Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Historical melodeon choices  (Read 1418 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Scott C.

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7
Historical melodeon choices
« on: September 16, 2021, 11:57:59 PM »

Hello all! New member here. I'm a former historical military reenactor who is looking to start learning the melodeon but perhaps in a unique way. I'm extremely partial to traditional Irish folk music, sea shanties and such. I'd like to purchase a first instrument that is modern but "looks" like an instrument from say the 19th century.  I've seen the Hohner 1 and 2 rows like the Poker Work or Vienna. Also the Weltmeister 86W.
 Does anyone have any other suggestions for similar boxes that would be suitable for a beginner? And would those mentioned be a good starter instrument? Thanks in advance!
Logged

Brian Wyneken

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 53
Re: Historical melodeon choices
« Reply #1 on: September 17, 2021, 04:20:21 AM »

Several thoughts from another beginner in the US:

I've been scanning this forum for ideas on a DG keyed instrument to replace the Delicia "Popular" instrument I bought. I have thought about putting in an order for Weltmeister 86W (but am going to wait a bit until I "deserve" a better box). Because I am in the Midwest US it is difficult to try out melodeons - no retailers of which I am aware other than Stoney End in Redwing, MN ("Sherwoods" mainly). I'm fairly convinced the Weltmeister 86W would be a pretty good beginner melodeon, and I think it can be ordered through one of the east coast retailers. It also kind of looks like it might fit the picture of trying to find a melodeon that could look "old." I've been internet shopping for a bit and I cannot think of another that combines the advantages of being a reliable beginner box with the appearance you are seeking.

I'm reading a history of the accordion in North America. If you were thinking 19th century replication you could also try finding a one-row. There is one on FB marketplace that looks very nice (a Hohner) and is only around $200, but the seller will not ship - you would have to pick up in person in Louisiana.

Bellinger's Button Boxes in Rochester NY sells restored melodeons.

The reason I went with a two row in the keys of DG initially was because of the availability of internet based tutoring products and method books in English. Also, the English folk tunes are fun to learn. If Irish music is your interest, then I think people here will advise that you buy a melodeon/accordeon with rows a semi-tone apart rather than the 4th apart rows (e.g. GC, CF, AD, DG). There seems to be plenty of instructional material (and US based interest) in that design. If I was interested in someday performing with a band in the US (other than Tex-Mex etc.) I would have gone the Irish direction (especially on the East coast).

That's probably too much from a new guy, but hope it helps a bit.
Logged

Peadar

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2039
Re: Historical melodeon choices
« Reply #2 on: September 17, 2021, 10:23:14 AM »

If you are seriously interested in the history of the button accordion / melodeon in Irish Music Mairé NíCaoimh's 2010 Doctoral Thesis is the definitive work : https://ulir.ul.ie/handle/10344/1616

My initial interest in the melodeon was as a self playable support instrument for learning Gaelic song melodies and an interest in how and when it became embedded in Gaelic traditional music. 
Two important distinctions need to be made: Firstly -Irish Gaelic was re-packed as "Irish" in the early twentieth century for political reasons. Correctly Gaelic encompasses both Irish and Scots Gaelic, but excludes Hiberno-English and Scotch. Internal to the Gaelic world there is a distinction between Gaeilge (of Ireland) and Gaidhlig (of Scotland) but to pretend the distinction from an English linguistic perspective is either ignorant  (excusable) or disingenuous (in excusable).

How does that play out in your interest in a historical instrument type?

First off the - seann-bhocsa (1 row) appears to have become established in Irish music in the late 19th century and remained long dominant in the Gaelic speaking West. Mid 19th century Irish emigration was disproportionately from Gaelic speaking districts. NiChaoimh's research indicates that the 2 row semi-tone box only really became established in Irish music from the 1920's onwards. Chromaticity making it acceptable - like the piano- to Ireland's developing urban middle class.

So if you are into 19th century realism - you are going in the direction of a 1 row and Hohners are out. They didn't make a melodeon until 1904 - after nearly 50 years of making harmonicas. Stradella corners (as fitted to Hohner Pokerwork models) are also anachronistic. 19th century designs didn't have them.

That said it's pretty clear that both "German" and "Vienna" types of 1 row were used by Irish and Irish-American players. I would suggest on that basis a good solid starter box could be a Hohner 1040 - the 1 row pokerwork. Alternatively Scott Bellinger as Brian has pointed out sells restored melodeons - The old brass reed models don't sound like a modern box but they are good  in their own right.
Logged

Scott C.

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7
Re: Historical melodeon choices
« Reply #3 on: September 17, 2021, 11:17:48 AM »

Thanks Brian, I appreciate the reply. I'm from New Jersey and whether it's an advantage or a curse is to be determined but I live within 20 miles of two accordion shops. One is the Acme accordion school in Haddonfield, NJ which is a few towns over and Liberty Bellows in Philadelphia. I'll eventually be paying them both a visit.
  The other melodeon I was looking toward is a Castagnari Lilly. A smaller two row in wood. They come in Cherry and walnut. It's not as "old looking" but I feel it could pass.
  As far as tuning, I haven't really given that any consideration at this point. I suppose once I settle on a box that will be my next decision. I don't plan on singing with it so that won't figure into my final decision. I have so much to learn but it's an exciting journey!
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Historical melodeon choices
« Reply #4 on: September 17, 2021, 04:58:25 PM »

I played a Lilly only  (+ concertina) for my first 7 years and it’s a great starter box. Clean sound with a purity that almost begs you to learn right hand chords an a surprisingly good bass for the weight. I loved it, but moved on to a Mory as I discovered French bal music. Great for travel! Mine’s been around the world, and in a motor cycle pannier across the Alps.

Never sold it. A swedish protegée had it for 3 years. Now with my son-in-law, a guitarist, singer and occasional band player. He’s going great guns.

As D/G it is … rather shrill in top octave. Eventually you might move on to LM voicing if you want to explore there without changing to eg G/G tonality. But it’ll keep its value. 

Looks? A bit modern 🥴 But you could easily eg stencil it to fake age. It’ll sand and varnish back. Mine had a St Chartier fire dept “pin” inlaid into the left end. But frankly … few will notice.
« Last Edit: September 17, 2021, 05:04:04 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Scott C.

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7
Re: Historical melodeon choices
« Reply #5 on: September 17, 2021, 05:21:48 PM »

If you are seriously interested in the history of the button accordion / melodeon in Irish Music Mairé NíCaoimh's 2010 Doctoral Thesis is the definitive work : https://ulir.ul.ie/handle/10344/1616

My initial interest in the melodeon was as a self playable support instrument for learning Gaelic song melodies and an interest in how and when it became embedded in Gaelic traditional music. 
Two important distinctions need to be made: Firstly -Irish Gaelic was re-packed as "Irish" in the early twentieth century for political reasons. Correctly Gaelic encompasses both Irish and Scots Gaelic, but excludes Hiberno-English and Scotch. Internal to the Gaelic world there is a distinction between Gaeilge (of Ireland) and Gaidhlig (of Scotland) but to pretend the distinction from an English linguistic perspective is either ignorant  (excusable) or disingenuous (in excusable).

How does that play out in your interest in a historical instrument type?

First off the - seann-bhocsa (1 row) appears to have become established in Irish music in the late 19th century and remained long dominant in the Gaelic speaking West. Mid 19th century Irish emigration was disproportionately from Gaelic speaking districts. NiChaoimh's research indicates that the 2 row semi-tone box only really became established in Irish music from the 1920's onwards. Chromaticity making it acceptable - like the piano- to Ireland's developing urban middle class.

So if you are into 19th century realism - you are going in the direction of a 1 row and Hohners are out. They didn't make a melodeon until 1904 - after nearly 50 years of making harmonicas. Stradella corners (as fitted to Hohner Pokerwork models) are also anachronistic. 19th century designs didn't have them.

That said it's pretty clear that both "German" and "Vienna" types of 1 row were used by Irish and Irish-American players. I would suggest on that basis a good solid starter box could be a Hohner 1040 - the 1 row pokerwork. Alternatively Scott Bellinger as Brian has pointed out sells restored melodeons - The old brass reed models don't sound like a modern box but they are good  in their own right.
Peadar, that is quite a bit to digest but I certainly appreciate your insight. I'd like to be as authentic as possible but staying as practical as possible as well. I have looked at the single row 1040. If I end up using it for events I could always remove any identifying names from the outside. Oh and thanks for the link. I will definitely read it. Research, always research!
Logged

Randal Scott

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 399
  • Detroit MI
Re: Historical melodeon choices
« Reply #6 on: September 17, 2021, 08:36:37 PM »

Hi.  A few weeks ago we were discussing on old Hohner box from the early period (on ebay for a few hundred dollars US).  Seems like type that would be suitable for sea shanties and such - aged wood, ship anchors printed on the box...maybe even a few cobwebs inside  :|glug
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal