I've found both types of action can perform really well in a quality build. I never had humidity problems with the open action of my Castagnari Nik, but an earlier Dino Baffetti model suffered somewhat. I cured the problem by stripping the action, scraping the sides of the lever arms, sandpapering a little off the ends, radiusing the sharp edges and rubbing them all over with a candle. The action never stuck again and was appreciably faster. On the other hand, I've found the metal actions in Castagnaris (Trilly and 1914) to be fast and quiet in contrast to a Pokerwork which is noisy and slow and whose design almost precludes improvement!
My point was that a metal action can be produced and fitted quite cheaply if design and tolerancing is right whereas to match its performance with an open mechanism is a skilled, labour intensive process. I like both.
Rob.