Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4   Go Down

Author Topic: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)  (Read 19052 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #40 on: October 20, 2009, 10:10:24 PM »

I prefer cross-row playing and I think an A/D/G gives much more possibility to avoid heavy push-pull sequences when playing tunes upto speed.

As a player of both 3-row and one-row boxes in a style in which speed is a major element, I think that this "speed" reason for cross-rowing (or using multi-row boxes) only applies for beginners -- once you have worked on press/draw bellows technique, you should be able to play "up to speed" on one row.  There are good reasons to play cross-row (chords and smoothness among them), but when speed is the issue, my concern is that a beginner may cut him-or-herself off from learning better bellows/air-button technique -- playing on one-row with determination and grit should provide excellent lessons in this.  If you have doubts about playing press/draw quickly on one row, then don't just take my word for it: Listen to some Quebecois players -- I recommend Raynald Ouellet's excellent solo album; or check out Brendan Begley if Irish playing is your aim.
-Andy
P.S. as for the original poster, I think that A/D/G would be an excellent choice.


Thanks again, Andy. Now that's the kind of inside information I knew I'd get from you forum experts. More smoothness from cross-row playing on a 3-row, but learning better bellows/air-button technique from a 2-row. Very interesting. More food for thought...
Logged

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #41 on: October 20, 2009, 10:18:38 PM »

I think that the reason why you don't get D/G/C tunings might be something to do with the pitch.
If the G & C rows were in normal G/C pitch, the D row would be very low. If the D & G rows were in D/G pitch, the C row would be very squeeky.
If you think of the keys used for A/D/Gs and G/C/Fs, they cover the whole range of pitches used in the more popular tunings, ie the G on the outside row of a G/C being the lowest, and the G on the inside row of a D/G being the highest.

When I got my G/C + accidentals, I had a moment when I thought I should have got a G/C/F, but then I realized that you miss out on some of the basses which are so nice when you're playing G/C.

It would be nice if you could design a box that was like a G/C and a D/G stuck together, but I'm not sure how you would do it.

Thanks again for your thoughts, ganderbox. You've shed some additional (and important) light for me. I had assumed that a G/C/F was in fact a G/C with the F row added, and that the A/D/G was simply a D/G with the A row added. In other words, I had assumed that in an A/D/G or a G/C/F you would be getting a two-for-one, namely, that you would also be getting a D/G or G/C built in, but I now know it doesn't quite work that way.
Logged

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #42 on: October 20, 2009, 10:24:13 PM »

A little detail which I have found a bit puzzling in the beginning is the fact, that - for example - a G/C/F 3-row accordeon
is in fact a 2-row C/F accordeon extended with a G row and additional 4 basses instead of a 2-row G/C extended with a F row
A  D/G/C 3 row would be nice, but I have never seen such a thing ...

An A/D/G is nice, you can play it like a 2-row D/G
but for those who are used to G/C there is no 3-row equivalent like an A/D/G for D/G players,
or a G/C/F for C/F.


Thanks, michik, for helping to clear up my misconception about 3-row boxes. And again, thanks to all forum members who've responded with your thoughts and expertise!
Logged

nemethmik

  • Guest
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #43 on: October 21, 2009, 04:58:49 PM »

I prefer cross-row playing and I think an A/D/G gives much more possibility to avoid heavy push-pull sequences when playing tunes upto speed.

As a player of both 3-row and one-row boxes in a style in which speed is a major element, I think that this "speed" reason for cross-rowing (or using multi-row boxes) only applies for beginners -- once you have worked on press/draw bellows technique, you should be able to play "up to speed" on one row.  There are good reasons to play cross-row (chords and smoothness among them), but when speed is the issue, my concern is that a beginner may cut him-or-herself off from learning better bellows/air-button technique -- playing on one-row with determination and grit should provide excellent lessons in this.  If you have doubts about playing press/draw quickly on one row, then don't just take my word for it: Listen to some Quebecois players -- I recommend Raynald Ouellet's excellent solo album; or check out Brendan Begley if Irish playing is your aim.
-Andy
Andy,
I agree completely and I am very happy that you posted your comment; I wanted to discuss it a number of times on this great forum. I am (nearly) sure that I (and possibly many of us less talented musicians) will never be able to learn proper bellows press/draw techniques to play up-to-speed on one row. I am simply not talented enough to learn with a reasonable amount of efforts/practicing. I think a major reason of the emergence of the popularity of Piano Accordions or Continental Chromatic Button Accordions is that their bellows techniques are much-much easier to learn than the push/draw (single row) boxes. IMHO, the delicate bellows control required for (single row) push/pull boxes when playing fast tunes is terribly difficult to learn, and I (and possibly many of us) will never get there.
I have bought not less than 8 instructional DVDs about (Irish/Cajun/English) diatonic music, and none of them had a single minute about bellows push/pull techniques. These videos teach you pressing the melody buttons as if the listener were an idiot, they teach melodies, ornamentation, chords but nothing about bellows (and air button).
I gave up learning B/C; it's terribly difficult. I am much more successfull with my new G/C box because of the much more flexible cross-rowing possibilities (I think).
Miki

Logged

Eric Barker

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 49
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #44 on: October 21, 2009, 10:45:19 PM »

If G/C is the lowest pitch for a 2 row melodeon where is G/C/F pitched?  I thought the G/C rows were the same between the two instruments.  Also where does the BCC# fit in the pitch scheme of G/C being lowest and D/G being highest?
Thank you!  Eric in Montana
Logged

Steve C.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2075
  • Erica, Morse Anglo
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #45 on: October 21, 2009, 11:08:44 PM »

Since you are in the US, consider an Irish Dancemaster D/G.  On the other hand, the lower price Hohners (Panther, Compadre) in GCF are pretty good starters for the money. 
You will not find a lot of tutors for the GCF unless you are wanting to learn Tex-Mex.
I started out with a Pokerwork DG and the Mally book and am convinced that you would learn the most, in the shortest time, with the best sense of accomplishment with this combination.
Then you can figure out what you want going forward.  You never know.  Have you listed to Derek the Nutter's CF?
Logged
Located in Central North Carolina, USA; credit for picture: livingplanet.ca

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #46 on: October 21, 2009, 11:58:41 PM »

I thought the G/C rows were the same between the two instruments.

That's correct - all things being equal.

As far as the lowest-pitched system goes, note that while C/F is normally higher than G/C, there are some C/Fs that are pitched an octave lower, hence lower than your average G/C - a friend of mine is selling one here : http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2410.0.html

A D/G pitched an octave lower than normal would be a nice instrument, just a tone higher than my friend's C/F.

Quote
Also where does the BCC# fit in the pitch scheme of G/C being lowest and D/G being highest?

The lowest row is the B row, and that is higher than the G row of G/C - in fact it's just a semitone lower than the C row on a G/C. And the C# row is a semitone lower than the D row of a D/G and hence a flattened fifth lower than the G row of a D/G. So you could say BCC# was in between G/C and D/G - but a very different sort of animal. It think it wins the "heaviest diatonic" category...

ganderbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 734
  • Melodeons from Brittany, Italy, Germany* and Leeds
    • www.choughedtobits.co.uk
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #47 on: October 22, 2009, 11:20:22 AM »


If G/C is the lowest pitch for a 2 row melodeon where is G/C/F pitched?  I thought the G/C rows were the same between the two instruments. 

The G/C rows on the treble end are the same for both instruments, but you don't get the full G/C bass layout. You get the basses for a C/F box on the bottom 8, and the extras for playing in G are on the top four.
The main bass you miss out on is the F on the pull, which you need if you want to play in A minor in the same way as on a G/C. You still have it on the push, but it means finding different fingerings for the tunes and moving around the basses more.



As far as the lowest-pitched system goes, note that while C/F is normally higher than G/C, there are some C/Fs that are pitched an octave lower, hence lower than your average G/C - a friend of mine is selling one here : http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2410.0.html

A D/G pitched an octave lower than normal would be a nice instrument, just a tone higher than my friend's C/F.


Thinking about  a D/G/C, maybe it's not a daft idea?. As you say, a low pitched instrument could sound very nice.

I suppose if I'd bought that Streb on eBay I could have programmed it all in to see how it worked..... >:E
 
Logged
Pauline from Cornwall

*  including a customised Hohner Club from Cornwall (and very nice it is too!).

juker

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 838
  • Hohner 2 row G/C and C/F,
    • Julie's Art'nAll
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #48 on: October 22, 2009, 11:29:49 AM »

There is a lot of really good information here, however I think in the end you have to go with your 'gut feeling' a bit. When I bought my box I knew almost nothing about them and I bought mine off ebay. It is a G/C Hohner and I love it. I am learning a lot and enjoying playing it. It is light (in weight) and sounds great and the keys (G/C) are versatile and I am finding it very easy, at this stage, to find lots of great tunes to play on my box. Don't be afraid to just get out there and go with your heart and buy something you like  - and you are as well informed (thanks to mel.net!) as a person can be! Go for it  (:)
Logged
I don't get 'jigs'

michik

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 412
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #49 on: October 22, 2009, 11:36:47 AM »

I made list with some possible 3-row instruments
the bold letters are the 3-rows usually available (Hohner Corona for example)
a possibe D/G/C would be at the very top/bottom of the list

D  G  C
E  A  D
F  Bb Eb
G  C  F
A  D  G
Bb Eb Ab

B  E  A
C  F  Bb
D  G  C
« Last Edit: October 22, 2009, 11:38:36 AM by michik »
Logged
Michael Knapp ~ Vienna ~ Austria
Playing on "Parigi Giovani" G/C (made by Bompezzo) - My recordings: http://www.onmvoice.com/mknapp

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #50 on: October 23, 2009, 02:42:40 AM »

Have you listed to Derek the Nutter's CF?

Yes, I've viewed all of Derek's videos. Amazing, isn't he? Quite an inspiration.
Logged

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #51 on: October 23, 2009, 02:50:41 AM »

There is a lot of really good information here, however I think in the end you have to go with your 'gut feeling' a bit. When I bought my box I knew almost nothing about them and I bought mine off ebay. It is a G/C Hohner and I love it. I am learning a lot and enjoying playing it. It is light (in weight) and sounds great and the keys (G/C) are versatile and I am finding it very easy, at this stage, to find lots of great tunes to play on my box. Don't be afraid to just get out there and go with your heart and buy something you like  - and you are as well informed (thanks to mel.net!) as a person can be! Go for it  (:)

Thanks juker, for your thoughts and especially your encouragement. You're right about balancing the much good advice on this forum with going with one's heart, and vice versa. Yes, I'm inching closer and closer to making a decision and going for it, and everyone's input has been invaluable. Mel.net forum members are the best.
Logged

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #52 on: October 23, 2009, 02:55:21 AM »

I made list with some possible 3-row instruments
the bold letters are the 3-rows usually available (Hohner Corona for example)
a possibe D/G/C would be at the very top/bottom of the list

D  G  C
E  A  D
F  Bb Eb
G  C  F
A  D  G
Bb Eb Ab

B  E  A
C  F  Bb
D  G  C

Thanks again for sharing your thoughts, michik. You're lucky to have the 3 reeds and 5 switches on your Corona IIIR for variety!
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #53 on: October 23, 2009, 08:44:35 AM »


Thanks again for sharing your thoughts, michik. You're lucky to have the 3 reeds and 5 switches on your Corona IIIR for variety!


I wouldn't worry too much about that, there is plenty of scope for making you music varied and interesting without having switches.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

michik

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 412
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #54 on: October 23, 2009, 10:21:40 AM »


Thanks again for sharing your thoughts, michik. You're lucky to have the 3 reeds and 5 switches on your Corona IIIR for variety!


Currently I'm playing exclusively on the light 2-row Erica instead on the heavy three row Corona :-)
Logged
Michael Knapp ~ Vienna ~ Austria
Playing on "Parigi Giovani" G/C (made by Bompezzo) - My recordings: http://www.onmvoice.com/mknapp

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #55 on: October 23, 2009, 08:35:05 PM »

Interestng topic...

I am now primarily a one row player, though have spent as much time on 2 rows.
I also have dabbled on 3 rows in the standard (4th apart) systems .
I have owned around 50 accordeons to date.

I have now crossed over to what I consider the best of all worlds..
1 rows and 3 rows.

To quote Andy from previous interchanges with respect to the same subject of 2 or 3 row box selection :
" anything you can play on a 2 row you can play on a 3 row and often with more fingering options."

Lest anyone think that 3 rows are slow, listen to Felix et Formanger, Denis Pepin , Gaston Nolet, Steve Jordan,
Joel Guzman and a long list of Zydeco and Tex-Mex players.

In reality I believe a 3 row GCF actually has only 2 notes not available on a 2 row G/C.. but that is not the point..
it is where all the duplicate notes are located, and their direction.. of course this applies to A/D/G and all the other
3 row systems. Because of the layout, "cross rowing" takes on a new meaning. Chord combinations are seemingly
endless and virtually every scale can be played ;albeit with some  modifications.

I recently explored acquiring a new box... wanting what many want, speed, modest weight, playbility, versatility..
the universal accordeon.......consider the absurdity of starting with such a basic choice after owing 50 accordeons.
After long consideration  I have concluded

I will always play 1 rows. They are, for me, the very essence of  accordeon..... so basic and limited that they are
a lifetime pursuit. Nothing substitutes for a 4 reed buzz..And every time I think I have made progress  I listen to the great players...
Begeley, Connolly, O'Halloran, and as previously mentioned the Quebec players such as Denis Pepin, Ouellet, Messervier,
Nolet plus Bruneau and the list is endless.. add to that the many fine (tradtional) Cajun players.
So I am adding more  1 rows to my inventory.

With respect to 2 row boxes, I suppose I will always have one around, but do not currently intend to buy a "quality" ( read that expensive)  unit.  I will still buy cheapies, fix them and turn them. If I specialized in a particular type of music that required a dedicated
2 row that would be different.

Weight..  I have 1 rows that are heavier than some 2 rows
And I find the weight of a 3 row 3 reed 12 bass  comfortable if not pleasurable.  Weight is not a detriment .. once th ebox is in your lap..
and you have some time behind the bellows, weight is a limited  consideration...

As to 2 reed or 3 reed... I'll opt for 3.. with registers for the variety of sounds. The advantages outweigh any other consideration, unless your budget is limited.

Conclusion

1 row and 3 row...

Nothing can substitute for a 4 reed 4 stop 1 row
Nothing can substitute for a 3 row
Either could substitute for a 2 row

To answer your original question.. 3 row  3 reed Lmm  with registers if possible
Or on a budget any of the 3 row 2 reed Hohners...





Logged

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #56 on: October 23, 2009, 10:42:26 PM »


Thanks again for sharing your thoughts, michik. You're lucky to have the 3 reeds and 5 switches on your Corona IIIR for variety!


I wouldn't worry too much about that, there is plenty of scope for making you music varied and interesting without having switches.

Once I get past the hurdle of Twinkle Twinkle Little Star, that is.  (:)


Thanks again for sharing your thoughts, michik. You're lucky to have the 3 reeds and 5 switches on your Corona IIIR for variety!


Currently I'm playing exclusively on the light 2-row Erica instead on the heavy three row Corona :-)

I still envy your Bandoneon (LM) register on the IIIR!



Logged

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #57 on: October 23, 2009, 10:57:46 PM »

Thank you, melodeon, for taking the time to respond with such a detailed analysis. Much food for thought and I'm much obliged.

When considering the 1-row/2-row/3-row question, does it all really just come down to personal preference and perhaps longstanding regional tradition? In other words, if one has cut one's musical teeth on a certain system, or if one has musically developed in a playing environment that favors a certain system, does that account for the lion's share of the reason for preferring and remaining with that system, regardless of the pros and cons of each?
Logged

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #58 on: October 23, 2009, 11:30:52 PM »

I forgot to add that my current plan is to own "some" 3 rows...the first will be probably be a GCF ( I have owned about 8 of them already)
Then ADG and FBbEb   all better quality.... more than likely Hohner Xtreme III N

Choosing a box system comes down to the "catholic" way or accidental exposure

Either born into it or you bump minto it along the way.

Most box choices seem to be based on regional or ethnic factors such as
Morris.. D/G 2 row
Quebec.. Single row D and possibly C or A  and 3 row more probably GCF and ADG
TEX MEX.. 3 row GCF  then FBbEb  sometimes EAD or ADg
German..  2 row CF and 2 1/2 row "club" CF
Irish B/C and C#/D as well as single row D  sometimes C
English East Anglia  single row C
France G/C and G/C accidentals
Cajun.. Single row C  then Bb then others

and so on

So then you have some folks such as me who want to play it all... so a longer way around the lake

Then there is the "it" factor which varies from one persaon to another  andf the 4 reed "buzz" is my "it" as well as the
incredible flexibility. power. and joy of a 3 row.

2 rows are great instruments but I don't really get "jacked" up when I play one
in spite of owning many including several Castagnaris and Serenellinis etc...


So, the standard question will be " what type of music do you want to play ? "

All that said  it is much like guitars,, the instrument of choice seeems to be built on tradition such as:
Blue Grass... Martin D-18 or D-28
Texas Fiddle... Gibson flat top
Jazz... Big archtop cutaway such as Gibson
BLues...Gibsons mostly
Electric Blues.. Stratocasters and Le Pauls
Gypsy Jazz... Selmer Maccaferri or clones


And for every case there are noteable exceptions in every category... this goes for the accordeon as well

My suggestion is let a box "fall on you"   or  take the averages and  just get a box and start playing.
My first box was a Saxon no name single row 4 stop sharped Bflat box I bought for $25 and played for some time.
As to quality and brand envy and so on...  many folks look down on Hohners but to quote Paul Groff  ...
"lots of great music has been played on Hohners."
Get what you can afford and "turn" without great loss and get into the process of learning as it that will take you in a direction
that will lead to other choices down the road..

I did not start playing until I was 47....FYI

Good luck

BTW  if you don't have a box ,Ill loan you an imminently playable  50's Hohner C/F pokerwork until you decide what to get.
No strings....  just let me know.






Logged

Medleyitis

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25
  • Hohner Morgane G/C
Re: A neophyte asks: 2 row vs. 3 row (advantages/disadvantages)
« Reply #59 on: October 25, 2009, 02:32:53 AM »

Melodeon, thanks again for taking the time for another detailed and well-thought out reply and also for your regional/ethnic breakdown of systems. Very interesting. And I'm glad to know that I will not have been the first to try to learn to play a melodeon/diatonic accordion well into my middle age years! I'm also very grateful for your kind offer to loan me a box to try. Many, many thanks for your generosity.

After much thought and consideration, and the advice you've all been so generous to provide on this thread, and viewing countless YouTube videos which have opened up a whole new world (actually, many different new worlds) of music for me, and based on the styles of music I feel most drawn to begin playing, (not to mention my financial budget), I have decided to place an order for a Hohner Morgane G/C. This was a decision as much of the heart as of the head for me, and given that I was initially leaning toward a 3-row, somewhat of a surprise as well. Believe me, the pendulum was swinging back and forth many times. Once my finances allow, though, perhaps my next purchase will be a 3-row.

My sincerest thanks to you and to everyone in the melodeon.net community who have responded. You're the best!

Logged
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal