefer having a G/E instead of a G/G...
Do they, though? Or do they just accept what they are given by manufacturers who seem to have decided that if B/C players ask for the "McComiskey" layout, the same thing transposed up a tone must be good for C#/D players?

Mind you, I have recently come to appreciate the need for a push E bass/chord. I used to think it would only be useful for playing in E major (basically playing D tunes B/C style) but I now realise how often it would be handy for tunes that are in A major. It's an option worth considering on a 12-bass machine.

Quote
Regarding Stiamh's suggestion of having the D/A and G/G pairs on the top instead of the bottom, I'd never really considered that but it makes sense!

I think you have misunderstood. I recommended having D/A and G/G in the middle of a 12-bass layout rather than at the bottom, as Robin suggested in his original post. This because I think they would get the most use, and because the lowest buttons on a 12-bass are more awkward.

I was under the impression that the main point of the "Irish" C#/D and Irish-American D/C# boxes is to be able to play tunes in D "on the row", so the lighter the back end the better - which is where the old German type spoon basses might really win out.

That's a curious observation to add to a thread started by someone who wants 12 or 14 basses. Not to mention a very reductionist view of the possibilities of a C#/D or D/C# system. Would you say this D/C# exponent would be better served with spoon basses?  (:)

Robin

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 101
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #17 on: December 01, 2020, 12:42:03 PM »

Quote
As a D/C# player I use the traditional bass layout for an A/D
Yes, it's a valid option too. If I went that road I'd probably choose a 12 bass layout to get a C on the pull and a B on the push.

Quote
The option to have 4x3 buttons is also a good one I think
Somehow I find having to reach further for a third row less comfortable, especially on a semitone box.
With 2 rows of buttons my wrist and my hand do the bellow work. With 3, I have to move my hand further and some of the work is done by the arm instead. I feel it gives me less bellow control and less precision.

Quote
regarding the Darwin layout, it depends on whether or not you'll need chords.
Upon reflection, I think I will happily use them!

Quote
Quote
    I was under the impression that the main point of the "Irish" C#/D and Irish-American D/C# boxes is to be able to play tunes in D "on the row", so the lighter the back end the better - which is where the old German type spoon basses might really win out.

That's a curious observation to add to a thread started by someone who wants 12 or 14 basses. Not to mention a very reductionist view of the possibilities of a C#/D or D/C# system. Would you say this D/C# exponent would be better served with spoon basses?  (:)
(:)
Logged

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: D/C# bass side - choosing a layout
« Reply #18 on: December 01, 2020, 03:53:06 PM »

Oops - thanks for the clarification, Steve. Regarding the G/E bass option, I had several C#/D players question my desire for G/G and recommend the former instead.  I’m quite happy I stuck to my guns on this one and went with G/G. When we’re talking basses, I don’t see there being any difference between D/C# and C#/D, btw.
Logged
C#/D player
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal