I'd like to consult the collective wisdom of melnet, if I may. I've recently bought an old concertina (but this is equally applicable to melodeons...) in its original leather case. Being an expert in restoring leather from watching "The Repair Shop" (😁) I know that saddle soap is the stuff to use to clean and condition the leather, and it's worked miracles - the case now looks superb.
My question is this: after three applications of saddle soap (rub it in with a damp cloth, let it dry, buff it with a dry cloth) the cloth is still coming up absolutely black when I rub the saddle soap into the leather. Should I carry on using it until that stops happening?
Thanks!